Vote on Extra History Topics: US History Edition!

Still neck and neck guys!

Enrique Diaz-Alvarez

The internet has had a boner for Teddy for forever, I'd love a more in depth look at the articles instead of pandering to an already popular figure

Alex Finch

I love Crash Course, but I do think we do things differently than they do and that both options deserve to be made. We have a different perspective than they do on some historical topics, and we also tend to tackle our topics as a mini-series whereas they might cover the same topic in one episode. They do it extremely well, but we have extra room for storytelling and detail that I think we put to good use!

Extra History

*I* (Soraya) very much do, but this month James was suggesting the topic votes again and he has his own set of things he wants to discuss. :) The US-History limited vote was something we've been discussing for a long time, and seeing how the Underground Railroad vote turned out clinched our decision to have one. Prior to that, we'd been considering an all-women vote but Catherine the Great won on her own. Basically, we're saving the "only this topic" themed votes for situations where we're concerned that a particular type of history CAN'T win on its own, but US History is the only one so far where we've seen so much disinterest that we felt like we really had to force it. I think that's unfortunate, but I'm glad the vote has turned out to have as much interest for people as it did.

Extra History

TR bully.

schuyler

I voted for Articles. It's an area of history not as well known as the others and I hope it wins

Jack the Rat

Yeah, it's really down to the wire, the two 55s have been leapfrogging each other.

RMS Oceanic

Just voted on the next EH topic and noticed the percentages listed: 26%, 32%, 55%, 55%, and 10%.

Christian Bone

I'm pretty sure that if the entire Zulu Empire, the first crusade and the opium war could all be done in six episodes, so can George Washington. The lead-up to the civil war is the only thing that seems too big to me.

Christina Maria Jessen

Articles of Confederation and Washington get my votes. The Washington one I assume will touch on his involvement with the Seven Years War as well as the War of Independence. I'd have added the intrigue and tragedy of the Garfield administration, but I haven't pledged enough to add topics in the hat

Jessica Cheeri

Or keep making interesting series and link them to Crash Course US History instead? :) <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6E9WU9TGrec&list=PL8dPuuaLjXtMwmepBjTSG593eG7ObzO7s" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6E9WU9TGrec&list=PL8dPuuaLjXtMwmepBjTSG593eG7ObzO7s</a> I can see the point of wanting to do US history yourself though, since it seems you're all american :) Good luck.

Mikael

My suggestion -- formation of the Republican Party (to 1856)

Brian Rose

I voted for the lead up to the Civil War and the Articles of Confederation

FallDragonFae

The Articles of Confederation (basically the Constitution before the Constitution) and the president who got a stuffed toy named after him get my vote.

Antti Björklund

I'm surprised that Underground Railroad isn't on the ballot, since you wanted to clear the misconceptions when we were discussing it in the last vote. When I said US topics are unlikely to win in the aftermath of the last vote ( underground railroad was in last place by a significant margin), I didn't think you would actually go through with my suggestion of an US history vote only. Despite it limiting patreons options, I kinda like having themed votess like the Economics and Science one or this one.

Marco Honrade

EH has already done a great job looking at less common topics. Does any western school cover Justinian or the South Sea Bubble? Not to my knowledge. Makes sense to cover something a little more on the path from time to time.

RMS Oceanic

I recall awhile back, Dan mentioning that if they'd to do extra history on a president, they'd want to make it be done to Teddy. I'm Ready for Teddy!

GrantZeebs

Oh wow the vote is tight. Which one should I go for? :P

RMS Oceanic

Even other people on the same continent might not know your history well. Canadian reporting in here, and while we got a bit more than Modest did, I still don't know very much about most of these topics.

Nessf

Yikes, I don't know what one to vote for because I want all of them.

Laura Galm

Sloganed!

Extra History

We explain at the bottom of the post why we specifically want to cover topics that are talked about in school! In short: students (and teachers) watch this show, it's been a great resource for some of them, and while we will continue to cover various parts of the world in the larger run of the series, we don't want to keep leaving out students because we ONLY cover more esoteric topics. Also Modest makes a good point that what's common history in one part of the world is not covered much or at all in other parts, and we want to introduce all parts of our global audience to new things!

Extra History

I can't get the Theme setting to work for me with Free Online Surveys today. Not sure if it's a brain fart or if it's currently a broken feature, but that's why you're seeing the broken image!

Extra History

I'm ready for Teddy!

Christopher Smith

Nicole Barovic

Is it just me, or is the background image for the vote broken? Like, the poll itself works, but the background is just white with a small 'broken image' icon in the upper left.

Nessf

I think if that's the winner, we'd probably pick a specific event (or connected series of events) within the antebellum period.

Extra History

That's good; Washington, for example, would absolutely justify a full 12 episodes, if not more.

Brian Rose

For Antebellum -- you could do ten episodes on 1848-61 alone (the period between the Mexican American War and secession)

Brian Rose

I'm not opposed to doing another Justinian and Theodora style "to be continued" set if needed. :)

Extra History

Sure did! Check your email!

Extra History

Word of advice: most of these could not be done justice in just six fifteen minute (or less) episodes.

Brian Rose

My topic made it on the vote! :D

RMS Oceanic