CrimeInSports

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE WEST MEMPHIS 3 (PART 2)

This week, James and Jimmie pick back up with part 2 of the West Memphis 3 case!

BONUS - CRIME IN SPORTS - TRAVIS RUDOLPH

This week, James and Jimmie discuss Travis Rudolph -- the NFL player who just got done with a murder trial.

#564 - First Family Of Murder & Pecans - San Saba, Texas

This week, in San Saba, Texas, police arrive to a pecan farm to find a dead woman, in the doorway. Not only that, there is another woman, known as "The Pecan Queen", who seems to have disappeared into thin air. What looks pretty simple, at first, turns out to be a complicated plot, involving a whole family, a man who has been married 8 times, his meth addict nephew... and the actor, Tommy Lee Jones! It's an insane tale of murder & greed!!

Along the way, we find out that if ...

#564 - First Family Of Murder & Pecans - San Saba, Texas

This week, in San Saba, Texas, police arrive to a pecan farm to find a dead woman, in the doorway. Not only that, there is another woman, known as "The Pecan Queen", who seems to have disappeared into thin air. What looks pretty simple, at first, turns out to be a complicated plot, involving a whole family, a man who has been married 8 times, his meth addict nephew... and the actor, Tommy Lee Jones! It's an insane tale of murder & greed!!

Along the way, we find out that if ...

#563 - The Major Murders - Pembroke, Kentucky

This week, in Pembroke, Kentucky, a very murderous evening, that leaves three people dead, including two of them being burned to cinders, leads investigators down a rabbit hole. The main suspect is an Army vet airline pilot, who insists it was his bigamist ex-wife, who was trying to frame him, but he's been in other trouble, including accusations of abuse & having classified documents. Will a shell casing & a dog tag be enough to convict him??

Along the way, we find out...

#563 - The Major Murders - Pembroke, Kentucky

This week, in Pembroke, Kentucky, a very murderous evening, that leaves three people dead, including two of them being burned to cinders, leads investigators down a rabbit hole. The main suspect is an Army vet airline pilot, who insists it was his bigamist ex-wife, who was trying to frame him, but he's been in other trouble, including accusations of abuse & having classified documents. Will a shell casing & a dog tag be enough to convict him??

Along the way, we find out...

✨SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT!!✨

MADISON, WI!!! Please join us on Friday, September 19, 2025 @ 8:00PM at the Barrymore Theatre

shutupandgivememurder.com/live

ARTIST PRESALE: Wednesday, January 15 at 10 AM local time – Friday, January 17 at 9 AM local time (password: TURKEY)

LOCAL PRESALE: Thursday, January 16 at 10 AM local time - Friday, January 17 at 9 AM local time

ON SALE: Friday, January 17 at 10 AM local time

shutupandgivememurder.com/live

#444 - Meth, Misery & Mini Me - Chyna AKA Joanie Laurer - Part 2

This week, we continue the tale with Joanie, starting a life after wrestling. It's a bit bumpy, to say the least. She poses more for Playboy, tries her hand in multiple less than blockbuster films, and some tv shows, including "The Surreal Life", where she fights with Mini Me, dances drunk & naked, and fights with X-Pac. She's also arrested for a domestic issue, and has developed a nasty meth habit!

Start your new life, away from the wrestling ring, get pummeled by Joey But...

Dirtiest Hotel In America, Hoarder Paradise, Nipspresso

More of the craziest reviews, from all around the internet! We check out the hotel that has ben repeatedly voted "Dirtiest Hotel In The US". A thrift shop that may make you feel like you're in a hoarder house, but with sky high prices. A very personal item that looks very simple, but somehow still confuses some people & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: The Reviews Section!

#562 - Murder On Slide Mountain - Incline Village, Nevada

This week, in Incline Village, Nevada, a horrible scene awaits police, when a car plunges 800 feet off a cliff, mangling the woman inside. Meanwhile, a man hangs from a branch, nearly 100 feet below the road, seemingly lucky to be alive. But was this really a tragic accident, or a truly evil plot to make it all look like an accident, just so he could grope women, in hot tubs?

Along the way, we find out that famous people seem to like to hang out, in the middle of nowhere, that ...

