XaiJu
SelkieMyth
SelkieMyth

patreon


Chapter 462 - Adventures in Nippon-Koku

AN: This chapter is me trying to dip my toes into comedy/satire a bit, and I'm not sure how well I succeeded. I feel it's so-so, and as a result, it's just a single mega chapter instead of being split into 2 or 3 smaller chapters. So enjoy the mega chapter, and I don't intend to be taking BTDEM in a radically different direction. Just thought this could be fun.

Enjoy!

===================================

I had a fairly uncomfortable realization when we finished crossing the sea to Nippon-Koku, one that shook my self-confidence and made me look deep inside myself. One that had me do some serious soul-searching.

I’d never really traveled to another country before. Not voluntarily, on a temporary basis.

Oh, sure, Hunting and I had crossed the Formorian wastes to see what was on the other side, discovering the dwarves. But I hadn’t gone out there intending to visit a new country, a new culture. Once there, my greatest goal had been leaving, and getting back home. Sure, I’d crossed through the centaur plains and the shimagu city, meeting new people and cultures the whole way, but it hadn’t been my goal. They were simply between me and my goal.

Technically, visiting the fae realm might count, but for a thousand and one reasons - mostly it’s the fae, they don’t count - they weren’t added.

Rolland was involuntary, the School of Sorcery and Spellcraft was an island, not a nation. The stops they made sort of counted, but it wasn’t like I’d deliberately gone out of my way to travel, more like they were pit stops.

Trying to find analogies for how the School moved around was weird. There was nothing quite like it.

Going to Cartref Clyd for the Gladiator Gauntlet also sorta counted, and traveling to Exterreri was to find a home.

Mission or not, this was the first time I ever felt like a tourist. Traveling to new lands to have a good time. I should totally see if I could find a book of magic or two to learn from. [Butterfly Mystic] would love that. Sure, it wasn’t as potent as the School, but critically for [Butterfly Mystic], it was new, and the class was all about new.

A level up notification broke me out of my musings.

[*ding!* [Ancient Loremaster of Legend] has leveled up! 182 -> 183. +100 Dexterity, +100 Vitality, +800 Mana, +800 Mana Regen, +1600 Magic Power, +1600 Magic Control from your Class per level! +1 Strength, +1 Dexterity, +1 Speed, +1 Vitality, +1 Mana, +1 Mana Regeneration, +1 Magic Power, +1 Magic Control for being Chimera (Elvenoid)! +1 Mana, +1 Magic Power from your Element per level!]

I held my breath as I looked at the notification, praying that I didn’t get another one. One notification was fine. Edge of a level, got a small trickle from pointing out the Void [Mage] island that we detoured around, Auri doing her thing splitting experience with me. Typical. Expected.

A second level would suggest that Auri was gaining some significant experience, and I didn’t want to return home to a smoldering wreck. She’d gotten a few levels here and there far faster than I thought she would, and nobody would let me know what was going on with that.

I let a sigh loose as nothing else happened for a few minutes, content that everything was alright at home with Auri and Nina, and refocused on traveling.

We’d gone a bit further south, and snow had already fallen heavily. Most people were tucked away in their homes, smoke merrily puffing out of chimneys, and there just frankly wasn’t a ton going on. Most people stayed warm and safe in the winter months, indulging in indoor activities with their families.

Plenty of people did brave the snows for various reasons, and quite a few people hurried over when Iona landed outside the village, while a few more went and hid inside their homes. Fenrir was pretty damn scary… and a rider didn’t really mitigate that.

Iona hopped off and went to chat with them, and get our bearings. I didn’t speak a word of Yayoi.

The people of Pallos were interesting. Most countries had a few dominant races that mixed freely in cities, but when it came to villages, they tended to only have a single species living there. My personal theory was it was one part xenophobia, and three parts families. Couldn’t easily marry a member of another species and have kids, it just didn’t work. Any village large enough to support two species would need to be the size of two smaller villages stuck together, along with a lack of interspecies friction at the village level - too easy to have a grudge lasting generations against an other, at which point it was well on its way to being a small town instead.

Nippon-koku was one of the more diverse countries. Small enclaves of elvenoids made homes here that weren’t found anywhere else in the world. This little village we’d stumbled across was the home of some kappa. Imagine a large turtle with intelligence and thumbs that walked on two legs.

Iona hopped back after a few minutes.

“Kobi here gave me directions to the next place. Do you want to do a quick healing pass?” She asked.

“Yeah!” I hopped off Fenrir and rose into the air, not bothering to go through the whole ‘mime explaining what I wanted to do before slowly going through the process’. I just blitzed through the village in an instant, using the same combination of skills that I’d used in Osengard. There was a nasty case of pneumonia in one baby, and I fixed one man’s cracked shell that had never healed quite right.

“Good to go!” I landed back on Fenrir’s back as a gale of snow whipped through the town, the wind finally catching up to what I’d done.

Iona took off, and I swear Fenrir tried to whip up an even larger snowstorm. Rivalry? Or working on his Storm element?

=================

Iona managed to get us to Kuri in a few days, her [Relentless Pursuit] skill leveling up as well as her [Traveling Archer] class. She also managed to quickly track down where Narukami Akamaru was located, and we quickly found ourselves in a hot spring.

“Oooh, this is nice.” I said as the heat washed over us. I liked a little bit of snow, but I was rapidly discovering that I was not a fan of prolonged cold at all. Rainbow snakes were tropical creatures, and I’d upped my nerve sensitivity. It wasn’t important that my new biology was a little more vulnerable to the cold… and for all the freezing I’d done, getting somewhere warm was all the nicer.

Iona made some appreciative noises as well.

“Maybe once all this is over, we can spend some time here together?” She asked with a cheeky wink.

“Sure!”

Iona navigated us through the various levels of people, all while I enjoyed the hot steam.

“They’re in one of the smaller baths.” She finally said. “Do we want to join them, or wait?”

“They?” I asked. “Thought it was just one?”

“He’s got some friends with him.” Iona explained.

Ah, yeah, that made sense.

“I’ll be honest, joining them or waiting seems to be a question that you’re much better at answering than I am.” I said, trying to make the right decision in spite of my excitement. I was almost vibrating with anticipation. I could meet someone else from Earth!

I knew my normal social graces were more likely to sink the initial impression than anything, so I deferred it to the person who actually liked that sort of thing.

Iona shrugged.

“Why wait? Let’s go say hi.”

I held Iona’s hand so I didn’t sprint forward in my excitement - it was frowned upon to do that sort of thing here, and I needed the solid physical marker to ground me.

Towels were the outfit of the day for the pool, and I froze as we were changing.

“Uh.” I paused, a little awkward, tuning down my senses as far as [The World Around Me] would go. I wasn’t a peeper or any sort of pervert.

“What’s up?” Iona paused.

“They sound busy in there. Why don’t we wait for them?” I internally grumbled as I got dressed again. I wanted to take a dip in the hot springs!

Later.

Iona laughed, and gave me another cheeky grin.

Goddesses, I loved that grin. It did things to me.

“Just have to wait I guess!”

==========================================

I spent the time uncomfortably waiting. There was only so much tuning down my senses I could do, and they were not trying to be subtle at all. Pretty sure it was fairly rude, but this wasn’t my place, this wasn’t my culture.

Iona tried to distract me with various plans, which only somewhat succeeded. I was too nervous, too impatient, and too willing to use [Parallel Thoughts] to my detriment.

I could see my relentless tap tap tap of my feet on the floor was driving Iona nuts, but she was nice enough to not say anything. She knew I was being restrained, but I just had to tap.

Finally, finally I heard footsteps and wingbeats heading towards the door. I patted Iona’s arm furiously as I stood up, expanding my sphere of perception and senses once again.

They washed over the people about to come back in. One dude, seven women. The guy looked like a human, which wasn’t a given with Papilion having offered me a chance to become a golden crow. Then there was a werewolf, harpy, yuki-onna, dryad, minotaur, catkin, and goblin. The yuki-onna looked vaguely familiar, but I couldn’t put my finger on why. Skye was the only other yuki-onna I knew, was there some sort of resemblance? Or was it simply a snowflake-like delicate look that they all shared?

