[BONUS] Gumshoes and Daddies - Criminal Mines

Please make this an annual tradition!

Kaylin Creason

I agree! Im on my 2nd listen of this because it just sticks in my head.

BaydaShark

Anyone having trouble with this playing?

ant

I've listened to this like five times, this is like in my top three things you've ever done. Please god do more with this format. Columbo works great for podcasts because the audience gets to hear everything.

BT Bishop

How did I entirely miss this?! How excellent! Love, love, loved this! <3

Xyta Midnyte

i want more

Alonzo the Bucket_Lord

honestly this bonus was awesome and so funny. really hope we get more.

Barf Drinker

"Milk Leg" Intronaut listener detected?

PapaEggnog

Damn. I totally missed this somehow last year. Good stuff.

Darryl Holiday II

So chaotic hahah

Risotto

I love these little one-offs! More things like this!

Brandon Wareing

I hope that Travis and/or Esther didn't cut down too much of Beth's intro - it was great as a psa and was super clear for those who are new to understanding mental illness. It was great to hear :)

Caz Flip Smith

Have you guys seen the show The Sniffer? It's Russian Columbo but sniffing crime scenes

Sand2Stone

This is my favorite MBIC of all time and not just because they used my name for the main bad guy (which made me very happy) or all of Mattisms that we got by having a 20ft tall Fog Giant. I also just loved the fact that this was all for a good cause. Hopefully this raises all the money that nami deserves for the help they provide to people who struggle with mental illness. Hope ya'll dads keep up the amazing content and the good work x

Ciaran boyd

This definitely works as a cute little one off, but if you ever revisit the concept you definitely need some more fine-tuning. Also if this is how things are with the whodunit with this group, Dadatha Christie is going to be wild as hell.

Uria, Lord of Searing Games

Lmao I felt like this was tame compared to Gungans and Daddies

Matthew McAdams

Got some laughs but if this is gonna be a recurring thing there’s gotta be some more structure and it never felt like Will got to try and throw the detectives off. A bit too many “yes ands” for the detectives that didn’t make this as fun as it could have been

Ethan

It’s a fun side campaign. I say keep it up

Gene Virgilio

This was fun to listen to. Would love to hear more!

Toriiish

such a funny episode

Seth de San Jose

You guys always make me laugh so hard

Gene Virgilio

I can honestly see this as a format with new guests being the murder each time.

Daniel Atkinson

This was muy fantastico!! #justiceformilkleg

AshFlexum

i need more. feed me daddies, feed me.

Christian V Smith

As with everything you guys do, I got at least a few laughs. That said, I think that was the weakest thing you’ve done in a while. So, so, so engaged right up until it was in a fantasy world. I guess I was hoping for more of a Mountains of Dadness vibe, classic film noir. Hope we are still gonna get something like that soon! #MoreMountainsForDsds

Josiah Muskrat

I think this was pretty funny, but it might be a bit *too* chaotic for my tastes. Like just random bullshit thrown at a wall. I feel like if this were to work it needs at least a bit more setup, or something like that.

MalixCrash

I listened to this while getting fillings.

hexebak

I think Anthony saying, incredulously, "What'd you say?" is my new favorite thing to exist

DungeonBrat

More of this, please!

AutumnOpossum

…Should I be embarrassed that I finally recognized it from Without A Recipe (the Try Guys series), but not from Overcooked?

Maria M

I love this so much I want one every day please and thank you!

Devon Hein

This is the most I’ve laughed in ages, please please do more of these it’s so good

Lucky Lila

This was so fantastic! Would love more with each player being the murderer. 💕

Sharon

"I'M JUST MAKING IT!!" lmao

Rachel MacArthur

loved this episode!!! also love that it’s to benefit a charity i love! please give us more!!

Ophelia

More more more!

Michael Kurowski

Would love to have everyone as a turn as the murderer, this was great!

