One Tree Hill 4X4: Can't Stop This Thing We Started
Added 2024-04-26 18:00:08 +0000 UTCOkay, so it's not Brooke who is pregnant and I'm pissed about it. That doctor definitely walked in and looked right at Brooke, not Haley, and said, 'you're pregnant.' It would have been fine if the doctor just looked at the chart of something, but that's not how it happened! Grrrr. But I really, really, really love the friendship that Haley and Brooke are building.
Nathan, sweetheart, you need to stop engaging in risky behavior. If anyone will get injured doing it, it's you!
Also, I've now put Dan, Deb, and Rachel into a throuple. The three of them deserve each other. Please stay the hell away from everyone else on the show. Thank you.
We're all overly grossed out by Derek, right? This is just creepy as fuck. It was bad enough when he was 'just a stalker' but now, he's paying people to dress up like Peyton so he can sleep with them? Ewwwww. As much as I've been complaining about how Lucas is gonna swoop in and rescue her from him, I kinda think he might need to here.
Please let the person who is actually pregnant decide what they want to do. You have zero say in the matter. Other then, "I'll support you whatever you decide, please be quiet!"
Comments
This was always a who's pregnant storyline since it was introduced in the season 3 finale, even Rachel was in the mix for a minute. I did not care for Brooke and Rachel's "friendship." I felt she was just stuck with Rachel to give her something to do since she couldn't hang out with Lucas or Peyton anymore and she's not that close with Nathan. She really only has Haley and Mouth atm. Anyway, I really love Brooke and Haley's friendship. They tie with Lucas and Haley's friendship for my favorite friendship on the show. I loved the Lucas and Haley scene at the end of the episode.
Sabrina
2024-04-27 07:00:35 +0000 UTCPeyton and Derek have the same father, but different mothers. Ellie was not Derek's mother.
Sabrina
2024-04-27 06:45:18 +0000 UTCYour reaction to the pregnancy debate between Brooke and Haley these past few episodes has been so amusing, lol!!! And I love that you didn't figure things out, until basically the very end of this episode, hehe. And you would make the perfect case study on what the show was aiming for during the first few episodes of this season...so mission accomplished. I have so much more to say on the subject, but I don't want to accidently give anything away for you, so we'll table the pregnancy talk for later, hehe. And no Joy (Haley) wasn't pregnant....it was strictly storyline dictated why Haley is the one pregnant....so keep watching to see if you figure things out or can guess why and where things might be going?
Melissa
2024-04-27 03:30:49 +0000 UTCOoh, that's a really good idea. I think I'm just so mad at Rachel all the time, that I don't stop to think that she actually encounter a traumatic event recently (granted it was her fault, but still). Ugh. She's driving me crazy with this manipulation. She's really gotta back off Nathan. I'll ordain myself as a minister and happily marry her off to Dan.
Dana Licciardello
2024-04-26 21:58:07 +0000 UTCI always thought the montage with Rachel (shooting her magazine cover) and Nathan (driving the motorcycle) was to show how they both are coping with trauma in their own way. Could be wrong, but that's how I've always viewed it. Also Rachel knew to mention Keith because she overheard Nathan and Peyton's conversation at the party in the previous episode where he tells Peyton he saw Keith. So she used that information to get close to and manipulate him this episode.
Amy
2024-04-26 21:27:31 +0000 UTCThe only thing I thought was Haley was definitely looking at the ground when the doctor came in. So I thought maybe she could have looked at Brooke simply because Brooke looked at her? I 100% believed that the thing she was gonna tell him was Stanford. I thought she was nervous because it was so far away and they were still concerned they might not end up in the same place. I totally fell for that. Sigh. lol. Oh that makes me so happy. I love that Brooke and Haley are going to continue this friendship. I love it so much.
Dana Licciardello
2024-04-26 19:22:33 +0000 UTCOMG. Thank you! It was driving me crazy trying to figure out why Brooke went over there. I was too caught up in Brooke rummaging through purses and being pissed off about Peyton that I didn't even realize that happened!
Dana Licciardello
2024-04-26 19:19:42 +0000 UTCBrooke knew the pregnancy test was Haley's because of the perfume in the purse. Brooke let Haley borrow it. That's why she went over to Haley's. To confront her about it.
Heather
2024-04-26 19:06:51 +0000 UTCIf you go back and watch the scene in the first episode when the doctor says "you're definitely pregnant" Brooke looks at Haley then grabs her hand with one hand and then grabs Haley's hand with both her hands. I don't know for me it definitely felt like that was a sign Haley was pregnant and Brooke was being supportive additionally I always thought Brooke looked surprised while Haley looked more concerned at the doctor's office but that is just my analysis because everybody sees things different. Also remember Haley was going to tell Nathan something before the car accident but after the accident when Nathan ask Haley what she was going to tell him she just says she got into Stanford. After that accident I wouldn't think Haley was going to tell him she was pregnant right afterwards because the accident is a traumatic experience for him and she wasn't going to announce it "like by the way in addition to these new medical bills I'm pregnant". I actually think the show did a good job of writing how either Haley or Brooke could be pregnant but I thought it was Haley from the scene at the hospital with Brooke. Speaking of Haley and Brooke I personally love Haley and Brooke's friendship more than Brooke and Peyton's friendship because there is far less drama but I'm totally aware there are people that love Brooke and Peyton's friendship. It will be great for you to see how Haley and Brooke's friendship grows throughout the rest of the series.
Morgan
2024-04-26 18:31:48 +0000 UTC
