Spider Ornament Contest + Sunday Dec 27th Livestream at 5:00PM (EST)

omg thta movie terrorized me in my dreams! I am 53 and was way too young to have watched it in the early 80s but I did. To this day it terrifies me.

Michelle Ford-Copley

Hair is cut from people when they are living. Not dead. Otherwise the hair is full of mites. There was a C S I episode about it. CSI Miami.

Linda

Ohhhh I love this!

Amy Watler-Thomas

I am gonna have to try these covers both Halloween and Christmas! These are beautiful!

Margaux Allard

Ohmygod, that was my grandmother's favorite movie! We used to listen to the soundtrack in the car every time we drove to Lake Tahoe. <3

Sara Logan

Victorian hair art! I have a deep disdain for hair and I feel like the fact that the owners of the hair are now dead would freak me out too

Shanika Haws

Ugh! Be still my heart! This reminds me of my favorite romance movie “somewhere in time”.

Kelly Skelley

I like your sweater, very nice!

Kris

Lace with names of my family and friends hidden in it.

Siobhan

A Barbie doll with my face and my own hairstyle and the clothes I wear when I receive it

Kira Buffy

A second pandemic. 😑

Guinevere Rhoads

A framed photograph of me in my room, unsuspecting... from the point of view of someone in the closet. The card would be signed, "Your closest friend".

Alexa Harrington

A box with a "Must Take One Pill 💊" note with two pills in it reading: Blue Pill - 'All your life was a dream and you will be reborn to RE-live it all over' or Red Pill: 'You will come back as your pet and watch your life unfold'.

Christina Galaviz

a funeral wreath...with MY name on it..

Jennifer Todd

A creepy Christmas present to receive would be two front teeth!

Hannah Rose Anderson

Probably one of those human skin bound books 📚

Paulina Colonna

An unaddressed box, gorgeously wrapped in slightly singed antique fabric and lace( that looks suspiciously like pieces of an old dress).Inside is an old photograph from 1910 of a woman who looks exactly like me, standing in front of a big beautiful Victorian mansion. And written on the back is 3 words " come home, Sara"

Sara Logan

On Christmas morning after my children and I have opened our stockings and presents and they are sitting by the fireplace playing with their new toys, I notice a small wrapped box behind the tree that is partially hidden by a low hanging branch. I get on my knees and reach under the branches to grasp the present, seeing a poorly scrawled note on top that says “Father”. I open the box and notice a folded piece of construction paper sitting at the bottom. When I unfold it, my heart begins to race as a see a figure drawn next to a Christmas tree, lying down with two “x”s for eyes, with dark red crayon filling the space next to the body. I spin around on my knees and gasp as my children are standing together behind me, eyes unblinking, the glint of knives in their hands reflecting the christmas tree lights

Christopher Jones

The black and red Furby I got when I was 11, and promptly disposed of. The very identical Furby. No box. It just shows up on your doorstep, expectantly, those hollow eyes staring back at you. Watching....waiting...

Georgina

Same!!!!!! Those fiery guys scared the hell outta me as a kid. I still crying when I watch Labyrinth and they try to take off Sara’s head.

Kate Balinski

My recently deceased dog in taxidermy form. I'd honestly love that but it would be just be the creepiest Christmas gift for me!

Elda Negrete

The creepiest present I could receive would be a handmade photo album filled with candid pictures of me from my childhood until present day. All the pics would be of me with my gaze slightly off perspective as if someone had been to all my soccer games, holiday parties, my school musicals and graduations. Lovingly decorated with craft paper, stickers, dates and descriptions of each event... From an anonymous stalker. Someone who has been tracking me my whole life. Oh... September 26,1998? Brookfield Zoo. Chicago, Illinois. 3pm. Kate saw manatees.

Kate Balinski

A dozen black roses with a card that read...’See you soon!’ 🖤... 😳

Kerri L Neighbors

It's probably too late, but I only just thought of one. A complete set of your own baby teeth. Creepiest if the present isn't signed and/or no one knows who put it under the tree.

Kristine Sprague

Hellraiser puzzle box, The Lament Configuration

Veronica Diehl

A Dybbuk box.

Chelsea Anderson

A fancy, outdoor grill from an estate sale. You then find out the property owner was a serial killer who barbecued their victims before eating them.

Kimmie Cat

A puppy that looks like the spitting image of my dog that passed when I was a little girl. Creepy, but in a good way. A doppelganger, perhaps even with her same mannerisms, curled up under the Christmas tree with an attitude like she already owned the place.

Riona O'Faoladh

A beautifully wrapped present with endless layers of wrapping and no matter how many layers you take off you will never be able to unwrap your gift...it draws you in...it sends you insane...

