Chaotic Love (Good And Bad News)

(Tail's POV)

I was out searching for Amy, Cream, and Cheese since Knuckles and Sonic confirmed they came to this world with us and we are not leaving without them. I was in The Tornado flying over the city Knuckles last saw her in for clues or maybe she was around the area. Not many places for her to hid and scavenge to survive in a city without being spotted, but for Cream and Cheese, nobody has saw them. I just hope nothing bad happened to them and they were with Amy in the best-case scenario.

Tail's mind-Please, be alright.

(Amy's POV)

This was the best day ever since I got here. Not only was the house clean, Cream and Cheese were cuddling (Y/N) while scratched his favorite spots on his back from time to time, but I got to watch Bri forced into giving Rouge a foot massage and I was next. I decided to go step outside for a bit in the backyard and even dip my feet in the water and if dirt or anything sticks to my feet, it's just gonna be more Bri's problem than mine. When I did get outside (Y/N) looked happy that I won't be scratching his sweet spots anymore... until Cream took care of that a little. I went up to the fence to look off into the woods as I heard another plane from this world fly over then I heard another sound over it, but ignored it until... it got closer and I saw something in the corner of my eye land in the woods. I was curious, so I tried to get a closer look until I saw an old friend of mine come out of the bushes.

Amy-Tails!

Tail-Amy!

He ran over here and I was glad to see him and even led him to the front gate to let him in the front yard.

Tail-Are you alright?

Amy-Yeah, Cream, Cheese, someone else, and I have been staying here.

Tail-Cream and Cheese are here too? That makes this much easier. Can you go get them?

Amy-Huh?

Tail-Sonic, Knuckles, and I are looking for the last chaos emerald already and we'll be going home soon. It'll be quicker if we're all in one place.

There was no way I was leaving (Y/N) here and I didn't even think about how the others would react if we brought someone from this world back to us. I had to think of something to get him on board and quick, but just like that it hit me and I put on a look that made him look concerned.

Tail-Hey, what's wrong?

Amy-Oh, it's just we met someone here that could really use our help.

Tail-Help like how?

Amy-It's just awful how a poor boy was treated here.

I took the truth and just put it in a worse way than it already was while making it sound like nobody even cared a little about (Y/N). Also I added how I thought it would be best for him to come back with us, so I could give him a loving home since he already likes us. I could tell he was buying it more and more until it was time to bring it home with some tears.

Amy-Please, *sniffle* I know I can't just leave him here.

Tails-Um... I don't know... Is there any other way to help him? This world seems well organized.

Amy-I am telling you that we can't without hurting him some other way and he's already been through enough. His nanny hits him.

Tails-I mean... Who is this other girl, Rouge?

Amy-Tails!

Tails-Alright, alright, look... i'll come back after we find the last emerald and when I do, i'll ask him personally if he wants to come to our world and live there or not. Does that sound fair?

Amy-Yes.

Just then we heard some beeping off in the distance that must be The Tornado and Tails suddenly looked like he was in a hurry.

Tails-I gotta go! Tell him that he has a choice!

Amy-I will!

Little does he know that he already wants to come back with us and I just have to tell Rouge, Cream, and Cheese about this when we're alone. I just felt so happy and when I saw Tails take off to find the last emerald, I started to have fantasies about (Y/N) living with me.

(Cream's POV)

It felt so nice to have (Y/N)'s head on my lap while I pet him and he is just so good to stay still even when I scratch the spot he loves so much. Rouge was still getting a massage by Bri and since (Y/N) was looking into my belly, she even teased Bri a bit without him knowing. Later Amy walked in and she looked happy before she sat on the couch then Rouge got up to stretch.

Rouge-She's all yours. I'm gonna go tan for a while.

Amy-Actually, I was thinking Bri can run me a bath... Now.

Rouge walked past us and even scratched (Y/N)'s back a bit to make him shiver in the cutest way and I thought about scratching him again. At first I wanted to let him relax,... but I couldn't stop myself and he looked so cute! Bri left the room to go make Amy's bath then sat next to us on the couch.

(Y/N)-Cr-Cream, can y-y-you please stop?

Cream-... Maybe in a bit.

Amy-Oh, before I forget, we'll back some of your stuff up soon and take you to our home in a few days or so.

(Y/N)-Really?

Cream-*Gasp* Are you sure?! I can't for my mom to meet him!

Amy-I'm sure.

I wasted no time in getting and taking (Y/N) to his room to get him ready for when we leave and he was kinda excited too. It made me so happy and I could just picture us outside my house and he was laying his head on my lap with my mom next to me.

