Poison the Well

Pairings: Maggie Lindermann/Madison Beer

Summary: Maggie loves when a good girl falls into her lap. 3rd POV.

Content: Semi-public sex, hook-up, innocence kink, corruption kink, dom!Maggie, oral, fingering, ass play, masturbation.

Maggie can't get over how Madison smells like fresh baby powder and sweet innocence.

She's the last person she expected her friend to bring out with them tonight. Maggie has no clue how her friend Mike knows a girl like Madison who is like Bambi in this bar. It's not her scene, and it's obvious that it's not because when she went to order her drink, she totally flubbed. Maggie just so happened to swoop in and save her from the social embarrassment. The bartender had looked like he wanted to throw her out even though Madison is over the age of 21. His expression softened once Maggie began ordering for her instead.

It was a friendly gesture to disguise Maggie's desire to get closer to her. She was so curious about her that she had to find her opportunity.

Madison was a giggly girl. Maggie wondered if this was Madison's true nature or if she was nervous, or even if this is her way of flirting. Maggie couldn't stop staring at her perfectly glossed lips. Everything about her is so perfect: her hair, her make-up, her outfit, everything. She wore a sweet shade of pink on her cheeks that almost matched her tinted lip gloss and the dress she's wearing. Maggie felt the pressing urge to want to see her in total darkness. She wondered how Madison would sound with her head between her legs, feasting away at her cute pussy. Soon enough Maggie's cheeks were turning a similar shade of Madison's blush because of her own thoughts.

"Are you hot in here? I think it's a little hot," Maggie quips. It's always hot in the bar. She's used to it by now but she can see that the heat leaves Madison a little rattled. Maggie looks down at Madison's legs under the table and sees that she has them pressed together. She looks up at Madison's face and Madison nods in agreement that it is indeed hot in this packed bar.

Soon enough they were outside together. To any newcomer, the back alley of the bar would feel creepy and seedy. But really it was an area where people would just smoke, both cigarettes and other things. Maggie is no stranger to the back alley, and she never comes back here alone. She's glad that tonight is no exception and that in a matter of minutes she has Madison's hands pressed up against the brick wall with the skirt of her dress over her ass and Maggie's digits buried in her pink pussy.

Madison's legs tremble as she struggles to keep herself up. She turns her head around to look down at Maggie who has a smug look on her face. She's almost purring at the sight of her fingers disappearing into Madison's welcoming pussy. Madison blushes deeply at the sight and whimpers. Maggie looks like she's in love with her pussy and it's only been a minute.

"Mag...Maggie," Madison loves her name so lovingly for just having met her less than an hour ago.

Vocalizing her pleasure was hopeless when it was written all over her face. Maggie looks up at her with a glint in her eyes. Madison's mouth is parted and her pussy is so wet. Her low whimpers allow for the two of them to hear how sloppy her pussy sounds gushing around Maggie's diligent fingers. She plunges her fingers deeper into her.

Madison has never been fucked like this. She never thought she would have sex in such a public place even though it's so dark out beside the little light they get from the bar windows and the flickering lights outside. The sounds of the city fill Madison's ears while her moans fill Maggie's. She feels so overwhelmed, especially when Maggie slips in a third finger and has all of them pumping raw inside of her and filling her up. Maggie fingered her like she was insatiable. Madison of course welcomes her fingers deeper inside of her, enjoying this unexpected intimacy she feels with a near stranger.

"Love this cute little pussy -- so wet and pink for me. Wish I could take you home and bury my strap inside of you and fill you up with cream."

Her dirtiness makes Madison burn inside. She moans loudly which only encourages Maggie's filth.

"That sweet cunt is gripping me so hard baby. Fuck...are you gonna cum for me?" Her voice is almost a hushed whisper.

Madison nods her head wildly, unable to bring herself to speak actual words in fear that her voice will crack and she'll embarrass herself.

"Good girl," Maggie coos as she pumps Madison's cunt harder and faster now.

Madison reaches back to grab her ass cheek and spread it open for Maggie's viewing pleasure. Maggie can't help but feel spoiled by the sight of both her glistening pussy and tight hole. Madison is no longer that shy, little thing that had trouble ordering her own drink. Now she's offering up both of her holes to Maggie. Of course Maggie takes the offer and plants her face right between her cheeks and swipes her tongue off Madison'sa tight hole.

"Oh god," Madison moans. Her cries of pleasure are so angelic that Maggie is convinced she tainted an angel. The combination of her fingers pushed deep into her pussy and the warm tongue on her tight hole makes Madison shake. She tries to grab at the wall but obviously fails. She never thought she would be the girl the get fucked in the back alley of a bar but she's loving this so much. It makes her feel naughty and like a slut.

Maggie groans into Madison's ass when she feels Madison's pussy tightening around her fingers. Maggie feels her own pussy getting wet but she wants to focus and spend time turning Madison into a moaning mess. It turns her on so much to be fucking a cute girl like this; and Maggie thinks Madison is the cutest girl she has ever fucked. Her pussy is so sweet and warm and Maggie can't wait to have a taste of her sweet nectar. Maggie wants to bury her tongue in her pussy so bad that she thinks she might die if she doesn't lick her out tonight. But first she's going to make her cum.

Maggie pulls her face away from between Madison's cheeks and takes in a fresh breath of air.

"You gonna cum for me like a slut? Are you gonna show me how much of a slut you are for me?"

"Yes yes yes!" Madison cries out. There is a chance that someone can hear them and what they're doing, but it's to be expected outside of a bar, right?

"Good girl. I don't know how I got so lucky to meet such an obedient slut."

Despite the harsh words, Madison's heart flutters as Maggie compliments her; all she wants to do is be a good girl.

So, like a good girl does, she cums around Maggie's fingers and drenches them with her cum. She moans louder than ever before as her orgasm runs through her entire body. Maggie and the wall are solely keeping her propped up. Maggie doesn't let up on her sensitive pussy though, she keeps fingering her cunt until she is satisfied with her own work. When she does pull her fingers out they're drenched in Madison's cum. Madison only gets a few seconds to regain her strength before Maggie sticks her face in her pussy.

Maggie feels so gluttonous as she feasts on Madison's wet pussy. She tastes better than she expected and the taste intoxicates her more than any of the alcohol in the bar. Not being able to take it anymore, she slips her hands in her own pants and starts rubbing her clit while licking at Madison's folds. She hums into her pussy which starts Madison's moans up again. It's completely overwhelming and they're feeding off of each other's energy. Madison doesn't think she isn't going to be able to cum again because her pussy is so sensitive, but she has a feeling deep in her belly that wants her to let go.

Maggie fills her pussy and moves them hard and fast in a similar way she did to Madison's pussy. She keeps moaning into her cunt which sends more vibrations throughout Madison's body. Her cum mixes with what's left of Madison's cum on her fingers. It forces another scenario to enter Maggie's head where the two of them bumping pussies and their juices mixing that way. Madison turns her on so much that Maggie is considering breaking her 'one-night-only' rule for bar hook-ups, but maybe she'll just let this be a one time fantasy for the both of them.

As much as Maggie likes eating Madison out, she's solely focusing on her own orgasm now. She was jealous of the total pleasure Madison felt as she made her cum and wanted to feel the same way. She wraps her lips around Madison's clit while finger fucking herself into an orgasm. Madison doesn't cum again but she completely drenches Maggie's face with her juices.

Maggie pulls away and takes a deep breath. her body feels completely satiated and an almost wicked smile forms on her face. She can't believe how easy it was to adulterate someone so sweet.