*Auto-Update*

Ascendence of a bookworm is a very wholesome isekai

Chibi

i wonder what day it is :D

Nut Kon

idk why it seems complicated for some people. It is intended to watch as its airing order. Narratively events happening at different times doesn't make watching things complicated., it is pretty simple. People are overthinking for no reason. You can literally go to myanimelist or any decent anime site and you can follow the airing order.

Zipzip

yup, that was what i was thinking too! from the shows they already watched, this would be pinnacle of the „genre“ (i dont want to spoil the plot)😁

lmaokiji

I'm watching Dark-reactions right now. While doing this I'm thinking "this would be a great show for Autosave". So I literally re-joined the patreon just to recommend it. I don't know if it was too late this time around, but luckily I see I'm not alone in suggesting it. Not only is Dark objectively a great show for reactions (particularly among "live action" shows), it seems to me like a perfect fit for the format of this channel especially.

Gottolf

86 & psycho pass

Rigo Rojo

86 - it's a masterpiece

Cristi

Parasyte/Kiseijuu Land of the Lustrous/Houseki no Kuni So underrated and I'm 100 % sure you would love it !

Julien

86 all the way

Astal

Apothecary Diaries! The FMC is unique and funny!

piqs

I mean, he's easily embarrassed and there are a couple of scenes that.. you know...

KenthalasAT

I don't know if Ben's heart can take it lol

Neutr0n

Yeah, it's a problem. It makes it worse that the story is actually disjointed too. Kizu is the chronologically first one, but one of the last ones made. It was also made as a trilogy of "movies" with a much higher budget, so they can definitely set the wrong expectation for what the rest of the series would be like. Generally, just watching them in release order works, maybe with Kizu right after Bake for context.

KenthalasAT

86 1000000%

Reqorium

could you imagine them walking into the endless 8 blind :D

Daniel Borrego

i second it. one of the best world building series out there.

Daniel Borrego

its almost like the fate series for me. i have no idea where to start. theres like 3 or 4 of them isnt there? i think i watched Kizumonogatari but have no idea how this works into the order

Daniel Borrego

vivy for sure.

Daniel Borrego

evangelion remakes or original? both have thier strengths and weaknesses. the remakes especially 2.22 are extremely well paced, but the characters are almost caricatures of the original probably for time constraints. they are much prettier though and might be easier to react to just because they are shorter. but the original show is much meatier and far longer. im also one of those that thinks that eoe is a far better ending then 3.0 + 1.0 . i also hated 3.0.

Daniel Borrego

Different slots for poll suggestion: For Older Shows: - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (Classic hero's journey) - Code Geass (Speed chess on a global scale with complicated MC) - Zankyou No Terror (Dark and beautiful visuals + ost similar to Made In Abyss) For Newer-ish Shows: - Apothecary Diaries (Drama, Mystery, Romance with top-tier female MC) - Journey of Elaina (Dark Slice of Life with witches and gays) - Hinamatsuri (Yakuza Comedy)

sleepysorceror

86, vivy, houseki no kuni, overlord, konosuba, danmachi, saga of tanya the evil, ascendance of a bookworm

Daniel Borrego

Konosuba

K-On Evangelion Fruits Basket Hibike Euphonium

Reinhard's Burner

Anime

Fuufu

Fate Zero for sure!

DJ Hunter

The live action version or the anime?

DJ Hunter

1) The Saga of Tanya the Evil 2) Psycho Pass 3) Konosuba

DJ Hunter

BoJack Horseman would be my pick.

Oak

While I agree To Your Eternity definitely had some slumps and loss of direction further in compared to the truly 10/10 initial momentum, I personally still feel it picked itself up enough again towards the end to stay a solidly good anime overall (tho I know many disagree) ^^

Mikael Hultman

Thoughts on your recommendation: To Your Eternity - Great Premise, fell off by loss of direction and tapping heavily into sorrow but without interest or any real resolution. Not sure what they were aiming for but community lost interest before they hit their target. Vivy: Flourite Eye's Song - Felt Empherical, as in we never REALLY connect with anyone/thing in the story because of how abstract it is. I loved this anime, great choice.

Ttsukasa

My personal recommendations with non-spoilery pitches would be: To Your Eternity Amazing fantasyish story that will make you cry over and over yet leave you wanting more. Vivy: Flourite Eye's Song (Sci-fi mystery/action/music story that'd give a lot to speculate and discuss on top of simply bring great) The legend of Vox Machina (Fairly unique show in being an adapted livestream DnD campaign made by the voice actors who played it, meaning it doesn't always follow normal story conventions, in a good way) Doctor Stone Loads of loveable characters doing crazy science hijinks while trying to uncover a mystery and save humanity (and the science/engineering however farfetched it may seem at first is for the most part fully believable)

Mikael Hultman

I'm again suggesting Baccano!, just so that wont be forgotten.

