CrimeInSports

#524 - Trust Game - Skygusty, West Virginia

This week, in Skygusty, West Virginia, one of the strangest stories that has ever happened, all starts with an odd family, with a creepy background. The murder is a brutal two day torture session, which includes a bad batch of homemade meth & a motive that seems unclear. Then, the body is dug up, multiple times, for insane reasons. Everything becomes clear when the strangest wedding, possibly in history, takes place! Awful people, doing awful things!!

Along the way, we find...

#524 - Trust Game - Skygusty, West Virginia

This week, in Skygusty, West Virginia, one of the strangest stories that has ever happened, all starts with an odd family, with a creepy background. The murder is a brutal two day torture session, which includes a bad batch of homemade meth & a motive that seems unclear. Then, the body is dug up, multiple times, for insane reasons. Everything becomes clear when the strangest wedding, possibly in history, takes place! Awful people, doing awful things!!

Along the way, we find...

#523 - Beauty And The Beast - Marion, Indiana

This week, in Marion, Indiana, a frantic 911 call from a man, driving to the hospital, who says he found his wife, choked to death by her home workout machine. But this former Jean Claude Van Damm impersonator doesn't tell the detectives that he's been having a raucous affair with a cop's wife. Between that, how similar his name & face is to Scott Peterson & some discovered home security footage, he's quite suspicious! Did he viciously choke her with a barbell??

Along t...

#523 - Beauty And The Beast - Marion, Indiana

This week, in Marion, Indiana, a frantic 911 call from a man, driving to the hospital, who says he found his wife, choked to death by her home workout machine. But this former Jean Claude Van Damm impersonator doesn't tell the detectives that he's been having a raucous affair with a cop's wife. Between that, how similar his name & face is to Scott Peterson & some discovered home security footage, he's quite suspicious! Did he viciously choke her with a barbell??

Along t...

#424 - Human Animal - Nicole Bass

This week, we delve into the story of a woman who started out as a successful bodybuilder, and transferred that into notoriety by her many, many appearances on The Howard Stern show. Wrestling was the natural next step, and she was employed by WWE, ECW & others. A very naturally sweet person, she had some outbursts, apparently really enjoying biting police officers, pushing her husband around, and not understanding how check out counters work!

Dream of being a frilly girly ...

Quarter Nazis, Colosseum Of Meh, McNugget Ogre, Small Perversions

This week, we hear all kinds of reviews, including a world famous tourist location with more muggers than history. An airport fast food location that seems to take pride in making you miserable. A personal item that should probably make you feel like a pervert, and a bit of a weirdo. A laundromat that may take security to an insane level & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: The Reviews S...

#522 - Facebook Catfish Killer - Old Town, Maine

This week, in Old Town, Maine, a young lady is lured from her house by a Facebook message from a friend. But it turns out that this wasn't the person she thought it was, and was actually a very different young man, who had a plan, sneak up on her, kidnap her, drop her off in a field... then come to her "rescue", and be treated as hero, while gaining her affection. The problem is, all he does is murder her, in cold blood. Will all the evidence in the world, and pages of handwritten confessions...

#522 - Facebook Catfish Killer - Old Town, Maine

This week, in Old Town, Maine, a young lady is lured from her house by a Facebook message from a friend. But it turns out that this wasn't the person she thought it was, and was actually a very different young man, who had a plan, sneak up on her, kidnap her, drop her off in a field... then come to her "rescue", and be treated as hero, while gaining her affection. The problem is, all he does is murder her, in cold blood. Will all the evidence in the world, and pages of handwritten confessions...

#521 - Attack Of The Death Twins - Cosby, Tennessee

This week, in Cosby, Tennessee, a brutal & heartless slaying, on a rural front lawn, leads detectives down a rabbit hole of conspiracy, twin sisters, and multiple guys named George. The plot seemed to be years in the making, and still wasn't done very well. Paper trails, logic, and many murder requests lead to very close family, that reeled in some outsiders to solve one of their problems. Will it all come crashing down on them?

Along the way, we find out that most of the m...

