Cody Croquet

Gloryhole With My Friend 03

Everyone is 18+ and fully consenting.

Chapter 3: Back to the Mall

The night after everything went down, we chilled in Rugger’s basement playing video games. Neither of us brought up what had happened, but my mind wouldn’t let it go. I kept replaying the feel of his thick dick in my mouth, how wide it had been, almost like an apple in girth. I wanted to do it again so badly, but I didn’t want to risk crossing a line. Rugger acted completely norm...

Pretending To Be Gay 14

Everyone is 18+ and fully consenting.

Chapter 14: Prom, Part 2

Just when I was about to go down on him, I saw Rob down the hall, turning a corner.

"Oh shit, there he is!" I whispered. Miles turned to look and caught him just as he disappeared. We jogged down the hall to find him, and when we turned the corner, we saw a bathroom door closing. We looked at each other, and walked in.

We didn't see anyone when we walked in,...

Pretending To Be Gay 13

Everyone is 18+ and fully consenting.

Chapter 13: Prom, Part 1

April started with college decisions. Miles came over on the day they were coming out, and we both opened our laptops side by side on my bed. We were a bit tense. My heart was beating in my throat. We’d been waiting for this moment for months.

“Ready?” Miles asked, his finger hovering over the mouse.

“Yeah, let’s just do it.” My heart was hammering.

We opened ou...

Gloryhole With My Friend 02

Everyone is 18+ and fully consenting.

Chapter 2: Wait, Did Your Dick Change?

I pulled back from Rugger’s lap, my lips wet, my head spinning. The realization hit me all at once. That guy’s meat that I had felt earlier, the way the dick had fit in my mouth, the weight of it. None of that matched what I was holding now. Rugger’s was different. He was thicker, heavier. My gut twisted.

"Wait," I said, "oh my fucking god."

"Hey I didn't ask you to ...

Pretending To Be Gay 12

Everybody is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 12: Pool Party

The holidays passed with plenty of little pockets of alone time for us. Now that we were out, it was actually more complicated to have time alone for sex. Having a sleepover was too cringey to say to my parents when I knew they knew we were having sex, so I snuck him in after everyone went to bed. Thanksgiving break he was out of town, but we facetimed and I showed him my ass while we jerked off together.

Gloryhole With My Friend

Everyone is 18+ and fully consenting.

I was hanging with my best friend, Rugger at the mall one day, just killing time like we often did. His real name was Danny but we called him Rugger since he loved rugby and his parents were British. Long story. So at the mall we were honestly getting pretty rowdy playing little pranks on each other. He filled my soda with salt while I wasn't looking and watched me drink it and spit it out, cracking up. I got him back by sneaking some women...

Pretending to Be Gay 11

Everybody is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 11: Coming Out

Sunday morning I finally felt better. Miles and I were in bed, joking around and grabbing each other’s morning wood like usual, when I blurted out a spontaneous thought. “I think we should come out.”

He didn’t even flinch, just grinned. Later that morning we stood side by side in in kitchen and called in my parents from their room. When they arrived I just started without being sure w...

Pretending To Be Gay 10

Everybody is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 10: Sick Day

Saturday I woke up sick again, worse than the day before. My head pounded, my body ached, and I knew I probably shouldn’t have stayed up all night with Miles. I barely opened my crusty eyes when Miles turned to me and sensed my pain. 

"You should go," I said, "you're gonna get sick."

"No," he said, then slid down my body under the blanket, and grabbed my morning wood, aiming it at ...

Pretending To Be Gay 09

Everybody is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 9: Movie Day

Time passed, and over the next few weeks we found sort of a flow. Things didn’t feel as shaky anymore, and it was like we had settled into our own rhythm. We got more comfortable being ourselves in public, and every day it felt more obvious that we were basically together, like a regular couple of gay dudes, even if we hadn’t said it out loud yet. Miles was writing our story and sharing it with me...

Pretending To Be Gay 08

Everybody is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 8: Nude Art

One afternoon Miles surprised me with something different, his art. Miles was actually really artistic. I always knew that he “liked” woodshop, but he never really talked about all the artistic hobbies he was into. 

After one class we stayed behind in the classroom after the teacher had left. Miles and I and a few other buddies, including Joey, Greg, this guy named Eric, and a few others were just sitting...

Updates

Hi all,

Just wanted to talk a bit about my plans moving forward. Pretending To Be Gay has been one of my favorite stories to write in a long time. It is based on a true story from a reader for chapters 1-2, then drifted further into "filling in the blank" territory as I found it a rich area to write in. I will be continuing this story alongside regular posts, and plan to make it a long form story.

Secondly, there is some movement lately from Patreon to ban gay writers fro...

Pretending To Be Gay 07

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 7: Bathroom Buddies

Over the next few days, Miles and I leaned into the act like it was a running dare. We weren’t exactly walking down the hall holding hands, but he’d drape his arm across my shoulders or hook me in with his elbow while we talked between classes. At lunch I’d lean into him without caring who saw. Greg always seemed to be around, subtly egging us on. He’d text me random stuff like “do it a...

Pretending to be Gay 06

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 6: Freaks

The next day at school, Miles wouldn’t shut up about the idea of trying something wild again. Between classes he kept nudging me, making comments, daring me to go along with him. By lunch he had worn me down, and by the time practice ended I had already agreed. He wanted another shot at the shower stalls, as risky as yesterday was. The whole thing made me nervous as hell, but I couldn’t say no to him. A...

