Dominated by the Girl Next Door - Part 3

Click here to read the previous parts of the story.

"Come to my apartment. Right now," Chloe texted.

Phil had just put a frozen pizza in the oven, but he was more than happy to skip dinner for the chance to spend even a little time with his beautiful, amorous young neighbor.

He turned the oven off, rushed out of his apartment, and knocked on Chloe's door. "It's open, Phil," she called out.

He let himself in and saw Chloe and an equally beautiful young blonde sitting on the couch. The TV was on, a Netflix show was playing, and both girls turned to look at him as he shut the door.

"Phil," Chloe said with a smile, "this is my friend Cassidy. Cassidy, this is Phil."

"Hey Phil," Cassidy said as she too offered a smile, though hers was decidedly - and somewhat confusingly - flirty. "It's nice to meet you."

"Uh, it's nice to meet you too," Phil replied as he wondered why Chloe had called him over. He was certain it wasn't because she wanted to introduce him to her hot friend, as Cassidy was way out of Phil's league.

"I've been telling Cassidy about you, Phil," Chloe shared.

Phil felt a sudden and overwhelming sense of self-consciousness. He wasn't sure what Chloe had shared, but she only really knew him as a guy willing to do some pretty crazy sexual stuff for her benefit, so that's really all there was to share about him.

"But, she doesn't believe the things I've shared with her. She said it's not possible that a guy I barely know would be willing to do the things I've made you do for me," Chloe continued. "So, I called you over here because I want you to tell that it's all true. I want you to tell her that you're the kind of guy that would happily eat a stranger's cum out of my pussy, or wear my used panties, or fuck himself with a dildo for my pleasure."

"Is it true?" Cassidy asked as she looked at Phil with what seemed to be a certain kind of hunger that he didn't really understand.

"Yes," he admitted. "It's true. Everything she just mentioned is true."

"Did you really hide under her bed while she fucked a guy?" Cassidy asked as her face broke into a bright smile.

Phil couldn't help but feel a little of the joy that seemed to be emanating from Cassidy. "I did," he said.

"And then you ate his load out of her while fucking yourself with a dildo?" Cassidy asked. "Is that right?"

It sounded utterly absurd to hear her say it, and yet it had absolutely happened. Every bit of it had happened, and it was almost certainly nastier in person than it sounded when described. Phil had done it, though. He'd done every bit of it and he'd enjoyed it, too.

"I told you I wasn't lying," Chloe said to her friend. "I told you my neighbor is a fun little freak."

Cassidy got up off the couch and sauntered towards Phil with that same hungry look in her eyes. She stopped just in front of him and he caught a whiff of her perfume, which he found intoxicating. "Is she right, Phil?" Cassidy asked. "Would you call yourself a fun little freak?"

"A few weeks ago I wouldn't have," he replied. "But now, I guess I am. I don't know. I enjoyed what I did with Chloe. I even enjoyed the second time more than the first."

"The time when you rode a dildo like a fucking whore and then ate a guy's load out of her pussy? That time?" Cassidy asked.

Phil found the wild look in her eyes and the gleeful smile on her face utterly irresistible, like she was the sort of girl that always had some filthy idea spinning in the back of her head. "Yes, the time when I rode a dildo like a fucking whore and ate a guy's load out of Chloe's pussy. That time."

"Are you turned on right now, Phil?" Cassidy asked.

"A little," he answered.

Chloe got up off the couch, moved behind Phil, and reached around to unbutton his jeans and slowly push them down to his ankles. Cassidy then grasped his half hard cock through his underwear and stroked him slowly as Chloe lifted his shirt over his head, leaving him nearly naked in her living room.

He was hard before long, and when Cassidy looked down she giggled. "You don't have much to offer down there, do you Phil?" she asked. "I bet you'd struggle to hook up with anyone other than a fat chick or an ugly chick. I'm not sure why a hot girl would let you or this sad little dick of yours anywhere near her pussy."

He couldn't argue with her, as she was mostly right about his luck with women. He'd tried - from time to time, at least - to hook up with cute girls - never hot girls, as they were way out of his league - but he almost never succeeded and they never seemed to enjoy themselves when he did manage to hook up.

"He can still be useful," Chloe said as she slowly lowered Phil's underwear, leaving him completely exposed and fully erect in her living room. She grabbed his ass cheeks, squeezed them hard, and then spread them, exposing his asshole. "I would have enjoyed that guy's dick no matter what last week, but I enjoyed it more knowing that Phil was hiding under the bed like a little bitch. I enjoyed knowing I was going to make him eat a load out of my cunt. I enjoyed knowing that I could play with him in whatever way I wanted because he wouldn't dare say no. I came a whole lot harder because of that."

Cassidy took half a step closer and his cock nearly brushed against the part of her stomach that her cropped shirt left exposed. She wrapped her fingers around his shaft and stroked him slowly, teasing with every touch and making his heart pound with remarkable intensity.

