New Sodor's Finest Early Access Open NOW!

Do Emily!!! We need a female character to be spotlighted!

Pranav S Rao

Great episode 👏 👍

Mark Robbins

good as always

Thank you for doing Duck in Sodor Finest. Mabey next time do Diesel, Oliver, Emily or even Rosie.

Guy Knowles

I’m rolling XD. The entire vid is a fantastic introspection on Duck’s importance to both the series and the community. The spliced intro had a fantastic mix for a through line and the video as a whole worked wicked well with the established formula. But oh. My. God. You’d hinted at Thomas finishing Duke’s saga without Duck in the S4 retro, but having it tail end your theory section after seeing all the proof for your arguement puts the whole situation in such hilarious context. Everyone in the comments is already mentioning it, and I hope that doesn’t take away from how well put together this video and your thoughts are, but fuck me that realization is hysterical. And I don’t think you’re wrong! Evidence, personalities, everything. You’ve written a new head canon for the community and I’m so here for it XD. Thanks for the vid Tug. Loved it :)

Trace Pierce

Well, there was Henry and the Elephant where Thomas is genuinely nice to Henry at the end of the episode, but that's definitely not what happened in the book. Actually, here's how the episode should have ended. Thomas: Nevermind Henry! I think you were brave, and really reliable too! Henry: Really? Thomas: HA HA HA! NO!

Ryan the Writer

Awesome vid and fun HC but here’s one that’ll surprise everyone. If Thomas and Duck subtly hate each other then Thomas and Henry pre-Hit days outright loathe each other (we’re talking RWS and Classic). They’re both Ego shitheads it’s just that Thomas is cheeky and Henry is standoffish. Hear me out: When Henry’s been sick on multiple occasions Thomas is very rude and dicky instead of being sympathetic. In Thomas’ Train he’s more interested in pulling a train than Henry being ill. In Thomas and the Guard, he flat out insults him despite Henry vividly being poorly. In What’s The Matter with Henry, he plays a cruel trick on him. But at the same time, Henry is a complete prat to Thomas. In Thomas’ train, he flat out laughs at Thomas’ failure. In Coal, Thomas is the first engine Henry showboats to, not Gordon or James. In PPaQ, he gloats about pulling the royal train. In The Runaway, Henry is clearly delighted at Thomas being in trouble. In Something in the Air, Henry just gets angry at Thomas unreasonably, even calling him a “Danger to the Rails”. When Thomas goes to the NRM, Henry is jealous and then makes a cruel joke about Thomas being a museum piece, upsetting Percy, Annie and Clarabel. Hell even in What’s The Matter with Henry, he flat out gets emotional and cross at Thomas at the beginning, which ultimately leads to Thomas’ trick. In Better Late Than Never, Thomas is equally an ass to both James and Henry. Henry gets snappy and lippy while James apologises. Note how Thomas rescued James, got rescued and formed an alliance with Gordon, but he and Henry just fuck each other. THOMAS AND HENRY LOATHE EACH OTHER. Change my mind.

RTron

Loved this one, I would save Thomas for the very last Sodor’s Finest, a good way to end of Sodor’s Finest when ever it does end , and also so all of the main characters don’t get done first leaving only the side characters left, it would give some more consistency.It would be nice for Edward and Gordon to be redone someday, it would be really nice to have you go discuss them in the new style especially considering how much there is to talk about with them. Also one last thing, I forgot to mention this in the last one but remember how you mentioned how you would do the Thomas Retrospective Season 5 and then maybe a TATMR review? I would recommend doing the Season 5 Retrospective sometime in October, after the Sodor TV Map vid and have the TATMR review as the Christmas video for the channel, AND make it a thoughts on. That’s all, have a good one! - Mason

HOLY SHI-

DUCKK!!!!! I’ve been waiting for Duck!!!!! Thank you so much Tugggg!!!!!

Well done, well done !!!!!!!!!!!