Girl Next Door

Addison Rae x Reader x OFC. 3rd POV. Word Count: 4,624.  Addison wants Y/n's wife and both of them finally get their wish. Warnings for a tiny bit of moral fog, older women with a younger woman, slight (very slight) mentions of cheating. This features a random original fictional character similar to the Kim fic and is just there for the sake of the story!

☆・*。

Y/n was watching her wife "help" their neighbor's daughter. She called her name from over the fence when she spotted them in the backyard. She said something about "needing help with the pool filter." That was a lie. Y/n saw her parent's pool boy change it just two days ago. She knew it was another ploy from the teen to get Y/n's wife around her.

Addison had just turned 19, but she has had a crush on Y/n's wife, Valerie, long before. Valerie was oblivious to it and the girl, but as someone who had a wandering eye at that age, Y/n knew what those looks the teen gave her wife meant. She knew what the teen girl was doing when she lied her way into situations with Valerie.

"I just don't see it honey," Valerie had explained to Y/n that night. "She's young, why the hell would she want me?"

"Young girls love the idea of being with someone older, don't be so stupid! She asks for your help over the most asinine stuff and it's always when her parents aren't home. She's probably hoping to fuck you," Y/n jokes.

"Don't be ridiculous. She might have an innocent crush. Might. Anyway, why are you bringing it up? Are you jealous?"

"Ha ha, very funny. Yes, I'm jealous of a random girl who probably dreams about getting to fuck the person I'm bound to for life."

Y/n crawls on the bed, inching closer to Valerie as she gets the perfect view of Y/n's tits under her nightgown. She didn't intend to fuck her tonight, but right now she needed Y/n so bad.

"I'm totally jealous," Y/n says when she finally gets on top of Valerie and kisses her neck. She sticks her hand in Valerie's pajamas bottoms and her hand finds its way to her clit. She was getting wet already. Valerie pulled down her bottoms to give Y/n better access. Valerie's lips capture her as her wife starts to rub her clit in circles. She pulled away to groan, she needed Y/n's touch so bad.

"I bet you imagine it's sweet little Addison rubbing you instead of me."

Valerie moans unexpectedly when Y/n says that. She applies more pressure in reaction and starts rubbing into her faster.

"Better yet, I bet you'd love to have her sweet lips on you. I bet she tastes like honey."

Y/n's breath was hot against Valerie's ear. Her eyes shut tightly as her senses get overwhelmed.

"She'd probably beg for you to fuck her with the thickest cock we have in this house. To fill her up and then make her teen pussy cum so hard for you. You'd love that wouldn't you? A tight pussy to fuck and then making her cum until she has tears in her eyes. And, then having me cleaning up the mess and eating her tight pussy."

That does it for Valerie as she cums hard. Lena continues to rub her for a few more seconds before she pulls her hand out of Valerie's pants. She brings her hand up to her mouth to lick Valerie's cum off of it.

"You haven't come that hard in a long time, and I just used my hand. It must've been the thought of sweet little Addison," Y/n teases.

Valerie feels guilty. And wrong.

She has never thought about her neighbor's daughter that way. Her and Lena have gone on outings with her mother and they've been over there for dinner and vice versa. Valerie and Addison's father even trade gardening tips for god sake! Addison has never been a blip on her radar because honestly, she mentally tunes out all teenagers, assuming they just want to be left alone by adults to do whatever the hell it is teenagers do in 2020. But, Y/n really got her going. Valerie wonders how long Y/n has had thoughts about her and Addison like that. She only really started to come around last year, around the time her mother told Y/n that Addison had broken up with her boyfriend. Maybe she has always had a crush on Valerie, but kept it tame because she was young and had a boyfriend. But, now she's 19, has no boyfriend, and suddenly wants to be around Valerie a lot. It's harmless, right?

-

"I'll be back at 2. I gotta go to Cynthia's before I go to the grocery story. I love you honey." Y/n kisses Valerie before she leaves through the garage to run her errands for the day.

Valerie will be home alone for a few hours before Y/n gets back. It was a Saturday morning and usually she'd have plans, but one of her co-worker's daughter is sick so she ended up with a free Saturday. She almost told Y/n to run errands tomorrow so they could stay in bed and cuddle and eventually fuck, but Y/n hates to run her errands on a Sunday. Valerie wished that just this once she'd break her routine, she'd love to stay in the house all day and order pizza and fuck her throughout the day. They haven't done something like that since the beginning of their marriage and it was something Valerie missed, but life and their careers got in the way at times.