Pretending To Be Gay 05

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 5: Urges

Miles and I had crossed a threshold, and I just kept thinking that he was the coolest guy in the world. We had never done anything gay before with anyone, unless you count Miles saying he’d “always” jerked off with friends, but we were open enough with each other to find some really cool things to do together. I loved being weird and taboo with him.

After we changed back to regular clothes, we wal...

Pretending To Be Gay 04

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 4: School Showers

Monday morning, Miles saw me in the hall before I saw him. He was a tall guy, so I guess he had an advantage there.

I made a beeline for him, when suddenly out of the crowd jumped Brittany. She blocked my way. I hadn’t thought about her all weekend, and when she inserted herself yet again into my life, I had zero patience for it. I just tried to go around her but it was too crowded.

Miles stopped behin...

Pretending To Be Gay 03

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 3: Sunday

I woke up with his arm around me. For a second I stayed still, listening to his easy breath and the soft clicks of the ceiling fan. My stomach did a slow roll of happy and nervous, the good kind.

I looked at his body until he stirred. We giggled as we both acknowledged our morning wood situations. He poked mine with his finger, and I wiggled his. We just did this kind of stuff now. Then we were silent for a moment, and...

Pretending To Be Gay 02

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 2: Saturday

After we got our rocks off in the hot tub. The rest of the night was even more fun. We walked around the house in our underwear. My little brother woke up and joined us on the couch for a movie, and then fell asleep right away. We started piling pillows on him to see when he would wake up, and we ran out of pillows and he was still asleep.

When the movie ended we went back into my room. He joined me on my bed to sc...

Pretending to be Gay

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

This girl wouldn’t leave me alone. She was basically stalking me. So, I told her I was gay. She said it couldn’t be true, so I grabbed a friend of mine, Miles who was walking by in the hall, and pulled him into me and kissed him. He was a few inches taller than me. He was a swimmer, and I had met him a few times at school. He was a big jokester and I assumed this wouldn’t be a big deal for him to go along with. We kissed tenderly and I grabbed ...

Weekend AMA

Hi all! I thought it would be fun to do an AMA and answer any questions you had about my stories, the writing process, or anything you want. Ask away!

Cheers,

Cody

Caught Me Tied Up 02

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 2: Roommate Situation

The next morning, we both acted like literally nothing had happened. Connor  rolled out of bed and stretched. I looked at his crotch and saw his morning wood through his underwear. My mind flashed back to him fucking me while I was bound. He just looked at me and asked if I’d eaten yet, snapping me out of it.

"No," I said, "Does it look like I did?" I gestured to my body still unde...

Caught Me Tied Up

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

We were eighteen and stupid, and having a lot of fun. I dated this freaky girl sophomore year of college name Stella, and we had been playing with ropes, safe words, the whole checklist of freaky shit. I had varying levels of comfort with the escalating things she was into.

She always knew how to dig into any kink I said "maybe" to, and she loved the humiliation aspect of shit. I admit it was kind of addicting for me as well, and soon enough ...

Catching My Straight Crush With A Guy 03

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 3: Dicks At School

My heart was racing so hard I could feel each beat in my throat, and my dick was immediately hard as a rock, tenting my shorts. The room smelled like dust and old paper. It had the aura of those parts of the school that no one paid any attention to. The concrete floor was cold under my sneakers, and the chill ran up my legs when we walked in. 

Dom gave me that same look from Friday night....

Catching My Straight Crush With A Guy 02

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 2: Straight Guy

“Wait,” he said, like he had just realized something, “If you’re gay, do you want me to fuck you in the ass?”

My eyes lit up. "Are you serious??"

"Yeah dude. I haven’t fucked in weeks since Brittany went crazy and I broke up with her. My dick is deprived, man."

"I’ve never been fucked before."

"Well I’ve done anal with girls before. I can go slow and...

Catching My Straight Crush With A Guy

Eveyone is 18 and fully consenting.

In high school, I was hopelessly in love with this straight guy I knew named Dom. He was clueless, and I never let it on, but I couldn’t help myself, and I always hung out with him when I could. He was eighteen, he wrestled AND he played lacrosse. He had developed muscles and these perfect (to me) brown curls that bounced when he ran. Ever since I first met him when I came to this school freshman year, I always had a sort of desperation to be close ...

Smash Bros Bets 03

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 3: Waking Everyone Up

Jay didn’t say anything. He just kept staring, hand still slowly working his bulge. I stayed frozen on my stomach, breath slowing down, heart still racing.

Trevor hadn’t moved. He was lying on his back, eyes closed, chest rising and falling like he was falling asleep after destroying my hole. Maybe he was already asleep, or maybe he was giving Jay space to do his thing. Either way, ...

Smash Bros Bets 02

Everyone is 18 and fully consenting.

Chapter 2: Beyond the Bets

“I can’t sleep. Can you do me one more time?”

His voice was soft, low enough that the others couldn’t hear. I glanced around the room. My brother, Logan and his other friends were still passed out on couches, the floor, even one curled up with a blanket next to the stairs. I nodded, barely, and lifted my blanket.

Trevor slipped in next to me, our bodies immediately pre...