"Does it feel good to have a girl like me touch your dick, Phil?" she asked.

He nodded.

Cassidy released his cock, grabbed his balls, and pulled down hard enough that Phil nearly lost his balance thanks to the sudden rush of pain. She laughed, pulled once more, and then released his testicles from his violent grasp.

"Don't break him," Chloe said. "I just started using him and I don't intend to stop anytime soon."

"Aww, I didn't break you, did I Phil? A man's balls are remarkably resilient, particularly if you're just tugging on them," Cassidy said before offering a sweet smile. "It didn't really hurt that much did it?"

He shook his head.

"And it was worth the pain because you got to feel me playing with your pathetic little dick, wasn't it?" Cassidy asked.

"Yes, it was," he admitted. It had been exquisitely pleasurable to be in her hand and he could imagine jerking off to the memory of it and experiencing a rather thrilling orgasm later that night.

"What should we do with him?" Chloe asked, making Phil feel like he really was nothing more than a toy, a notion that proved arousing in the moment.

"I kind of wanna see him fuck that toy," Cassidy answered before rubbing her index finger over the tip of Phil's cock. "But I wanna direct the action. I wanna make you my toy, you little bitch."

Chloe gave his ass a good smack and said, "Get the toy, Phil. You know where it is."

Phil headed for Chloe's bedroom as Cassidy called out, "And get a pair of her dirty used panties, too. I know there's a pair with crusty cum in them. There must be. She's a total fucking cock addict, she can't help herself."

"Fuck you," Chloe said, though she laughed while saying it, and Phil had heard her fucking often enough that it seemed like a fair way to label her.

Phil stepped into Chloe's closet and found a pink lace thong with what looked like cum stains in the gusset. He grabbed those, retrieved the dildo from her nightstand, and returned to the living room to find the two beautiful girls sitting on the couch.

"Put the panties on," Cassidy said.

Phil stepped into the panties and pulled them snugly against his stiff cock and tight balls.

"Now put the dildo on the floor, get on your hands and knees, and suck on it," she instructed. "And make it a sloppy fucking blowjob, too. You're gonna want lots of spit on it because it's going deep in your ass."

Phil dropped to his knees, put the dildo down, and bent over to take it in his mouth.

"Look up at us, slut," Cassidy said. "Always make eye contact when you're giving head. Guys love that, and you should really start learning what guys love when you're sucking dick, because I have a feeling that it won't be long before you've got a real dick stretching those pretty lips of yours."

Phil experienced an odd mixture of panic and lust at the idea of being made to suck a cock, something he'd never considered doing despite having given head to a dildo without hesitation.

"What do you think, Chloe? Is that cocksucker on his hands and knees going to have a real dick in his mouth soon?" Cassidy asked.

Chloe watched his mouth bob up and down on the lifelike dildo and smiled. "It would be fun to make him suck dick, a real dick. It would be fun to make him slap his face with the dick, suck on a big pair of balls, lick a guy's fucking taint. It would be fun to make him eat a guy's ass, too. Holy shit, that would be fucking amazing. Can you imagine this little panty clad bitch tongue fucking some guy's asshole because I told him to?"

It was depraved, and yet Phil imagined himself doing that very thing for the beautiful girl sitting in front of him. Even more depraved was the fact that he didn't find the idea utterly abhorrent. Maybe because it seemed like a complete fantasy, but his balls tingled in the hottest way possible as he imagined doing something so filthy for such a beautiful girl.

"I don't think I can imagine it quite clearly as you can," Cassidy said with a smile. "You and the panty boy might be made for each other, as I'm pretty sure he wouldn't object to you ordering him to tongue fuck some dude's hairy asshole while you watched and played with your sloppy cunt."

"My cunt's not sloppy!" Chloe shot back.

Cassidy laughed, put her arm around her friend, and pulled her close for a hug. "I know. I'm just teasing. Though, if the guy Phil's rimming just came inside you, your cunt would definitely be sloppy."

Chloe smiled. "Fair enough."

The toy moved in and out of Phil's mouth with greater ease the wetter and slipperier it got, and now the entire shaft was coated in his spit thanks to a steady stream of saliva emanating from his mouth.

"Speaking of sloppy cunts, I think it's time for you to take that thing for a ride with your ass pussy, Phil," Cassidy said. "But I want you to do it reverse cowgirl. Show us that fine ass of yours while you bounce on that dick like the only thing you care about is making it nut in your ass."

Phil spun around on his knees, pulled the thong aside, and reached back to guide the toy to his asshole. He knew it was an utterly absurd thing to do - what kind of guy surrenders himself to a pair of girls that see him as nothing more than a toy to use and abuse - and yet Phil didn't hesitate, thanks almost entirely to the intense arousal coursing through his body.

