Jeremy didn’t think twice when he grabbed one of Katie’s dresses for his costume party. It wasn’t like he planned on wearing it—he just thought the flowy fabric would make a perfect toga for his last-minute Roman emperor idea. He picked something simple and white from her closet, figuring she’d never miss it. A few safety pins later, he was strolling into the party with a plastic laurel crown on his head, completely unbothered by the idea of returning the dress crumpled, stained, and snagged from his wild night.
The next morning, when Katie discovered the dress in a heap on her bedroom floor, it looked like it had been through a war. “Jeremy!” she shrieked, storming into his room. He barely glanced up from his game. “What?” he said, his tone dripping with indifference. She held up the ruined dress, its once-pristine white fabric now smudged with what looked like beer and nacho cheese. A tear along the hem swayed accusingly. “Do you know how expensive this was?!”
Jeremy shrugged. “It’s just a dress. You see stuff like this on Temu all the time. Five bucks, tops.” He fished into his wallet, pulled out a $10 bill, and flicked it toward her. “Here. Go nuts.”
Katie’s jaw dropped. “You’re such a jerk!” she snapped, storming off. But she wasn’t done. Oh no, she had a plan, and when she told their mom what had happened, the wheels were already in motion.
An hour later, Jeremy found himself sitting in the back seat of the car, arms crossed and sulking. “This is ridiculous,” he muttered as his mom and sister chattered up front. He thought the lecture about “respecting other people’s things” had been the punishment, but no—this was going to be hands-on learning. When they arrived at the mall, Katie practically dragged him inside. “Since you’re so sure dresses are cheap and easy to replace,” she said with a wicked grin, “we’ll let you find out for yourself.”
The first store was a boutique Katie loved, full of bold, glamorous styles. She immediately zeroed in on a hot pink wrap blouse that hugged his frame and a matching miniskirt that left little to the imagination. “This one,” she declared, holding it up to Jeremy’s chest. “It’s perfect.”
“Wait, I’m not actually wearing it—” Jeremy protested, but their mom cut him off. “Oh, yes, you are. And you’re paying for it, too.” His stomach sank as Katie added a pair of towering hot pink heels to the pile, followed by sheer black tights with a bold leopard print and a bright pink handbag with gold accents.
In the dressing room, Jeremy stared at his reflection, horrified. The blouse showed more chest than he was comfortable with, and the skirt barely covered his thighs. The tights clung to his legs like a second skin, and the heels made him wobble dangerously every time he took a step. “Mom, this is insane!” he hissed as he stumbled out.
Katie was waiting with her phone ready. “You look amazing,” she teased, snapping pictures as Jeremy tried—and failed—to look dignified. The cashier was barely holding back her laughter as Jeremy paid, his eyes bulging at the total. “Who pays this much for clothes?!” he muttered.
“Oh, sweetie,” their mom said with a grin, “we’re just getting started.”
The mortification reached new heights when his mom pulled him into a nearby salon. “If you’re going to learn about the cost of looking good,” she said, “you might as well go all in.” Katie clapped her hands in glee, and before Jeremy could argue, he was in the chair.
By the time they were done, he didn’t recognize himself. His shaggy hair had been transformed into sleek, jet-black locks styled perfectly straight, flowing down past his shoulders. His makeup was bold and striking: dramatic winged eyeliner, perfectly shaped brows, and glossy pink lips that gleamed in the light. Even his nails had been done—long and sharp, painted in a bold hot pink to match the rest of his look.
As they finally made their way back to the car, Jeremy climbed into the backseat with an awkward wobble, the short pink skirt riding up slightly as he sat down. Letting out a groan, he adjusted himself carefully to avoid tearing the tights. His feet throbbed from the towering heels, and he let his head fall back against the seat with a sigh.
“Alright,” he muttered after a moment. “I get it. I shouldn’t have taken your dress, and I shouldn’t have been such a jerk about it.” He glanced down at the glittering pink nails on his hands, the smooth tights hugging his legs, and the ridiculously tall heels on his feet. “I didn’t realize… women’s stuff is so expensive.”
Katie spun around in her seat, a triumphant smirk plastered across her face. “Well, well, well. Jeremy, admitting he was wrong! I should’ve recorded that.” She grinned, her tone teasing but laced with genuine satisfaction. “Apology accepted. You actually learned something today!”
Jeremy let out a small sigh of relief. “Great. Lesson learned. Can we please go home now?”
Katie and their mom shared a knowing glance, fighting back smiles. “Of course, sweetie,” their mom said lightly, starting the car. But as they drove off, Katie quietly pulled up directions to a nearby club, her smirk widening. After all, it’d be a shame to waste all that effort.