Cuckolded at a College Party

She’s the first girl you’ve ever had sex with. She’s funny, smart, and beautiful and from the day you met in your calculus class you’ve known she’s out of your league.

That didn’t stop her from going out with you though. It didn’t stop her from eagerly making out with you in the back row of the movie theater you went to on your second date. It didn’t stop her from giving you a handjob in your dorm room.

You were her first, too. It was awkward, just like it always is when two people try something they’ve never done before. It was good though; at least for you. Your orgasm came fairly quickly, but you got better each time.

She’s still going out with you and you’re still having sex, so you figure it can’t be all that bad. You’re not sure if she’s climaxing when you fuck though. She definitely does when you go down on her. It took a little while to figure that out, but eventually she got you to a place where you can reliably get her off with your tongue.

Guys hit on her. She’s beautiful, so of course they do. Sometimes a guy is hitting on her as you arrive for a dinner date or at the movies. Sometimes guys hit on her when you’re standing right there. That never feels good.

It makes you jealous when they hit on her, but not in a way that makes you angry. There’s something else there. Mostly it’s just confusing. All kinds of emotions rush through you when it happens.

You try not to think about it, but you’ve noticed that the sex seems to be a little hotter after you’ve witnessed someone else flirting with her. You’re pretty sure she always cums during that kind of sex. You cum harder, too.

That’s why you’re okay watching her flirt with another guy right now. You’re at a sorority house for a party and there are dozens of people crammed into the main room. You and your girlfriend did a few shots before separating to talk to your friends and you’re feeling a little buzzed. You know she is too.

Someone is talking to you, but you’re not paying attention. You’re watching your girlfriend flirt with a guy that flares up your insecurities. He has to be an athlete. He’s big and strong-looking and he seems to have the kind of confidence that comes from being a star on the field. He’s certainly not shy about openly flirting with a girl he knows is dating another guy.

As you watch, it’s hard to shake the feeling that something about this is different. This isn’t like when you show up to a date and some guy is flirting with your girlfriend. She knows you’re in the room. She probably knows you’re watching and she’s not doing a damn thing to stop it.

When the guy leans closer your heart skips a beat. For a moment it looks like he’s going to kiss your girlfriend. He doesn’t, though. He just wants to be closer. He runs his finger up and down her arm and leans in even closer to whisper something in her ear.

Then he walks away. Your eyes follow him across the room and up the stairs. You’ve seen a few couples disappear upstairs and figured they were leaving to enjoy the kind of intimacy that a few drinks and plenty of flirting can inspire.

You look back to your girlfriend. She’s staring at you. You’re too far away to say anything. She wouldn’t be able to hear you over the noise of the party. You see a familiar look of lust in her eyes. Then there’s the briefest flash of regret as she moves across the room and up the stairs.

For a moment you allow yourself to believe that she wants you to follow her so the two of you can have sex in one of the bedrooms upstairs. You know it’s not true though. You know what she’s going up there to do, and it doesn’t involve you.

You sulk as you watch her ascend the stairs. She’s going up there to fuck someone else. She’s going to cheat on you and she’s doing so with your knowledge. Then it dawns on you that she’s actually doing it with your permission. You could have stopped her. You could have talked to her. You could have dumped her and walked out of the party if she insisted on fucking another guy.

You didn’t, though. You acquiesced. You offered no resistance. You watched her go upstairs knowing that she would soon have another guy’s cock inside her. You’re still not doing anything about it.

Then something clicks. You realize that what you’re feeling through the mild, alcohol-induced haze in your head is arousal. That’s when you decide to go upstairs.

Your legs feel weak as you climb the steps your girlfriend and her soon-to-be lover climbed before you. You hold the railing for stability as your mind rushes through the scenarios that might be playing out in the bedroom they chose.

You walk down the hallway, which mostly features closed doors. There are moans coming from a few of the bedrooms, but none that sound familiar.

You make a left turn at the end of the hallway and there’s a door that’s been left open. You can feel your heart pounding as you step closer. Your eyes adjust to the darkness and you see a girl on her knees. It takes a moment to realize that it’s your girlfriend and, more importantly, that she’s giving a blowjob.

You can see his hand in her hair and you can see his cock, but his face and most of his body is hidden by the door. You have a perfect view of your girlfriend though. You can see very clearly that she has another man’s cock in her mouth and that she’s offering him a rather passionate blowjob.

“Fuck that feels good,” the guys says.

Your girlfriend doesn’t stop. If anything, she goes deeper on his cock. It seems like she wants to show him how passionate she is for his cock. He moans in response.

You stand perfectly still in the hallway. Even if someone came up the stairs they wouldn’t see you, but you don’t want to disturb what’s happening in the bedroom. You’re not sure why, but you want to watch.

