♡ Love Bunny: In It Together

Sub!Ari x Dom!Reader, Word Count: 3,105

Y/n was surprised that she enjoyed taking Ariana from behind as much as she did. She always loved looking at Ari's face while she fucked her. While she was missing out on seeing her face contort from pleasure, the view she got from their current position was delightful.

The sound of Ariana's thighs slapping against her hips was hypnotic and driving her insane. It made her drive her strapon into her sloppily, unable to control how turned on she is. Y/n was able to plunge so deep inside of her; deeper and deeper. Ariana was letting out moans Y/n has never heard from her before. But, the best part was directly seeing the way the cock was splitting her open. The way her pussy gripped it looked so fucking sexy. Y/n drove the cock home, deep inside of Ariana.

Y/n grabs at the meaty flesh of Ariana's ass. She is so soft and plush. Her arms look like they were going to give away from pleasure, but she was staying strong.

Y/n spreads Ariana's cheeks apart, getting a better view of her holes. The way her pussy stretched around her cock is so lewd, but what was calling Y/n is Ariana's untouched, tight hole. She groans when she runs her hand over the stretch of her ass. Y/n takes one hand off her ass and places her thumb against the bundle of nerves. Ariana gasps and does a sharp inhale. She jumps a bit away from him, only to be pulled back by Y/n's other hand.

"Y/n," she lets out a drawn out whine.

When Y/n pressed into her again, she gripped her harder. She had to keep pushing because Ariana's tight pussy was making it harder to move successfully in and out of her.

Once again, Y/n pressed against the opening of her hole and pushed in a little bit. Ariana's thighs start to quiver. It's a new feeling that's currently swirling through her body.

Y/n pulls the cock out of her. Ariana lets out a desperate cry and collapses onto the bed with her ass still up in the air. Feeling this empty is torturous. Y/n is torturing her.

Instead of pushing back in, flipping her over, or even teasing her cunt, Y/n places the cock between her cheeks and starts sawing slowly. It makes Ariana groan more out of curiosity than pleasure. Y/n pokes the tip at her hole, hitting the head a few times against it.

"Fuck," she says under his breath. "Looks so fucking perfect." The toy is covered in Ariana's slickness after leaving her pussy. Her arousal is not to act as lube, Y/n knows this, but she does press into her hole just a little tiny bit. Ariana cries out and immediately Y/n pulls out.

"Has anyone fucked this little hole before?" Y/n asks as she goes back to just resting the thick cock between Ariana's cheeks.

Ariana shakes her head no, but then realizes that Y/n probably can't see her. "No," her voice cracks when that word comes out. Ariana can't see what Y/n's doing or going to do to her, however she feels like she's under her heavy surveillance, like she's exposed.

"Such a shame," Y/n moves the cock back to its target. "It's so pretty. I'd love to fuck your ass someday."

And with that, Y/n plunges back into her pussy along with her thumb in Ariana's ass. Ariana lunges forward when the force of her pushing into her again until Y/n grabs her hip and rocks her back into Y/n. This time she's fucking Arianahard, fast and rough. Y/n has a new sense of vigor now that she has a new obsession.

The orgasm she has that night is one that made her fall asleep right after they fucked. She came so hard around Y/n's cock, she had to clean Ariana up with a towel while she slept. Maybe it was because it was a new position or how hard she fucked her that is the reason for why she came so hard compared to their previous times fucking each other. Or maybe it was the extra adding of her thumb in her other hole that made Ariana cum like a slut.

-

Ariana got to thinking. She's never had anyone go down there (or at least pay a lot of attention to that area), but the way arousal swirled in her chest and how hard she came when Y/n took her while filling her ass with her thumb has her enamored. She never thought she'd try anal, but god were Y/n's words from last night enticing her.

She's watched porn with anal before. It was hard to tell if the girls actually enjoyed it because they'd over-exaggerate so much. In some videos she did notice that the women would cum extra hard when they were rubbing their clits while someone fucked their ass. Or when someone was behind them and tonguing them down. She has also come across double penetration videos. They always made Ariana blush a little, but they turned her on so much. It felt so taboo to have two people inside of you and using you as their fuck toy. But, Ariana desired that so deeply in her core.

She's going to let Y/n have her ass. It's going to take some time and stretching first. She feels vulnerable even just thinking about it. The visual of telling Y/n she can have her ass is both humorous and hot to her. Maybe she'll bring it up when Y/n's being a good girl.

-

One thing Y/n loves when she comes over to Ariana's place after a long day is that she cooks for them. Y/n he has to do is mention work and then when she gets to Ariana's place there is a full course meal waiting for her.

When she opened the door she seemed different, a little timid, but sometimes she can be like that.

"Hi baby," Y/n greets Ariana with a kiss. When she steps inside, she expects a waft of something to hit her nose (she's like a spoiled dog), but Y/n doesn't smell anything. Y/n tries to inspect without seeming too nosy. Ariana however, catches on.

