The Christmas Threesome - Part 1

“Thanks,” Faith said as Amara set a cup of tea on the mahogany coffee table in front of her.

“Milk?” Amara asked.

Faith nodded. “That would be lovely.”

Amara added a dash of milk, added a little to her own cup, and joined her friend on the couch. “Can I ask you something a bit odd?”

“Sure,” Faith replied.

“Has Gabe ever asked for a threesome?” Amara asked.

Faith nearly spilled her tea all over her Amara’s exquisite couch at the surprising nature of the question. “Oh, wow, sorry about that.”

Amara laughed. “No problem. I told you it was a bit odd.”

“Well, to answer your question, no, he hasn’t,” Faith said. She chuckled to herself and added, “To be honest, I’m not sure Gabe could handle a threesome.”

Amara smiled. “Really? I thought all guys fantasized about a threesome with two women.”

Faith nodded as she said, “I’m sure, at some point in his life, Gabe fantasized about being with two women at the same time. I think you’re right, I imagine all men do. And I love my husband dearly and he has many strengths, but I think he might find it a bit overwhelming to be with two women at once.”

“Do you think he wouldn’t enjoy it?” Amara asked.

“I can imagine two entirely different outcomes, to be honest,” Faith began. “In the first, Gabe enjoys it far too much and finishes up long before the two women get close. In the second, he’s so overwhelmed at the idea of tending to the needs of two women that he can’t do much of anything.”

Amara seemed amused at Faith’s assessment of her husband, but Faith knew Gabe better than anyone and she understood that he really wasn’t the sort of man that would relish the opportunity to be with two women, no matter how beautiful they were.

“Does Gabe finish quickly often?” Amara asked.

Had anyone else posed that question Faith would have thought it far too personal, but she and Amara shared a particularly close relationship, in part because they were the only women among their friends that had been married for more than a decade.

“Sometimes, when he gets really excited – like if I’ve put on something particularly naughty or done something a bit different to get him turned on – he will finish quickly. Sometimes it’s disappointing, but to be honest, sometimes I really like it. That might sound strange, but I like the idea that I can still excite my husband to the point that he can’t quite control himself,” Faith explained.

Amara sipped her tea, nodded, and said, “I can see that.”

Silence hung between the two friends for a short spell before Faith asked, “Why did you ask about the threesome?”

“Oh, right, the threesome question,” Amara said with a laugh. “Well, I was thinking of arranging a threesome as Kai’s big Christmas gift this year.”

Faith was stunned. She knew Amara and Kai had a more adventurous sex life than she and Gabe did, but she had no idea it was adventurous enough to support a threesome.

“Does that look on your face mean you think it’s a terrible idea?” Amara asked.

“Sorry,” Faith said. “No. The look is surprise, that’s all. I don’t know why it should be, though. I’m not interested in shaming anyone for their sexual choices. I’m just surprised. I mean, how do you know that’s something Kai would actually like?”

“Last year, when we went to Hawaii, we actually came pretty close to having one,” Amara explained. “One of the girls that worked at the resort – she couldn’t have been more than 25 – was getting really flirty with Kai and for whatever reason I didn’t feel jealous. I don’t know if it’s because we were on vacation or if there was just something about her that I liked, but I actually suggested that Kai see if she was interested in a threesome.”

Faith’s eyes went wide as Amara shared an entirely different side of herself, a side Faith never would have imagined existed. “So you were the one that suggested the threesome?”

“I guess so,” Amara answered. “Though I think Kai was sort of hinting at it, to be honest. I’m not really sure. I was definitely the one that brought it up, though.”

“So what happened?” Faith asked as she leaned a little closer.

“Kai asked and she expressed interest,” Amara explained. “It feels a little weird to say this, but I was actually really excited.”

Faith wasn’t going to admit it, but she felt an unexpected sense of excitement as she listened to her friend’s story.

“It didn’t happen, though. The girl said that her manager noticed she was being a little too friendly with Kai and that she’d be fired if she continued to behave like that,” Amara said. “So, she told us that as much fun as she thought it would be, it wasn’t worth risking her job.”

Faith tried to hide her disappointment at not getting to hear a tale of her friend’s threesome while also trying to understand why she was disappointed in the first place.

“That night…well, you can stop me if this is too much, but that night we talked about her while fooling around,” Amara continued. “I don’t know why, but I couldn’t stop thinking about Kai having sex with her, and with both of us, really. I just kept imagining all the sorts of things that could happen in a threesome and it had this intoxicating feel to it for reasons I truly don’t understand.”