Nossso

one piece live? or yous saw?

daragh faro

Symphogear!

- Durarara - Breaking Bad - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Leo

I'd love to see you guys do the Monogatari series. It's long and complicated, but totally worth it.

KenthalasAT

I'll second Konosuba

KenthalasAT

Let's see if I can dig some gems out of this smooth brain... Baccano Darker Than Black Mushishi Ancient Magus Bride The Promised Neverland season 1

Justin_IVIX

Ooh Grimgar is a good one. It's a crime that it never got any more seasons D:

Nucl3ar Snake

Bit of a niche choice but would love to see Grimgar of fantasy and ash

Mason Smith

Violet Evergarden Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Dr. Stone

Julien

Would love to see Baccano / Durarara someday, but I am sure that'll have to be an Autosave pick, idk if they will win any poll. Would also love to see Overlord

The_Venomous_Viper

86 Eighty-Six Girls' Last Tour Psycho Pass

RetroNitez

86!!

Eighty six 86, Violet Evergarden, Houseki no Kuni, Rascal does not dream of bunny girl senpai, beastars. These are all great and I'm sure the reactions for these will be good.

Erando

Would love to see 86. Also gonna vote Odd Taxi, because im currently watching and enjoying it and its one of the less popular but good anime that also deserve a chance.

Alexiel Knight

eighty six 86

Christian Clark

I love Bleach, but it would take them almost half a decade to finish (this is just counting the 229 current canon episodes, not all the fillers).

Markus

Violet Evergarden, Heavenly Delusion, Rascal does not dream of bunny girl senpai, Dangers in my heart, Konosuba

XDrakeX

I have to second that one! Seems like their type of show. Very cool and mysterious.

Tempered Glasses

Doctor Stone 100% You guys would love this show. It's a smart show with a lot of room for theorizing and prediction, but it's also very fun and heartfelt at times. There is a big cast and I'm sure you would find your favorites :)

Tempered Glasses

I already commented this under the YouTube post, but I would recommend The Apothecary Diaries. Unless you're not really looking for a currently-airing show, in which case I would go with the Monogatari-series.

Noctislolig

FMAB (Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood) Dr. Stone

Shivam Bansal

I also second the Odd Taxi recommendation, that was one hell of a ride.

Coughme

Madoka Magica : )

Matter

Konosuba! It’s the comedy version of Mushoku Tensei and Re:Zero. Only 20 episodes long, and a stone-cold classic of charming anime jerks. It’d be a nice changeup, and there’s a third season coming too 🎯

The most underated, ergo proxy!

Vahid rahimian

Your Lie in April, Madoka Magica, or Ouran High School Host Club

Ascendance of a Bookworm; a very wholesome Isekai. As additional info: I like this series as much as Mushoko Tensie and RE:Zero in terms of world building; character work is also quite good.

Ian Driscoll

DARK

lmaokiji

Monogatari series, 86, Kanata No Astra

Verols

Monogatari series or Heavenly Delusion

Zombiie

86 is a banger y'all should watch!

lumen

I'll suggest these: Madoka Magica FMAB (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood) Code Geass Kill la Kill Houseki no Kuni Still wish they had a list of EVERYTHING they have seen, not just reactions.

Zillatain

Monogatari Series / Rascal does not dream of a bunny girl senpai

Priam

LYCORIS RECOIL

Antonioda1ST

Rascal does not dream of bunny girl senpai. Kind of a wierd name, but this anime would be right up your guys' alley.

Kilfane

Monogatari series Mawaru penguindrum

Golden Eagle

To your eternity, Anohana, Violet Evergarden, Sagrada Reset, Death Parade, Sonny boy, durarara, Shinsekai yori, The promised neverland, Erased, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, link click, One Piece live action

Monogatari Series, Madoka Magika, Ergo Proxy, FMAB, Fate Series, Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex, Erased, Darker Than Black, Overlord

Russell Gambardella

Will always recommend monster. It’s a slower thriller. Given how deep into discussion you guys can get though I would love to see it someday. Idk if it would ever win in polls though sadly.

Goob

86 would be a great show!

