XaiJu
longlivetheprincess
longlivetheprincess

patreon


An update on sales tax for Long Live the Princess

Hi, patrons!

I'm sure half of you fell asleep just reading the title. I understand. This is important, though, at least for some of you. You might already have received similar updates to this from other campaigns you support. If not, you most likely will very soon. 

Here's an edited version of what Patreon wants me to tell you. You'll find my own thoughts at the end of this post.

Patreon is making some big changes that may affect some of your pledges. Due to new laws passing in several countries and US states, Patreon will be required to start charging sales tax on some pledges starting July 1st. 

Less than half of all patrons will be charged sales tax, and for most, the amount will be very small. For example, sales tax rates in the US range from 4% to 11%, so on a $5 pledge, that would be between 20 cents and 55 cents. 

Whether or not you will be charged sales tax depends on your location, and what is considered taxable there. Not every pledge is taxable, not all benefits are taxable in every location, and sometimes only a fraction of a pledge will be taxable. The money that Patreon collects as a result of these laws are paid directly to local governments.

I'm working closely with Patreon to ensure I'm able to save you as much money as possible when it comes to sales tax.

If you're in a location where sales tax will be required, you should expect to receive an email from Patreon with more information about this very soon, but I wanted to make sure you were aware of these changes way ahead of July 1st when they go into effect. 

If you have questions, you should be able to find answers here. If you still have questions, the best place to get an answer is from Patreon's customer support team, here

My own thoughts

So, sales tax. According to what Patreon has told me, this change should affect roughly 30% of all patrons. That doesn't mean it will affect 30% of my patrons, but it gives a rough idea of the scale here. 

Some of you are probably angry at Patreon right now for introducing this concept. Please don't be. This change is vital. Many Patreon campaigns, mine included, have most likely operated illegally because sales tax wasn't supported adequately outside of the EU until now. And as everyone knows, ff there's one thing you don't try to skip out on, it's taxes. Competing platforms, like SubscribeStar, will have to make the same changes soon enough.

In fact, I contacted Patreon about this very subject more than two years ago because I was worried about it, but they never got back to me. Turns out, they were probably working on a solution behind the scenes. 

I'm not happy to see that some of you will be forced to pay more money to support your favorite creators, however. Thankfully, Patreon will offer a comprehensive tool for me to make fine adjustments to what the various pledge levels contain. This should allow me to minimize the cost for as many of you as possible. For example, if you pledge at the $10 level, you're basically pledging $5 for early access to digital goods, and $5 for access to my longer posts and polls. In many places, only the first half of that qualifies for sales tax. The new solution from Patreon will support such granular detail in how taxation is handled.

The following image shows the current range of countries that should expect to pay sales tax from July 1st. Note that if you're in the EU, there should be no changes. You are already paying VAT on your pledges.


So, there you have it. Things will proceed as normal until July 1st, at which point this change comes into effect. I apologize for the inconvenience and additional cost this will impose on some of you. 

Feel free to ask any questions you like, though be aware that I don't currently possess all the answers myself.

Comments

She cheats.

Wait! I thought Belle couldn't read! How is she so versed in the ways of taxes? Did she ask Primrose for help?!

wstlndwarrior

Well, unlike previous taxes and fees that have been added, these don't directly cut into my profits. Instead, the fee is added on top. But yes, it is likely that it will cause some patrons to drop or lower their pledges since pledging will become more expensive for them.

My only concern is that this doesn't cut into what you get monetarily to much.

Ishandul

Now everything is clear. Thanks for the detailed explanation.

FEYADA

Because giving money to a beggar doesn't give you a tangible benefit. Take my Patreon campaign as an example. If you donate $1, you get progress reports every week. If you donate $5 you also get one month's early access to the game itself. If you donate $10, you also get longer posts and polls. Additionally, if you donate $20, you get extra images not available to anyone else. Finally, all of these tiers come with exclusive Discord access. These are tangible rewards, though different countries/states disagree on what can be considered taxable. Some US states, for example, don't consider any of this to be something that should have sales tax. Other states will only consider the $5 tier taxable. Add a large number of other possible combinations on top of that. Basically, anything that rewards you with a "digital product" (definitions of what this is may vary) can be taxed. If you're in a state that only taxes the $5 reward and you pledge $20, 15 dollars of your pledge are tax-free. What you say about Patreon being a donation would only be true if there weren't rewards associated with various pledge levels. Now, if you, say, pledge at $20 but actually pay $50, the $30 on top would be considered a donation and would not be taxed by any state or country that I know of. But unless you donate above and beyond the preset tiers, this doesn't apply to you. You will receive an email from Patreon soon that will go into more detail about what this will mean for you, based on where you live.