Faith was astounded that Amara was willing to reveal all of this to her, though she noticed that she was once again leaning in as if her friend was telling the most interesting story she’d ever heard.

“Both of us had really good…well, the sex was really good,” Amara said. “For both of us. Kai hasn’t brought up the idea of a threesome since – I think he might just be waiting for another vacation – and I haven’t either, but I feel like I could really surprise him – in the best way possible – if I managed to arrange one as a Christmas gift for him.” Amara paused, looked away, and smiled before adding, “For both of us, I suppose.”

“How would you do it?” Faith asked. “I mean, would you look for someone on Tinder or some other dating app, or did you already have someone in mind? Is this the sort of thing you want to do with a total stranger or someone you know? Would you do it here? Would you go to a hotel room? Would you do it on Christmas Day?”

Faith felt embarrassed as she heard the excitement in her voice while she lobbed questions at her friend without giving Amara even a moment to squeeze in an answer. She sat back and reached up to cover her mouth as if she was silently apologizing for suddenly dominating every word of the conversation.

Amara laughed and reached out to put a hand on Faith’s arm as she said, “It really is kind of exciting, isn’t it?”

Faith nodded. She wasn’t sure why she found the prospect of her friend having a threesome so exciting, but there was no denying she felt that way.

“In a perfect world, we’d do it on New Year’s Eve,” Amara said. “I like the idea of ending the year with a bang, so to speak.”

Faith laughed out loud at her friend’s play on words and briefly pictured Amara, Kai, and a stranger all having fun in a hotel room.

“As to where to find the right woman for a threesome…well, I have someone in mind,” Amara said as she smiled.

Faith leaned closer. “You do? Is it a friend? A coworker? Someone Kai knows?”

Amara leaned in a little, took Faith’s hand in hers, and said, “It’s you.”

Faith sat back and Amara put her tea on the coffee table and scooted closer.

“It’s okay if you don’t want to, of course, but you were the first person I thought of when this idea popped into my head,” Amara explained. “I know it’s probably crazy – I don’t know how you’d convince Gabe to let you do it, for instance – but I had to ask before I move on to finding someone else.”

“Why…why me?” Faith asked.

Amara smiled as she’d won a small victory and said, “Kai thinks you’re beautiful…”

“He does?” Faith interrupted.

Amara nodded. “He does. I think you’re beautiful too, and the more I’ve thought about it, the more I like the idea of doing this with a friend. I know that might be a terrible idea – I don’t really imagine a threesome as somewhere where the women just take turns having sex with the guy so maybe we’d be crossing a really weird line if we did it together – but I can’t get the idea of doing this with you out of my head, Faith, so I had to ask. I’m really, really sorry if I’ve crossed a line in a way I shouldn’t have and ruined our friendship or made it really weird, but I had to ask.”

Faith’s heart was pounding so hard she could barely hear herself speak as she asked, “How do imagine it going? I mean, what sort of…what would happen? What would we do?”

Amara moved a little closer to her friend and slowly, almost absentmindedly ran her fingers over the palm of Faith’s hand. “I keep thinking it will go like I imagined the threesome on vacation would have gone.”

She hesitated and Faith felt an overpowering desire to hear Amara’s vision for a wild night with Kai. “Please, tell me,” she said softly.

“I imagined the girl – her name was Anna – I imagined Anna and me putting on a little show for Kai. I saw us…” she looked away for a moment before continuing, “I saw us in bikinis. I saw us…I saw us kissing as we undressed each other while Kai watched and played with himself. I saw us playing with each other a little as we watched Kai get hard for us. I saw us crawling into the bed and between his legs to offer him the pleasure that he deserves. I saw us claiming our pleasure by enjoying Kai’s body, and his…well, his beautiful cock, and his tongue. I even saw us offering each other pleasure.”

Faith’s mind swirled with the imagery her friend conjured and she felt a little lightheaded and, much to her surprise, aroused.

“What do you think?” Amara asked. “Will you be Kai’s Christmas present?”

“Yes,” Faith answered without much thought. It was pure instinct that gently lured the word out of her mouth. Saying it brought about an intense mixture of nervousness and desire, but Faith didn’t change her mind.

Amara smiled delightfully, but asked, “Are you sure? What about Gabe?”