Patricia Dunn

A Deluxe Gore-met gift box tower… tag reads: “Have a very Mayhem Christmas” tower includes: top box- a beautiful bottle of Strychnine box 2- a cookie jar of live Deathstalker scorpions box 3- variety tin of poisonous mushrooms box 4- assortment of homemade mini bombs box 5- coiled rope with noose box 6-variety knife set -includes dagger, Bowie knife and machete box 7-large bear trap

Ghoulella

an empty box with a note inside. it says "its in your home now"

Julie

It was a creepy looking stuffed animal...I never could determine what it was supposed to be. If you pushed it's belly it would laugh...and not a exactly a happy little kid brand of laugh...I buried that thing in the bottom of the toy box!

Cj Franklin

Labyrinth's The Fireys under the Christmas Tree, singing Chilly Down and trying to remove my head !

Claudia Kerr

A doll

Clare Buswell

The creepiest present I could receive is a picture of myself with no makeup and hair done💀💀💀😥

Christina Zavala

If my brother gave me a copy of Flowers in the attic or 50 shades of grey....

MichelleShari

This is totally creepy!

Welikemeatloaf

I like Heidi K’s, but this would be creepier for me: Receiving in the mail a photo album inscribed: “Allison grows up. Love, Mom” filled with photos of me with a family I’ve never before seen.

Welikemeatloaf

A letter detailing the rest of your life and the date and time you’ll die. ☠️

Julie

I didn't receive my Christmas card😕 I did receive a gift that was the canvas painting, which is so awesome!

Jana McDowell

An 1814 Emerald Green Victorian gown to match the arachnid. Will prove to be more deadly. The dye is cast...in arsenic.

Mary Sacco

True story I once received a box of cicada shells and snake skin as a gift on a 2nd date.

Zachary paige

The hideous Dorian Gray-style painting of Santa Claus that allows him to live forever in a frozen wasteland!

Rae

You receive Great Uncle Norman’s moustache complete with upper lip. Gift wrapped on a pale grey silk cushion in a black box tied with a satin purple bow. Accompanied with a simple hand written message “we know, we know”.

Karen

A letter detailing all of the reasons I should be on the naughty list. WIth photos of said events attached.

Nicholas Favia

a pig’s heart. with a nail through it.

Cecelia Breslin

I think the creepiest gift someone could receive would be a box filled with things like a photograph of you you don't remember ever seeing, a little lock of your hair you never noticed went missing, and a list of daily habits you weren't fully aware of!

Hope ♡

I got mine last week, and it is stunning! Shipped by regular USPS mail. Happy Holidays!

Suzanna Dunn

A picture of myself sleeping in my own home taken from outside by an unknown person left on my doorstep. Attached to a lock of my hair...

Rebecca Mitchell

Gwyneth Paltrow's head in a box.

Bonnie Lindsay

Anything taxidermy! Something that was once alive and then stuffed freaks me the Hell out.

Misty Henneke

I just found out my sister-in-law once received a John Wayne Gacy Jr. painting of "Pogo the Clown". I now know why clowns creep her out and I don't blame her.

Heather M

My aunt has a HAWAIIAN... HULA... ANIMATRONIC... DANCING... SANTA!!! Horrible.

Racheal Jones

Two twin girls, aged seven, in lace dresses, that never blink and always move and speak in unison.

Racheal Jones

Baby doll head lamp. The bulb is the brain and the eyes get darker when it’s turned on. Made one for my cousin for Christmas and it comes out every year.

Sarah Cringan

A skin suit that fits you perfectly.

Jenny Werner

An album full of photographs of yourself at various ages that you don't remember posing for, with people you've never met at places you've never been. It's signed "from: the other you".

Heidi K.

The creepiest gift I could receive would be all the teeth I lost as a kid neatly placed in a box, because we didn’t keep any of them!

Allegra Mroz

a teeth necklace from one of the naughty children krampus punished

Gabriela Bello

Grandfather's tattoos cut from his body and framed as an art keepsake. ...interesting concept, but I'd rather some "inspired by" artistic rendering than the actual skin scraps.

Morgen Meier

The creepiest gift I could receive would be a coffin, and when I open it up, my body would already be inside.

Rebecca Senger

a doll that whispers my name whenever I'm leaving the room.

Krysti

Hi everyone!! Just wondering if the Christmas card was sent out from Christine? Im still looking for mine in the post🎄

Susan S

Those spiders! 🕷🕷

Shelley Anders

My tonsils were removed when I was 16. At that time the hospital let me take them home in a see through plastic container. I hide them in our old dirt floor cellar, in-between the rocks of the foundation. The family home was sold 4 years ago. I would like the new owners to return the tonsils to me for Christmas. I would feel it as a nice gesture, ever so . . . .creepy.

vermont witch

I actually received an angel figurine from a lady that passed away 20 years ago. With a signed card from her.

