A College Cuckolding - Part 5

Click here to read the previous parts of the story.

---

Chloe hadn't expected that she'd enjoy watching a college football game. Sports had never really been her thing, after all.

She learned quickly, though, that it was different when her boyfriend was playing. The game didn't interest her all that much, but watching Chad turned out to be thrilling.

The first time he ripped off a long run and the crowd cheered, Chloe felt an unexpected sense of pride and a touch of elation. That was her boyfriend that thousands of people were cheering for.

"He's pretty good, isn't he?" she asked Owen - her primary boyfriend - at one point.

"He is."

Chloe looked towards the man she'd been dating far longer than she'd been with Chad and smiled at the look of consternation on his face. She should have expected that he'd grapple with jealousy. After all, they were watching Chad excel at football, which the world had placed great value on. Owen was smart and funny and charming and good looking, but in the pecking order he would come in behind Chad if a random woman was choosing between the two of them because Chad was the handsome, fit football player.

"Are you jealous, baby?" Chloe asked as she took her boyfriend's hand and leaned in to kiss him on the cheek.

"I think so, yes."

Chloe was surprised at the touch of arousal she felt at her boyfriend's jealousy. "Are you jealous because you know that Chad gets to claim my body after the game? That he gets to claim me as his reward for succeeding on the field today?"

"Yes," Owen answered without taking his eyes off the game.

Chad broke through the line and scampered twenty yards down field. The crowd erupted and Chloe cheered loudly along with everyone else in their section. She felt a sense of pride that she was dating - and now fucking, as of their last date - the man that was carrying the team to what seemed like an assured victory, at least based on their three touchdown lead at the start of the second half.

"You know, he's having his best game of the season," she said while resting a hand on Owen's leg. "That feels like it's worthy of a more significant reward, don't you think?"

He shifted his body a little and Chloe let her hand move up his leg.

"Maybe I should let him have me more than once," she said softly. "Or maybe I should suck his cock first, taking my time with it and letting him cum in my mouth. You know, do all the work to pleasure him. Show him that I appreciate that I'm lucky to be with the team's star running back."

Chloe was trying to foster Owen's jealousy. She realized it was potentially cruel, but it turned her on to do so and as her fingers neared his crotch she felt the tip of his cock, which had moved down one leg of his pants as it had gotten hard. Owen might have been jealous, but he was plenty aroused, too.

The quarterback faked a handoff and Chad ran out of the backfield and down the sideline. A few seconds later the ball was in the air. It fell right into Chad's outstretched hands and he ran into the end zone, scoring his second touchdown of the day. He spiked the ball enthusiastically and his teammates rushed over so they could all do a coordinated celebration.

Chloe stood and cheered. Owen remained seated, though that was likely because of the erection he was sporting.

"That's two touchdowns," she said. "Maybe I need to do even more to reward him. After all, Chad's likely to have women throwing themselves at him after a game like today. I need to make sure that I'm the only woman he wants."

Owen turned to her and smiled. "Is that what you want? To be the only woman that Chad wants to fuck?"

Chloe was feeling bold, so she caressed her boyfriend's cock through his jeans, doing so with dozens of people seated all around them. She smiled at the pleasure that washed over Owen's face and felt her pussy tingle as she nodded. "Is that bad? Am I being the worst girlfriend in the world right now?"

Owen shook his head.

"Are you sure, baby? Because I could stop talking about how much I want Chad to want me. I could stop telling you about how badly I want my other boyfriend to fuck me after the game."

Owen looked down and groaned. His cock felt remarkably stiff in his jeans and Chloe smiled gleefully as she kissed him on the cheek and pulled her hand from between his legs.

"You know, I do like Chad and I like fucking him, but it's you that makes it all worth it," she said.

"What do you mean?"

"The fact that you're into it, Owen, that's a big part of what makes it so exciting. When I'm with him I think about you. When he's inside me, I think about how much you're going to enjoy hearing about it. I think about how much you're going to enjoy being the second man inside me."

Owen's face was alive with desire and Chloe imagined he would have been more than happy to leave the game for a quickie in the bathroom or in an equipment closet if they could find one. Chloe considered it, too, but she wanted Chad to be the first man to have her that day.

"It's not all about me though, is it?" he asked with a smile as his hand moved to Chloe's inner thigh. "You like the fact that a guy like Chad is into you." He leaned in and kissed her neck before whispering, "You like that the star running back is going to spend the night pounding your tight little pussy."

Chloe closed her eyes as her whole body hummed with desire. Owen was right, of course. Chloe was turned on by her boyfriend's desire for her to fuck someone else, but she was equally turned on by the fact that Chad was gorgeous, muscular, and quite popular on their campus and that he wanted to fuck her more than anyone else.

"You're right," she said before turning to kiss Owen. Someone behind them commented that they should get a room and Chloe giggled with pure delight. "I am going to work hard to make sure that tonight is memorable for Chad. He deserves to be rewarded after leading the team to victory, don't you think?"

Owen nodded.

"I can't wait to come back to you after I've been with him, though."

"I want you right now," Owen replied.

The crowd roared and Chloe turned to see that the opposing team's quarterback had thrown an interception. She cheered as the offense ran back onto the field, including Chad.

"Does it bother you that you can't have me when you want me?" she asked as the team huddled up.

"Yes," Owen answered. "It's kind of exciting, too."

The crowd cheered again as Chad ran for a first down before being pushed out of bounds. Owen clapped and Chloe did the same as she watched her other boyfriend get up and run back towards the huddle.

"You know what Chad might like?" she said.

"What's that?"

"If I told him that the sex with him is the best I've ever had."

Owen looked at her with a now familiar sense of lust in his eyes. "Is it?"

Chloe smiled and kissed him softly. "It is," she whispered.

The crowd cheered, but Chloe kept her focus on Owen. She kissed him again, this time deeper. She played with his cock, too, as she figured that just about everyone was watching the game.

"Should I tell him?" she asked.

"Yes," Owen answered softly.

Chloe smiled, kissed him on the neck, and turned her attention back to the game. She understood that the sex with Chad was great - at least in part - because she was thinking about her and Owen's shared kink while Chad was inside her, but that wasn't entirely the reason it was great. It was also great because Chad was gorgeous, sexy, muscular, and really fucking good in bed.

Chad scored another touchdown, bringing the entirety of the stadium to their feet and sealing the game before the fourth quarter had even begun.

Chloe really did intend to reward Chad for his success on the field because she was absolutely certain other girls would throw themselves at him and she wanted to keep Chad all to herself. Maybe she wouldn't succeed at that, but she damn sure going to try.

---

It was a few hours after the game before Chloe could meet up with Chad as he had to get cleaned up and celebrate with the team before all the players were free to go about their business. Chloe made good use of the extra time, though, as she went back to her room to put on lingerie for Chad and touched up her hair and makeup to look a little sexier.

They went out to dinner - his idea - and cozied up in a booth. They ate, but they also spent a great deal of time kissing and touching in a manner that had Chloe's body humming with an intense level of desire. Her pussy was soaked by the time they walked out of the restaurant and headed towards Chad's dorm.

As they walked, at least half a dozen people stopped Chad to offer compliments on the game. That included a few women, each of whom seemed like she would have been more than happy for Chad to toss Chloe aside.

He didn't, though. Each time he put his arm around her and pulled her closer. In those moments, Chloe understood the allure of being with a man that so many other women desired. It felt good. Great, even. It made her want to ensure that the sexual portion of his evening was memorable, too.

"You're very popular," she said as they waited for the walk signal.

Chad smiled.

"Some of the girls on campus seem especially interested in you now that you're a star."

"I'm not interested in them," he said.

"I know. I'm going to make sure you don't develop an interest in them, either."

"Oh yeah?"

The walk signal changed and Chad put his arm around Chloe as they walked.

"How are you doing to do that?" he asked.

"I'm going to blow your mind," she answered with a smile. "Though your mind isn't the only thing I'll be blowing. I hope you're not too tired from the game, as I intend on ensuring your night is just as memorable as your day was."

He grabbed her ass and gave it a good squeeze. "I'm not too tired. I promise."

As it turned out, he was nowhere near being too tired to go as many times as Chloe wanted.

---

"Wow, Chloe, you look so hot," Owen said.

He was in his bed and she'd just stripped out of her dress to show off the lingerie she'd worn for Chad.

"He thought so too."

Owen hadn't touched his cock but it was already half hard and showing quite clearly in his jeans.

"I danced a little bit for him," she said. "I had him sit in his desk chair. I guess I acted a lot like a stripper would. Dancing and touching myself and rubbing on him. I wanted him to feel desperate for me, baby."

"Was he?"

Chloe nodded as she approached the bed and unbutton Owen's jeans. She tugged them off and tossed them across his small dorm room.

"The lap dance helped. I could feel his stiff cock pressing into my ass as I sat in his lap. I could feel his desire in the way he touched me, too. In the way his hands moved over my tits and down my stomach and into my panties. That's when he felt my desire, Owen. I think I was as wet as I've ever been. As it turns out, there's something really exciting about getting to fuck the star running back, about getting to fuck the guy that all the other girls want."

Owen stroked himself through his underwear and Chloe was pleased to see that her boyfriend was hard as a rock.

"I wanted to make it a memorable evening, though. I didn't just want it to be a quickie. I wanted to take my time. I wanted to make myself into Chad's fantasy girl."

"How did you do that?" Owen asked.

She smiled and bent over to remove his underwear. She tossed them aside, leaving her boyfriend wearing only a t-shirt.

"I sucked his cock," she replied while grasping her breasts and playing with them through the thin lace of her sexy bodysuit. "Or, I suppose you could say that I worshiped his cock."

"Worshiped?" Owen asked while stroking himself.

"Most girls give a blowjob with the intention of getting a guy hard so he can fuck or making him cum as quickly as possible so the blowjob will be over as quickly as possible. I did neither. I gave Chad the kind of blowjob he deserved. I gave him a blowjob that was all about showering him in pleasure, about making that pleasure last as long as possible. I worshiped his cock because that's the kind of thing he deserved after a performance like the one he put on today."

"What about me?" Owen asked.

"What do you mean?"

He smiled. "Do I deserve that kind of blowjob? Do I deserve to get my cock worshiped?"

Chloe crawled into the bed and kissed her boyfriend. Her tongue slipped into his mouth and she moved his fingers off his cock so she could stroke him. "Are you the star of the football team?" she whispered. "Did you singlehandedly win the game today?"

"No."

She moaned. "Then no, you don't deserve to have your cock worshiped. Only one of my boyfriends deserves that."

Owen moaned and Chloe felt his cock swell up in her hand. Her lips found their way to his and she kissed him again.

"I swallowed Chad's cum," she whispered. "I worshiped his dick for twenty minutes and then he came in my mouth and I swallowed like a good girlfriend."

"He's a very lucky man."

"He deserved every bit of pleasure I gave him, Owen. You're the lucky one. I could still be with Chad. I could be in his bed. I could be in his arms. I could be stroking his cock to get him hard so he could fuck me again. I could be screaming his name as he pounded me. I could be sucking my pussy juices off his cock and urging him to cum in my mouth again so I could swallow his load like a good girlfriend. He deserves all of that, if for no other reason than a guy like him could find half a dozen girls willing to be everything he wants them to be in bed."

Chloe pulled off Owen's t-shirt and sat across his upper thighs as she tossed it aside. She inched her hips forward until his cock head was pressed against the soft, sheer material of her bodysuit and then teased the underside of the head with her index finger as he moaned.

"You're so fucking sexy," he said. "I'm so lucky to be with you."

Chloe felt the same way, but in the moment she wasn't going to say it. She wanted to keep indulging in the naughty dynamic she'd established. "Yes, you are, and don't you forget it."

Owen smiled, sat up, and kissed her. He leaned back and she happily went with him. Chloe inched her hips forward until the head of his cock was pressed against her crotch.

"Did Chad appreciate your willingness to worship his cock?" he asked while playing with her tits.

"He did. He said - and this isn't the first time he's said it - but he said that it was the best blowjob he's ever had."

Chloe sat up and reached down to rub her pussy.

"I like that I give Chad the best blowjobs he's ever had, Owen. I like that I suck his cock better than any girl ever has, and I'd be willing to be that he's gotten quite a few blowjobs in his life."

Owen sat up, but Chloe put a hand on his chest and pushed him back down. He smiled at her aggressiveness.

"Does he eat your pussy?" Owen asked.

"He has. He didn't tonight. He's good at it, though. Not as good as you."

"Yeah?"

She bit her lower lip and rubbed her pussy with a little more vigor. "I imagine he hasn't eaten pussy anywhere near as much as you. I imagine that girls are more than happy to just get fucked by Chad, that he's more than capable of making them cum that way, that they're not going to complain that he doesn't eat pussy becuase it feels really good to get fucked by a man like that."

Owen reached down and grabbed her hips. He tried to pull them forward but Chloe resisted.

"I want to eat your pussy," he said.

"Even after Chad fucked me?"

He nodded.

Chloe inched her hips forward, but stopped as she sat on Owen's chest. "Wait."

"What's wrong?"

"There was something else I did to make tonight special for Chad."

"What?"

She smiled. "I let him cum inside me."

Owen's gaze shifted to her pussy - which rested on his chest - and after a few seconds he looked back up at her.

"Twice," she added.

"Oh...so...so his cum is still inside you?"

"A little, I'm sure. I mean, it's been almost an hour so most of it has probably leaked out, but it's probably messy down there. Really mess, I'm sure, so if I sat on your face...well, your face would be messy. Your lips would be messy. Your tongue would be messy. And you'd absolutely taste him."

"Just like you did," Owen said. "When you worshiped his cock, I mean."

Chloe smiled. "Yes, when I worshiped his cock and he came in my mouth. I certainly tasted him."

Owen reached up to play with Chloe's breasts. "What did it taste like?"

"Salty. A little bit sweet. Not terrible. I...it's weird, I don't know that I'd say I liked the taste, but I liked having his cum in my mouth. I liked the feel of it. I liked knowing that his cum in my mouth meant that I'd made him feel good."

Owen's hands moved down Chloe's back and he applied pressure, inching her hips forward. She moved until her pussy hovered just a few inches from his mouth. He applied more pressure and she moved until she was sitting astride his face.

Owen pulled her down. She felt his tongue move against the bodysuit. He was licking her. He was licking her messy pussy through the thin lingerie she'd worn for another man.

Arousal surged through Chloe's body. It wasn't just that it felt good. It was that Owen was licking her pussy after someone else had fucked her. It was the sheer kinkiness of it that drove her wild.

"Fuck, Owen...that feels so good."

He grasped her breasts and played with them while licking her as she sat on his face. She closed her eyes and surrendered to the overwhelming lust she felt.

Owen's hand moved between her legs. Chloe opened her eyes to see him pull the bodysuit aside. She was tempted to ask him if he was certain he wanted to do what he was doing, but she kept her mouth shut. Owen was fully informed and in that moment, Chloe wanted nothing more than for her boyfriend to devour her messy pussy.

Owen did just that. He pulled the bodysuit aside and pushed his tongue inside her. Chloe immediately began to ride his face a little, moving her hips back and forth. She ground her clit into his lips and tongue and her body trembled.

"Fuck, Owen...fuck...I'm cumming!"

Chloe had an otherworldly orgasm. It was powerful enough that she had to lean forward and brace herself against the wall behind his bed. She closed her eyes as the intense pleasure worked its way through her. The climax felt longer than most, too, and when it ended Chloe had a giddy smile on her face.

She lifted her hips, pulled the bodysuit back over her pussy, and scooted back until she was seated across Owen's thighs once more. She smiled as the glistening mixture of pussy juice and cum on his face and leaned down to lick it up while sharing sloppy, salty kisses with him.

"You just made me cum harder than Chad ever has," she whispered.

"Really?"

"Fuck yes. Now tell me, what would make you cum the hardest, Owen? Because you deserve the best orgasm of your life."

He considered the question for a moment and said, "If you sat on my cock and told me that Chad fucks you better than I do."

She smiled, kissed him, and carefully freed her pussy from the bodysuit and took him inside her. She rode him slowly while their tongues entwined. When Owen moaned Chloe couldn't help but feel a certain giddy sense of desire. She liked that he wanted her so badly. She loved that he seemed to want her even more because she'd fucked someone else that day.

"Chad fucks me better than you do," she whispered. "His cock is bigger than yours. His body is sexier than yours. He's better in bed than you are. He fucks me so much better than you ever have, Owen. That's why he gets my pussy first. That's why you get it second. That's why you're fucking a pussy that's messy with another man's cum. Because he fucks me better than you do."

Owen tensed up and then unleashed a series of grunts and groans as he came inside her. Chloe smiled and kept on riding him, though she did so slowly to ensure he wasn't overwhelmed.

"That was the best orgasm I've ever had," Owen said afterwards.

"You deserved it," she replied. "Just like you'll deserve many more just like it in the future."

"Yeah?"

Chloe nodded and then lifted her pussy from his cock and once again pulled the bodysuit over it to soak up a second man's cum. She cuddled up next to Owen and rested her head on his chest as he put an arm around her.

"I like Chad a lot, but I like you more, Owen, so yes, you're going to have lots more great orgasms, and I expect that you'll give me lots more great orgasms, too."

"I will. I absolutely will. I'll give you more tonight if you'll let me."

She smiled and kissed his chest a few times. "I will."

He did, too, starting with another orgasm by tongue, this time while cleaning his own load out of her. Owen fucked Chloe to a great orgasm, too, though of course his cock couldn't quite compete with Chad's. That was fine by her, though, as sex with either of her boyfriends was a deeply satisfying experience.