#562 - Murder On Slide Mountain - Incline Village, Nevada

This week, in Incline Village, Nevada, a horrible scene awaits police, when a car plunges 800 feet off a cliff, mangling the woman inside. Meanwhile, a man hangs from a branch, nearly 100 feet below the road, seemingly lucky to be alive. But was this really a tragic accident, or a truly evil plot to make it all look like an accident, just so he could grope women, in hot tubs?

Along the way, we find out that famous people seem to like to hang out, in the middle of nowhere, that ...

#561 - Losing Streak Lois - Blooming Prairie, Minnesota

This week, in Blooming Prairie, Minnesota, a beloved local is found, brutally murdered, and his wife is missing. Detectives quickly realize she isn't a victim, and start a manhunt for the seemingly mild mannered Grandma. But she is anything but mild mannered, as she stays one step ahead of the law, looking for people that resemble her, to steal their identity. Which leads to more murder! Will they get this Grandma on the run???

Along the way, we find out that these "new" 4th of...

#561 - Losing Streak Lois - Blooming Prairie, Minnesota

This week, in Blooming Prairie, Minnesota, a beloved local is found, brutally murdered, and his wife is missing. Detectives quickly realize she isn't a victim, and start a manhunt for the seemingly mild mannered Grandma. But she is anything but mild mannered, as she stays one step ahead of the law, looking for people that resemble her, to steal their identity. Which leads to more murder! Will they get this Grandma on the run???

Along the way, we find out that these "new" 4th of...

#443 - The Glamorous Hulk - Chyna AKA Joanie Laurer - Part 1

This week, we check out a woman who came up with some hard times, to end up as one of the first women in wrestling to actually wrestle men. With her muscular physique, and aura of menace, she became a giant star, and even had a relationship with HHH. This leads to bigger things, like acting, interviews, autobiographies, and a Playboy cover spread. But there was problems bubbling under the surface, the whole time!

Grow up always feeling a little bit awkward in your skin, grow yo...

Head Injury Diner, Hostile Japanese Mountain, Offensive Pizza Maker

James & Jimmie bring you more crazy reviews, including an old school diner that may leave you with a concussion & stomach problems. A volcanic mountain in Japan that people are upset with... about the weather, and blame a "hostile" Japanese attitude. A home pizza maker with tech of a space heater, and a name that makes us crazy & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: The Reviews Sec...

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE WEST MEMPHIS 3 (PART 1)

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the West Memphis 3 case from West Memphis, Arkansas in 1993. (This case is still ongoing... and this will be part 1 of a series! Don't worry! We'll get to it!)

Happy New Year!!

BONUS - CRIME IN SPORTS - PERSONAL ADS!

This week, James and Jimmie get back into some Personal Ads!

Happy New Year!

#560 - Solving A Murder Puzzle - Chicopee, Massachusetts

This week, in Chicopee, Massachusetts, who could have brutally killed a happy, bubbly, very cool young woman in her own home? It's a mystery, but detectives have DNA, some very small shoe prints, and a name, written on a white board to go on. When a suspect is found, he has many different stories to tell, including one that has him risk his life to save hers. But it's all a lie, and the only question is, will the jury believe any of it??

Along the way, we find out that central ...

#560 - Solving A Murder Puzzle - Chicopee, Massachusetts

This week, in Chicopee, Massachusetts, who could have brutally killed a happy, bubbly, very cool young woman in her own home? It's a mystery, but detectives have DNA, some very small shoe prints, and a name, written on a white board to go on. When a suspect is found, he has many different stories to tell, including one that has him risk his life to save hers. But it's all a lie, and the only question is, will the jury believe any of it??

Along the way, we find out that central ...

#559 - Be My Baby - Keokuk, Iowa

This week, in Keokuk, Iowa, it's absolute madness, when a woman & her baby son disappear. Her car is found, but no sign of the pair. Then, some very strange events take place, and the baby is found safe & sound, in a completely unexpected place. This unravels one of the most insane tales that could exist, filled with murder & one person's lies, stories, and outright head shaking craziness!!

Along the way, we find out that no bands want to play The Dam Festival, that...