Ms. Cordelia

My ex's head

Sarah Cortez

Old dolls really creep me out. Mine used to scare me as a child. They always stared at me while I was sleeping...

Ketima Labrador

Your own placenta and umbilical cord saved for when you were an adult. Worse is when you find out moms been carrying it in her purse all these years.

Christine M

Antique gynecological tools, and a jar with a preserved fetus in it...it's a themed gift! Who doesn't love a theme.

Jodie Treloar

A fourth haunted doll - I've unintentionally been gifted 3.

Laura Unkefer

A 2021 calendar where you relive 2020 all over again just like a Twilight Zone episode.

Amanda Lovell

My own ashes along with the date on the box saying I've died last year. After I open it nobody sees me and they start talking about me like I have passed.

Sam Routzon

A beautifully handmade necklace or tiara made by a master jeweler featuring baby teeth throughout mixed with precious gemstones like emeralds and rubies. ✨🦷

Heather

Hair of the Dead - Funerary Keepsake 😳

Alicia McLeod

A handwritten note, written in gothic lettering saying that this year will be my last.

Allison Waldron

My own obituary alongside my certified death certificate in a Krampus themed Christmas card.

Angee Erickson

Victorian era, antique ormolu perfume bottle. But instead of the ornate floral motif that was popular at the time, mine would have a beautiful (but deadly) tangle of gilded gold webbing and arachnids.

Trace

For me, the creepiest gift wouldn't be just one. It would be progressive gifts that get darker and darker with each gift. It gets to the point where you realize that the person obsessed with you is completely insane!

Jana McDowell

Human skin covered book 😳

Kym Storms

The creepiest thing I could receive would be the Zuni Fetish doll used in the 1975 horror movie Trilogy of Terror staring Karen Black. In the third segment of the movie, she is terrorized in her apartment by the doll.

Karri Thompson

A framed picture of me sleeping in my bed that a stalker took

Mandy Spitzer

I think the creepiest thing you could receive would be a beautifully framed photograph of you that you don’t remember being taken.

Britt Thompson

My partner gave me the most perfect creepy gift this year. A coffin-shaped ring, which is carved from a historic gravestone. That night I dreamt of walking through a cemetery and the ring was glowing. I am yet to test if this is true in real life!

Hollie Quinn

Marilyn Manson painted pictures of Elizabeth Short ( the Black Dahlia) using his own hair in part of the paintings...I would say receiving a portrait of yourself with human hair added for embellishment would indeed be very creepy.

Katheryn B

My creepy sister that I don’t get along with hand me a tray of baked goods and watch me eat them with a huge creepy smile on her face and an odd twinkle in her eye.

jennifer torres

I love reading everyone's creepy ideas!

Aunt Debbie Halloween

A faded Christmas Card, addressed to me. Inside the card, in crimson ink, is written “I can see you” Warm wishes to you and your captive and pets for the holiday season Christine 🤍

Madam G

Creepiest Christmas present, which is also the coolest Christmas present, I could receive: An antique mirror with an old golden, stained and scratched frame. As I set to restore the frame I keep it in my bedroom. At night I wake up by a strange light spilling into my room. At first I presume it to be light from my phone screen, but then the light seems to flicker like the flame of a candle. I would sit up in bed, look around, and notice the light shining from the mirror. There is no other light source in the room. The golden frame glistens in the moving light like it is brand new, reflecting in the curves of the ornaments. I lean forward to get a better look. The mirror has become like a window. I do not see my own confused and sleepy face reflected back at me, but a dark corridor, candles burning at sconces set in the walls. It is like I am walking forward, in the world of the mirror. I catch a glimpse of a staircase leading down from the corridor. Then, like a switch, the candles in the mirror flicker out and I am back in complete darkness in my bedroom. I scramble for my phone, switch it on, shine the display at the mirror and all that is there is my Christmas present, a slightly scratched, antique mirror. To be continued? ;D Creepiest Christmas present: Spooky old mirror.

Marielle Bodenheimer

Yes, one of the previous posters is creeped out by plain white buttons.

Aunt Debbie Halloween

A doll that looks like you a la Coraline, just showing up mysteriously under the tree. I think dolls are SUPER creepy in general, and that is one of my favorite movies. The idea of a mirror world with a spider-esque woman who wants to sew buttons on my eyes? Terrifying, but fascinating!

Kristen

Wow!

Aunt Debbie Halloween

An acquaintance? Gave you one like her father was buried with? OK, maybe don't hang out with that person...