“I’m sure,” Faith said. “And I don’t know about Gabe. I just…Amara, I’m not sure what’s going on, but it’s been a long time since I’ve felt the excitement I feel right now. It’s almost as if I’d forgotten I could even feel this excited.”

“I’m excited too,” Amara said. “To be honest, I’ve been thinking about it constantly since the idea of a threesome for Christmas came to me. I can’t believe how much it…well, how much it turns me on to think of the two of us teaming up to make Kai, and each other, feel good. I never thought I’d want that sort of thing, I really didn’t, but then that girl on vacation started flirting with Kai and something changed. And I just can’t help but think that it’s going to be even more fun with you than it would have been with her.”

“How do you want to do the gift?” Faith asked.

“You mean on Christmas Day?” Amara replied. Faith nodded and her friend smiled and pulled out her phone. She pulled up a photo of two girls in matching lace bodysuits. One was red and the other dark green. “I was hoping to recreate a photo like this, but with a bit more Christmas flair – maybe a hat and a pair of boots to go with the lingerie – and then I’d print it out, put it in a box, and have Kai unwrap it.”

“I could write a little note,” Faith said.

“Really?” Amara asked.

Faith smiled. “Yeah. You could tuck it in the box. I could write something about how you asked me to join you for a threesome and that I’d love to, but I’d make it sexy, of course.”

“Are you really on board with this?” Amara asked.

Faith knew it was utterly insane, but she wanted to be Kai’s Christmas present. “I am. I want you to wrap me up – in picture form, at least – and give me to Kai for Christmas.” Faith felt an intense surge of pleasure between her legs as she gave voice to her desire and it served to confirm that she really did want to dive into the sexual unknown with her friend.

“Do you have time to do a little lingerie shopping?” Amara asked. “I’d love to get the picture done today.”

“Absolutely,” Faith said.

“Let’s finish our tea and go, then,” Amara replied with a bright smile.

“Or we could just go now,” Faith suggested. She felt possessed by a deep, previously unknown need for a new level of excitement and she didn’t want to wait.

Amara stood, grabbed both tea cups from the coffee table, and said, “Excellent. Let’s see just how good we can look in lingerie.”

Faith looked at herself in the bathroom mirror and adjusted the lace camisole she’d bought at Victoria’s Secret – she’d purchased a few things for herself in addition to the outfits they’d picked up for Kai – and smiled at how good her breasts looked.

She took a deep breath, quickly went over her plan for what promised to be one of the most interesting conversations of her marriage, and stepped out of the bathroom.

“Wow,” Gabe said as he looked up from his phone to see Faith in her camisole and matching boyshort panties.

Faith smile as she watched lust wash over her husband’s face. She really only wore lingerie to bed on special occasions, so he rightly assumed that she intended on having sex with him. “Do you like it?” she asked while posing a little at the foot of the bed.

“I love it,” Gabe said. “Faith, you look incredible.”

Faith crawled into the bed and snuggled up next to her husband under the covers. He reached out to run his fingers over the soft material of her camisole and she looked up at him and smiled before softly kissing him.

Faith moaned quietly and slipped her fingers under the waistband of Gabe’s underwear. She took his half hard cock in her hand and stroked him while welcoming his tongue into her mouth. Gabe moved to roll on top of Faith but she put a hand on his chest and kept him in place. She had a plan, after all, and she wasn’t anywhere near finished executing it.

“Have you ever fantasized about a threesome?” Faith asked softly as her lips hovered achingly close to Gabe’s while her hand moved up and down his stiff shaft.

“What?” he asked.

“Have you ever fantasized about being with two women at the same time?” Faith asked.

“I don’t…Faith, why…why are you asking that?” Gabe replied as confusion seemed to meld with the increasing lust brought about by Faith’s handjob.

“I had a very interesting day,” Faith said. “With Amara.”

Gabe’s eyes went wide and Faith imagined all sorts of images running through her husband’s head.

“Not that kind of day,” she added before kissing him again. It was important to keep Gabe thoroughly aroused so he’d give Faith what she wanted and she knew he wouldn’t be able to contain his lust if she offered a steady dose of kisses and cock stroking.

“What…what made it interesting?” Gabe asked before closing his eyes and moaning.