He wanted to fuck his ass for Chloe and Cassidy. He wanted to stretch his hole with the toy. He wanted to ride it in reverse cowgirl. He wanted to bounce his ass pussy on it.

It hurt as it moved into his ass, but of course it hurt. It was big and his asshole was quite small. Phil sank down on it slowly and looked over his shoulder to see that same wild desire in Cassidy's eyes.

"Fucking hell, he's actually doing it," she said. "Holy fuck."

"I told you," Chloe replied with a smile. "He's up for anything. He didn't even hesitate the previous times I played with him. Phil is down to get fucking wild."

Cassidy looked into his eyes and said, "You've never had a girl ride your dick in reverse cowgirl, have you Phil?"

"No," he admitted.

"Of course you haven't. You're not the kind of guy that inspires a girl to do whatever she can to make him cum. Some guys are that way, though. Some guys are worth working hard for. I want you to fuck that toy like you're fucking one of those guys. I want you to work his dick with your ass pussy. I want you to put on a show for him, Phil. Show off what a good slut you can be. Show off that you're the kind of girl that's worth fucking again," Cassidy encouraged him.

Phil wanted to do it. He wanted to please Cassidy and Chloe. He wanted to make them both happy, to show that he was the kind of guy that was down for just about anything. He'd never thought of himself as that kind of guy, and yet the idea of being that for Chloe and her friend sounded so fucking hot.

So Phil rode the toy with his ass. He put his hands on the ground in front of him and he pushed his hips back and down, taking the dildo to the hilt and then lifting his asshole off it slowly before dropping back down again. He arched his back to try and make his ass look better and then he added in a few lusty moans so it sounded like he was getting off on having the dick buried inside him.

"You should do more than make him suck dick and eat ass," Cassidy said. "This little bitch was made to fuck. Look at him go. Look at how badly he wants to make us happy. Look at the fucking show he's putting on riding that toy. You could fucking film him and put his ass on OnlyFans. You'd get a few freaks signing up to watch this little bitch ream out his asshole with a fat fucking dildo."

Phil definitely didn't want that to happen, but he rode the toy harder. In fact, he rode it so hard and so deep that it started to feel like he might actually orgasm from it. It must have been massaging his prostate as it bottomed out inside him, and while his asshole ached from the constant stretching, the prostate pleasure felt fucking amazing.

"Holy shit, are you going to cum?" Chloe asked.

"Yes," Phil replied.

Both girls laughed, but to Phil it sounded like there was at least a bit of genuine delight in that laughter.

"Should I let him cum?" Chloe asked.

"No," Cassidy replied. "He hasn't earned that. He doesn't deserve it. He doesn't cum until we've cum."

"She's right, Phil," Chloe said. "But we can fix that. Come over here. Put that toy up your ass, and take it for a nice slow ride while you eat our pussies."

Both girls had their pussies out with remarkable swiftness as Phil moved into position in front of the couch, slid the toy up his ass once more, and waited for further instruction.

"You first," Chloe said. "He's my neighbor, after all, so I can play with him anytime I want."

Cassidy leaned forward, grabbed a handful of Phil's hair, and pulled him between her legs. "Eat my cunt and ride that toy with your ass pussy. Right fucking now. And don't you dare cum."

Phil settled the toy onto the floor and then took it for a slow ride while his tongue went to work on Cassidy's pussy. She kept her fingers entwined in his hair the entire time, occasionally pulling, seemingly because it turned her on to make him feel pain. Phil found it thrilling that she was soaked the moment his tongue slipped inside her, as he took it to mean that he'd turned her on through his willingness to do whatever she and Chloe wanted.

Cassidy came quickly, too, calling him a series of degrading names while grabbing two fistfuls of his hair and clamping her thighs around his head. She smothered him with her pussy, too, covering his face in her juices.

"Fuck, that was really good," she said. "Really fucking good."

"Maybe I shouldn't let him cum after he's eaten my pussy," Chloe suggested. "Maybe we should use him all night before we let him nut while fucking that toy."

Cassidy smiled, looked down at Phil, and then pulled his head back as she leaned forward. "Does that sound fun, Phil? Do you want to be used by two beautiful girls for their pleasure? Do you want us to do whatever the fuck we please in the name of our pleasure?"

"Yes," Phil answered.

A wicked smile crossed Cassidy's face and remained there for a few moments before she spit on him and released her grip on his hair. "Then I think that's what we should do."

"Come eat my pussy, Phil," Chloe instructed. "Keep the toy in your asshole while you do. Be a good little bitch."

Phil crawled between her beautiful legs and set about eating her pussy. He hoped he'd soon give her the first of what would be many orgasms that night. He hoped that she and Cassidy would continue to be imaginatively wild with him, as he felt a deep need to serve at whatever cost they desired.