Aunt Debbie Halloween

My husband and I have a running (and sort of sick) joke that perhaps one of us is only a figment of the other's imagination. Someone that our subconscious created to help cope with the stresses of life. For certain, the most NIGHTMARE gift I can think of is this: We wake up on Christmas morning and all is heavenly and right. We pour our coffee, sit down by the beautifully decorated tree with our three lovely kitties. There's a box under the tree that is lovingly written for me: "to my dearest wife." I open the box and in it is the perfect gift. Straight out of my dreams. I surely couldn't have picked out something better myself. It dawns on me that this gift is indeed very familiar. I recognize this. Wait -- I purchased this. I wrapped this. This was all me. Trembling, I look up and my dear husband is gone. My cats are gone. They were, in fact, never there. I have finally realized it. My husband, my cats, my beautiful life; it was only my imagination. I am alone.

Diana Rose Lindahl

Finding a journal of a deceased love one and finding out you were not their favorite person!

Brenda L.

letters or cards from dead ancestors

Amy Rainbow-Beahan

A book titled "The Handbook for the Recently Deceased".

Sarah Early

Your work does a Secret Santa exchange, and you receive an absolutely beautiful box wrapped in red velvet paper and adorned with black satin bows and dried roses. The tag on the box simply reads, "With Love". You untie the bows and remove the lid of the box, noticing what looks like odd, red-brown scratch marks inside the lid. Nestled in black tissue paper within, you find what appears to be a box of the finest chocolates in the world. You excitedly take the box out and open it, eager to taste this magical gift. Written on the protective paper under the lid is another note that reads, "Hope you enjoy the variety." You remove the paper and reel back in shock and horror when you find not exquisite confections, but various fingernails in each slot where a candy should be. Some are painted, some are plain, some are masculine, some are feminine, with bits of flesh still attached to them - obviously ripped right off of their original bearers' fingers. Then Christine McConnell pops into your office and says, "Surprise! Merry Christmas!", and you realize that you are the recipient of one of Christine's incredible, edible creations. You have a good laugh about it as soon as you're done crying and shaking.

Tammi Harris-Crocheted Atrocities

Merry Christmas ,Christine !!!! Cant wait for the livestream

Tass Lerion

😲 oh no!

Tammi Harris-Crocheted Atrocities

😳

Tammi Harris-Crocheted Atrocities

A beautiful, intricate locket with a lady's picture you don't know.. You think it's absolutely beautiful so you wear it but something doesn't feel right. Over time, you don't want to wear it any more but can't seem to bring yourself to take it off. You look in the mirror and realize you don't look like yourself and your behavior, likes and dislikes seem foreign. One day you realize, you're in your body but you can't do what you want to do. The locket now contains your picture and the mirror reflects the face that once lived in the locket.

Jennifer Gray

Wouldst thou like to order deliciously? Free Prime shipping for thou.

Tammi Harris-Crocheted Atrocities

Any of the things we buried with my dad.

Maureen S Holloway

All inclusive discount package for cremation. To be honest, I’m surprised my frugal family hasn’t tried it yet.

Stephanie Bennett

I think clowns are creepy so anything to do with a clown. (With the exception of jesters. I think jesters are cool.)

Nancy Wittmayer

A relatives remains! Merry Christmas! Here's uncle Frank. We know he meant a lot to you lol

Sara Vetoich

I received a tiny silver standing picture frame with a tiny mouse skull and buttons within the frame. Most would think this morbid and creepy. My dark little heart absolutely loves it!

Jane Duprey

A collage of my face that a creeper made out of there own clipped toenails

Danielle Doll

An antique projector arrives with a mysterious film reel that is footage of your own funeral

Joe Black

Anything with clowns on it. I don’t know how people find them funny or amusing! They are just creepy to me.

Jaclyn Goodballet

A spooky selection box with chocolate coated body parts and live spiders with your own face on them (my 8 year old child’s idea) 😂 🕷🌟🎁

Victoria Gates

Groundhog Day 2020 Pandemic Special Edition DVD 💽🎥😷😄 Just to watch this "amazing" year again and again

Ronja Schuster

A vintage Victorian post-mortem photo of a person who looks exactly like me.

Colleen Cunningham

ANIMATRONIC..... DANCING....... SANTA...

Elmari Jankowitz

Food poisoning (two years ago). Nobody wanted it, everybody got it. Christmas celebrations like no other, we all hope to never live again through moments like this 😂

Magda Mazur

A scrapbook, from an anonymous sender, containing pictures of myself taken through the windows of my apartment. It could include trinkets of mine, like locks of hair or nail clippings.

Jordan C

An Amazon Alexa that has a voice like Black Philip from The VVitch and only works when you speak to it in arcane latin incantations.

Hailey Kremenek

The creepiest gift I could receive would be if I got a beautifully wrapped box with a little bow, and inside is a severed finger. On the finger is the most gorgeous 3 carat vintage diamond engagement ring. Slowly, with growing horror, I realize it is my own finger, because of a distinctive scar on my ring finger.

