Love Marry Kill

Kathleen and Michael Peterson - Part 3

In December of 2001, Kathleen Peterson’s body was discovered in bloody scene at the foot of the stairs in the Durham, North Carolina, home where she and her husband Michael lived. While Michael claimed it must have been an accidental fall while he was outside, the police were immediately suspicious due to the amount of blood, and they homed in on Michael. Thanks to The Staircase documentary series on Netflix, this story has become one of the most talked about and baffling cases ever. In par...

Kathleen and Michael Peterson - Part 2

In December of 2001, Kathleen Peterson’s body was discovered in bloody scene at the foot of the stairs in the Durham, North Carolina, home where she and her husband Michael lived. While Michael claimed it must have been an accidental fall while he was outside, the police were immediately suspicious due to the amount of blood, and they homed in on Michael. Thanks to The Staircase documentary series on Netflix, this story has become one of the most talked about and baffling cases ever. In par...

Kathleen and Michael Peterson - Part 1

In December of 2001, Kathleen Peterson’s body was discovered in a bloody scene at the foot of the stairs in the Durham, North Carolina, home where she and her husband Michael lived. While Michael claimed it must have been an accidental fall while he was outside, the police were immediately suspicious due to the amount of blood, and they homed in on Michael. Thanks to The Staircase documentary series on Netflix, this story has become one of the most talked about and baffling cases ever. In p...

Laci and Scott Peterson - Part 3

Laci Peterson, 27, went missing while walking her dog on December 24, 2002. She and her husband of five years, Scott, 30, were expecting their first child, a boy they’d named Conner. Scott’s image of the perfect husband quickly deteriorated when his mistress, Amber Frey, came forward. Suspicion quickly fell upon Scott; his every move was scrutinized and questioned as the nation and media became heavily invested in Laci’s disappearance. Months later Laci’s and Conner’s bodies washed ...

Laci and Scott Peterson - Part 2

Laci Peterson, 27, went missing while walking her dog on December 24, 2002. She and her husband of five years, Scott, 30, were expecting their first child, a boy they’d named Conner. Scott’s image of the perfect husband quickly deteriorated when his mistress, Amber Frey, came forward. Suspicion quickly fell upon Scott; his every move was scrutinized and questioned as the nation and media became heavily invested in Laci’s disappearance. Months later Laci’s and Conner’s bodies washed ...

Laci and Scott Peterson - Part 1

Laci Peterson, 27, went missing while walking her dog on December 24, 2002. She and her husband of five years, Scott, 30, were expecting their first child, a boy they’d named Conner. Scott’s image of the perfect husband quickly deteriorated when his mistress, Amber Frey, came forward. Suspicion quickly fell upon Scott; his every move was scrutinized and questioned as the nation and media became heavily invested in Laci’s disappearance. Months later Laci’s and Conner’s bodies washed ...

Deadly Love Triangle: Moriah Wilson, Colin Strickland and Kaitlin Armstrong

Moriah “Mo” Wilson, 25, was the breakout star in the world of gravel cycling before she was brutally murdered in Austin, Texas on May 11, 2022. Colin Strickland, Mo’s former love interest, was the last person to see her alive but traffic cameras confirmed he was not near her at the time of her death. Suspicion quickly fell upon Colin’s long-suffering girlfriend, Kaitlin Armstrong, when a neighbor’s doorbell camera captured an image of her vehicle at the scene of the crime. Before Ka...

Jennifer and Fotis Dulos

In the peaceful town of New Canaan, Connecticut, Jennifer Dulos dropped off her five kids at school on May 24th, 2019 just like any other day, but then she vanished without a trace. Investigators quickly turned their attention to Jennifer’s estranged husband, Fotis Dulos. Their messy divorce had been dragging on for almost two years, and Jennifer had said she was afraid of Fotis. But was he responsible for her disappearance? And if so, what happened, and where was she?

Original Love ...

Bonus episode: The Disappearance of Amy Bradley

In March 1998, 23-year-old Amy Lynn Bradley disappeared from a cruise ship while traveling with her family in the Caribbean. Despite rigorous searches, international investigations, and reported sightings in the years that followed, Amy has never found. In this episode, we look at her disappearance, the main theories, and the questions that remain unanswered.

Sources:

• Cindelshade, Lyra . The Disappearance of Amy Bradley: The True Story of a Young Woman Who Vanished f...

  2025-09-16 00:35:36 +0000 UTC View Post

Betty and Dan Broderick - Part 3 of 3

Betty and Dan Broderick were a golden couple in San Diego, CA. He, a powerful attorney; she, a devoted, fun-loving wife and mother of four. But when Dan turned 40 he became a cliche. He bought a Corvette, fell for his much younger legal assistant, and left Betty after 16 years of marriage. Their bitter six-year divorce became the most contentious in San Diego County history, a battle over money, custody, and control. On November 5, 1989, it ended in shocking violence when Betty walked into th...