“Goblin. Looks friendly enough.” I muttered quietly to Iona, giving her the heads up. She was not a fan of the little green gremlins, and given her history, I wasn’t surprised.

Then he walked into the room, followed by the rest of his group. His eyes widened as he saw us, and he said something that instantly got Iona all stone-faced and looking pissed. Then as fast as the emotions appeared, her face smoothed over and she replied in English.

“No thank you. We heard a rumor you might be from Earth?” She said.

The dude’s eyes widened up, but before he could say anything the harpy - only level 189, nothing special - shrieked and launched herself at us, flapping her wings and battering Iona, who basically just ignored her.

“What’d he say before?” I asked quickly in Creation under the beating wings, swaying back to avoid getting smacked by one.

“He was excited to see a ‘pair of smoking hot babes’ and wanted to know if we would join ‘the hero’s harem’.” Iona answered with clear disgust. “His actual name’s Jake Jason.”

Ew. She had better self control than I did. I might’ve just walked right out, mission or not.

“Yellow here’s yelling about ‘how dare we turn him down’ and ‘he’s the best’ and other such nonsense.” Iona added in as the rest of the party tried to talk Yellow down.

I didn’t think it was her name, but of course they all had different hair colors. I suspected that was the so-called hero’s doing, and not natural.

After talking down Yellow, and a whole three rounds of discussion, we agreed on a better place to chat, and found a language that enough of us spoke.

English, of all things. Jake only knew Yayoi and English. Some members of his… harem, ew, just saying it made me feel squicky - spoke it, ‘to better impress the hero’, and with Iona’s blessing, it made it the strongest language.

It took a bit of shuffling around, and an utterly inane argument/fight about who got to sit next to Jake, but we finally got down to business in a tea shop. Most of the girls were dressed normally, but the minotauress was in a maid’s outfit for some ungodly reason.

“You two chicks from Earth or something?” He opened the conversation up with that, staring at Iona’s chest. I crossed my arms over my chest. Iona shook her head.

“Just me.” I said. “Heard something that made me think you were as well?”

Jake’s eyes lit up.

“Yeah! But this place is totally cool. It’s like a magic Japan! They even have rice and soy sauce!”

“Master is the best ~ nya!” The catkin draped herself over Jake, and my eyes narrowed as something clicked.

“Slaves? Really?”

Forget recruiting this asshole, maybe there was a nice prison we could throw him into.

“Whoa! She’s cool with it!” Jake protested.

Iona and I traded a Look. She gave me a tiny shake of her head.

Fine. If Iona didn’t think it was worth making a huge fuss over right this second, I wasn’t going to. I wasn’t going to lie to Arachne at the end of the mission, but right now my personal needle was set dead to ‘throw into a lake and figure out if there was a way to delete memories’.

“How’d you come here?” Iona diplomatically asked, changing the subject. I just sat and fumed, keeping my eye from twitching.

“Got wasted by truck-kun. Some goddess told me that the world needed a [Hero], shoved my soul into a practically dead body, and here I am! Living my best life.” He eyed us up again and got an idea.

“Hey! We need a healer with us, and two for the price of one? I wouldn’t say no to being crushed between your thighs!” He leered at Iona.

I could see Iona’s toes digging in through the floorboard as she tried to remain civil.

“We’re representing the Exterreri Empire. We’d like to extend an offer for you to come settle in over there, and we’re empowered to offer you significant incentives to join.”

Dear goddesses, I had no idea how Iona managed to stay on-task like that. Her social skills had to be capping out like crazy in the background. I would’ve already put him through a wall.

Jake clicked his tongue and did finger guns at the two of us.

“I want something from you, you want something from me, I’m sure we can make something work!”

One of the girls protested.

“But then there’s less of you for meeeeeeee!” She whined, and quickly swapped languages to let everyone else know what was going on.

“Why do you even like this guy?” I asked in pure confusion. Nothing - nothing - about him was attractive in any way, shape, or form. I just couldn’t see it.

“Because he’s so nice.” The seven girls said in eerie chorus, nevermind I wasn’t sure if half of them understood me.

I glanced at Iona with no small amount of concern while Jake was trying to reassure everyone else that there was more than enough of him to go around, with quite a few crude gestures. Mind magic wasn’t supposed to be a thing, but he clearly had some sort of divine fuckery going on. Her eyes unfocused, communing with her goddesses.

“Just a shareable experience buff.” She snapped back and explained.

[Warrior - 420].

Not much of an experience buff, was it?

Actually - depended on when he came over, and his current age. If it was only a few years ago, that was an insane pace. Such bullshit! I got smacked around with having large chunks of my memories removed, and Jake got a fucking buff!? A shareable buff!?

I had a brief, heretical, blasphemous thought, wondering how hard it’d be to kill a god, before purging the idea entirely. The gods could clearly hear prayers in the privacy of my mind, I didn’t want to give anyone any ideas about smiting me.

I took a deep breath and tried to refocus and center myself.

I didn’t have to like the guy. I had a job to do, and I was going to do it to the best of my abilities.

Within reason. I was not letting him get anywhere near me. I had standards, and I’d rather fail the mission first.

I’d focus on that. My curiosity was secondary. Once we’d figured out if he was coming or not, we could chat about Earth. I had so many questions.

Although… hmmm… wouldn’t making some sort of connection first be a good idea? Would that make him more amenable to moving? It sounded like a good idea to me…

I glanced at Iona, raising a questioning eyebrow, trying to communicate my question. By some magic known only to Iona, she figured out what I wanted and nodded.

“What year was it when you came over? And where are you from?” I asked.

Jake and I started comparing notes, and it was surprising. The date he left was just a few short years from the last date I remembered. Which was weird to me.

Had whatever happened to my soul caused it to drift through the currents of time? Had it been involved in Samsara, the great cycle not caring about when a person was reincarnated (or so some monks claimed)? Or did Jake’s own divine meddling cause him to be blasted forward?

Could the different worlds be operating at different effective speeds? That didn’t quite make sense to me - I felt like some fundamentals would break if that were the case, but I couldn’t point to an easy example - but hey, it was magic, it didn’t have to make perfect sense.

In spite of my faint hopes, he’d had no idea about me or my family. No news from anyone I knew. The world had just… continued to turn after I’d died. Oh, it sounded like everything had gone to shit, but didn’t it always?

A nice thing about news and information on Pallos - I wasn’t constantly bombarded with how things were terrible all over the world. Just small, local woes that were more gossip than anything else.

Jake’s background was unfortunate. He claimed to be a misunderstood genius who couldn’t decide if he wanted to broker peace in the Middle East, revolutionize mathematics, or create a new genre of music that would be famous world-wide.

“Of course, my teachers misunderstood me.” He confided. “Kicked me out. It’s just so hard being so smart, you wouldn’t understand.”

Iona’s fingers twitched like she wanted to strangle him. Only my [Oath] prevented me from cheerfully joining her.

Jake’s… dubious sense of his own intelligence made most of his ideas and information suspect. Global information systems, perpetual motion machines, anti-matter, which was like the opposite of matter… somehow… Die-Sun spheres - the name alone had me frowning - something about perfect free markets, cellphones, and a hundred other ideas that spewed out like a firehose. I swear he was making words up to sound impressive.

Attempts to gain any sort of details usually ended poorly.

“What’s a gamma ray burst?” I asked.

“Oh, it kills everyone, instantly. Bang! Every single living thing, dead!”

Iona couldn’t keep the obvious question to herself.

“So how are you alive?” She asked. Jake rolled his eyes.

“Duh! It’s never happened!”

How would it happen?”

“Well, a bunch of gamma rays would come, and kill everyone.” Jake said very slowly, like he was talking to a small child.

I was half suspecting this was a test by Arachne to see if I could keep my cool. Never before had the self imposed shackles of my [Oath] been so keenly felt.

I almost - almost - missed Kerberos, my once-fiance.