Keegan Pulido

When you visit St. Olaf and a Kaflügenachen gives you a vegan Genügenflürgen cake.

Rez NYC

I asked my Jewish husband “what if you opened a “gift” box and all of the sudden a disembodied voice started speaking and followed you every where you went?” His reply? “You mean like a Dybbuk box?” 😂

Alyssa Epstein

A human leather-bound bible written in blood with your tattoo on the cover. Inscribed in the front is "Love, Bea Arthur".

Amanda Winters

A brain-transplant surgery, but not any brain, I would love Christine's!

Nat Caleti

A private tour to Christine's new home and the possibility to cook a deceptive meal with her in her kitchen and to enjoy it with our captives in her gorgeous dinning room.

Nat Caleti

The creepiest thing I could think of receiving is something I never vocally asked for... the scene in The Little Princess when the two girls wake up to a literal wish come true: a breakfast buffet enjoyed while lounging in luxury robes and slippers, all set in a gorgeously remolded room of bright sun yellow furnishings. The room previously was a dingy cold dark attic and the girls are being punished unduly. Very good book, movie, fantasy and dream creepy gift! To remind myself of the magic in that scene, I made my own velvet, sun yellow pillow covers with blue tassels. Much love and fond thoughts-Hanna

Hanna

A doll that looks like you that has been fashioned with all your old baby teeth, given to you by your older step brother

Cori Espelien

A collection of photos of yourself, taken by a stalker, but these photos date all the way back to the early years of your childhood and up to the present--- with the most recent one being taken the night before you open the box.

Catie Sackman

The creepiest gift I could receive is a Christmas gift from my grandmother... she's been dead for 12 years.

Dakota Crocker

🖤💜 If I lived alone, a present left under the tree that I did not wrap. On the inside a description scratched into the box of my most hidden desire. Who put it there, who has been listening to me while I am home alone, the possibilities are endless.🖤💜

Danielle Gutierrez

We have a family tradition to provide 3 gift choices so that other people may choose from, so mine would be: 1. A time machine device that requires half of my remaining life to function but that would take me to any time I would like to go. 2. A victorian haunted house where I could live in company with some spirits and hopefully my departed loved ones. 3. Animal skeletons that my crush would had collected for me when his patients died (he is a vet).

Nat Caleti

Oh this one is good. Really good. I'm scared and creeped out.

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

I posted in the wrong place! Sorry. In any case, I have lots of political enemies. 2021 might be my year...........

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts A beautiful dark grey marbled cemetery headstone, ornate with angels and gargoyles and it reads: Here lies the body of my enemy, Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts, Born, March 25, 1957. Killed Month:____, Day:_____ Year:2021.

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

OMG, you so funny! This is my favorite!!!

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

My severed head in a box with a frightened expression, I look.in the mirror and my head is gone!

Linda

A mysterious box of ashes, beautifully wrapped. Clearly mortal remains, and clearly addressed to me, but otherwise entirely unidentifiable. Sender unknown.

Vixi Vale

How about a Christmas card left for you that just says "I see you when you're sleeping..."

Madwarlock

An ear. With my missing diamond earring.

Tonya

A weird baby with hooves in a basket on my doorsteps lol

Paulo Samu

My own death certificate

Veronica Diehl

A necklace made of random peoples baby teeth

Melissa Baxter

Anything made by Christine McConnell... the creepiest things I've ever seen (in the best possible way!)

Crow Hollow

Framed photos of myself sleeping, gifted by someone who doesn't live with me.

Jennifer Crumley

Veal.

Erin

A doll that my aunt handmade!

Erica Lynn

the deed and cemetery location of the mausoleum my love is having built for me. 🖤

rebekah kik

My old milk tooth on a necklace. I got that last year from my grandmother

Sarah Marciszko

Guacamole on a half skull.

Heidi Eschedor

Annabelle

Morgan Wanner

A prophecy of my death date, time, and how.

Leah Montes

The creepiest Christmas present I could receive would be a modern gift from a loved one who passed away.

Laura Chambers

An oil painting of a scene labeled “the place you take your last breath “

Abbyanne Postawa

A dybbuk box full of cursed objects and sealed shut with the wax of a blood red candle, with an anonymous card that says "This made me think of you."

Theresa Clay

The creepiest one I *have* received is a two headed taxidermy bird from my boyfriend! I think it would even creepier to get an album of photos from the past of what looks like me or my doppelgänger! 😱

Oddly Weird

Aw I'm sorry, my elderly dog passed a few years ago too. Always takes a bit of time to get used to a close pet passing

Erin Solomon

An exact copy of ones head on a platter.

Yolanda LeBreton

A box full of body parts.