Valerie found a way to make herself busy though. She'd check her phone periodically to see if she got a text from Y/n or to text her. Even through the phone, Y/n could sense that Valerie really missed her, but she had to get things done or else she'd keep putting them off.

It was around noon that there was a knock on the door. The likelihood of someone coming over unannounced was very low. Maybe it was one of her friends, or someone at the wrong house.

Valerie opened it to Addison being behind the door.

"Addison?" She questions with a furrowed brow.

"Hi Mrs. Y/L/N , is Y/n home?"

She shook her head before responding with a light, "no."

Addison looked a little nervous, but Valerie couldn't figure out why.

"Well, can I come in?"

What was she going to say? No? She was her neighbor's daughter and both Valerie and Y/n were on great terms with them. Sure her mind kept going back to last night and she felt awfully guilty, but she was not going to slam the door in her face and leave her alone in the doorstep.

"Sure, sure. Come in."

Once she's inside she looks around aimlessly, observing the place around her.

"Is everything alright Addison?"

"Yea...yea. It's just a...specific problem and I really need Y/n's advice. My mother won't be home until the evening. Um, when does Y/n get back?"

"In about two hours I believe. Is there anything I could do for you?"

Addison shakes her head before she pauses.

"Actually, can you show me where the bathroom is?"

Valerie guides her to the bathroom and she locks herself in there for a few minutes. This is why Valerie stays away from anyone who was born in the 2000s, they were hard to read and just...odd to her. Addison was certainly sweet but Valerie isn't one to decipher teenage actions. She figures Addison knows her way back and goes back to sitting on the couch.

Addison was in the bathroom, slightly freaking out. She thought it'd be easier after flirting with Valerie for so many months. Now was her time, Y/n wasn't here and Valerie looked bored. She had to do it today.

Now in the kitchen, Valerie finally hears the door for the downstairs bathroom creak open. Addison quickly finds Valerie and this time she notices the change in her demeanor.

"I didn't come here for Y/n."

"What do you mean?" Valerie probably didn't even have to verbalize her question because it was already written all over her face.

Addison comes closer and she doesn't stop where Valerie expects her to. She places her body against Valerie's, she's much shorter than her so she's looking down at her, panic now coloring her face.

"Don't play stupid with me, Valerie," she fiddles with the top button of ers shirt. "I've wanted you so badly for so long. I'm tired of fucking with stupid boys, I need someone with experience to take me. I'm sure you're not stupid enough to pass up fucking a hot, younger girl. I'd let you do anything to me."

Her voice was seductive and Valerie wondered where a 19 year old girl would learn to say things like that. But, she was getting turned on and Addison could tell her words were working on her.

"C'mon, your wife won't be home for a while and neither will my parents. We can have so much fun together. Isn't it a fantasy to have a young girl throwing herself at you? I can do so many things for you your wife can't."

Addison's back was against the kitchen wall in seconds and she gasped at both the sudden movement and the change of Valerie's attitude. Her hand was around Addison's throat, pinning her to the wall. It felt dangerous, and that's what turned her on.

"Don't talk about my wife like that little girl. You may have a mouth on you, but I doubt you're very experienced; just all talk and no bite."

Valerie sticks her hand underneath her jean skirt and roughly runs the pads of her fingers against Addion's slit, making her gasp again.

"I can feel how wet you are even through your panties. Sluts like you get wet trying to wreck homes, don't they?"

While Valerie e did have the upper hand over her, Valerie couldn't resist the teen at this point. Addison's panties were soaked and she was slightly grinding against her hand, this little slut wanted it.

"I'm going to shut you up once and for all. You need to be put in your place," she spits.

Valerie runs her hand down the front of Addison's thin t-shirt before she pulls it up from the bottom. Her bra could hardly be called that, it was thin and barely contained her. She pulled it down roughly and caressed her breast.

"Is this what you wanted? The older woman next door to touch your titties?"

Valerie bends down and takes Addison's pink nipple into her mouth. "Oh god yes," she moans, answering both her question and reacting to how she sucks languidly on her nipple. Valerie feels them start to pebble under her tongue. She keeps her pinned to the wall by grabbing her hips and forcefully keeping her in place.