"Uhh I didn't cook."

YN turns around and just blinks at her for a few seconds.

"Oh okay, did you order takeout?"

"Baby, sit down"

If she didn't know any better, Y/n would think she was about to dump her. But, by the way Ariana looks and the way her place looks (Y/n noticed the low lighting quickly, it's like she's trying to set the mood), she doesn't think that's happening.

Once they're on the couch, Y/n waits for her to speak.

"You okay baby?"

"Yes I am, it's just-" she struggles to get her words out, her face feeling flushed. "There is no other way to say this, I want you to fuck my ass tonight."

Y/n laughs in response and Ariana frowns.

"Y/n! Don't laugh at me!"

She grabs Ariana's head and plants a kiss on her forehead.

"You're so precious. You want me to fuck that pretty ass huh? I take it you liked what happened a few weeks ago?" Y/n says referring back to the thumb in her ass. Ariana nods sheepishly.

"Why did you think I didn't cook? I've spent all day getting ready for you. I even bought lube!"

"Well, I shouldn't keep you waiting any longer, should I?"

-

Y/n thought the living room was done up for her, but she didn't imagine that her bedroom would look like something out of some stupidly rich couple's honeymoon suite in a hotel. She had some candles going and the room smelled like lavender. The lighting was low just like it was in the living room. It dawned on Y/n that maybe half of it was for her and the other half could've been to calm Ariana's own nerves.

Ariana sighs as she stands before Y/n. She's sitting on the edge of the bed. She's really doing this.

"Come across my lap baby," Y/n beckons her.

Ariana walks over to her and lays across Y/n's lap, her ass perfectly in her line of vision. Y/n runs her hand against her clothed ass. She recognizes Ariana's dress as one that she bought her (when Y/n spotted it in a store while shopping, he instantly thought of her and had to get it). It boosts her ego a little bit that Ariana purposely chose that outfit for today. She pulls the dress up so it bunches around her waist. Red panties to match. Y/n loves the color red against her skin, it's so sexy.

Y/n gives her ass a few swats. Ariana jerks in her lap, but does her best to keep her composure. Y/n loves that ass so much and now she finally gets to make it hers.

Y/n pushes Ariana's panties to the side and rubs her clit a little bit. A moan vibrates in her chest. Y/n delivers another spank to her ass. All the blood in Ariana's body rushes to her clit.

Finally Y/n pulls her underwear down. What awaits her is a treat he didn't expect. A little plug was stuffed in Ariana's ass. She pushes against the red jeweled head and Ariana groans.

"You really do want me to fuck that ass huh? You've been stretching that ass out for me baby?"

Ariana moans in response. It felt weird to have it inside of her all day and moving around, but it was helping her get ready for the thick cock that's going to go inside of her eventually.

Y/n grabs the tip and starts to pull it out. She watches with baited breath as Ariana's hole stretches wider and wider. It makes her mouth water. She finally pops it out and Ariana's hole has a mini-gape.

"So fucking pretty," Y/n's mouth is practically watering at this point.

Y/n pushes the tip back in eliciting a groan from Ariana. The plug stretches her again. It slides in with ease and Y/n wonders for how long has she been stretching her ass. And Y/n wonders if Ariana's used her fingers to stretch herself out.

"Where's the lube?"

"In the nightstand."

Y/n reaches back to open it up and grab the bottle. It's big, probably bigger than what is needed.

"I take it this isn't the last time we're going to do this," Y/n says referring to the size of the bottle.

Ariana's face burns in slight embarrassment at that. Her eagerness for getting her ass fucked is obviously showing.

"Naughty girl," Y/n pours some lube on her fingers. "I'm gonna fuck you with my fingers first. You remember the word in case it gets to be too much?" Two of her fingers start to prod at Ariana's waiting hole.

"Cupcake."

"Good girl."

Y/n plunges two fingers, Ariana's ass welcomes her finger, the plug did a nice job of stretching Y/n out, but she's going to need more to take a cock inside of her. Y/n adds another finger, filling her ass with three digits. When she refills her ass with more of a stretch, she inhales sharply.

"Rub your clit, relax baby."

Ariana obeys immediately. Y/n can see her fingers pressed to her clit, rubbing in small circles.

Ariana's ass starts to accommodate the fullness of Y/n's fingers. It's starting to feel really good. She pats herself on the back for taking the liberty to stretch herself out before Yn had a chance to because now they get to enjoy this together. Now she's starting to understand why those girls in the videos would moan really loudly as they got their ass fucked while playing with their clits; the feeling is immaculate. It's all so new and overwhelming Ariana's body.

"Good girl. Ass nice and full," Y/n praises. Of course her fingers are going to be nothing compared to her cock.

Eventually she pulls out and Ariana is actually missing the fullness.

"C'mon, get on your knees for me. Ass in the air baby."