Jan

A Burial plot

Lauren Jiles

A severed penis with a card that says I’ll always be with you from a recently deceased husband/captive☠️

Sara Cunningham

Ancient wooden box with "Pandora" label carved on it. "A present which seems valuable but which in reality is a curse."

Ernesta Kebelyte

A gift card for a funeral

Janice

a funeral service contract.

Zuria

Clown suit and mask with a bloody knife.

Diana Snider Forbes

My missing husband’s teeth with a note that says “it’ll all come back to bite you”

Viktoria Martens

My own head in a box.

Amanda Williams

Spike the gremlin :)

Lisa Eagleton-Muir

Creepiest gift would be......... a Krampus bell or gingerbread man 🤷‍♀️

Alicia McLeod

Any of kind of clown doll!!

Michelle Hall

A Christmas Story Leg lamp, but with a real human leg! Lol

Sara E Briggs

I see a small package under the tree with my name on it. I open the package to find a dvd. I watch the dvd to see that my whole life and everyone else around me is not real. Like the Truman show. It was all fake and set up.

Rebecca Valentine

My own head.

helen crawford

A very formal offer to buy your left eye for a million dollars

LydiaThimble

There's a slim, flat package under the tree, wrapped in festive paper, no card attached. I tear off the paper to reveal a plain manilla folder, my name on the tab. I open the folder. Inside is a copy of my autopsy report... and morgue photos... (suggested by my partner, Scratch)

Mina Murray

Ex-husband girlfriend and divorce papers!

Kimberly Larto

Bracelet made of dead flies.

Michelle Lofthouse

A polaroid of yourself looking at the same polaroid of yourself, looking at a polaroid of yourself, into infinity...

Merilee Phillips

A last unopened gift and no one seems to know where it came from. It has your name on it, and when you open it you find it is a small jewelry box. Inside is a small piece of paper that says "you are going to die in 5 years"

Alena Marchak

The creepiest present to me would be if my gift of a DNA test would have the FBI show up to my house needing to collect more DNA because I came up as a hit in the GEDmatch data base as a possible close relative of a serial killer they are trying to nab! I think my heart would skip a beat and I'd wonder which family member it could be: Grandfather/mother, Parent, Child, Brother/Sister, Aunt/Uncle? I feel for the people not only who lost loved ones to the crimes, but also the people who's reality is now upside down knowing their loved is a monster.

Belle Summer

A gift certificate to one of those fish pedicures where you dunk you feet in a fish tank and they eat off all of the dead skin off your feet! I have a terrible fear of fish and that would send me over the edge! 😬

Whitney Haddad

A life time of christmas mornings on repeat.

Kari Olson

Your own obituary. 🪦

Shelby K

Embalming fluid in a heart shaped bottle and two martini glasses with a card that says "don't wait for me to toast christmas in"

Roada Hawse

Shadow-boxed baby teeth

Blythe

I love this one......omg, very creepy!!!!!!!

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

Omg Colleen!!! This one is good!!!

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

This is really good! Made my day!!!

Judy K. Zamlen-Spotts

I always thought a framed picture of the back of my own head taken from a empty corner of the room with no windows would be a doozy!

Rachel Guy-Whittle

I dont think there is anything in this life that if someone gifted it to you is creepy. Most things are either considered creepy due to the nature or societies perception. Since most people put thought into gift giving it is all about perception of what you recieve when you recieve it and your personal experience. Also everyone has a different idea of what creepy consists of.

Rachel Pop

A beautifully wrapped old timey Christmas record, but when you go to play it, it plays the song jeepers creepers and as it plays it starts to go slower and slower and the music distorts. It plays until it’s so slow that it stops and then all the lights go out.

Annie Skinner

A vial of my lover’s blood to wear it around my neck.

yourgirldolly

A dehydrated cat eye ball wrapped in a cotton ball. Ask me how I know, it’s the creepiest. #disturbing

Stephanie Harris

My own hair, from the drain!!

Charlotte Sandodden

We once got an elf on the shelf in the mail. Not sure who it was from but it was promptly burned.

Emily Rose Coates

My mum would like to add her idea. Boris Johnson and Donald Trump sat under the tree with bows on their heads. My mum has a scary mind 😂

Emily Rose Coates

A creepy present I’d love is a regal jumping spider, despite my past arachnophobia I’d absolutely love to own one. I’d give them lots of treats and bugs to eat. At taxidermy otter would be fun, or an entire bear skeleton. I’d don’t have room for one but I’d still love one. A creepy unpleasant present would be a severed foot in a running shoe. With a bow on it.