"I just want you to fuck me," Addison moans out.

Valerie pulls away and to Addison's surprise, she gives her a small slap on her face. It wasn't too hard or forceful, but it was still jarring.

"You don't call the shots around here. You need to learn some manners. Get your ass in the living room."

Addison obeys her and scurries into the living room, leaving Valerie alone in the kitchen. She decided she needed to shut her up by making her hot little mouth gag on a cock. Quickly, she goes to Y/n's "study" and rummages through one of her draws. She found the suction dildo that she loves to watch Y/n bounce on so much. It's not too thick which will be perfect for breaking Addison in. Valerie also grabs the strap-on she left in here when she fucked Y/n.

Addison sat in the living room, this time she was fully topless and her panties were discarded. Valerie was sort of feeling smug about Addison's eagerness to fuck her.

Valerie fastens the strap-on around her waist and then places the suction dildo on the hardwood floor in front of the couch. Once she makes sure it's secure, she turns to Addison.

"I want you to fuck yourself while I fuck your face. No cumming."

The instructions seemed daunting, but Addison was so turned on she was going to obey regardless. She removes the last piece of clothing, her skirt, and places it with her other discarded clothes. Valerie sits on the couch, her legs spread and the thick cock strapped to her waist standing up tall. Addison was intimidated to say the least, but she slid down on the dildo like she asked of her.

"Ahh," she sighed as she slid all the way down to the hilt. She sat on her knees to be able to bounce better. She has plenty experiencing riding as she use to fuck her boyfriend in the back of his car during 6th period math her last year of high school. She rode it slowly, feeling every ridge against her walls. It wasn't too long or thick, which made it easier for her. Addison hasn't had a long, thick cock inside of her; that's why she had mild anxiety seeing the thick cock Valerie has.

"Instead of being a nasty slut you need to put that mouth to use."

Addison was hesitant, first she grabbed the cock and felt the weight of it in her hand. She marveled at the size before looking up at Valerie with wide eyes. "It's so big Mrs. Y/L/N." Valerie just hums at her observation before responding, "that's why you've got to get it nice and wet before I fuck that tight cunt of yours."

Her boyfriends have never used such caustic language with her. It made her flinch, but it made the experience even hotter.

Addison took the tip in her mouth and swirled her tongue around it. She assumed that it was going to be like the times with her ex where she alternated between sucking and giving handjobs. But, she was wrong. Valerie grabbed the back of her head and forced her further down onto the cock. She held her head in place while she started to fuck her face.

"I didn't say you could stop riding bitch, keep going."

Addison focused on riding the dildo as Valerie did all the work to fuck her face. She'd feel the tip hit the back of her throat and it made her gag. She had to remind herself not to cum even though her body was barreling towards it. Her senses were overwhelmed and it made her body weak; she was giving into her and ultimately submitting.

"That's it Addi...you're such a good slut. If I'd known you do all this, I would've fucked this cute little face a long time ago."

Valerie loved watching her struggle to take the cock in her mouth, gagging on it and causing tears to form in her eyes. She did so much begging all for her not to be able to handle it.

It was getting harder for Valerie to just keep watching Addison suck on the cock, she needed to fuck her cunt. She needed to see Addison squirm beneath her.

When she finally lets up, Addison pulls her mouth off the cock and lets out a gasp for air. Her make-up is ruined and her face looks sloppy, she looks like a porn star.

"C'mon, get on the couch, face down ass up."

Addison was grateful for her command because her knees were starting to hurt against the floors. Pulling herself off the dildo, she felt empty again, but Valerie was going to be filling her up in seconds. Valerie admired her juicy pussy first. It was so soft and pink, begging for all of her attention. She aims the head at her slit and slowly pushes in. There was some resistance and her pussy was so goddamn tight but she kept going. Addison clawed at the cushion beneath her. Her pussy has never been invaded by something so big; it was scary yet exhilarating at the same time.

"It's so huge Mrs. Y/L/N."

"Sluts like you love big dicks. Don't act like you can't take it, I bet you fucked plenty of boys after school...letting them use your tight holes and then cumming inside of you like a cum dumpster."

It wasn't true, but in this moment Addison wished it was. She wanted to be the slut Valerie assumed her to be, but if she couldn't then she'd become a slut for her.