#559 - Be My Baby - Keokuk, Iowa

This week, in Keokuk, Iowa, it's absolute madness, when a woman & her baby son disappear. Her car is found, but no sign of the pair. Then, some very strange events take place, and the baby is found safe & sound, in a completely unexpected place. This unravels one of the most insane tales that could exist, filled with murder & one person's lies, stories, and outright head shaking craziness!!

Along the way, we find out that no bands want to play The Dam Festival, that...

#442 - Runnin' Through The Okra Patch - Bryant McKinnie

This week, we look at a man who had nothing but success in his future. He achieved a great deal of that success, including a Super Bowl, but he always had something dumb, hiding around the corner. From too many nightclub incidents to count, to making a spectacle of himself during a boat sex party, to blowing tens of millions of dollars, he screwed it all up! Will he turn it around, with music??

Be anywhere from 6'8 to 10'3", be one of the grossest people at a giant boat orgy, a...

Line Fights, Roller Hostages, Lube Shooting

More crazy reviews! We hear all about a roller skating rink, where you can drop your kids off, but it will cost you, if you want to get them back. A discount store that makes you battle for everything from a chair to sit & feed your baby, to fists flying in the 2 hour lines. A very personal item that may have your stomach aching, but you'll still be slippery & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of th...

#558 - Helping Mom With Murder - Grovetown, Georgia

This week, in Grovetown, Georgia, a woman is horribly murdered, in her own home, in what looks like an interrupted burglary. The house next door is also burglarized. But once the story begins to become more clear, it's obvious that this is actually a complicated plan of killing & cover up, all to be able to more easily have an affair, and has a mother & son looking down the barrel of very long prison sentences!!

Along the way, we find out that Nelly won't even come to t...

#558 - Helping Mom With Murder - Grovetown, Georgia

This week, in Grovetown, Georgia, a woman is horribly murdered, in her own home, in what looks like an interrupted burglary. The house next door is also burglarized. But once the story begins to become more clear, it's obvious that this is actually a complicated plan of killing & cover up, all to be able to more easily have an affair, and has a mother & son looking down the barrel of very long prison sentences!!

Along the way, we find out that Nelly won't even come to t...

#557 - Suburban Ax Murder Mystery - Brighton, New York

This week, in Brighton, New York, a woman is brutally murdered with an ax, in her very comfortable suburban home, making everyone wonder if a crazed killer was on the loose. Detectives seem to have no clue who could have done this, until a old neighbor, with a violent past confesses. But police still don't think he's the guy, and focus on the late woman's husband. Who did it? The neighborhood murderer, or the mild mannered economist husband??

Along the way, we find out that the...

#557 - Suburban Ax Murder Mystery - Brighton, New York

This week, in Brighton, New York, a woman is brutally murdered with an ax, in her very comfortable suburban home, making everyone wonder if a crazed killer was on the loose. Detectives seem to have no clue who could have done this, until a old neighbor, with a violent past confesses. But police still don't think he's the guy, and focus on the late woman's husband. Who did it? The neighborhood murderer, or the mild mannered economist husband??

Along the way, we find out that the...

#441 - Dedicated To Death - Kaboni Savage - Part 2

This week, we finish the story with a trial for 12 murders, including the firebombing of women & children. He wants to be his own lawyer, then changes his mind, but his whole case unravels when several of his crew testify against him. he lashes out & makes more threats, but the evidence is very strong. Will he be executed, or will the President of the United States get him off the hot seat?

Call the judge in your murder trial a "nazi", have your best friends turn on you...

#441 - Dedicated To Death - Kaboni Savage - Part 2

This week, we finish the story with a trial for 12 murders, including the firebombing of women & children. He wants to be his own lawyer, then changes his mind, but his whole case unravels when several of his crew testify against him. he lashes out & makes more threats, but the evidence is very strong. Will he be executed, or will the President of the United States get him off the hot seat?

Call the judge in your murder trial a "nazi", have your best friends turn on you...

Hot Frosty Flop, Santa's Angry Village, Candy Cane Of Love

More all new reviews from around the internet! We spread some holiday complaint cheer with a Santa's Village, that has an owner who will challenge any slight. The Netflix holiday romcom "Hot Frosty", where women swoon for a dummy, made of snow. A very personal item that will probably look better of the tree than, under the sheets. A dog costume, with antlers that don't quite meet expectations & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore ...