From Bull to Boyfriend on Valentine's Day

“I want you, Michelle,” Caleb said as he pulled the naked married woman in his bed closer to him.

“You just had me, Caleb. What are you talking about?” Michelle asked as she enjoyed the tight, almost possessive way he held her.

Caleb laughed. “That’s not what I mean,” he said.

“Well then what do you mean?” she replied.

“I want all of you, Michelle. I know it wasn’t our deal, that I said I was okay just being your bull, but I changed my mind. I want more than that. I want a relationship. I want to be your boyfriend,” he declared.

Michelle sat up and looked into Caleb’s impossibly beautiful blue eyes. Those were the eyes that lured her to him in the first place.

“What would that mean?” she asked.

Caleb seemed heartened that she didn’t immediately deny his desire. “It would mean going out on dates, spending the night together, getting to know each other better. Maybe having unprotected sex,” he suggested.

A hopeful, happy smile flashed across Michelle’s face and then faded.

“I don’t think Adam would be as upset about it as you might be imagining,” Caleb assured her.

“You don’t think my husband would be upset if I started dating another guy?” she shot back.

Caleb gently caressed Michelle’s face and ran his fingers through her hair. He pulled her close for a slow, soft kiss.

“I think you underestimate how much he enjoys being cuckolded. This is a perfectly logical next step for him. He can prove just how devoted he is to you by letting you take the next step in your relationship with me,” Caleb said.

“But this is different,” Michelle protested. “I just can’t see him being okay with me falling in love with someone else.”

“Falling in love?” Caleb asked.

Michelle immediately wished she hadn’t used that word, but now she was committed. “I’m sorry. That’s presumptuous. I’m not saying I’m in love with you, I’m just saying that if we take that next step it seems like a logical conclusion. Women fall in love with their boyfriends or they break up with them, and I can’t see breaking up with you,” she said.

“I certainly wouldn’t want that,” Caleb added as he kissed Michelle again. “I could see myself falling in love with you.”

Michelle reached between Caleb’s legs and wrapped her fingers around his hard cock. She couldn’t help but love that the idea of being her boyfriend and of taking the next step in their relationship had him so turned on.

“Then I guess you’re not my bull anymore. I guess you’re my boyfriend now,” Michelle said as she straddled Caleb.

“I guess so,” he said while reaching for a condom and quickly unwrapping it. He rolled it down his shaft and guided his dick into Michelle’s wet pussy.

As she sank down onto her boyfriend’s cock, Michelle hoped Caleb was right about her husband’s reaction. It would be hard to make this work if Adam wasn’t on board with stepping back and letting his wife date another man.

---

“Happy Valentine’s Day, baby,” Michelle said as she pulled back the covers and kissed her sleeping husband’s cheek.

Adam stirred awake and opened his eyes to see his beautiful wife in a sheer red bra and panty set.

“Wow, you look incredible,” he said.

“Well, it’s Valentine’s Day,” she said, “and I wanted to show you what I’m going to wear for Caleb tonight. What do you think?”

Michelle stepped back to show off the beautiful bra and thong. She spun around as Adam sat up in bed and ogled her beautiful body.

“He’s going to love it,” Adam said as his cock sprang to life.

Michelle tossed the covers aside and pulled down Adam’s briefs, exposing his small, stiff cock. She straddled him and rubbed her panty-clad pussy over his erection.

“I have something to tell you, cucky, and Valentine’s Day is the perfect day to do it,” Michelle said as she leaned forward and kissed her husband’s neck while he moaned.

“What is it?” Adam asked.

“Caleb wants more of me,” she said while leaning back and slowly grinding into her husband’s crotch. “He wants all of me.”

Michelle watched a confused look spread across Adam’s face. She was going to have to be more explicit.

“Caleb wants to be more than my bull. He wants to be my boyfriend,” Michelle said as she wrapped her fingers around Adams’s stiff cock and stroked him.

“Is that what you want?” Adam asked.

Michelle wanted to be honest with Adam. She owed it to him to be as truthful as possible.

“Yes,” she said while playing with her breasts in the sheer bra. Her nipples were hard and she could feel the heat of desire between her legs. She was turned on at the idea of being Caleb’s girlfriend. “The truth is, I really want it. I want to be his girlfriend. I do.”

“What would happen?” Adam asked. “I mean, what would it mean for you to have a boyfriend? What would be different?”

He looked a little scared. Michelle took his hand in hers and lifted it to her lips to kiss him. “I’m not going to leave you, Adam. You don’t have to worry about that. You’re always going to be my husband. Nothing will ever change that. The simplest way to explain it is that you’re going to be more of a cuckold from this point on.”

“More of a cuckold?” Adam asked.

Michelle laid down next to Adam and ran her fingers over his chest and stiff cock. She kissed his neck and listened to the purrs of pleasure that escaped her husband’s lips.

“Yes, honey. You’re going to sink deeper into cuckoldry. You’re going to commit yourself to my pleasure more than you already have. You’re going to accept that Caleb is going to meet some of my emotional needs along with all of my sexual needs. You’re going to embrace taking on an even more supportive role in my life,” Michelle explained.

She watched a drop of precum form at the tip of Adam’s cock as she informed him of what his new role would look like.

“Why do you want this?” Adam asked in a pained voice.

“At first, I wasn’t sure if this was what I wanted, to be honest,” Michelle said as her fingers danced over Adam’s testicles. “It seemed like it go could wrong in so many ways that it wouldn’t be worth it.”

She rubbed her fingers over Adam’s taint and teased his asshole a tiny bit before stroking his cock once more.

“But then I started to think about how our marriage has already changed since Caleb and I got together,” Michelle said. “I used to let you fuck me after Caleb and I had been together. Do you remember that?”

Adam groaned. “Yes, I remember.”

“Do you remember why I stopped letting you fuck me?” Michelle asked as she squeezed Adam’s cock hard enough to make him wince.

“Because I always disappointed you,” he answered. “I always came too quickly and you could never feel me inside you.”

“That’s right. It was all about you and it didn’t make any sense. I got absolutely nothing out of letting you inside me after I’d been with Caleb. Do you remember how you used to feel after you’d fucked me?” Michelle asked.

“Terrible,” Adam said. “It always felt so good to cum and then I’d feel terrible about it. I could see that it had done nothing for you, that I was being selfish. It always ruined the pleasure of it.”

“That’s right,” Michelle said as she let go of his cock and ran her fingers through Adam’s sparse chest hair. “It wasn’t working for either of us, so we stopped. We made a change that worked better for our marriage. You got to stroke your little dick while I directed you and sometimes I would give you handjobs. Hasn’t that been fun?”

“It has,” Adam said as he looked at his wife. “But this is different,” he argued.

“Is it, though? Or is it just another step down a perfectly logical path? Shouldn’t a good cuckold be willing to take a back seat to the man that gives his wife what she needs? Shouldn’t you be willing to let Caleb take an increased role in my life?” Michelle asked as her fingers moved over Adam’s chest.

“I…I don’t know,” Adam said.

Michelle kissed his neck softly and listened to her husband purr again. “Do you remember how you used to watch every time Caleb and I fucked?”

“Yes,” Adam said.

“And do you remember that you gave that up when I wanted to spend more time alone with Caleb?” she asked.

“Yes, I do,” he answered.

“You were doing what a cuckold is supposed to do. You recognized that my needs should come before yours and you gave me what I needed. You let me enjoy Caleb the way I wanted to enjoy him. You recognized that I needed to spend the night with him in our bed, that I needed to shower with him in the morning, that I needed the freedom to enjoy him as I desired,” she recalled.

“I did,” Adam admitted.

“And that turned out to be pleasurable for you, didn’t it?” Michelle asked.

“It did,” he said.

“It was different than watching, of course, but you liked listening to us fuck from the guest room. You like knowing that I was showering with him, that I was free to enjoy my bull as I desired,” Michelle said.

She watched Adam’s cock throb without any help from her. A steady stream of precum had started to drip from the tip.

Michelle wrapped her fingers around Adam’s little erection and stroked him slowly. His precum was the perfect lubrication.

“This is just the next step, honey. It’s no different than the rest, even if it feels scary,” she said while giving him a slow, sensual handjob.

Adam closed his eyes and moaned. Michelle smiled at his willingness to be led down a path of lusty cuckold pleasure.

“What will this mean, practically speaking?” Adam asked.

“It means Caleb and I are going to spend a lot more time together and that you’re going to be less involved when we do. It means I’m going to spend the night at his place more often and that when he comes to our place you’re going to have to respect our desire for time alone as a couple,” Michelle said.

She smiled as Adam groaned. She knew when her husband was turned on by something and he was clearly warming up to the idea of taking a back seat in their marriage.

“It means Caleb and I are going to go on dates, real dates,” Michelle said. She wondered how Adam would respond.

His eyes shot open and there was genuine worry. Michelle had been expecting this response.

“Wait, real dates? In public?” Adam asked.

Michelle waited for the initial wave of panic to pass before she kissed her husband and stroked his cock. She returned him to a state of arousal before answering his question.

“Yes, honey, real dates in public. And yes, that means what you think it means. People are going to find out that I’m dating another man. They’re going to find out that I have a boyfriend. They’re going to find out that you’re a cuckold,” Michelle said.