#521 - Attack Of The Death Twins - Cosby, Tennessee

This week, in Cosby, Tennessee, a brutal & heartless slaying, on a rural front lawn, leads detectives down a rabbit hole of conspiracy, twin sisters, and multiple guys named George. The plot seemed to be years in the making, and still wasn't done very well. Paper trails, logic, and many murder requests lead to very close family, that reeled in some outsiders to solve one of their problems. Will it all come crashing down on them?

Along the way, we find out that most of the m...

#423 - I Am Denzel - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter - Part 4

This week, we finish up this epic tale, waiting to hear if Rubin will be convicted, for a second time, in his retrial. He is sent back to prison, and furious to be convicted with the same, shifting evidence. This time, Bob Dylan & Muhammed Ali aren't there to help, either. Rubin never gives up the legal fight, but the state also isn't backing down. Will he ever be free? Plus, Denzel Washington plays him in a major & successful movie!!

Get let out of prison, just to be p...

Fighting Children On Roller Skates, No Miracles Church, Something For The Slim

This week, we hear all kinds of reviews, including a roller skating rink, that may have gangs of unsupervised 12 year olds, who assault mothers & wield tasers. A church that has upset some people with it's lack of miracles & judgmentalness. A condom that you may end up gifting to one of your "smaller" friends. A liquor store, where you seem to also be able to buy any street drugs you need, right outside!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explo...

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - BRYAN KOHBERGER

This week, James and Jimmie discuss Bryan Kohberger.

BONUS - CRIME IN SPORTS - THE DUKE LACROSSE SCANDAL

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the Duke Lacrosse Scandal!

#520 - Taking In The Strays - Benton, Kentucky

This week, in Benton, Kentucky, a rural trailer fire leads to a horrifying discovery, inside the home. A very dead woman. It seems like a tragic accident, but the victim's "roommate" seems to know a bit too much about it, and has a history of everything he's around, catching fire. When it's found that she died before the fire started, things get crazy. Was it a cold blooded plot, or self defense against a wild, knife swinging, gun shooting lunatic??

Along the way, we find out t...

#520 - Taking In The Strays - Benton, Kentucky

This week, in Benton, Kentucky, a rural trailer fire leads to a horrifying discovery, inside the home. A very dead woman. It seems like a tragic accident, but the victim's "roommate" seems to know a bit too much about it, and has a history of everything he's around, catching fire. When it's found that she died before the fire started, things get crazy. Was it a cold blooded plot, or self defense against a wild, knife swinging, gun shooting lunatic??

Along the way, we find out t...

THE HALLOWEEN SHOW IS ON SALE NOW!

The 🦇🧛🏽‍♂️Small Town Murder Halloween Show🧛🏽‍♂️🦇 is coming back to your living room! Tickets are on sale now!!

👻🦇Be there, or be scared!🦇👻

WHEN: Wednesday, October 30, 2024 @ 9 PM ET 🎃

WHERE:

moment.co/smalltownmurder 💀

#519 - Show Me Your Belly - Ord, Nebraska

This week, in Ord, Nebraska, a local woman vanishes from a small town bar, after walking outside with a young man. When she can't be found for almost 3 years, it looks like it could be "no body, no crime", but she is eventually found, horribly butchered. Detectives are most suspicious of a man, who has a peculiar fetish, and a completely strange story about his interaction with the murder victim, the night she disappears. Will it be enough for a case??

Along the way, we find ou...

#519 - Show Me Your Belly - Ord, Nebraska

This week, in Ord, Nebraska, a local woman vanishes from a small town bar, after walking outside with a young man. When she can't be found for almost 3 years, it looks like it could be "no body, no crime", but she is eventually found, horribly butchered. Detectives are most suspicious of a man, who has a peculiar fetish, and a completely strange story about his interaction with the murder victim, the night she disappears. Will it be enough for a case??

Along the way, we find ou...

#422 - Blood Out Of A Turnip - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter - Part 3

This week, we catch up with Rubin, as a convicted murderer. The original witnesses are now recanting their stories of seeing Rubin at the murder scene. Meanwhile, Bob Dylan has written a popular song about him, and Muhammed Ali has taken up his cause. This leads to the charges being set aside, and a retrial. Problem is, while out on bail, he's also accused of beating a woman half to death! Will he stay out of prison??