Faikar Fazazaman

I'll suggest Monster, hopefully it makes it into the poll again

Daco

The Wire Bakuman Chihayafuru Shinsekai yori Kiseijuu: Sei no Kakuritsu Scavengers Reign From

Shulman

I know Ben and Anna will love ERASED :)

Fuufu

Here are my recommendations - 86 - Apothecary Diaries - Summertime Rendering - Heavenly Delusion

Pey2003

The Apothecary Diaries Monster Golden Kamuy Odd Taxi

Saku

Code Geass or 86 would be an incredible watch/reaction with great in depth discussions!!

Toidleboy

Summertime Rendering Tokyo Ghoul (if you haven't seen it already) Black Clover Heavenly Delusion (also known as Tengoku Diamakyou)

Violet Evergarden

Daniel

Heavenly delusion or tengoku daimakai is really good.

Tyler

Monogatari Series Madoka Magika Katanagatari Haruhi Suzumiya

Oshi

Apothecary Diaries, My Dress Up Darling, My Happy Marriage

Alathea

Houseki No Kuni Ranking of Kings Katanagatari Hinamatsuri Promised Neverland (...season 1) ODDTAXI Doroherodo

Neutr0n

Monogatari Series Link Click Houseki no Kuni Summertime Rendering

Invincible

Alex M

Madoka Magica

Nakirium

Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Marty Hard

Spice and Wolf (the original, not the remake).

Gus N

The Legend of Vox Machina cause i always wanna drag people into the wonderful little rabbit hole that is critical role

Night Sterling

Apothecary Diaries Ranking of Kings Darwin's Game Eden of the East Blue Eye Samurai Heavenly Delusion

Aaron Griffin

Code geass or Full Metal Alchemist :)

Joshua

Monogatari Series

Zipzip

yu yu hakusho fate series code geass summertime rendering is your sister (ben) ever coming back for a reaction?

Jc full

Monster, Code Geass, Apothecary Diaries and Ranking of Kings are the shows I would recommend

Bibi

Adventure Time

Gus N

Hope you both have fun! ❤️ That said, Monster is likely going to have to be wormed in the same way you did with MiA. Actually might be a great replacement for when you finish MiA. Having a slot for shows that aren't likely to win against modern ones in a poll could be a solid thing.

I3ladeDragon

Madoka Magica, Monogatari Series

Sanbiki No Kaeru

Would you guys ever do a manga read-through? I would love to see you guys read Berserk! There are anime adaptations, but none of them do it justice.

Gus N

Ranking of Kings

Tim Zaum

Monster or Heavenly Delusion would be a treat

Styx TV

Helluva Boss

Gus N

I'd recommend Chihayafuru. I think you 2 would like it

The Expanse

Gus N

Recommendations: - Apothecary Diaries - Dangers in my Heart - Vivy Fluorite Eye's Song - Hinamatsuri - Code Geass

GhostPhil

Technically isn’t anime but still great animation. I recommend Blue Eye Samurai, double length episodes like Arcsne, 8 episodes.

Andres Lozano

I heavily agree with Shinsekai Yori

Andres Lozano

Fate series starting with Fate/Zero

Drathian

Shinsekai Yori Suzumiya Haruhi

sabeurre

Psycho-Pass (Multi-season) Baccano! Ajin: Demi-Human Chihayafuru (Multi-season) Hanasaku Iroha Kaiba Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Multi-season)

Hollow

Monster! Monster! Monster

Q Mt

Invincible

Vincent Spivey

'Houseki no Kuni' for some excellent character writing, outstanding visuals and amazing score.

Nucl3ar Snake

My favorite anime of all time! Hibike! Euphonium is so under rated. Kyoto Animations finest work imo. They’ll probably start the KyoAni journey with Violet Evergarden though, which is the case for almost all reactors.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Heavenly Delusion

Code Geass Fate Zero Yona of the Dawn Vivy

Sirdanik

VIOLET EVERGARDEN K-On! Neon Genesis Evangelion Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Hope you guys are enjoying your break! As a recommendation, I would suggest Sound! Euphonium. Its a music anime, with 2 seasons and a 3rd releasing next spring. Definitely plenty of meat there for discussions. It's more drama based rather than comedy based. And one of its movies is a certified masterpiece. Think you guys would enjoy it.

DetectiveYuki

The Apothecary Diaries has one of the most charming and entertaining protagonists I've had the pleasure watching this year. This mystery/romance/drama show is definitely worth a watch!

Coughme

erased would be amazing!!!

Fuufu

Code geass and Ragna Crimson

Jacob

Code Geass would be awesome in a poll with older shows!

DennisAnimeFan

Will do.

AutoSave

If you want to do an animated show that is not anime i recommend invincible or castlevania

BigJo H

You guys need to watch Bleach!!!

Slykou

Tell her brother I said Hi

GodZefir

ganbare

PandaPanzerProductions