Maybe you're right. But why don't we pay tax when we donate money to a beggar? I think patreon is a donation, but not a sale. At least the Patreon themselves talk about it.

FEYADA

You have fundamentally misunderstood how this works. Patreon doesn't get any money out of this. In fact, they'll likely lose money because patrons might have to pledge to fewer creators because of the increased costs. Sales tax is mandated by governments around the world. In fact, I personally contacted my own government to ask about this concept over two years ago and was told by a lawyer that, yes, crowdfunding with early access rewards is indeed subject to sales tax. Patreon can't pay these taxes on their own. Where would that money come from? The pledges made by patrons? If it was handled that way, I'd see my income drop by around 20% overnight. This new system is how sales tax is handled for all online transactions that operate legally. If you have to blame and be angry on anyone, don't blame Patreon. This isn't their fault, and in fact, they've gone above and beyond to make this process as cheap and painless for you guys as humanly possible. They have to follow the law, as do I. Patreon isn't the dehumanized monster of a corporation that some of you make it out to be. If it wasn't for Patreon, there would never have been a Long Live the Princess. Don't be saddened. Be grateful. And if you don't have to pay sales tax in the first place (which I'm going to use Patreon's tools to ensure, if at all possible), be doubly grateful.

I am saddened. Why is it called "Sales Tax"? Creators do not sell anything, they create content, and people simply donate to them. I do not pay tax to help the poor, and if I paid , it would be absurd. Everything seems easier to me. Patreon wants someone to pay taxes for them. Last time, they wanted the creators to pay for them. Then they did not succeed in doing this. Attempt number 2 is now, and they want their patrons to pay. I am still saddened.

FEYADA

Thanks for your update, honest opinion and efforts :) I'm a EU backer, too, so it won't affect me. Interesting to know, tho

Fynn Nix

Percentage doesn't care for the difference between a single amount or a sum of several amounts equaling that former amount. 25% of 100 = 25 While 25% of 50 = 12,5, so 25% of 50 + 25% of 50 = 25. That goes for any way of splitting, as percentage is just a multiplication in disguise. And you probably know that (n×a + n×b + n×c ...) = n(a+b+c ...) Same goes for percentage :) Conclusion: If you pay 25% on each, you also pay 25% on the whole

Fynn Nix

It's because the UK has always been handled under EU regulations, and they've been charging VAT from Patreon for many years.

They already charge at 20% to every pledge here in the UK and have done for years

Lossow

After what i can see they charge sales tax for each i support and not for the full amount that i pay each month so 25% from each i support and not 25% from them all togther. I haven't really calculated it just i have a set amount i use on patreon and don't want over that.

Hun73rdk

A tiny update: One thing I'll be looking into is to see if I can arrange for tax-free months. Now that we're moving away from monthly releases (check the progress reports for more details on that), there will be the occasional month without any new update. In my opinion, it doesn't make sense for a $5 pledge to have sales tax in a month like that. While I don't know this for sure yet, I hope there will be some way for me to control this in Patreon's new tools. If not, I'll suggest it to them as a new feature.

2x the amount would mean they charge 100% sales tax, but since they only charge 25%... The math doesn't check out. ;)

Yea Denmark been paying it a long time now It makes my bill from patreon almost 2x the amount had to cut back on how many i support

Hun73rdk

EU?

They already take 25% from me :D

Hun73rdk

I'm fine with paying sales tax on Patreon pledges, although the amount I pay will be minuscule compared to some. It's not like you have any control over it, but thanks for the update regardless.

Scott S.

No problem, as the old saying goes: You don't charge tax, you are forced to collect it.

hisstoryman

It's actually 9.975%. Wikipedia claims it ended up that way because a provincial 9.5% sales tax was applied to prices that already included a federal sales tax, making the total effective rate that strange number.

HarmlessArachnid

9.98% in Quebec? Is there something that doesn't allow them to charge 10%?

Troz

Thanks for letting us know. It won't change my intention to support you.

Troz

Yes, as I mentioned in the post above, the EU has paid VAT for a long time on Patreon. If you're an EU citizen, there should be no changes for you.

Denmark already payes taxes on any pledges

Phillip Kokholm


More Creators