Some of the things Jake talked about made no sense to me at all, and given his surprise, I suspected they were at the heart of what Papilion had stripped from me.

“Wait, you don’t know what nukes are?” Jake asked with utter disbelief. “Are you sure you’re from Earth? Everyone knows what nukes are. You know, Hiroshima, end of World War II, all that?”

I frowned. World War II rang a bell, but either huge parts had been stripped out of my memories, or he was making a bigger deal out of it than it actually was. Given that it was called a World War, I suspected the issue might be on my end.

“I… don’t. What do you know about them?” I asked.

Jake gave a too-confident laugh that Iona frowned at. She twitched a finger, and I divined it to mean ‘absolutely nothing’.

“They destroy cities! Just, boooooooooooom, city gone!” He made explosion noises as his hands mimed a large explosion.

My eye twitched at how utterly useless that was. The only part that was vaguely useful was the fact that pure technology, with no System or anything helping things along, could create such an effect.

Iona could see that I was nearing the end of my rope, and frankly, the whole conversation felt like a bust.

“Is there any amount of money, status, or items that could persuade you to relocate to Exterreri? I know the brothels in Sanguino are quite famous and rather extensive.” Iona offered up.

I suppose, on some level, Jake and Iona were on similar wavelengths. I knew Iona was resisting going out and screwing everyone she wanted to because of me and my desire to be monogamous, and maybe she’d be able to speak his language enough to get him to come over.

That, and he couldn’t stop staring at her chest. There was a part of me that didn’t feel great about it, but I compartmentalized it.

“We’re buying him passage on a ship if he says yes.” I muttered to Iona in Creation. “I am not letting him get close enough to be grabby on Fenrir the whole way back.”

Iona gave me a small nod of vigorous understanding.

“Fenrir would literally eat him halfway through.” She agreed. “Plus, ten people and all their supplies might be too much for a full overseas trip.”

Thank fuck.

Jake snapped his fingers.

“Yes, actually! Apart from everything else you’re willing to give me, you round my party out perfectly for this quest I have!”

Iona and I traded another look. She lifted an eyebrow, and my shoulders slumped.

“What is it?” I asked, managing to keep the despair out of my voice. Of course there’d be a dumb side-quest. It was almost like I was an [Adventurer].

If I had to do it, I had to do it.

“I want to be a [Dragonrider Hero]. I heard rumors of a dragon nearby, and what’s a more perfect companion for a hero than a dragon? Help me steal one of its eggs.”

I froze at his proclamation, biting down on my tongue from saying something inadvisable.

We were going to get so fucked.

“Iona.” I didn’t even bother finishing my tea, jumping up and out of my seat and heading for the door. She instantly got what I wanted, and the two of us headed out of town, just in case.

Jake and his harem followed us.

“Hey! What’s the big idea?” He asked.

“Let’s talk outside the town, okay?” I said.

I was frankly terrified of a dragon deciding to torch the town to the ground. If things were going to escalate - okay, that was a lie, things were already escalating, hard - I wanted as many people out of the way as possible.

I was thinking furiously as we walked, a thousand and one implications tumbling together. I crafted what I thought was a decent sentence, knowing that we were being eavesdropped on.

“There is a dragon nearby if I remember where we are correctly.” I told Iona in a hurried voice. “Kanadaj, the Carmine Fixer. I’m going to do my best to stop anyone from raiding his nest.”

There. Message sent. Someone was after his eggs, and we were working on stopping it. Hopefully the dragon wouldn’t budge unless something happened.

“My [Vow] is active, by the way.” Iona quietly told me. “I must stop Jake, one way or another. I don’t have the option of walking away from this.”

I gave a curt nod of understanding. Just like how my [Oath] could trap me in unfortunate circumstances, so could Iona’s [Vow]. This was blessedly less unfortunate than usual. I was completely on board with stopping Jake’s stupid plan. It was now a higher priority to me than recruiting him, although I’d happily take both wins if I could somehow manage it.

We finished getting out of town.

Fenrir had landed in a beautiful glade next to a half-frozen lake. The trees were dormant for the winter, but in the spring and summer this had to be the place in Kuri.

Iona stopped in the snow as Jake and the rest piled out into the field. Fenrir opened one magnificent eye at them.

“Bitching dragon!” Jake yelled. “That’s what I’m talking about! Got a spare egg or eight?”

Fenrir didn’t have all the social graces. He didn’t need to make nice. He loomed over Jake, brought his face down, and roared.

I clapped my hands over my ears, mentally cursing as all the women were blown away. Somehow, all of them landed in compromising poses, and they had to have done that deliberately.

They were mildly injured though. Blasted [Oath]. I healed them all.

Jake had demonstrated some sort of spine, and only took a few steps back.

“Whoa, yeah! I gotta get me one of these! He for sale?”

Iona looked murderous, and I was entirely inclined to let her go to town. Heck, I could easily spin this to Arachne as ‘too stupid to live’ and ‘prevented a dragon attack’. Might even get a few [Loremaster] levels out of it.

“Fenrir is not a dragon, and not for sale.” Iona patiently explained. “Listen, dragons are dangerous. Not like most creatures and monsters where you can get away with nonsense, dragons are on an entirely different level. They will kill you, eat you, then burn down the closest few towns because they can. We’re talking here, and not in the town, because every time you say ‘dragon’, every single one of them can hear it. If they decide to do something about it, I don’t want thirty thousand civilians caught in the crossfire.”

Not a word of that got through to Jake. He swelled up with pride.

“Your words simply validate how much of a genius I am!” He boasted. “Nobody else would even dare to think it! Yet, I will be the strongest!”

Red - the catkin - jumped in again.

“Nothing but the best for Akamaru ~ nya!” She took the chance to jump on Jake, which of course had the rest of the girls fighting for his attention, and to get their fair share.

“You know what. I think I’m reporting this mission as a failure.” I told Iona as we waited for the gaggle to sort themselves out. Again.

“Thank the goddesses.” Iona sagged in relief. “Is your [Oath] still applying, even with the threat?”

I nodded.

In some ways, our respective restriction skills were at odds with each other. Iona’s demanded that she stop Jake, and violence was likely. Mine demanded that I did no harm, and while he wasn’t trying to directly hurt anyone, I was bound and shackled.

We were on the same wavelength at least, so we weren’t coming into a harsh conflict. I believed that communication would carry the day.

“Even if they were at the entrance to the cave, I couldn’t do anything unless they attacked me first.” I confirmed. “The same logic that lets me detach my healing a [Soldier] who’s going to try and fight someone else, from the harm they will cause there. The same way it doesn’t worry about people I can’t see, also applies here. They wouldn’t be directly attacking me or causing me harm. Just indirectly antagonizing someone else. I’m not great at that.” I admitted.

Iona grinned at me.

“Good thing one of us is, yeah?”

“Yeah. What’s the plan? I don’t want him to die if at all possible. ‘Hi Arachne, I know you sent me to recruit him, but we murdered him instead’ isn’t a good look on my first mission.”

Iona made a sound of agreement. “Ten years from now, that’s all they’ll remember. I can punch down. His antics, level, and plan means he’s far from being considered meek or defenseless, and his class is double [Mirror]. All about borrowing power from the girls. Limited, but with how many he’s got, Jake has a lot of tricks up his sleeves. I think I’ll just slowly escalate with him and see how it goes.”

I patted her shoulder.

“Sorry that my mission is halfway turning into your mission.” I said. Jake and his harem were still sorting themselves out, and I wish I could block my ears at the promises being made between them all.

Iona smiled again.

“You kidding? I’m delighted! I get worried that I’m just tagging along, contributing nothing and being a huge money drain on you. I get concerned about all that. Now I get to basically fix a problem for you? It’s great! That, and I made my [Vow] for a reason. Protecting an entire city? It’s what I swore to do. Imagine if I dragged you to a war zone.”

Well, hey, it took all types.

Jake sorted himself out again, and Iona stepped forward.

“Jake! Listen. Come to Exterreri, and we’ll figure out a wyvern’s egg on top of everything else. Can’t let you go after a dragon, but the image is the same.”