(Rouge's POV)

I was out in the back getting a bit of sunlight when all the sudden I hear a truck pulling up front and opened the gate by themselves, so I flew to the top of the house to see who it was and it was 3 men unloading boxes. Thanks to my hearing I could heard the jewelry clanking together from here and there was 4 whole boxes worth and they were put by the front door. I waited until they left to go down and opened them to see all the beautiful jewelry and just then my phone started to ring then I looked and saw it was her, so I answered it.

Rouge-Hello.

(M/N)-The order said it was just dropped off at the front door like you wanted.

Rouge-I'm looking at them now. This just about makes up for your last visit.

(M/N)-Also... I want to talk with my son... Please.

Rouge-Hmmm... No.

(M/N)-What?

Rouge-I mean unless you have something or do something for me. Talking to my son isn't gonna be free.

(M/N)-But I gave you half of my-!

Rouge-For making me mad last time. This is different, so unless you're willing to pay, i'm hanging up.

(M/N)-... What do you want?

(Timeskip 30 Minutes)

((M/N)'s POV)

Not only did I have to buy something to help pull "her jewelry" around, so also told me to say something to my son for her and it was going to be humiliating. I had to go out in public tot to makes things worse for myself, but the thought of saying that to my son was ridiculous.

(M/N)'s mind-Yeah... I should demand I talk to my son now without her terms! I can do it!

(Timeskip 25 Minutes)

((Y/N)'s POV)

Amy was helping me pack all my clothes while Bri was not allowed in my room to help and instead was making us something. We left a few clothes out for when i'm still here, but they said I can't take my bed, computer, or anything big since they said i'll be getting a new bed and other things to have lots of fun. Just as we started to play a board game in here that we found in my closet I told them the rules and in the middle of the game my door opened and Rouge came in kinda smiling like she was laughing about something a little.

Rouge-Here sweetie. It's your mom.

(Y/N)-My mom?

She gave me her phone and I saw her name on the screen, so I held it up to my ear and smiled since I barely get to talk to her. In the corner of my eye I saw Rouge smiling a little bigger now for some reason and I think she was just happy about me talking to my mom after I don't do it a lot. I heard other voices in the background of her, but I think I can still hear her.

(Y/N)-Hi mom!

Mom-Hi sweetie, are you doing ok?

(Y/N)-Yeah. I even got some great news.

Mom-Well first I have something to say.

(Y/N)-What is it?

Mom-Well... It's about Rouge and... you need to listen to her just like mommy does now. No matter what.

(Y/N)-But I thought you were the boss?

Mom-Not anymore and just to show that she's in charge... I... need you to call her your mommy now or we're both in big trouble. She even said after this that I already have to punish myself by putting something... big in me.

I was confused when she told me to call my nanny my mom and that she was the boss now. Just then I looked at Rouge while she was smiling still and if she said it then I guess I have to listen to adults.

(Y/N)-O-Ok I guess... The news that I have is that they're taking me to their home and I would like it if you visit.

(M/N)-Y-Yes sweetie, but I have to go. I love you.

Just then she hung up and I just gave Rouge back her phone and she leaned in closer to me before she kissed my head. She even scratched my chin a little before she looked at my bags and suitcase full of closed and toys.

Rouge-So you're coming home with us? I'll make sure to have a nice spot in my room just for you.~

Amy-Excuse me, but he's staying with me.

Cream-What, but I was here first. He can stay with me and my mom.

Cheese-Chao, chao, chao.

They all started to fight over who I would stay with in their world and I tried to think of something like I can spend the night at their houses on certain days, but they said no to that. They even all went silent for a moment while looking at me then Rouge leaned right in front of me.

Rouge-Why don't we let him decide? I think it's far to give him some time, but since i'm clearly his new mom already-.

Amy-Like you can give yourself that title with a snap of the fingers. He also doesn't need to be living with a thief.

Just then I felt a tug on my arm and I saw Cream giving sad eyes like she was begging me to come live with her and her mom. I just looked away and I didn't want to pick one and hurt the others and I need to put my foot down.

(Y/N)-Hey!... If you don't stop fighting... I... I won't go, so figure something out!

That felt kinda good, but mostly bed as i just went to sit on my bed and I really do want to go see their world since I rarely leave the house. I just need to look serious on this and they should think of something.

(No POV)

The day went on as the girls were still thinking of a way to settle this and they tried a competition, but none of them can trust another not to take the prize after losing. They wanted to see who the favorite was still to let him decide, but the same issue came to trust to not steal (Y/N) again. They had a few days to figure this out, but at night they all came up with the same idea in the back of their head.

Rouge/Amy/Cream's minds-When the time comes... i'm taking him.