XaiJu
raeoffrecord
raeoffrecord

patreon


Three attempts to color the same art

(The top image is preview version; you can download the bigger image from the attachment of this post)

Without any surprise, they're all failed. Sometimes I feel maybe I should make a quick post without too much comment so I can save some time to work on painting. While I'm also very lucky to have very active patrons willing to share opinions. So...sorry about those gibberish & my odd English. Also if you'd like to see my comment but don't have time to reply, leaving a like is also appreciated :))

Let's conclude my thoughts about these three practice:

Practice A: I introduced very strong light source on this one. It means I need to describe every form by various value. I roughly apply values on it, but it's still quite flat and hard to add more details. I guess I just painted it too hastily and don't know how to make a good start.

Practice B: I softened the light impact and directly paint with color. I got lucky with this one and it's kinda promising. The color scheme is from cold(light) to warm(dark); there's also some saturation variation to make it looks more nature. Thus it became very hard to apply this transition to every form while also to keep the values in order. To finish it is not impossible, but time-wise it's not a sustainable method for being productive.

Practice C: I gave up on value and tried to paint with flat style. The shapes are very clear to see and overall, faster to paint. But I have no idea how to choose colors if without concerning values. I guess I just have a poor sense for flat painting style ;o;

(首圖是壓縮過的版本,大圖請下載附件)

再發三個過程圖,雖然沒畫成功啦但總之還是放上來吧...(非常心虛)話說我目前是盡量把想講的話都全丟上來,不過其實這樣整理感想(而且還要搞雙語版)挺花時間的。有時在想也許我該速速丟圖上來後就躲起來乖乖繼續畫圖?假如你有興趣繼續在未來的帖子裡看我的廢話,可以留言或至少按like讓我知道一下。

以下是這次的練習感想:

練習A: 這張放了強烈的光影效果,但有光呢就有灰度,有灰度就有更多問題要解決。簡單來說就是我在練習這張的當下還是很不會控制灰度,所以不管怎麼接著畫都很醜。

練習B: 把光影效果弱化,用一半腦子處理顏色一半腦子處理灰度的方式作業。一開始還算順利,但越細化就越吃力,越發現自己不知道要在這邊填什麼顏色?要多少飽和度?要多少灰度?要偏冷調還是暖調?事實證明我的單核心大腦畢竟是無法立刻就升級為雙核心。

練習C: 自暴自棄,直接丟開灰度,試著用比較平的風格做畫(不曉得在華文圈該怎麼稱呼這種畫法)。然後也因為丟開了灰度,可以一直專心刻輪廓,速度上來說真的快很多,但同時也對於該在哪裡塗上什麼顏色毫無頭續。感覺就是在亂畫,而這亂畫的成果又很不好看。我大概真的是很沒有這方面的sense(啜泣)

Three attempts to color the same art Three attempts to color the same art Three attempts to color the same art Three attempts to color the same art

Comments

Thanks for yor reply! Yeah I guess the better way to describe my attempts is that, uh..., I have no idea how to finish them :p

I have to agree. These aren't failures at all. You're simply trying different things to see what works best for you, and that's perfectly okay, no matter what the perfectionist in your head says. <3 I love how you did his hair in the third one.

K T

Ah thank you for being so helpful! Just want to mention, these practices were made earlier than my another WIP post which I'm currently working on. (<a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/push-values-19958981)">https://www.patreon.com/posts/push-values-19958981</a> )This one got lots attention on twitter so I guess it could be very promising.

Thanks for your attention ❤️

噢噢久違的中文留言!話說如果找得到可靠的方法,我也很不想一直這樣實驗下去...但是現在邊苦學邊能得到實值的支持真的給了我很大的動力,感謝你的支持QDQ 我有時的中英文內容會有點不一樣,假如兩邊都看的話可能會有更多收穫(毆)

Thank you for your feedback! I also adore the charm of flat painting style, because it gives artists more freedom to create. Somehow in my case it often ends up as a chaos LOL. But value is so hard to paint so I can totally understand if anyone want to stay away from it. &gt; how long it took to do each painting I haven't developed any strict method for painting so it's hard to sums up. I'll use the earlier two illust packs as examples. --May reward ( <a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/special-reward-19120507">https://www.patreon.com/posts/special-reward-19120507</a> Old work in 2010 ) It tooks about 4 days. The line art took most of the time. The paint stage is actually a lot to be desired since I was not familiar with art fundamental at that time. --June reward ( <a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/special-reward-19724122">https://www.patreon.com/posts/special-reward-19724122</a> 2017 work) It took about 12 days. 2-3 days for line art, some days being super confused and didn't know how to color it and kept failing, and 5-6 days to do the shading. (I actually canceled some of the shading process and repaint it several times) I do wish I can finally find a stable way to paint. I'm betting on grinding values method at this moment. ( I posted a WIP on this post: <a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/19958981">https://www.patreon.com/posts/19958981</a> ) &gt; critique as a tier in the future? There's too much I haven't learned, so for my level of understanding it's odd to take money for doing any critique. I supposed there could be some alternative ways which I can interact with my patron's works. Like overpaint; or one doing line art, one doing color...something like that? Anyway first thing for sure, is that they all require a reliable painting method for my own.

omg why XDD These are not 'fails', they are 'experiments'! And thank you for detailed commentary, it's really useful! (I'll try to give more feedback at the weekend)

Not gonna lie, this is the first thing I opened on my phone when I woke up this morning.

Mary B

其實已經追喇A大很久了,一直以來都很敬佩你的實驗精神。除了看圖之外,我很享受看你的心得與記錄,這時常可以幫助自己思考創作(雙語版對我的幫助也很大xd

Though they seem like fails, there is a charm to your coloring that works with the constructional lines. There is also need no need to apologize since I always appreciate the words you put in your work, I am still attempting to color without messing up the values and it can be tedious haha. So your words help. May I ask how long it took to do each painting and if you have considered critique as a tier in the future?


More Creators