Human in human form vs human in pony form poll results and game discussion.
Added 2017-06-20 01:06:45 +0000 UTC
I ran a poll earlier about whether the protagonist would be a human in human form in ponyville, or human in pony form in ponyville.
A small majority voted more for human in human form, but the question is this then.
The idea I had was that as anon you would be in human form while in twilights house, and venturing outside would turn you into a pony if you're not in field of the mirror portal.
The reasoning for this is that for sexual story/encounters, it seems like being in pony form would allow ponies to trust you and see you as one of them, where as a human walking around would be regarded as something like zecora and largely avoided. This way that once you have been with a pony in her quest long enough, you could bring her back to twis house and have human on pony based scenes.
Celestia would be aware you're a human from the getgo due to her magic and mirror traveling, and would be interested in the human on pony aspect.
However, if the majority of you feel stronger that anon should only be in human form in the town then question is this: how do you feel about the reactions of ponies to the human and even going as far as intimate moment with them? Would it not stick out too much that not only is the humanized shape is there but making advances on them?