Superman & Lois 1x15 Finale - Poll!

This is definitely the best written/produced/directed/everything else season 1 of any of the shows but I Legitimately enjoyed The Flash Season 1 better because I like that fun feel more so than this more serious tone. This is a close second though.

William Tanner

Yes, it probably doesn’t have my favorite finale but the consistency in character and subtlety in writing which make the bombastic moments even more satisfying

Gavin Hardiman

Arrow S1 > Flash S1 > S&L S1 > Supergirl S1 > LoT S1

It’s tied with flash in my opinion but with flash there were some bad episodes here it’s less episodes so there’s pretty much no major complaints that I have

Dfd

This may well be the best written season but I think I might prefer either Arrow s8 or LoT season 3/4 just out of pure entertainment value

Charlie Pears

This is definitely a much better show in writing and production. But Arrow, Flash, and Legends all hold a special place in my heart as each of their first seasons were very memorable for different reasons. I SAY THEY ALL TIE! Unless of course the later seasons keep their stride and don't suffer the same fate as the rest of the arrowverse.

Ryan Mendoza

If I were to base my favorite on the "objective" quality of the show then this would be it but in terms of pure enjoyment, The Flash will likely always be the winner for me.

Hunter Maynard

I can’t remember arrow and flash just the feeling from them. This show makes me feel satisfied like those two did. It’s my favorite because it rekindled my interest in the arrow verse

Chris D. Jones

favorite first season is either supergirl or flash, i cant remember all the episodes to compare the two for a winner but i know i really enjoyed both those first seasons.

rickie woodson

fuck this show. i was so not going to watch season 2 unless someone i care about shows up like the legion and bam! nat shows up! this is agents of shield all over again! bad shows putting in good characters le sigh le sigh

rickie woodson

Other show's first seasons had some great positives, but also some negatives for me. This show was consistently all positives. Plus I think they nailed the length of it for the story they wanted to tell - enough time to let it breathe but not so long that it would have to be padded with several irrelevant-villain-of-the-week episodes.

TheUndeadFish

I like Arrow's first season, but Superman and Lois is up there on the list.

sonicburst3

This season was really good but without doing a rewatch I give a slight edge to Flash season 1. The Wells is Reverse Flash reveal was awesome. I think Thawn being a better villain than Edge is the difference. And I love Diggle but liked the Flash crossovers better too.

I like Arrows and FLash's first season more but this was excellent

Jason Usher

you know this show has a bigger budget than all the other Arrowverse shows put together already right

Jason Usher

This season is easily in the top 3 with Arrow & Flash. If only it had a Tom Cavanagh "Fly, Clark, Fly" then it would have been #1.

Fallen

Arrows my favourite show but since it was the first show CW had to find their footing which they definitely did with this show now they just need to cancel batwoman and throw the money from that and Supergirl at this

It was great first season but arrow season 1 is mine it was amazing

Bryan Malacaro

As horrible as it’s been ever since the third season, I still think The Flash had a better first season. I wasn’t a fan of how they wrapped up the story with Morgan Edge. However, this is easily the best season from the Arrowverse since arrow season 5.

Adam Grunther

I say this beats the flash and arrow season 1 because of the cast and writing they did so well the flash and arrow cast still did good jon in their season 1 but super man and lois cast were pick so well. The writing was really well done and they didn’t dragged the season so much it became a problem.

spencer

Arrow is pretty close but this nailed its ending better in my opinion.

Cal

Arrow S1 was serious and dark grounded gritty is my favorite and what i like, this was great but superman represents to much hope and there are no serious stakes but utter destruction when he's involved

Matt Modlinski

I would say the first season of Arrow is still my favorite, as it had a lot of promise, good writing and interesting characters. But this one is a close second.

AndyV85

I think it may be the best structured and written of all of the 1st Arrowverse seasons it also had probably the best character development at first I didn’t care about the Cushings storyline but it became some of my favorite stuff as time went on

Christian Bolda

I am probably a little biased in the moment with it but there wasn't a single episode I left going "meh it was fine" so this was the best 1st season for me. However, the 1st seasons of Arrow and Flash are very very close behind. Mainly because the Reverse Flash and Malcom were better overall villains compared to Edge for me. Otherwise S&L takes it in every other area.

Nothing beats The Flash season 1 for me. I just love RF so much as a character.

Yes, this is my favorite by far, but Arrow, Flash and Legends all ride a close second. Damn, the Arrowverse has had so many great first seasons, they almost feel like different shows. What a shame.

MarkIsDaBoss

The first couple of seasons of Arrow, but this is right up there

Errolowl

Flash had good characters and power exploration but also better main villain, a compelling mystery, made characters memorable outside the main cast and mixed with the arrowverse better. This show is a good personal story about this family and has great characters. But flash took on a lot more jobs and did it well.

Doby Greg

Yes because it told a story in less than 20 episodes

Joel

I say this one is the best but I feel it is because it has wonderful writing. But the first flash season is close behind then arrow. Hopefully they can keep it up!

Hunter R.

Mmmmmmm. I think its definitely the best written and highest quality. But i really enjoyed the first couple seasons of Arrow and The Flash. Its either tied or i enjoyed Superman & Lois just a bit more. But ill still vote yes cause its too close either way to say no.

MOB12

Arrow and flash aren’t better seasons is any way but I just love them so much

Cojotaho

Yes but i probably have recency bias

Dip602