Betty and Dan Broderick - Part 2 of 3

Betty and Dan Broderick were a golden couple in San Diego, CA. He, a powerful attorney; she, a devoted, fun-loving wife and mother of four. But when Dan turned 40 he became a cliche. He bought a Corvette, fell for his much younger legal assistant, and left Betty after 16 years of marriage. Their bitter six-year divorce became the most contentious in San Diego County history, a battle over money, custody, and control. On November 5, 1989, it ended in shocking violence when Betty walked into th...

Betty and Dan Broderick - Part 1 of 3

Betty and Dan Broderick were a golden couple in San Diego, CA. He, a powerful attorney; she, a devoted, fun-loving wife and mother of four. But when Dan turned 40 he became a cliche. He bought a Corvette, fell for his much younger legal assistant, and left Betty after 16 years of marriage. Their bitter six-year divorce became the most contentious in San Diego County history, a battle over money, custody, and control. On November 5, 1989, it ended in shocking violence when Betty walked into th...

The Mysterious Death of Robert Wone

On the night of August 2, 2006, Robert Wone, 32, an attorney in Washington D.C., worked late into the night. Rather than taking a train home to the suburbs, he crashed for the night with his college friend, Joseph Price. He was found dead one hour and 19 minutes later from three abdominal stab wounds. The inhabitants of the house claimed an intruder stabbed Robert but there was no evidence supporting this theory. I promise, you won’t be able to forget this story for days and weeks to come�...

Cari Farver, Liz Golyar, and Dave Kroupa - Part 2

In the summer of 2012, Dave Kroupa of Omaha, Nebraska was getting back into the dating scene after the end of a long-term relationship. He was looking for something casual and fun, but instead he ended up being part of a deadly love triangle involving two women - Liz Golyar and Cari Farver. But who was the stalker and who was the victim? It would take investigators years to unravel the mystery in this story of love, jealousy and obsession.

Original Love Marry Kill air date: 11/20/2023<...

Cari Farver, Liz Golyar, and Dave Kroupa - Part 1

In the summer of 2012, Dave Kroupa of Omaha, Nebraska was getting back into the dating scene after the end of a long-term relationship. He was looking for something casual and fun, but instead he ended up being part of a deadly love triangle involving two women - Liz Golyar and Cari Farver. But who was the stalker and who was the victim? It would take investigators years to unravel the mystery in this story of love, jealousy and obsession.

Original Love Marry Kill air date: 11/13/2023<...

Judi Buenoano

Born Anna Lou Welty in 1943, Judi Buenoano had many names and many lovers over her 54 years. Men in Judi’s life had a way of suffering a tragic fate when their affairs fizzled out; her husband, boyfriend, and even her son all died by her hand, which earned her the title “Black Widow”. A fourth man survived an attempt on his life which led to Judi’s ultimate demise and eventual execution in 1998.

Original Love Marry Kill air date: 11/6/2023

Sources:

1. 2025-09-16 00:25:01 +0000 UTC View Post

Jennifer and Sarah Hart

Jennifer and Sarah Hart, a same-sex, white couple living in Minnesota adopted 6 black and mixed-race children from Texas. That would be a challenge for most people, but Jen and Sarah made it look easy. Jen’s social media was full of beautiful pictures of their children in nature, political rallies, protests, and musical festivals. They seemed like the perfect modern family until reports of child abuse and neglect mounted and Child Protective Services (CPS) was called in 3 different states a...

Erika and BJ Sifrit and the murders of Geney Crutchley and Joshua Ford - Part 2

Joshua Ford and his girlfriend Martha “Geney” Crutchley were looking forward to a Memorial Day 2002 weekend filled with sun and fun in the resort town of Ocean City, Maryland. Unfortunately for them a random encounter with another couple, BJ and Erika Sifrit, turned into a real-life horror movie. In part two of this two-part episode, we discuss the investigation and subsequent trials.

Original Love Marry Kill air date: 10/23/2023

Erika and BJ Sifrit and the murders of Geney Crutchley and Joshua Ford - Part 1

Joshua Ford and his girlfriend Martha “Geney” Crutchley were looking forward to a Memorial Day 2002 weekend filled with sun and fun in the resort town of Ocean City, Maryland. Unfortunately for them a random encounter with another couple, BJ and Erika Sifrit, turned into a real-life horror movie. In part one, we discuss the background of the victims and the killers, and the events of May 25th, 2002.

Also featured is the story of Kennedy Walton, a 26 year old woman from St. Louis wh...