Emily Rose Coates

A large neatly wrapped box with only a small note inside reading, "I'm warning you."

sofia herrera

The creepiest thing I could ever receive for Christmas is the souvenir/trophy from my serial killer boyfriend took from his latest victim. This is all hypothetical, of course ;)

colleen quinn

Imagine opening a gift and there is a timer in it with an upsettingly long time on it - a couple of days / months and nothing else. For all this time you will be wondering what is happening when it goes off - and then nothing happens o.O

Julia Karl

Getting a raggedy Ann doll from an unknown sender that turns out to be Annabel . No thank you ! Merry Christmas everyone 🖤🖤

Lili Martinez

Socks

Kaitlyn

legally buy a cadaver chop them into pieces and have it sent separately until you can make you very own Frankenstein

Kaitlyn

A dug up old relative who i hoped I’d never see again

Kaitlyn

An old photo album full of photos that are unmistakably you, but from the 1800s, with a handwritten note in scrawling cursive attached, saying “Come home”.

Lily

Was it also wrapped?!

Lily

A tablet live streaming me opening the gift with loads of other video clips of me just living life the past few months. Maybe have a creepy shadow I wasn’t aware of lurking in the background.

Alisa Jordan

A box of pictures of me sleeping and just generally photographs of me completely unaware I'm being stalked or photographed

V

I know you would probably love this, however my unusual fear is...buttons. Like the gross plastic ones you use to do up clothes or craft a million things from if you're a sicko. I hate them. I refuse to hold them. They make me so angry even talking about them puts me on edge... I'm picturing one of them oldy worldy grandma tins with biscuits on the front. You know, the type you shake excitedly awaiting it's baked innards? But alas!! The thing is full to the brim with bright, shiny, cavity ridden plastic monstrosities. The slow spine chilling horror of submerging your hand into that tin of doom. I'm aware this is most people's idea of a great time, not sure what childhood trauma has led to this. This would creep me out for the rest of my existence but to be honest, would be peak 2020. Have a fantastic Christmas, to you and your family.

Josephine Doyle

A China clown doll, but when i look closer it is actually a China representation of me. Embroidered into the fabric on the ruff is the date of my death. (I blame the hot chocolate I have just devoured for this pretty terrifying image I now have in my head!)

Jerry Moore

An anonymously sent box full of the matching socks that disappeared throughout the years.

Vanessa

A box full of live moths. I've got shivers down my spine just imagining opening the box and having all the moths fly at my face. A lepidopterist's dream is my worst nightmare.

Nicole

A busted up antique clown that whispers my name in the dead of night. Along with vague and ominous warnings. 😐

Julie A

A biography from the future about my life

Louise Smith

I unfortunately had an experience that involved a creepy gift. An acquaintance of mine gifted me a crucifix necklace once, it was gold and beautiful. So, even though I’m not overly religious I was touched. Especially considering we didn’t know each other well, it was very sweet that she would give me something so nice. Come to find out later she had given me the twin of the necklace her father was buried with. I still can’t wear it now that I know.

Gina

A box full of teeth and torn off fingernails.

Thommy Deah

Finding out that Santa Claus actually does exist 🎅🏻☠️

Sophia Z

i would say any severed body part would be horrifying

Stephanie Wolfe

A post mortem photo of me with my whole family but it was done in the 1800's. Same names, same looks, same everything. Just received in the mail from an unknown sender. I love creepy and I'm not sure how I'd react to this. Happy Creepmas everyone 🖤🕷️🖤

Liana Palumbo

A beautifully decorated little box with a full set of your baby teeth. Sent by a complete stranger.

Bibiane Choi

Well I guess if it’s something that I could get would have to be real dead hands that look like they been soaking in water and are all wrinkled and slimmy ( I can’t swim in lakes that have seaweed because that’s what I think of that’s grabbing my legs it really creeps me out!)

Bonnie Coniguliaro

I love this ! My mother opened the poster for me since I am out of country ! absolutely fantastic <3

Amanda LaBrecque

I love creepy things, but one way to really creep me out by sending chills up my spine would be the old classic Ventriloquist dummies. 😱

Paulette Mickle

A doll made in your likeness that every night has it location moved and a new physical ailment added to it.

DarthPackman

Hair.

Dave Taylor

Random body parts

Amy & Willy in Tucson

Who's Soul? Eek 😁

Sky Blu

A doll with hair made from locks of my own...that I didn’t know were taken. 👀

Jennifer Treviño

Reminds me of "Ninety Years Without Slumbering"

Sky Blu

An organ of your spouse who had to have it removed!

Brittany Bedwell

Baby doll parts. That's it... No more, no less. Happy holidays everyone! 🎄

Samantha Neumann

At least he wasn't at epstein's island fornicating with a bunch of minors. Also Trump said he would date his own daughter if they weren't related. That is beyond wrong and creepy in so many ways 🤷

Felicity

A severed head resembling me! With a very fri g.j themed expression! Yikes!

