Crisis on Infinite Earths, Part 1 - Poll!

Super late but I legit saved every show until crisis and just binged everything including the first 3 crisis episodes, would’ve waited even longer if I knew they weren’t all going to finish in 2019......anyways just wanted to make a little remark I absolutely loved how Oliver just told Superman what to do in the beginning when he wanted to travel into 2046 for his son. Stephen Amell is such an incredible actor it’s a shame that we most likely won’t see much of him post arrow. He deserves the big screen just as Andrew Lincoln does too.

I want consequences to be permanent but it probably will return.

Chris D. Jones

I kind of don't want them to bring it back, I do want them to be in the same in the same universe, make it easier and stuff, they'd have to adjust, but they can make it work.

Matthew Rodkey

Yooo that. Black lightning epispde was great. Please ultra they need to see it

Tilted Krow

I have a theory, what if the Anti-Monitor accomplishes destroying majority of the earth and the Monitor sacrifices himself and creates an earth (prime earth) where earth 38, earth 3 and earth 1 exist as one.

Naveen Thampy

Ultra, please have them watch and do a reaction for Black Lightning 3x9 before The Flash episode of "Crisis". It does tie in with "Crisis" (including the "red skies" of "Crisis" and they talk about parallel universes). Black Lightning will then be in The Flash episode of "Crisis". Thank you.

David Brown

Probably coming back other wise all of supergirl’s characters r out of jobs. And they would have to build brand new sets not practical or cost effective, alternative theory lex gets the book from last crossover and writes catco the DEO Lcorp and the rest into earth 🌍 1 the Monitor did say we need a mind like his ( bet he makes himself president)

Hey you guys should watch the latest episode of Black Lightning at least, it has some tie ins to the crisis. You won't regret it please.

John Anthony

I think Earth-38 is gone. Supergirl is on a different Earth because the show started on CBS, and since it’s been with the CW for a while now, I think having them on Earth-1 will solve a lot of problems they have with crossovers. I can even see the rest of Season 5 of Supergirl dealing with adjusting to the changes as well. She could even have small crossovers with Flash to ask Barry for guidance on her adjusting, or Batwoman when Kate needs help with Superhero troubles. Just my theory, though.

Black Lightning S3 had a tie in episode right after Hour 2, and the season’s been pretty good so far. You should’ve been watching.

Jon Mercano

Now that we have Batwoman it would be more convenient for Supergirl to be on Earth 1 for future crossover stuff between these two shows.

I have to assume that they're doing the comic thing of merging all the earths, but for the moment Earth-1 just received an extra three billion people from nowhere, it's probably best not to think what that will do to the economy.

Kevin Bartelen

Supergirls didn’t wrap up their story. Leviathan was setting something up. So we are definitely getting that earth (and maybe the others) back

ChiefChill

I think it will come back, even tho i would love for it to be gone for good, make it easier for crossovers having all these chatacters in the same world

Kaleb A. Diaz

I believe without a doubt the earth is gone but the real question is who else made it out, cat grant, James? In that case mallefek, magon, the legion are all dead because they weren’t on earth with a way to cross dimensions

I am Ironman

Everyone needs to just accept that loses will happen people will die, there are no do overs. If you can always reset every consequence than what be even be the point of experiencing them.

Andrew Courtney

I really hope it’s gone for good, just because Supergirl (the show) has always felt like the odd one out to me due to being on a separate Earth.

Dylan Carpenter

Well only half of the population escaped so the other half was probably asleep lmao

Able

I think it is gone as this makes crossovers easier to do rather than needing to explain the whole time vagina scenario each time. Also random thought what if you were asleep during the Earth-38 evacuation you would be screwed

Here’s the thing: we saw the Titans Earth get destroyed, but that show is coming back, so we know some of the Earths will (probably) come back. I don’t know if Earth-38 will be one of them though

Bradley Ogilvie

Ask brainy he's from the future right. Where's Mon-el, Cat Grant, M'gann. What about Kara's and Alex mom and dad. I need answers.

It's gone, I think this version of Crisis will be a Lite version of the comics where the comics said "ok now everything is on only 1 earth" the show will say "we wiped most earths, now there are a solid N number (lets say 5)". Then they can move earth 38's people to a habitable but uninhabited earth where humans never happened that only needs 1 "Super" Person so Kal (maybe Brainy to build civilization) goes there. That would keep all the main characters on the one Earth like the comics but still have a mini-MultiVerse

Crispy_Gin

Barring time travel shenanigans, I'd say it's gone.

Jessica Bogues

Also yes the addition of 3 billon more people will be drastic that’s the point of something this huge! Plus the people who came from Earth 38 have ships. Maybe some of the aliens who came to Earth 1 return to their planets in that universe. But something you didn’t even mention is we just had the big things happen with Johns Brother in Supergirl, but he and everyone else on Mars are now dead for all we know! But it opens so much possibility! Maybe Superman and Supergirl go to find the Krypton of Earth 1 Universe?!

Ziegenbagel

It’s gone. On a different note I don’t believe Oliver is dead, it is possible we have to watch all 3 prime heroes die in these first 3 parts. Then we come back in a month and it starts with the Legends who bring them back with time travel! It is what they do although sometimes not well!