Ariana complies, putting her face against the mattress. This position gives Y/n the perfect view of her little gape. She can't help but bend over and tongue Ariana's ass.

"Y/n!" She squeals loudly. Y/n's wet tongue surprised her but it felt like heaven.

Y/n has never done this with anyone and she figures from Ariana's reaction that she hasn't either. They're both experiencing this in real time with each other.

Her tongue runs along the tautness of Ariana's flesh as Ariana buries her face into a nearby pillow.

Ariana's ass is stretched out enough for them to go forward with fucking, however Y/n wants her to completely relax. Even when she was stretching her out Y/n could tell she was tense and a little bit on edge. It's understandable why she's nervous, but she has no reason to be at this point. It feels way more taboo having Y/n's tongue on her hole than the tip of a cock. It excites Y/n so much and makes all the blood in her head rush to her sex.

"That's it honey," Ariana encourages, breaking out of her sub mode a little bit. If this was any other time, Y/n would reprimand or spank her, but she's about to have a cock in her ass for the first time, so Y/n can be a little lenient just this time. Plus the encouragement turns her on.

Y/n's reluctant to pull away. She loves how Ariana makes the most helpless whimpers as Y/n's tongue pleasures her. But, she's ready for all of her now.

She positions herself behind Ariana, the tip poking at her cunt just to tease her.

"I need you to really relax for me baby."

Ariana takes her words seriously. She closes her eyes and lets her body get comfortable in its current position.

"Good girl."

The head of the cock pushes at her hole and instantaneously Ariana tenses up.

"No, no, no, it's okay. Don't get nervous, it's going to make it worse."

Ariana reaches back and grabs his hand that is resting on her ass. Knowing that he is there in more than a physical way helps her to relax again.

"You're so tight baby girl. Fuck that ass is really stretching for me."

The plug and fingers seem like nothing now compared to the cock that's invading her ass. Her instinct is to clench, but Ariana does her best not to. She keeps still while the cock sinks into her. Y/n watches Ariana's ass stretch and accepts the toy almost fully. Then Y/n pulls out and Ariana lets out a loud groan.

"You're doing so well baby. So proud of you," Y/n rubs Ariana's lower back as a means to comfort her. She nods absentmindedly, Y/n's words comforting her. A little confidence surges in her and she slides down on the cock as Y/n pulls it out. Y/n notices this right away and takes this as a cue to speed up her pace. Soon Y/n is rocking in and out of Ariana's ass. The grip her asshole has on the cock is unbelievable.

"How does it feel baby? Tell me how it feels."

"Oh god Y/n it's so big. You're stretching out my ass so good — fuck it feels so good."

"Play with your clit baby girl. Love you so much sweetheart," Y/n mostly mumbles that last sentence.

Ariana complies with her wishes and oh my god does it make her jump. Y/n slams her back down on the cock and she cries louder than Y/n has ever heard her before. For a second Y/n worries that maybe she hurt her, but she can see Ariana's hand rubbing her clit furiously. Y/n smirks when Ariana starts to whimper and move her hips again. Ariana grinds her ass against Y/n's hips.

"Your ass is so tight and pretty baby girl."

Ariana melts at the way Y/n calls her 'baby girl'. Her mind is so clouded with lust and pleasure she can only moan in response. She can feel her ass stretching wider and wider as the minutes go on, accepting the intrusion in the best ways possible.

"Baby I'm gonna cum," she manages to choke out.

"Yea? You gonna cum? Cum for me angel."

Y/n words help coax Ariana to cum around the cock in her ass. She can barely breathe when the pleasure hits her like a freight train. It's a heavy feeling in the pit of her chest, the weight of her orgasm dragging her down into the depths of pleasure. Ariana can feel just how wet her cunt is. Y/n barely even touched her pussy and yet it's dripping more than ever. She slides two fingers into herself, curious about how it would feel to have both holes stuffed. Y/n watches her do so and makes a mental note that they must try that some other time.

When her pleasure subsides, the sensitiveness takes its place.

"Y/n...Y/n," Ariana whimpers pathetically. Y/n can tell by the tone of her voice that she's tired and absolutely fucked out.

Y/n pulls out of her and Ariana's gaping hole greets her and it's a sight to behold. It's like night and day compared to how it looked before Y/n fucked her ass.

"I'll be right back," Y/n murmurs and disappears out the room. Ariana relaxes completely and slumps against the bed, laying flat on her stomach.

When she re-emerges, she has a warm towel. Y/n presses it against her asshole to help her relax which she does immediately.

"Good girl. You did so well — you took me so well. I'm proud of you."

"Did you like it?"

"I loved it, but it doesn't matter what I think, how about you? Are you okay?"

"I'm fine — more than fine. I loved it so much. You were perfectly gentle with me. I'm just a little sore and tired."

"How about we cuddle for now and then I'll run us a hot bath later."

"That sounds perfect."