"Good sluts will fuck anyone. That's why you're here getting pounded by the old lady next door. So insatiable that you'll find cock anywhere and in any form."

Addison starts to throw her ass back to meet Valerie's thrust. Her ass slaps against her pelvis and makes a lewd sound. She takes every inch and hard thrust of the cock inside of her. She reaches her arm around to spread one of her ass cheeks. Valerie gets the perfect view of her face, which is scrunched up in pleasure. Addison's nipples graze against the material of the couch and add to her pleasure.

"I love how you fuck me Mrs.Y/L/N," she stammers.

Addison spreading her ass gives Valerie the perfect view of her asshole. It's most definitely untouched and she gets excited about the idea of being the first person to use. But, maybe some other day.

Valerie leans forward and places her hand on Addison's head. Her face is mushed into the couch as she picks up her speed into a punishing pace. She can barely moan because she's so overwhelmed.

Addison was too much in a daze to hear the sound of shoes clicking against the hardwood floor. She didn't come until someone was kneeling beside her and stroking her hair. Her eyes fluttered open and it was Y/n. She was looking up at her wife.

"I told you she wanted to fuck you."

Addison could've swore she was in a dream. Tears were stinging her eyes which made her vision blurry and her hearing was fuzzy too.

Y/n walked in on an unexpected sight, but she was the one to put those ideas in her wife's head; it only took her two days to execute it.

"How is this sluts pussy?"

"Oh, she's so fucking tight, but she's obedient."

Y/n loves to hear that. The more submissive, the better. She moves over to where Valerie is and watches her fuck into Addison roughly while she moaned like a little bitch. Y/n grabbed her waist and started pushing Addison back on her cock again. They were both so rough with her.

"I told you that teen pussy would be so good and needy. They're always so compliant and easy to break in. They always want more." Y/n was enamored, to say the least, with how hard Addison was getting her teen twat fucked. Something about the way her body took it turned Y/n on to no end.

Y/n sits on the couch in front of them and lifts up her dress. She wore no underwear because she had plans to come home after running errands and ride her wife's face, but this was better.

"C'mon girl. I know Valerie put that mouth to good use, now I want a turn."

Addison was just eager for sex that she didn't hesitate to put her mouth on Y/n's pussy. She has kissed and fingered a girl before but never ate pussy. Y/n could tell she was inexperienced by the way Addison licked her out, but she moved her tongue eagerly which made up for her lack of skills. Y/n runs her fingers through her long hair before she pets her head like a dog.

"Good girl. Take that dick and keep licking my pussy. I should've put that teen cunt to work a while ago. You're just so much sweeter and riper when your young and stupid. You're just our stupid slut aren't you baby?"

Addison nods against her cunt and Y/n smirks.

"Good girl. You're just the slut of the neighborhood. Is that what you want to be? The neighborhood slut who gets her pussy ruined every day?" Addison pulls away from Y/n's pussy to respond.

"I want you to make me a slut! I wanna take it everyday like a slut is supposed to!" Her pleas are desperate. Addison rests her head on Y/n's pelvis but continues to rub her clit.

"Your wife loves my teen pussy. I need to be used so badly!"

"I know baby. That teen pussy isn't going to be as tight when we're done with it."

Addison rubs Y/n's clit until she's having an orgasm. The mix of their back-and-forth and her short fingers rubbing circles into her sends Y/n over the edge. It gives her the tingles to watch her wife continue to fuck Addison. The girl looked like she was close to cumming which Y/n didn't want yet.

"Wait baby, slow down."

Valerie breaks out of her own trance of watching Addison's pussy get filled and looks to her wife. She slows down before ultimately stopping.

"I want you to fuck me while I get a taste of her." Valerie may have been dominant, but she let Y/n call all the shots today. She knows in the back of her mind when they are alone tomorrow, or even later tonight, she's going to drive this cock into Y/n while praising her for being such a slut tamer. But, now she was just going to fuck her slow enough for her to still be able to savor the taste of Addison's pussy.

They switch positions, now Y/n is getting fucked by her wife while she buries her face in Addison's pussy. Addison gets her first taste of what pussy eating really is with the way Y/n devours her. Y/n's tongue slides against parts of Addison's pussy she didn't even know could feel this good.

"Oh my god please don't stop!"