Jake blew a raspberry.

“Wyvern, smyvern. Dragon or bust! Dragon or bust!” He started chanting, his backstage dancers soon picking up the chant.

“It’s a stupid idea. Is there anything we can do to get you to change your mind?” Iona asked. Her mallium was starting to spread across her body and down her limbs, still hidden by her tunic, but she was getting ready for a fight.

Red jumped forward again, power posing with not nearly enough clothing for the weather.

“You take that back! Akamaru is an unparalleled, once in a thousand years genius ~ nya!”

Something about that seemed to give Jake an idea. He got a sly look I didn’t like.

“Okay! Let’s duel! Me versus you. If you win, we’ll stop. If we win, you’ll go out to dinner with us. I’m sure I’ll win you two lovely ladies over.” He flashed us what he probably thought was a charming smile, and just made it feel like spiders were crawling over my back.

Iona looked at me. I grimaced and nodded.

“Fine.” She agreed. “When do we start?”

The two worked out the fine details, which was to say - in just a few minutes.

Iona and Jake went to separate sides of the field. Armor coated the Valkyrie, and she retrieved her glaive, shield, and axe from Fenrir’s gear bags.

Jake put on some questionably light armor, then held his hand out. There was a snap-hiss as a curved blade of glowing red Radiance sprang to life. He swung the blade a few times experimentally in front of him.

I pinched my nose.

A lightsaber-katana. I don’t know why I expected anything else.

“Watch the blade.” I murmured to Iona. “It should cut through most things. Aim for a dodge, not a block.”

She nodded her thanks.

“Omae wa mou shindeiru.” Jake said right before we began. Iona didn’t translate, but she didn’t look impressed.

“Go!” Orange cheered, and the fight was on.

This fight was almost harder than the Gladiator Gauntlet duels. Iona didn’t want to kill the obnoxious brat, and there were no protective shields here.

She shot across the snowy shield in an instant. Jake tried to do an Artemis, and blasted Iona with sustained Lightning coming from his off-hand.

“Unlimited P-” He got out as Iona completely ignored his attack, ducked under a wild, amateur strike - seriously, I could swing a sword better than that and I had almost no training in long blades - and punched him.

Lightly. Gently.

With a gauntleted fist.

It went through his pathetic excuse of armor, and I could hear his sternum breaking as his entire chest caved in. He went flying back to his gaggle, who cooed over him. Green popped out a potion and poured it into his mouth.

Unfair! Foul!

Jake sprang up.

“All according to keikaku!” He declared.

“That’s outside interference.” Iona’s voice was colder than the weather. She did not like dishonorable actions.

The warning rattle in Iona’s voice was completely dismissed by Jake.

“My friends are my power! With the power of love, we will-”

Iona didn’t wait to hear the rest. She grabbed him by the hair and spun. Round and round she went, until she let him go like a discus. He spun over and over in the air, arcing above the lake, before landing with a mighty splash.

Iona hummed a war tune as she got her bow out and a few arrows. She nocked the arrow, pulled it back, and fired it.

Way, way over his head.

Then she rapidly fired a second arrow, they collided in midair, and both went straight for Jake. Good [Trick Shot] practice.

Both arrows ended up in his feet, a testament to Iona’s skill. A carefully calculated blow to let him know he was in trouble, that Iona could kill and sink him at any time, but not enough to hinder his return if he promptly gave up. He sank a little further, but could keep swimming.

“Surrender?” Iona asked.

“Never!” Jake yelled.

Four arrows later, and he was shouting his surrender. He was losing steam fast, and sank under the icy water right as he was about to get to shore.

“Do we fish him out, or…?” I asked Iona. She sighed.

“Maybe?” She started to approach the edge as all the women ran over.

There was an eruption of water as Jake and another lady exploded out of the lake.

“Oh Fated King,” The Lady of the Lake Spoke, her voice echoing in an ethereal and magical way. “Oh destined [Hero]. Take this sword, and become king. Rule the world, wisely and justly.” She offered him a jewel-encrusted greatsword, glowing runes in a language I didn’t know etched down the blade.

I threw my hands up in disgust.

“You have got to be fucking kidding me!” I shouted as his harem cheered.

Jake stepped forward, extending his hands out to the sword.

“Tha-” was the last word he got out.

In a single swift motion, the rest of the oversized anglerfish erupted out of the water, the lady of the lake lure on the end of its tendril whipping away as row upon row of pointy teeth closed around the hero. In a single grinding motion, he was gone, and the fish submerged itself once again.

[*ding!* Your party has participated in slaying a [Harem Hero (Mirror - 420)// [The Main Character] (Mirror, 369)]]

[*ding!* [Ancient Loremaster of Legend] has leveled up! 183 -> 190. +100 Dexterity, +100 Vitality, +800 Mana, +800 Mana Regen, +1600 Magic Power, +1600 Magic Control from your Class per level! +1 Strength, +1 Dexterity, +1 Speed, +1 Vitality, +1 Mana, +1 Mana Regeneration, +1 Magic Power, +1 Magic Control for being Chimera (Elvenoid)! +1 Mana, +1 Magic Power from your Element per level!]

Averting an epic threat from manifesting was solidly in [Loremaster’s] domain, and dealing with Jake’s quest to disturb a dragon clearly counted. I’d been a little more on the edges than I would’ve liked - the fish solved the problem, Iona strongly contributed, and I was on a third order effect at best - but a dragon was potent enough that it trickled over nicely.

I checked the fish.

[Anglerfish - 1871]

That was a mean one, and Iona took a few short hops back.

“Well. I can’t say I’m sad to see him go.” She said as she got back.

“Best of all, we didn’t do it!” I agreed. “Home?” I asked. After all the nonsense today, I was in no mood to explore Nippon-Koku. Forget their magic, forget their books, I just wanted to be warm and safe in my own bed again. After about a four hour long hot bath.

Iona looked around.

“Home.” She agreed.

Red - the catkin - whirled on us, and I expected a tearful tirade, maybe a vow to figure out a way to reanimate him or something. Instead, she started cussing up a storm, quickly joined by some of the others. I only understood what Red was saying, but given the body language of the rest of them, they probably had similar thoughts. I’d have to ask Iona later.

“Fuck!” She swore, ripping off her collar in a single easy motion and hurling it into the lake. “Do you know how much bullshit I had to put up with for that sweet, sweet experience boost!? Nya~ this and nya~ that, and now he’s fucking dead!? Such bullshit!”

Comments

Chapter was not per se. But it being comedy is an utter fail.

MrMegaPussyPlayer .

I disagree with people not liking the hero. He was an idiot and I liked that part of him.

shaun

That was really good

shaun

That ending makes me think of https://swordscomic.com/comic/IX/

Ben

I wonder if time dilation is the reason not much time passed on earth. Something like the planet has less gravity compared to earth and/or is moving far slower than Earth. Both low gravity and velocity would lead to Earth experiencing time far slower than people on the planet

Foxner

That the goblin knew the story of Princess Kaguya but not how any technology works reminds me of the liberal arts majors I knew in college that couldn't make change but could recite MacBeth from memory.

Nobody

Is the fish a Bleach reference?

Pratish Sungum

He prolly only has surface level knowledge of anything at best, so not a threat as far a knowledge goes.

Pratish Sungum

They wanted others to join so they had to deal with him less! This is honestly brilliant

elijah pickett

I think my main dislike of this chapter is that it had too much of a monster (harem seeking antagonist??) of the week vibe instead of the rest of this story's vibe. i feel like a lot more happened in the interlude chapter and this just felt like filler since they encountered a carcature and he died as a gag, when elaine in the first part, her culmination of effort basically resulted in more women's rights, and it didnt even seem to connect to her past. further she seemed wholely uninterested in even figuring out what knowledge was ripped from her and why and finally, given how wanton he acted i doubt there will be any real consequences from this mission, as this might arguably be one of the best resolutions for exterrari hes not a looming risk of somehow inventing nukes and he isnt a landmine who might set off a dragon or worse in exterarri.

John

That was a cameo. Kana picked that name.

matt

The mango minions put in a ton of suggestions for the cringiest isekai lmfao.

matt

Second this

a passing Fnord

I think he found out anyway that there is always a bigger fish.

Lorcogoth

So, yeah, this chapter fell a little flat—at least from the comedy side of things. Perhaps most primarily, that’s because this chapter is from Elaine’s POV. Elaine is analytical, detail-oriented, and strong-moralled. Her character just doesn’t take well to comedy—at least, the random satiric slapstick off-the-wall comedy seen in xianxia or harem stories. Unexplainable stuff happens in a harem? Fly on the wall. Unexplainable stuff happens to Elaine? She holds it at radiancepoint until it explains itself. Situational or ironic comedy still works well with her, but if you were shooting for satire, I think it makes much more sense for Jake to be the POV.

Auburn Meadow

I think you have a very fair analysis. Jumping off of it, it would be interesting if Iona and Elaine took a second now to go "what the hell was that?" and now that the farce is over perform a deep dive into what went down. The theater companies and their connection to our harem king, the dangerous angler fish, the fallout of the brainwashed sex slaves as they snap out of the long months of being influenced. It would serve as an introduction and might hint towards a different power at work. Like a malevolent god/wizard summoning questionable people or something. I don't know. I heard writing advice recently that was people reading your stuff are always right about what is wrong with the story but are never right about how to fix it and that resonated with me.

Valderan

It seems to me that an author can’t satisfy everyone. I hope you write what feels fun and compelling to you and the readers will just come along for the ride. I liked the satire approach. I think it is true that there was a fair amount of build-up to something that resolved itself so rapidly. I don’t believe we learned why and how the theater performance came into existence in Exterri. Also, shouldn’t Iona have been able to read his stat sheet and determined it mind control was in action?

Austin lloyd

As others have said, I thought the chapter in itself was fine. What felt odd and off was the tone and timing. This was Elaine's first mission as an Exterreri Sentinel, her chance to show that she can still handle this stuff and get back in the groove. Now look back at her first mission as a Remus Sentinel and see how different the tone is. In Remus she ended up having to fight for her life and earned the respect of her peers. Here, she did... nothing and ostensibly failed her mission. Now, it's entirely possible that Jake is a red herring and that there's another person from Earth out there being much more discreet. In fact, I think that's probably likely since Jake didn't seem like the sort of person to either care or remember enough of a play to introduce it to Pallos. But unless/until we find that out it seems weird to have spent so much time building up a possible meeting/confrontation with someone else from Earth only to make them a caricature and then kill them off immediately. Did you decide you had too many pending plotlines and decided to cut this one off? I'd much rather you let things like this fade into the background than quickly tying them off like this. Finally, Elaine and Iona seem WAY too unconcerned at the end about a monster that's over three times their level that just demonstrated it will lure and eat people. They should be escaping as fast as they can instead of casually thinking about what they want to do later.

Matt H

Seems like a waste of the build up. I'm either hoping the whole thing was a gag and tomorrow we get the start of their real adventure, or there's some second Earthling running around (that we'll get back to in the future), and you just needed Elaine and Iona away from home for a few days while Artemis and Julian showed up.

Jay Kominek

Amusing as a once in awhile chapter as a break in the serious. I enjoyed the chapter and honestly think as a creative flexing of a new idea/skill, this is a fine practice. I think it and the lead-up stuff would make a fun little side story.

Jim Moak

I liked the chapter, it shows the gods can and maybe have brought more people from Earth, and it must not cost much if they're making comic relief "heroes" when there's no need for one. Give some actual useful info while also parodying the oversaturated mess that is the isekai/transmigration genre like Cultivators were before.

Nobody

It fits as long as it doesn't become the norm, the gods were established as being a bit all over the place personality wise and now that "normal" people can join their ranks they're bound to be even more off the wall. It could be that some goddess was bored and wanted to recreate a bad isekai from Earth since they can clearly see at least some of what goes on over there.

Nobody

Where the stories his famely history the way he told them? That would totaley fit him.

Håvard

So I will agree that the chapter was funny, but I think the major problem is the genre shift. This entire novel has not been a parody, it has been a serious take on fantasy. Having a sudden break to completely change tone is disruptive I will agree. That said, I welcome you trying new things, stretching your skills, and exploring the space.

‘Will It Work’ Dansicker

Hope the next hero fares better!

Joppest

Uff, hard letdown. Not really funny and weird chapter. Maybe delete and rewrite? Sorry :S I love btdm but this... Please, just No.

Bagknigehard

Another more general disappointment... I was greatly looking forward to an alternate view of Pallos, from someone with a similar background but who underwent a significantly different experience from Elaine. Commiseration, philosophical discussions, maybe even a new friend. It almost feels like what should have been a significant event got replaced by a cheap joke. It is my recommendation, if you do want this chapter to be canon, for there to be TWO people from Earth. One is making a living as a playwright, while the other is this idiot who somehow lucked into his current level. Maybe because the other one kept bailing him out of trouble.

Gremlin Jack

My one disappointment is I was looking forward to this idiot learning how small a fish he is in how big a pond. Unfortunately, he's too dead to remember the lesson.

Gremlin Jack

Loved it. Great chapter 👍

P3t1

I found this chapter amusing overall and thought parts of it were pretty good, but I feel like there was a definite rough patch that drags it down overall (though definitely nowhere near to the point that I'd even remotely consider it the worst chapter, like some other commenters). In particular, I think it was going reasonably well up until somewhere around "One of the girls protested." After that, things got rough until rapidly recovering starting around "Iona could see that I was nearing the end of my rope, and frankly, the whole conversation felt like a bust." I'm definitely not in the camp that thinks this whole chapter needs to be totally reworked or discarded, but there seems like a lot of potential for some changes in this area to significantly improve the chapter as a whole. I think a big chunk of the issue in that section is that while the overall portrayal of it being mystifying that the guy could attract such an enthusiastic harem is core to the humor of the situation, it really seemed like the scene was badly overplaying its proverbial hand with establishing that. Also, while I do think it's fair to basically immediately resolve this dangling thread in one chapter despite teasing it for a while (not all threads need to take a long time to wrap up once you get to them), it does seem odd for the presentation of the "hero" to be so completely at odds with having been able to spread a story Elaine could so easily recognize. If you do attempt an edit, one possible change that I think could help with both of those concerns would be to do something along the lines of switching out the "Because he's so nice." chunk with something where the harem members start trying to go on about how great his stories are, and then slightly recasting the discussion of Earth portion as completely undercutting their claim (while the harem nonetheless is hanging on his every word - maybe move the double-checking about no mind control bit to be a response to that instead).

Andrew K

Kinda funny for a change of pace. But I'm rather concerned about the whole thing. Though it could be nice foreshadowing for some kind of "Hero Invasion" or some God going a bit too far with their nonsense and Elaine somehow getting involved via Iona.

Jeanean

Threw me off kilter but after the last chapter I’m glad they’ll be headed home sooner than later and he totally got what he deserved

H

i think the general reception is bad- whether this would justify a rewrite or not is up to you but this was frankly...

Phoenix M.

Bit of a letdown that the other one from Earth was just a delusional moron delivering all horrible anime cliches and gets offed in a terrible manner. Keep your good work up tho :)

Cypha

A bit of a shit post but a funny one. 9/10

DireGoat

Yeah, this was... funny but a bit of a letdown. As others have alluded to there was a decent amount of buildup to 'another earthling' that could have led in a lot of different directions especially if they hadn't been limited in the same way Elaine was. So while I do appreciate the cliché being appropriately put to rest I do think it's a missed opportunity.

Reid Palmquist

Rather meh, tbh. First other person from Earth Elaine meets - something that was notable when she discovered he existed - and it's just kinda... thrown away for a gag. It felt like you were writing this just to write it, rather than out of any actual desire. Guy shows up, is a creep for twenty minutes, Elaine and Iona are mad because he's a creep, then he dies out of nowhere with no build-up and both MCs shrug it off and go on with their lives with no impact and no reaction on them. Humor was fine, good in moderation. I'm mostly disappointed that it just feels so low-quality.