Brian Figueroa

I love Anthony going “oh what a big boy” I will be playing that to my cat when he looks sad

dagny

Please do more this was great

Nick

"It's a thing you use to get things to go through things better" is my new favorite Matt-ism

Tyler Sanders

Loved it, would listen to more

Mr.ClassyRamen

couldn’t figure out why the music was so familiar for an EMBARRASSINGLY long time. this was a really fun ep!!

Alexandra Rutkowski

Love it. Great system, great concept, amazing how Matt took it off the rails immediately. Clouds will never be the same.

Danny Tunker

I mean Will got done dirty. The detectives in whodunits normally don't know who did it right at the beginning.

Logan Reed

The killer should get a certain amount of Interference Points as Will seemed uncertain about how much & how often he could intercede. Or something reminiscent of Honey Heist flashback mechanic to rewrite or alter a clue not-yet-found or to run interference for something crucial.

Christopher Lasasso

This episode was great to listen to while I used a butt plug for the first time. My asshole stretched almost as far as Will's alibi.

Amy Waller

Dwarves don't believe in trials? I never root for Will but he got cheated.

Jess Carlson

Please let Freddy be the killer next time. I want to see how perfectly he’d go through every loop to get away with murder

Shallow Rivers

I genuinely don't know why that was so good. Could be the anti depressants kicking in thanks to NAMI 👍

liam sullivan

really misse out on calling it "Daddy, he wrote"

Drednot

More please 😊

Sunder

More! More! More! This was so funny!

Ruby Doo

oh my GOD please do more this was so funny 😭😂

ea-nasir's seventh favorite wife

Ita funny how the funniest joke theyve made "I just make the lube" was on a bonus

FusRohNahSon

I love the NAMI support, and I also love Matt's commitment to the bit!

Katherine

He gave me a Tobias vibe lol

Katherine

Oh man I'd subscribe to a second Patreon for this

Sam Elgart

Matt is so wild in the one shots I love it.

This episode was especially funny! I also love you guys opening up about your mental health issues it’s very brave and helps remove the stigma surrounding it. I know the running joke is no one reads these but Will so hi Will this was great do more of these thank you.

Ajay Thibodeaux

Just started this episode, getting some Gob and Michael vibes.

Max Wilson

Man I need more of this!

Anderson Van Dang

Reminds me of D&D Minus' whodunit. In a very good way. Both were hilarious, but in their own crazy way.

Gmork

this was awesome!! my bestie and i were cracking up the whole time and it sounds like you all enjoyed it a lot too, which makes it that much better!

Kendall Hale

Please make more

Robbie Taylor

Just started this and had to bust in right away and say it gives such a warm sense of kinship to hear a shared diagnosis with someone as well as inspirational to see their success in life! BPD celebration!

Nobi Wolff

please do more of this, i beg you. my stomach hurts from laughing.

ronny

This is incredible!! Would love more episodes like this. Had me laughing consistently throughout

Anthony Smith

This had great energy and I hope it becomes a side series!

PeterThoma

Love it

Charles Arnold

Very funny

Breo Padden

Neutral Milk Hotel made me very happy.

Michael Miller

Great episode!

Jimmy Lundrigan

Ah come on, I heard "it shall be mine, one way or another" and wanted a montage set to One Way Or Another so badly. It'd be perfect.

Racing for Tips

I’ve been a fan of y’all for so long. I’m Autistic with OCD and enough Anxiety to power a jet engine. I listen to y’all when I do my delivery job and to help focus while I’m working on things at home so I’m just happy y’all are talking about things like this. I hope y’all keep doing awesome work and have only gotten through the intro but know I’m going to love it as always

Christopher Black

milkleg is really reminding me of buster bluth from arrested development

Barhd_

This is such a fun system! Love the concept of one of the players being the murderer. You guys were all hilarious 10/10

Billie Davies

Last time I came this early I was.... View more

Lorelei The Succubus and Kyra her busty Queen

Oh my

Parrot Paramour

Hi rusty

Sean Hegarty

Hi

Rusty Dubrule