She could see Adam wrestling with that realization. “But…but that’s…” he said before trailing off.

“I know it’s scary, but it’s time, Adam,” Michelle informed him. “You can’t provide me with what I need and Caleb can. I want you to be my cuckold husband forever, but I want Caleb and I to take the next step in our relationship, too, and that means being out in public together. I’m not going to flaunt it and we’re not going to go to parties with our friends or anything, but people are inevitably going to find out and you’re going to have to deal with that.”

Michelle felt sympathy for her husband as she watched him deal with what was clearly upsetting news.

“It’s not all bad, though,” she said. “You’re finally going to get to clean creampies out of me.”

“Really?” Adam asked.

Michelle smiled at his sudden ebullience. “I’ve already started on the pill and Caleb and I will no longer be using condoms. He’ll be cumming in your wife starting tonight and you’ll get to clean his creampies as often as possible.”

Michelle knew that cleaning her messy, cum-filled pussy was Adam’s biggest cuckold fantasy and one of the few he hadn’t yet gotten to live out. She could feel his cock get harder in her hand.

“You like that, don’t you? You like that I’m going to feed you my boyfriend’s cum, don’t you?” she asked.

“Yes,” he groaned. “Fuck, yes, I fucking love it.”

Michelle felt like she’d finally pushed through the wall of resistance Adam had put up. The creampie cleanup had been enough to break it down. All he needed was the proper reward to motivate him.

“Good, then it’s settled. Your wife has a boyfriend,” Michelle said.

“Yes, she does,” Adam answered.

He no doubt hoped Michelle would give him an orgasm, but she released his cock from her grip and slid out of the bed.

“Sorry honey, but a cuckold has to earn his orgasms, and today that means you’ll need to clean a creampie from your wife’s pussy before you’re allowed to cum. Do you understand?” she asked.

“Of course,” Adam said.

---

Caleb climbed on top of Michelle as she spread her legs. Her red dress rode up to her waist and exposed her dampness of her sheer panties.

Their first date had gone spectacularly well. They’d enjoyed a long, slow, romantic dinner at a beautiful restaurant. They’d shared intimate conversation, lots of sensual kisses, and opened up to each other like a new couple tends to do.

They’d shared a bottle of champagne and couldn’t help but make out on the Uber ride home. The bubbly buzz provided by the alcohol left them both feeling utterly delighted as they made their way to the bedroom.

Adam was nowhere to be found, as Michelle had instructed him. He would be called upon to clean his first creampie when they were finished, but not before then.

Michelle wanted to be free to enjoy having unprotected sex with her boyfriend for the first time. As they kissed in the bed she usually shared with Adam, she couldn’t help but feel an overpowering desire to have Caleb inside her.

Michelle didn’t bother stripping her boyfriend naked or going down on him. She pulled his cock out of his pants, pulled aside the panties she’d bought for Valentine’s Day, and guided his stiffness inside her.

She groaned when Caleb’s big cock bottomed out inside her the first time. Her legs wrapped around him and with every slow, deep thrust Michelle moaned louder.

The sex was slower and far more sensual than usual and something about it felt better. The lack of a condom was unquestionably a big part of that. The skin on skin contact was more thrilling than she’d expected.

Knowing that Caleb was going to cum inside her for the first time was intensely arousing too. She’d been looking forward to that moment for months. The very idea of it turned her on. She loved that Adam was going to live out his fantasy too.

All of that must have thrilled Caleb too, because he didn’t last long. Soon after Michelle experienced a body-shaking, screaming orgasm, Caleb released his cum inside her.

They both laughed at how quickly they’d cum and shared an intensely pleasurable, long, sensual kiss before Caleb pulled out.

“Honey!” Michelle called out.

Moments later Adam appeared in the doorway.

“You may clean me,” she said.

Adam promptly moved between her legs and went to work licking up his first creampie.

Michelle pulled Caleb’s lips to hers and kissed him while her husband ate another man’s cum from her freshly-fucked pussy. Everything about the moment thrilled her and she wanted it to last forever.

“Happy Valentine’s Day,” Michelle whispered to Caleb.

He smiled and kissed her again. “Happy Valentine’s Day,” he said in return.

Michelle gazed longingly at her boyfriend as Adam continued to feast on the cum dripping out of her. “Will you spend the night?” she asked while running her fingers through Caleb’s dark hair.

“I wouldn’t have it any other way,” he answered. “Once isn’t nearly enough to satisfy my desire for you, after all.”

Michelle slipped her tongue into Caleb’s mouth and moaned as Adam feasted on the cum dripping out of her. Her perfect Valentine’s Day wasn’t nearly over. There was so much more fun to be had.