“Amara revealed that she and Kai almost had a threesome while they were on vacation in Hawaii,” Faith explained. “One of the girls at the resort had taken a liking to Kai and was doing quite a bit of flirting. Unbelievably, Amara was the one that suggested they invite the girl to have a threesome. She said she didn’t understand why but she found the idea irresistibly sexy.”

Faith couldn’t tell if Gabe was turned on by the idea of a threesome or because his lingerie-clad wife was stroking his cock, but she loved that she seemed so filled with lust.

“Amara said she was enormously aroused at the idea of fooling around with the beautiful girl while her husband watched,” Faith continued. “She imagined them kissing each other, undressing each other, and even pleasuring each other while Kai watched from the bed and played with his beautiful cock, as Amara put it.”

Gabe groaned and his hips subtly thrust upwards as if he was trying to fuck her hand a little faster than she was stroking him.

“Why…why did Amara tell you all of that?” Gabe asked.

Faith released Gabe’s cock and pulled her panties off. She yanked the covers back, worked Gabe’s underwear off, and straddled him. They kissed as she moved her slippery pussy lips back and forth over the tip of his stiff cock. He played with her breasts through the thin, soft material of her camisole and did his best to slide into her wetness.

“Do you want me, Gabe?” she asked.

“Yes, Faith, I want you,” he replied.

Faith reached down and guided his cock inside her. She was soaked with desire and he filled her in an instant. She moaned, sat back, and gently moved her hips back and forth, grinding her clit into his pelvic bone and no doubt providing his stiff cock with quite the thrill.

“There’s a reason Amara told me about her almost threesome,” Faith said as she moved her hips a little faster. Gabe moaned and Faith watched the pleasure dance over his face. “She wants to arrange a threesome as a Christmas present for Kai. She wants to give someone else to her husband as a gift. She wants the two of them to pleasure Kai together, and to pleasure each other.”

Gabe looked as though he was awfully close to cumming, so Faith slowed the movement of her hips and leaned closer. She kissed her husband and moaned when he grabbed her ass and squeezed it hard.

“She wants me to be the one to join them, Gabe,” Faith whispered. She kissed his neck and ran her tongue over his earlobe in the way he loved. “Amara wants to give me to her husband for Christmas.”

Faith rode him faster. Her loins came alive with pleasure and she could feel the wetness of her desire – desire driven by so much more than having sex with her husband – dripping out of her.

“I told her I’d do it,” Faith said. “I told her she could give me to Kai for Christmas. I told her I’d join them for a threesome. That’s why I was at Victoria’s Secret today. We bought lingerie to wear for Kai. We want to look good for him, Gabe. We want to look good as we fool around for his pleasure. We want to look good as we undress each other before crawling into bed and sucking his cock together.”

Faith was lost in fantasizing about the threesome she’d agreed to, but it seemed that Gabe felt the same way. He grabbed her ass and moved her hips even faster over his cock, using Faith’s slick pussy for the pleasure he clearly craved.

Gabe came before Faith did. He came hard, too. She could see it on his face and hear it in the sounds of intense pleasure that escaped his lips. Faith climaxed soon after her husband. Seeing his lust put her over the top and her pussy spasmed around his cock while he emptied himself inside her.

Faith sat in her husband’s lap with his pulsing cock inside her as she experienced a body-shaking orgasm fueled by the allure of having a threesome with Amara and Kai. She leaned forward and kissed Gabe. He welcomed her lips against his and her tongue in his mouth. He even moaned a little at what seemed to be his continued pleasure.

“Did you really tell her you’d do it?” Gabe asked.

“I did,” Faith replied. “And I’m going to do it.” She leaned over, plucked her phone from the nightstand, and pulled up the picture she and Amara had posed for. They were dressed in matching lace bodysuits – Amara in red and Faith in green – and they each had on a cute red Santa hat and a pair of Santa-style boots. “She’s going to print out this picture and wrap it up in a box for Kai to open on Christmas Day. Oh, and I’m going to write a little note to make sure that he believes that I’m on board for the threesome.”

Gabe looked up at her and Faith saw none of the hesitation, annoyance, or anger she expected. Instead, she saw what looked a lot like curiosity, and perhaps a touch of desire despite his recent orgasm.

“Can I watch?” Gabe asked.

Faith smiled. “I’m sure I can find a way to work that out.” She’d expected resistance of some kind, but it seemed that Gabe was full of surprises, just like Amara had proved to be that afternoon. Now, with the prospect of her husband as an audience, Faith was even more excited for New Year’s Eve.