DowagerOfVeils

Hm, I liked the chapter.. On one hand it is sad that we didn't get to explore Nippon-Koku a bit more, on the other we get to go back to more exciting stuff. I think this was far better than dragging it out given that it isn't its own arc.

Robin Berglund

As much as i enjoyed the angler fish, it will forever be a tragedy that it was not a catfish.

Daniel B

I'll agree with all the others that this chapter didn't land for me, and is easily the worst BTDEM chapter I can remember. I thought the majority of the humor was weak, and it felt like such a shift in tone from the majority of the story that it didn't make sense. There was a healthy amount of narrative build up to this event, and throwing away this mysterious other Earth native, and Elaine's first mission back, is disappointing. There's also a huge dissonance between the character that was portrayed and someone who is apparently also a renowned playwright. He's painted as a moron, but apparently his weeb-ness is the shotgun variety of equally knowing anime references and classical japanese plays? This quality of writing is the kind I'll stumble upon on Royal Road every now and again, and drop before the chapter's over.

andrew

I really liked this chapter. It was funny and relevant to the story, it made fun of one of my biggest pet peeves in stories (heroes with harems), and best of all it was short and sweet! Thank you @Selkie

Julie

I would have liked to see his reaction to that

Phsteven

He was too dumb to need the memory deletion. Pretty sure guy was just a massive weeb. Elaine went to college and took physics classes. With the knowledge she would have had from those classes alone she would have turned the world on its head more than she already did.

Phsteven

I had so many ideas and predictions of what would happen while Elaine and Iona were away... Only for them to have the shortest trip imaginable. Ah well, I found this funny TBH. Thank you for the chapter!

Hollow Marthon

Correct me if I'm misunderstanding you, but you're saying Selkie needs to research more bad isekai tropes? I've read some iseksi that are atleast this bad not in parody form.I see the slave thing more as a shot against those types of stories than trying to be funny. *Cough* Shield Hero *Cough* I don't think it's at all inappropriate to post this to a peatreon. Should not be included in the actual book version for obvious reasons.

kyle

Do you think it would work if the harem snaps out of their mind control and actually has something valid to contribute or do you think it needs to be reworked from the ground up? There might be some value in exploring the damage of surrounding yourself with yes men who feed into your fantasy and cause a spiral?

Valderan

While I agree your sentiment, he didn't have to be such a twit in the first place. This feels like the potential of a possibly interesting side character with interesting implications was wasted in favor a one-off gag character.

fox5s

Pretty sure that it was just a hilt, and he was using a radiance skill to make the blade. Not to mention that the fish probably ate it.

Kennyevilmonkey

I feel like this was a total waste of time and potential to boot. It sucked to find out the character was a creep, but it also sucked even more to find out that nothing about this was favorable for any of our protagonists. This was a filler arc in an anime, and that's worse than any one thing in the chapter. I think you can do better and got caught up in an idea that did not help your story. I'm not a satire writer. I don't have input from that area, but what I do have is the input that this chapter did a disservice to your overall narrative.

Malir Blackspear

I'm only slightly amused. The chapter had its moments, but was extremely cringe at others. I don't mind experiments though. All in all, it would've been better placed as something outside the canon as a Patreon benefit or the like. PS: Never reveal insecurity in front of the audience - some people love to jump for the jugular when they sense weakness.

gostsamo

Yeah, that's about how I feel about it. It was amusing but felt like wasted potential.

fox5s

Agreed. As a bonus side chapter it's weird and amusing but I don't think it fits as part of the main story.

Benjamin Smith

Total miss for me. This would have been better as a side chapter. Like a very brief unexpected encounter during some travels. I feel like Elaine and got hyped for no reason.

Lock

Have to say, I actually laughed out loud several times reading this. So good job on that! All in all a fun read, wouldn't mind having something like this once in a while.

Kota

This is where I am on it as well. While I did find it amusing, I also found it a wasted potential. There was enough build-up that I had not expected such such a one-off gag character. I'd probably be a lot more upset if the foreword hadn't tempered my expectations.

fox5s

Some ideas: 1 - He was too much of an idiot to do any serious harm with his memories, because he never memorizes anything important or useful. For instance, he remembers the existence of an Atomic Bomb and its ffect, but knows nothing about how it works. Elaine, on the other hand, might have known and remembered enough to do serious damage. 2 - He got a buff because he's a moron and needs all the help he can get in order to survive, and evidently, even that wasn't enough. XP is no substitute for a brain. 3 - The god wasn't as careful as Papillion in checking what danger the "hero" might do. I mean, they chose this buffoon as their destined hero, so unless they had no choice, maybe they aren't the brightest buld in the pantheon. One thing I will disagree on is him being killed off too quickly. Yes, this way he won't have much impact, but I think that's a good thing - while he's amusing in the short term, long term I think he would've been grating. Allowing a character like that to have any meaningful sway over the story would take it in a radically different direction. Plus, it was an incredibly cathartic way to end the chapter after all his antics.

Kota

I don't really think anything about this chapter was particularly funny. There are a lot of ways to be tongue in cheek towards your typical isekai protagonist, just look at Konosuba, but this was a total miss. Elaine has huge issues with slavery. But we get an implied "Some of his harem members are slaves," That is not funny. It's deeply and profoundly fucked up, actually. Not only does our POV not find this funny, neither is the audience in her head space. People make sex jokes all the time, and some of them are even good, but having this "Hero," make several sloppy passes at both Elaine and Iona, consistently, over and over again was fairly gross. Especially for a story that typically avoids this, likely due to no real confidence in writing anything approaching sexual tension in the first place. What's not in this paragraph? Funny. Everything to do with the harem felt like a lazy skim of a few mangas with harems and their summaries with a equally lazy pass of a character archetype wiki for how these characters act in groups. I'm sure you could crack a funny joke or two with a harem that isn't just how they fell in compromising positions (about the only joke that kind of hit for me in all this), but based on the way this was written, I can't see it. Again, I don't see an attempt at humor. If I'm charitable, I see laziness. If I'm less charitable, I see contempt. If you can't write what you know, then doing research about it enough that you can pull it off is the bare minimum. Put into consideration the kind of marathon hours it sounds like you, Selkie, and almost every other web serial author does and I'd say that it's kind of an instant deal breaker to even include. The time does not seem to be there for research, and when something is handled this poorly with an audience that may even consume the material, its just not going to go well. If the goal was to make fun of dumb isekai troupes, this was an incredible failure, and mostly trends on the story itself largely being inoffensive the majority of the time to avoid greater pushback. If the goal was to gauge how well you write humor in general, then, I don't know what to say other than nothing in this chapter was worth mentioning as funny when compared to how much was not funny at all.

Jasper

Okay count me into this was a bad chapter and a bad idea on itself. Itr comes from nowhere goes nowhere and leaves nothing behind and while I did found the joke funny, in itself it was just petty mean spirited jab at a strawman, mainly becauser at the end of the day Elaine is the same type of hero just significantly better written, so it felt just like punching down. The whole concept very much is first strike in three strkes, because until now the story was good enough at avoiding this type of punching down and if similar things will repeat there is not much point in reading it. Reframing it as something that happened before Eleaine and co arrived might work better, but as it stands now it very much is just badly written chapter.

zorb25

I think the chapter overall was fine though I think that the other earther was killed off a little too quickly to have much impact. One that I do have a question about is about why he still has his memories and a buff. Is due to his having stuffed into a more fully matured body compared to the protagonist. Or is it something else

Hunter Schleich

Personally, I enjoyed it. Loved the ending as I was so ready to jump into the page myself and bitch-slap that twit!

Kai Elanzo

TBH I think you hit tragedy more than comedy. The "main hero" at the peak of his power allows his own ego to bring about his downfall. Comedy usually doesn't get resolved in a death. Resolution comes about in an absurd manner after a series of misunderstandings and plausible, but unlikely, events. So, amusing, but not quite comedy. I'd also suggest reworking the chapter to be more serious. Don't necessarily care if "Jake" ends up dead, but maybe make the story itself more plot adjacent.