Crystal Rogers and Brooks Houck

Crystal Rogers, mother to 5 children, disappeared on July 3, 2015, from the home she shared with her boyfriend, Brooks Houck, in Bardstown, Kentucky. When Brooks woke up on the morning of July 4, Crystal was gone and her car was missing. He wasn’t worried, he assumed she spent the night with a friend after they had a disagreement. Her family, however, were very worried and have been searching for her for over 8 years. Bardstown, Kentucky has had a series of baffling, unsolved murders over t...

Tips for finding episodes

Hello friends! We're going to start posting more of our Just the Facts episodes, including our backlog of older episodes, as some patrons have requested them. That will make your LMK Patreon feed a bit cluttered for a while, so here are some tips for finding episodes:

• If you go to the Collections tab, you'll see both the original LMK podcast and the LMK:JTF version. Clicking into those podcasts, you'll see every episode we've published to each. ...

  2025-09-15 21:55:08 +0000 UTC View Post

Patreon Exclusive: Rhonda Casto and Steve Nichols

The Eagle Creek Trail, carved into the cliffs of Oregon’s Columbia River Gorge, is known for its stunning waterfalls and dizzying drop-offs. On a damp March afternoon in 2009, 23-year-old Rhonda Casto set out on that trail with her boyfriend, Steve Nichols. They were alone on the path, the mist hanging low in the canyon.

By the end of the hike, only one of them would return.

What happened on that isolated trail that day? Was it an accident on treacherous ground, or something mor...

Patreon Exclusive: Rhonda Casto and Steve Nichols

The Eagle Creek Trail, carved into the cliffs of Oregon’s Columbia River Gorge, is known for its stunning waterfalls and dizzying drop-offs. On a damp March afternoon in 2009, 23-year-old Rhonda Casto set out on that trail with her boyfriend, Steve Nichols. They were alone on the path, the mist hanging low in the canyon.

By the end of the hike, only one of them would return.

What happened on that isolated trail that day? Was it an accident on treacherous ground, or something mor...

Molly and Jason Corbett

Happy Saturday!! Hope everyone is having a wonderful weekend. Finally some new episodes for you all. The problem with doing multipart episodes is that you guys have to wait longer! We hope you enjoy this heartbreaking case. Jason was an amazing man and father. Let us know what you think in comments or the chat. I highly recommend watching A Deadly American Marriage on Netflix if you haven’t already.

The recipe Rich made in part two was so good! Give it a try.

Molly Martens and Jason Corbett - Part 1

After the sudden loss of his first wife, Irish widower Jason Corbett hired Molly Martens to help care for his two young children. In time, Molly became more than just an au pair, and Jason eventually brought her and the children with him to North Carolina to start a new life together. But in the middle of a summer night, a desperate 911 call shattered that picture of domestic stability. What unfolded inside the family’s home would lead to years of courtroom drama, international headlines, a...

Molly Martens and Jason Corbett - Part 2

After the sudden loss of his first wife, Irish widower Jason Corbett hired Molly Martens to help care for his two young children. In time, Molly became more than just an au pair, and Jason eventually brought her and the children with him to North Carolina to start a new life together. But in the middle of a summer night, a desperate 911 call shattered that picture of domestic stability. What unfolded inside the family’s home would lead to years of courtroom drama, international headlines, a...

Bonus episode: The Disappearance of Amy Bradley

In March 1998, 23-year-old Amy Lynn Bradley disappeared from a cruise ship while traveling with her family in the Caribbean. Despite rigorous searches, international investigations, and reported sightings in the years that followed, Amy has never found. In this episode, we look at her disappearance, the main theories, and the questions that remain unanswered.

Today's snack: Bro...

Amy Lyn Bradley

Happy Saturday!! Wishing you all a wonderful weekend. What do you think happened to Amy Bradley?

In March 1998, 23-year-old Amy Lynn Bradley disappeared from a cruise ship while traveling with her family in the Caribbean. Despite rigorous searches, international investigations, and reported sightings in the years that followed, Amy has never found. In this episode, we look at her disappearance, the main theories, and the questions that remain unanswered.

Betty and Dan Broderick

The case that I’ve been wanting to cover for three years. Finally. It’s a fascinating case. Excited to hear what you all think.

Betty and Dan Broderick were a golden couple in San Diego, CA. He, a powerful attorney; she, a devoted, fun-loving wife and mother of four. But when Dan turned 40 he became a cliche. He bought a Corvette, fell for his much younger legal assistant, and left Betty after 16 years of marriage. Their bitter six-year divorce became the most contentious in San Die...

Betty and Dan Broderick - Part 1

Betty and Dan Broderick were a golden couple in San Diego, CA. He, a powerful attorney; she, a devoted, fun-loving wife and mother of four. But when Dan turned 40 he became a cliche. He bought a Corvette, fell for his much younger legal assistant, and left Betty after 16 years of marriage. Their bitter six-year divorce became the most contentious in San Diego County history, a battle over money, custody, and control. On November 5, 1989, it ended in shocking violence when Betty walked into th...