Have Bob Dylan write a song, turning you into a folk hero, g...

Predicting A Murderer, Black Down There, Warfare At Leech Lake

This week, we check out reviews about a TikTok famous psychic who can apparently tell if you're a murderer. A personal item that allows you to keep certain areas free of gray hairs, or logic. A seemingly beautiful lake that may have you ducking for cover, while peeling leeches off your children. A popular grocery store that won't let you try on pants & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: ...

#518 - Conspiracy Of Fools - Keithville, Louisiana

This week, in Keithville, Louisiana, when a hay farmer is found, full of holes, with his hands tied up, it seems like an everyday robbery, until detectives scratch the surface. It turns out that this was a diabolical plot, cooked up by seemingly everyone he knows, to kill him, and take his money & property. This includes his wife, stepdaughter, granddaughter, the hired farm hands, and a man who seemingly gets sexually turned on by eating McDonald's!!

Along the way, we find ...

#518 - Conspiracy Of Fools - Keithville, Louisiana

This week, in Keithville, Louisiana, when a hay farmer is found, full of holes, with his hands tied up, it seems like an everyday robbery, until detectives scratch the surface. It turns out that this was a diabolical plot, cooked up by seemingly everyone he knows, to kill him, and take his money & property. This includes his wife, stepdaughter, granddaughter, the hired farm hands, and a man who seemingly gets sexually turned on by eating McDonald's!!

Along the way, we find ...

#517 - Slaughter At Bloody Ranch - Hondo, New Mexico

This week, in Hondo, New Mexico, a very famous person's ranch is the scene of the slaughter of three people. Brutal attacks took these people out, one by one. When the blame falls on the 14 year old son of the ranch's caretaker, the whole area goes crazy, some with support for him, others with anger & vitriol. The case comes down to whether he had a real reason to commit this act, and the evidence is overwhelming!

Along the way, we find out that: you shouldn't dress teen gi...

#517 - Slaughter At Bloody Ranch - Hondo, New Mexico

This week, in Hondo, New Mexico, a very famous person's ranch is the scene of the slaughter of three people. Brutal attacks took these people out, one by one. When the blame falls on the 14 year old son of the ranch's caretaker, the whole area goes crazy, some with support for him, others with anger & vitriol. The case comes down to whether he had a real reason to commit this act, and the evidence is overwhelming!

Along the way, we find out that: you shouldn't dress teen gi...

#421 - Dead Men Don't Smoke - "Hurricane" Rubin Carter - Part 2

This week, we start with Rubin's career going downhill, fast. Fighting three times in one month. From there, it gets worse. After a night out at a local night spot, he is accused of going into a bar, with an accomplice, and murdering 3 people, in cold blood, while making one very unlucky man's life even worse. There is very little evidence, and Rubin passed a polygraph, but never the less, we end this episode with Rubin sent to prison for consecutive life terms. Will the truth ever come out??...

Iconic Midness, Wipe Like A Dude, Rat Burgers, Fight The Owner

Reviews this week include an iconic landmark without an escalator. A personal item that seems to really want men that consider themselves to manly, to have filthy hands. A well known burger joint that seems to have some furry little mascots, running around the place. A salon that may leave you bloody, and that's before you have to fight the owner's husband & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the inte...

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - LORI VALLOW AND CHAD DAYBELL

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the "doomsday prophets" Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell.

BONUS - CRIME IN SPORTS - INEPT TEAMS

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the most inept teams in sports history!

#516 - The Office Stalker - Woodbury, Minnesota

This week, in Woodbury, Minnesota, a woman found brutalized & murdered with a hammer, near a corn field, had been dealing with constant issues at work, like someone who keeps stealing her keys from her cubicle, and dumping coffee on her chair. This seems to escalate, until she disappears from the company's lobby at lunch time. There are several suspects, but one has the strangest reaction when he was told that police found her body, then he has some even weirder pictures in his briefcase!...