Wizard Tim

Wouldn’t mind a few chapters like this every now and then. Easy to bite my teeth in and enjoy. A kind of palate cleanser

Chris_T

I actually loved this chapter, the guy was a stark contrast to what is considered normal in the writing and the world, just like he was on Earth. Completely delusional weaboo hero gets waffle stomped and murked in one chapter. Reminds me of filler episodes.. in anime...

Low Dudgeon

ah yes, the out of season Aprils foul chapter. Personally i didn't hate it but ....

Han Pol

A chapter like this should definitely be a one-off thing. I found it funny, because I went in with expectation of being something ridiculous. The angler fish was good, because it was a HARD reminder that this is not that kind of story. Some tart in a pond isn't just going to give you a sword and make you king, it's a fucking high level fish looking for a free meal, and idiots are on the menu. All in all though I'm sort of the opinion that this chapter should probably be deleted and replaced, or simple become a footnote as her first mission becomes a Pastos 2. I enjoyed it, it just felt like a waist. Jake had a lot of potential to be an interesting side character, an artist trying to bring culture from Earth. Making his living by creating plays and stories from Earth. Much like a callback to Elaine's early days in the Rangers. Instead he got turned into a gag character and killed off for a joke. At the end of the day this is just a recommendation, I already find the comedic elements of your story to be more than funny enough. Like when Night got 'mugged,' that was comedy gold.

Kennyevilmonkey

Hope they swiped the lightsaber before they left

Anonymous

It wasn't Shakespeare, I think it was a Japanese folk tale.

NondescriptGamer

Konosuba is god-teir. Takes the harem isakai trope, bends it over its knee and turns it into a master work of satire comedy.

Kennyevilmonkey

Frustrating and/or annoying readers is… actually an important tool for authors. It's part of why crowd participation writing can be a problem if an author is too prone to wanting to ALWAYS make people happy. Although it's worth pointing out that usually, frustration is a powerful tool as a form of tension, while annoyance has to be very carefully handled as there's a much finer line before it backfires badly. With that said, I'm pretty sure my eye was twitching at the Lady of the Lake part, until it got better instead of worse. Which eye? Probably both. Even with that twist to end it, I'm not sure the redemption of him getting eaten makes up for just how… teeth on chalkboard… everything was. I know the aim was comedy, but this was less amusing than it was horribly grating with a punchline of relief. Which, granted, is considered a form of comedy but some. But it's a little too close to that asshat guy thing (fine, some women do it too, but not to be overly sexist, in my experience it's mostly been men) of being an ass and then going "hey I was just joking, can't you take a joke?!?" for comfort. Beyond that, I'm having real trouble fitting this characterized Jake with someone who remembers anything well enough to pass out completed plays that actually perform decently. Even if they're his favorite anime or manga or light novel (because the idea of him being into traditional plays seems a bit preposterous, and I can't remember how the play previously featured was characterized), even if he manages to remember them well enough when he can't seem to hold even the slightest other thought together, he doesn't seem basically intelligent enough to write a script to perform, much less do it well. While I'm sure there's a way to handwave that via "the girls", as a reader it's actually my biggest problem with this chapter, other than his classes, as it immediately hits hard on suspension of disbelief, which then back flows against everything else. Because once the screenwriting part doesn't make sense, a lot of other things that don't make sense… really don't make sense, and less in the fun "I wonder what's going on that we're not seeing" way. If I had to offer critical feedback for this, that would actually be my most significant point (other than being concerned that the whole thing with the girls seems very on the edge of squiffy, even if **supposedly** there's no mental manipulation going on via his skills at least… which normally we could trust, but the other things in this chapter that don't fit together/logically to broader fictional consistency work to break that trust too)… he's so far off that he doesn't seem competent to have done what drew attention to him in the first place, and that's worse than just an annoying character who quickly disappears. Making him competent/intelligent enough to (re-)write plays that enjoy a modicum of global success, even by cribbing the source material, seems like it would run into the problem of him actually not then… being quite so self-endingly stupid, but maybe there's a way to make it work?

taswyn

So this is the point I will drop the story once and for all and my main reason for that is this: If you Selkie truly consider THIS CHAPTER "comedy/satire" but just about every other chapter since the "reset" NOT this story sadly won't be for me, you have been throwing comedic tropes and filler-jokes into the story the entire time and it escalated especially during the school-arc I think the first time it really "bothered" me was when the whole "extraction" mission to exterreri came into play that was such an obvious "funny misunderstanding set up" with almost zero plot relevance AND it in itself was very far fetched in my opinion (had to combine a bunch of entitled persons in important positions, the clerk who "ordered it" everyone who failed to check the order, the guy supposed to report back, then the ranger team itself...) and I thought maybe this was going to be the new tone now for a while as Elaine has basically "dealt with" any "real threats" and therefore we get a development arc with "funny side-plots", however the whole story has basically been that now... Even this chapter if there wasn't specifically an author's note saying it would be "different" I could definitely have believed it to just be another of the "funny plots". Now for me I read this story for it's plot for Elaine's development and the multitude of interesting countries you as the author have managed to construct in a brilliant way, sadly that's almost non-existent at this point bc everything is turned into some kind of "funny joke" that's fine for one character in a "serious novel" for example the quartermaster use her as the "consistent comedy aspect" but auri is also mostly that and the way Nina interacts with almost anyone AND the way Night and Arachne keep trolling Elaine and Iona AND the way the dragon triad came of as essentially a bad joke in the end AND Amber is also always good to include some more "funny fluff" no matter how irrelevant it's for her or Elaine's plotline but the jokes of course need to be made... And it's fine it's your story and many enjoy it, but I hoped it would go back to more of a big story driven adventure novel maybe where they explore different countries and broker peace between factions (just a random thing I thought would have fit very well into their respective oaths for example...) but if you didn't actually consider the story bevor this chapter as "comedy" or "mostly comedy" than it's not something I want to read. Thanks for the great story though! Elaine's story in Remus is easily one of my favorite stories of all times!

Gopard

Kinda funny, a lot of it feels forced and noticeably lower quality than your usual work (which is excellent). I still liked it and even the major plot points/ general outline of the chapter are solid, just the execution isn't great. Even so, I wouldn't mind something like this every once in a while as an intermission chapter or something, as long as it isn't too frequent, it could be fun and allow you to practice.

Brian

If I was Kanadaj, I'd make an appearance anyway. Gotta incinerate the Anglerfish to make sure this divinely blessed twit doesn't resurrect!

David Brims

On one hand, it was a bit on the nose. On the other, it wasn’t overly long, and the ending was a satisfying twist on fated powerup. I don’t really know how I’d have written it better, in any case. A fun little filler chapter! I liked the subtle humor of Papillon not taking any of this guy’s knowledge because he’s too stupid to actually use any of it. I think my one complaint is that the girls were one dimensional as well, it felt like they could have been used to add some depth to the chapter.

Joseph Marcia

Yeah that was completely awful. It's not even the comedy that's the problem, it's the breaking of so many norms already set up in the story.

FoolRegnant

I don't want to be a Debbie downer but I don't think there's anyone here who aren't familiar with isekai harem protagonists, so It feels like beating a very dead horse with potentially the only other character from earth.

bob semple

Also, cruise ships

Stranger

That was nice

Sage Hallward

Papion is that you messing around?

C Gillan

That really made the whole thing perfect.

elijah pickett

Whew, thank the twin goddesses.

elijah pickett

Whee

elijah pickett

The large fish has a deus ex machina feel.

Sam Redwine

That was a fun chapter. It clashed slightly with the normal tone and setting of this particular story, but it made for an amusing change of pace.

Melting Sky

I noticed what you did with the dragon's name there. Naughty naughty!

Eleeyah

good chappie

Elaine

Wow I actually completely hate this. All the bulld up to another person from Earth which could have been interesting and its just....this. Why even have the plotline if this was the endpoint to begin with?