Y/n hums against her cunt when her wife pushes in deeper inside of her. She takes every inch of the thick cock like a pro as she focuses all of her attention on Addison's sweet cunt. She wiggles two fingers inside of her, making goosebumps form on the teen's skin.

Valerie enjoys the view of her wife's ass while her face is in between Addison's legs. The teen, who looks like she's in heaven, got more than she bargained for when she came over only to fuck Valerie, but it seems like she's taking it in stride...or at least she has no choice but to.

"She has such a creamy, tight pussy baby. Did you get a taste of her?"

"I didn't. She was so good for me, some compliant, I just had to fuck her. She did everything I asked her to do, like she was made to be a slut for me."

"A slut for us," Y/n corrects before she's back to sucking on Addison's clit. Her face was flushed with pleasure and she was about to cum.

"Oh baby I want you to cum all over my cock and then make her cum with you."

Valerie's command did not fall on deaf ears because Y/n started to work her mouth harder against Addison's pussy and began to meet her wife's thrust. She was getting extremely close to erupting and she can only hope Addison was too. However, by the way she was grabbing at her hair, Addison was going to cum quicker than Y/n expected.

Addison pretty much gushed against Y/n's face. She knew the girl would have a creamy pussy, but she didn't know she could get this wet. It triggered her orgasm to have her face buried in Addison's wet cunt. The girl beneath her was moaning so loud that it affected both Y/n and Valerie.

Y/n stopped pushing back against Valerie, and she slowly slid out. Y/n hates the empty feeling of the cock leaving her.

"Did you make her cum before I got home?"

"No. You walked into me fucking her and then took over," she says with a slight laugh.

"Well, we can get one more out of her. She's young, her body can handle it."

Valerie gave her a look that asked, what about you? She shrugged it off and pushed her so she's sitting on the couch. "Later."

Y/n grabs the drowsy Addison and makes her stand up.

"Ride her."

Addison starts to turn around to face Valerie until Y/n is grabbing her arm again.

"No, no, face me."

Addison obeys, sitting on Valerie's lap while facing Y/n. Valerie guides the cock inside of Addison and she instinctively starts bouncing up and down on it.

"Fuck," she lets out a breathless moan.

Y/n gets down on her knees in front of Addison and her wife. She sucks on her clit while Valerie thrusts her hips upward to fuck her.

"Oh my god!"

They were both overwhelming her, but they had no plans to stop. The harder Valerie fucked her, the more she became aroused. The sound of her cunt squelching while being filled and Y/n sucking on her clit was the only thing she could focus on. The cock was so thick in her and reached even deeper in this new position. Her tits bounced up and down as she rode Valerie faster. Y/n tried to keep up and keep her mouth on her as Addison swirled her hips.

"She's such a fucking slut Y/n. Look how into this she is."

"Keep fucking my tight pussy. I wanna cum again so bad!" Addison cried.

It doesn't take long before Addison is cumming again. She comes to a complete halt as her body is wrecked with pleasure. Y/n keeps suck at her clit and Valerie keeps the cock deep inside of her, sending her further into a tizzy.

"I can't...I can't take it," she cries, referring to Y/n who was still devouring her cunt.

"Yes you can sweet thing," Valerie whispers in her ear before kissing her shoulder blade. "You didn't come here for nothing. You wanted that little pussy of yours to get used and you got what you wanted. You should be grateful." The grip she had on Addison's hips tightened.

"I am! I am grateful!" She cries desperately.

"Good girl. Then let Y/n make you cum again."

Addison nods and lets her body take over. She feels numb all over and especially in her clit, but she still feels pulses of pleasure. Y/n licks her into another orgasm, this one quick and not as intense but still good.

Addison goes limp against Valerie; they really wore her out.

What feels like hours, is really minutes that pass by. Addison is broken from her daze when she feels something soft hit her chest. She opens her eyes and it's her t-shirt.

"Get dressed."

Valerie had already slid out of her cunt and she helped her to stand. She was a little more nicer than Y/n was who was sort of rushing her.

Once she was dressed Y/n ushered her to the door, leaving a naked Valerie on the couch.

"If I ever catch you snooping around my wife again, I'm going to be the one to fuck and trust me when I say I am so much meaner than her."

The door slams in her face and the threat makes Addison's heart race. But, it also makes the arousal pool to her cunt again. Addison is a defiant teenager, she's gonna come back for more. Especially after that threat.