Ziegenbagel

I imagine Earth-38 is gone, but other Earths will remain after Crisis with some survivors of Earth-38 choosing to go to other Earths whilst some (the Supergirl cast) will remain on Earth-1.

G0d_Ginrai

FYI (and unrelated, sorry): you guys were wondering why the earth with the other Oliver was Earth-16. The Star City 2046 episode in Legends was season 1, episode 6.

Melissa Gunterman

I would be upset if they brought back Earth-38. It would undo the drastic consequences you need for an event like the end of the multiverse.

Luis Garcia

Earth 38 is 100% gone but Oliver is 99.99999999999999% not gone

Deadpool

It’s fine. It’s not coming back. The crossover will end with a merging of all the earths all The DC Shows going to take place in one earth from here on out. Including Titans. Earth-38 is no more. There is no bringing it back.

Darth Kal-El (Cory Weston)

Everything end with a black screen part 5

Andreas Froby

Levaithen is powerful, they maybe could use some way to escape too

Andreas Froby

Gone but if returns want some of the deaths to stick ....poor Miss Martian Megan?

Edwin B

This is the perfect time to merge the earth's together, so I think its gone

Tucker Lobner

I like the idea of more crossing over between all the shows, especially flash and supergirl, in the future! So Earth 38 being gone will definitely lend itself to that, we still don't know where superman in earth 1 is, so that could be cool for his show. Maybe Krypton is still around in earth 1 too? Could be some cool storylines there!!

Carson the Jedi-Panda-Man

As much as i hate to say it's GONE! Nooo my poor boy Mon-El 😭

Jak O'Hara

It's gotta be gone for good, if we just fix everything what was the point of the crossover? There has to be consequences for the biggest crossover

Billyb

In the words of Mac from "It's Always Sunny": That bitch is dead. Also, Hopefully this means there won't be a third season of Titans.

Darth Skhorrn

YES? NO? I have no idea. So much happened, my brain gave up

Ethan Prendergast

I have a feeling all except one earth will be destroyed and that Earth will end up being the new "Prime Earth"

Rubi Moon

I’m sure it’s gone and it’ll stay that way. It’s the perfect way to get the Kryptonians and a Green Martian on Earth-1!

BigFatSammich

Imagine if all the Earths get destroyed and The Arrowverse is ending with everyone dead

I have no name

I do believe some of the affected Earths will merge, so it's gone.

Erika Kobori

IT WILL RETURN As much as i would like every show's earth to get merged i think at the end of it the mejorty of earths will be back

Dip602

I think it’s gone, otherwise there are no consequences of these epic battles and then what’s the point if it’s all going to go back to normal.

Michelle Denny

ITS DEAD!

Dragon83

its gone so crossovers be more easier to do

spencer

I honestly believe Earth-38 is gone. Things need to stick with this crossover just because of the absolute scale of it. The only high stake I don’t want to stick at this very moment is Oliver’s death.

AdDifferent

It has to come back. Unless Levaithen snuck onto one of the ships, I don't know how we're supposed to tackle that part of Supergirl. It'll be interesting if they go with merging the earths, and now everyone is on the same earth though. Man. Talk about carrying over to the other shows.

Ian Vega

In the spirit of lasting consequences I hope it’s gone for good. Also now we’ll have Kara and J’onn on Earth 1. Fun fact, the full titans team were originally gonna have a full scene at the beginning but due to shooting permit issues it couldn’t happen.

Gone BUT where are they going to put all three people?! Does Earth one just get fucked over with all these refugees?! Maybe they should build a wall...

Gavin Hardiman

I think it's gone, but I'm not ruling out any wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey shenanigans.

The Amish Electrician

I think it's gone, I'm not too familiar with what goes on during crisis in the comic books, but If they just brought back earth - 38 it wouldn't give us the audience to fear the anti monitor, Also after this cross over what do you think the odds are that we will finally get a justice league name drop?

I'm assuming it's gone for good 🤔. I'm also hoping because everyone being on Earth 1 would be cool :)

Doco56

it's most likely gone, i'd imagine they're going in the route where the multiverse will collapse into one

AutomoTomto

I want real consequently for this crossover and having Kara's earth be destroyed is the perfect example of that, plus they more of excuse to do mini crossover like the Flash/Supergirl musical episode

AAA DATTERY

With the all mighty power of Beebo anything is possible

ChiefChill

I'm assuming gone, but then they would run into the whole "supergirl is on this earth, why not get her to help" if she stays on earth 1

SPARTAN 465

I think it’s gone for good. I think that’s why most of the shows kind of wrapped up their stories before crisis. They wouldn’t be able to continue the story without it feeing off.

Ryan O'Malley

In the words of Justin Timberlake "Dead & Gone"

Joel

I think it’s gone. Crisis has to change the status quo and from what we’ve seen there’s no way to restore an earth that has been destroyed. The Monitor offered that to Laurel has a test, but I don’t think he could actually do it.

I hope its gone. I want our heroes on the same earth, plus that keeps the stakes high.

Sam K