Bockus

The only thing I missed is that Elaine wasn't able to tell him that she is 24.000 years old and immortal.

Hauke Sattler

"trying to dip my toes into comedy/satire a bit, and I'm not sure how well I succeeded. I feel it's so-so, and as a result," I agree most is so-so, the last scene/ending are, however, so bad as to be something you should be sure to not repeat.

Sam Redwine

I really liked this chapter, which is rare because I don’t really like comedy stories. Also glad that it was all one chapter. Fun to have this for one chapter, but would get pretty annoying if it was a week’s worth of chapters.

Caedmon Fowler

Huh no deletion of memories and a buff.

Jeppe Fiig

Don't think I missed the hero's levels, Selkie!

Olly

Gets my vote just for the lols

Jason Hardman

Fun one-off gag but im glad its not a recurring thing. Kinda interesting how Ionas vow and mission as a valkyrie is gonna mesh/clash with the two of them now being attached to the exerri military

Kriss

I am very sick of looking at the KU top charts and 90% of it being harems.

Andrew Puterbaugh

At least steal his books/ manuscripts before going home.

Scott

No wonder why the goddess didn’t bother removing his memories. Elaine is smart and can figure things out, but this idiot wouldn’t be able to reverse engineer a bottle cap opener.

Julie

Let’s hope Iona triple checked his status page

Thorium

There were some funny parts, but overall the anime logic felt out of place in the more serious world of Pallos. Anglerfish-kun really saved the day by reminding everyone what kind of world they're in, that part made me laugh. By the way, for anyone who's into harem isekai parody, I can only recommend watching Konosuba.

Cirvante

> [*ding!* Your party has participated in slaying a [Harem Hero (Mirror - 420)// [The Main Character] (Mirror, 369)]] > “Problem solved!” With those kinds of classes, I wouldn't be surprised if he had some sort of a respawn skill and the problem is in fact not solved.

Uroš

Thanks for the chapter 😁

tr13ze

It was a good chapter, while I was hoping for another earth-human and was a mildly disappointed that he turned out to be everything I hate about Isekai and not a cool theater person that was trying to get by doing street performances to help their family to get by and exploded into popularity. I’m not saying to not write comedy again but maybe find a different thing to joke about because this was a slog to read through.

Shelbo

Thanks for the chapter. Good chapter, don't know how to feel about it.

Joshua Little

There *is* something quite like how the school moves around. I worked as crew on a touring musical and the amount of time you get off and where is all up to the tour schedule. Maybe you don't get any time off in North Carolina, but then you get the evening to wander around Atlanta on the way to Missippi because your tour bus drivers have their mandatory break. Maybe you get lunch off in South Dakota, or maybe 3 full days off in Indiannapolis because there's some time free in the tour schedule.

SkippyARC

Yeah, I'm not sure that worked that well. I'll have to think for a while about exactly why. Probably pacing, and the creepy sexual advances.

Stephanie Washburn

You know what? I dig it. It's a single chapter, it's not unreasonable for it to happen and it was fun for what it was - and the end was great.

Tobias Hammeken Arboe

That was hilarious and glad it was just one chapter instead of several but just wow. That was amusing

Tiffany Miller

thanks for the chapter, im not going to say that you are super good at comedy but it was refreshing to see the hero just be a fucking annoying jerkwad (like most isekai hero's) and die. also i find it funny that he didn't know how anything worked, its one of my biggest pet peeves in an isekai is that everyone can just perfectly replicate technology.

Karma Baris

He would suffer from a case of Instant Night-induced Decapitation.

Cormac

Thanks the chapter, but I was really hoping for some Nina and Artemis shenanigans

George

Thank, for this one, it was perfect, this type of hero are so annoying, good riddance, just imagine what would happen if he flirt with Arachne

Noah Pencherek

Thanks for the chapter! Not a style I want to see permanently, but yeah, was laughing hard for a bit there :) A beautiful conclusion there with the Lady of the Lake parody! Very satisfying end to that git

Bosparan

Great chapter, a lot of fun. I'm guessing this isn't the person who was spreading the works of shakespeare, though.

Dominic Cooke

I sense a distinct distaste with the harem junkfood literature that has been flooding the market for some time now.

Zadenae

they killed a hero Next Class Up : Demon Lord

Fraxx

Oh no, they just got Seven Seriously Sinister Spiteful Strumpets of Serial Sorties as their nemeses!

Julian

LMAO. Alright that was gold. haha

Weebeedee

I broke out into loud laughter at the anglerfish. Absolutely wonderful.

Zurulean

Why I cringed so much at that, but also feels like 80% of the protagonists of isekai stories. I am glad this whole thing wasnt a 10 chapter adventure and we are actually going to the meeting with Artemis and Julius so fast.

Zernasss

Thank anglerfish that [Hero] is dead

Virduckia

I had a solid laugh out of it at the end, but god the cringe. Ill feel that for a few more hours.

Alex E

Or just good at observation. Dude has a bunch of ladies around him, pretty easy to guess a honeytrap of some sort would work. Guessing they want to be a king is also pretty easy

Selkie

On a side note, do you think Auri is at home wondering why she just leveled up a bunch? And if Elaine just got a trickle of the experience, how many levels did Iona get?

Julie

I wonder if Night ever told Arachne about the Pastos incident and why exactly Elaine was banned from any social events. Maybe she’ll realize Night wasn’t kidding after Elaine’s first mission, to recruit someone, ended up with him dead. I know that it wasn’t Elaine’s fault, and Iona would have had to kill the stupid f*** if that anglerfish hadn’t eaten him, but I have a feeling that any and every mission where Elaine has to talk to people will end up just like this one, or maybe worse.

Julie

Glorious.

Cormac

Every Second i read that chapter since the word hero i wished him to die

Grissly1000

I thought a lot about that! Jake fundamentally doesn't know how any of this works. He can't describe things well. He could mention the words "Radiation poisoning" but that wouldn't mean anything to Elaine. It's not like the knowledge would neatly slot into the 'holes'. Elaine needs to figure out that it goes there

Selkie

Maybe it's more like the anglerfish has a mirage/mirror class that shows their prospective prey exactly what they would need to see to fall into it's trap.

Ant1h3ld

So wait, the fish can project an illusion at the end of its tendril. It must have some mind or emotion reading as well because the Lady of the Lake would not work with everyone. Keep it up. Also, he could have been brought by a god who wanted to use him to make a dragon mad without being blamed. Getting bored and maybe that dragon will help cause another immortal war.

Tyler Machado

Or, and hear me out, the goddess was just super fucking bored. I mean, summoning a “great hero” has to be top quality entertainment for them, right?

CringeWorthyStudios

Totally. Like, harem heroes aren’t *inherently* bad, but I didn’t know it was possible for anyone to be both THAT toxic, and THAT oblivious.

CringeWorthyStudios

A lady of the lake anglerfish is a scarely devious idea. It's level implies it's been pretty effective.

Dosahder

So...that just happened...too bad Elaine's first meeting with another earther had to be the cringiest weeabo f***wit the goddess could grab. Only concern is that there is a goddess that feels like a beefed up hero from another world is necessary. Wonder whether some kind of threat is brewing that a world that literally gets nuked by immortals every other era isn't equipped to handle or if it's just some lower goddess way in over her head.

Ant1h3ld

Wow. Thank f*** that guy is dead. What an absolute blight upon the world.

Hyperion

What in the flying, fishy fuck just happened. Like, the chapter was good and fun but like… what the fuck? Kinda want to know which god recruited that idiot. My only real feedback is that it’s a bit weird for Elaine to *completely* discount technology he mentions, when she knows for a fact and has mentioned dozens of times previously that she has massive holes in her memory. When she was building [The Dawn Sentinel] she mentioned that the perk for fixing “strange metal poisoning” was hitting a massive hole in her memory, so she should at least know when stuff like nukes and gamma rays hits a hole, if not why.

CringeWorthyStudios

Tftc

Nick

Nah this was really funny, good stuff!

heh


More Creators