You know that most guys would be furious if they were to witness such a display. If they were to watch their beautiful girlfriend sucking another guy’s cock they’d get violent, or scream, or storm out of the house and swear never to see the bitch again. Clearly, you’re not most guys.

You have an erection. You don’t want to acknowledge it, but you can’t deny it. You’re watching your girl suck blow someone else and your cock is hard.

“I wanna fuck you,” the guy says.

Part of you hopes she says no and that she’ll just suck him off and be done with it. The other part of you hopes they’ll have sex in a position that lets you watch from the hallway.

Your girlfriend’s mouth pulls off his cock. She looks up at him and uses her spit as lube while she strokes him and plays with his balls. Her eyes are alive with lust. She’s definitely not going to suck him off. That’s the look of a girl that needs to get fucked.

She lets go of his cock and stands up before pulling up her skirt and yanking down the skimpy panties she wore. She tosses them aside and straddles him. Your girlfriend reaches between his legs and guides the other guy’s cock into her pussy.

Just like that, another man is inside her, and without any form of protection. You hear them kiss as she sinks onto his cock and slowly rocks her hips.

He pulls her top off and unhooks her bra, freeing your girlfriend’s perky tits. You see his hands move to them but the door blocks you from seeing how he plays with her breasts. You hear her moan.

She starts to ride him. Your cock throbs as you watch your girlfriend slowly bounce on another man’s cock. She’s not shy about moaning. She clearly can’t help it. She’s got a big cock inside her and it feels good. He groans too. You know how good her pussy feels and now he does too.

“Oh my God,” your girlfriend says. “You feel so fucking good.”

Jealousy creeps in. She’s never said that to you before. She moans during sex. She urges you to fuck her. She’s never said that you feel good. Do you not feel good inside her?

You can’t help but think about the size difference. You’re not small; you’ve measured and at 5.5 inches you’re perfectly average. You know he’s bigger though. You saw it. He’s much bigger and it seems like she’s really enjoying his size.

“Oh fuck,” she cries out. “I’m cumming!”

Your dick is so hard it hurts. Your girlfriend is cumming on someone else’s cock and your response is overpowering desire. You nearly pull it out and masturbate in the hallway. The possibility of getting caught stops you from doing so.

After the pleasure of her climax passes your girlfriend leans back, turns her head, and looks right at you.

“Are you having fun out there?” she asks.

Your first instinct is to run. Maybe you could run far enough to get away from the embarrassment you feel. Even when that instinct passes you can’t think of anything to say. Thankfully, your girlfriend helps you.

“Get in here,” she says in a demanding tone that you find irresistible.

You push open the door, step into the small bedroom, and close it behind you. You look at your girlfriend and the guy whose cock is still buried inside her. He’s got a smug, satisfied look on his face. He probably should. He just fucked your girlfriend to an orgasm while you willingly watched.

You stand there as your girlfriend stands and lets his cock slip out of her pussy. It’s slick with her juices and still fully erect and ready to fuck. He’s not done yet, of course.

She walks over to you and offers a gentle kiss on the lips. Your body shudders with lust. She holds your gaze as her fingers work your belt and pants, pulling them down and exposing your hard cock.

Your girlfriend leans closer and whispers, “I know this turns you on. I want you to masturbate while you watch him fuck me.”

She leaves you and moves to the bed, getting on her back and urging her new lover to fuck her missionary style.

He turns his attention to her and you watch as another man guides his cock into your girlfriend’s wet, waiting pussy. His full length slips into her with ease and in no time he’s found a hard, fast rhythm that fills the room with the sounds of sex.

Your girlfriend wraps her legs around him and her hands move over his ass and back. Their moans mingle and fill your head. You wrap your fingers around your cock and masturbate like your girlfriend told you to.

Your orgasm will arrive quickly, so you grab a handful of tissues from the nightstand. You see your girlfriend’s face as you do. Her eyes are closed and she’s in a state of pure ecstasy. She loves that big cock inside her.

Soon the man fucking her groans. “I’m gonna cum,” he announces.

“Cum inside me,” your girlfriend says as she runs her fingers through his hair and over his back.

You’ve heard those words from her before. In the moment they’re even hotter when directed at another man. It’s as if she told you to cum, because you can’t hold back any longer. You ejaculate and catch your load in the tissues as he cums in your girlfriend.

Pleasure surges through you as you consider that someone else is cumming inside your girlfriend as you’re cumming into a pile of tissues in your hand.

He pulls out of your girlfriend and moves to quickly get dressed. You watch his cum slowly leak out of her pussy as you hold your still-hard cock in your hand. You know you should pull up your pants, but all you can do is stand there. He thanks your girlfriend, gives her a quick kiss, and leaves without saying anything to you.

The look of satisfaction on your girlfriend’s face makes you happy. The post-orgasmic bliss feels good too.

“We should do that again,” you say.

Your girlfriend smiles. “Absolutely,” she agrees.