Linda

My wife and I received a small plush stuffed banana in the mail. No explanation. No family members claimed it even as a gag gift. It is a genuinely creepy little banana, but we also kind of love it now.

Adam Byers

A voodoo doll of myself with pins in it (especially in the eyes)

shaani j

Your soul in a very, very, VERY fragile ornament.

Lucia Mascote

An apology from my boss or a gift from a deceased family member.

Eddie Vee

Jonathan, your gift idea truly gave me the heebie-jeebies! Nice work!

Tiffany Hicks

A taxidermized cat (especially if it is hissing).!!!

Debra Palermo

How about a cuckoo clock that goes off every day at the time of your death. You don't know what day it will be, just what time. Shudder.....

Kathleen Mroczko

A red velvet gift sack that looks like its from santa, but turns out to be a hex bag filled with all kinds of creepy stuff.

Kristen Faltysek

The creepiest gift for me would be a taxidermy animal, especially a cat. I can handle bones, but not the skin/fur.

Sarah Beth K

I loath this doll. My mother's sister bought it for her after I kept saying how creepy it was. Lol. She then would get mad when I would comment in how creepy it was. I hid it in the attic at one point.

Kat Bregman

An arachnid ornament that turns out to be alive, builds a beautiful ruby web in the entrance and leaps down to bite any unwanted guests. Or like a hand or something.

Ever Adventuress

The cat I had as a child left a dead mouse under the tree one year. Does that count? Lol She was so proud of herself for catching it! Merry Christmas!

Heather (Fotodeviant)

I would be terrified if I got photos of myself from inside my house

Rebecca Shelton

A death watch beetle

Oaknwichlane June G

Last Christmas my mother-in-law got be a framed piece containing four different hair clippings from four different women (one being a baby) from 1892. It was creepy for everyone else that holiday besides me. I absolutely adore it! It hangs above all my other curiosities.

Jenna Myers

I’ve been wanting to go on a cemetery tour to visit all of my ancestors in the area. I think an awesome yet creepy Christmas gift would be if my girlfriend planned a Christmas eve. cemetery tour and brought along a picnic and some mulled wine.

Lisa Law

A few years back, my wife found me a realistic Marley Door Knocker from A Christmas Carol. He’s very life like and you feel he will open his eyes and give you a cold stare!

Carey Netzloff

Anything from an ex-boyfriend!

Madam Thistle

Some people would probably love this gift, but I'm terrified of crickets, so an antique cricket cage would be pretty creepy for me (I'm also phobic of blood tests, so I wouldn't really enjoy receiving hypodermic needles either)

Leandra

Creepiest present for me would have to be a tie between victorian hair jewelry, and that diorama in the Carnegie Museum of Natural History with the human skull in it. Both are equally unsettling for me.

Emma Burke

I had a dream awhile back that I received a photo of what will eventually kill me but I had no idea when it was going to happen. I woke up sweating with a racing heart! That dream still scares me today so I would say a photo showing you how you were going to die is the creepiest gift you could receive 😟

Hayley

The present that would be real creepy to receive would be a burial plot in a cemetery.

LeRoy Humphrey

Creepiest Christmas gift I could receive... Besides one of my kidneys wrapped in ice when I had gone to sleep the night before with both... I think the creepiest Christmas gift I could receive is one Like the one I plan on leaving when we leave our home. (Sell) I have an old antique baby bassinet basket filled with haunted dolls that I bought on Ebay sitting in the rafters behind the entryway of the top attic/bonus room. I plan on setting up a package to be mailed the following Christmas after they move in. With a homemade journal, and a map. The journal being entries from children the crone witch who used to live there used to keep locked away. Their recounts and ghost stories on how each time one of them disappeared, a new doll appeared and was placed in the basket. The map will lead to various things I have buried in the yard that leads them eventually to the dolls in the rafters. I love creepy gifts. I would find a gift like this spooky in all the best ways. I sure hope the new owners of my home when we decide to move on, like spooky gifts too.

Diane Chattaway

I think I would have to say the unskilfully removed and home embalmed facial skin of your lover who left the house four days ago to get icing sugar, eggs and Lemons, and didn’t return ...

Jonathan Sutherland

The creepiest gift I could receive is getting exactly everything I get for other people. Complete copies of every single gift I buy for others.

Riley Slater

The creepiest gift I could ever receive would be one left at the bottom of my bed in the morning when I live alone

Sandy King

The creepiest present you can receive is a picture of your self sleeping.

Fawn Hutchinson

The creepiest present I've threatened my friend with is a lifelike doll of myself that just shows up on her doorstep one day haha

Nuka-Lola

An anonymous one you weren't expecting. Like a secret Santa but a secret stalker.

Rae

A nights stay in the creepy Oregon Caves Chateau. Not only is it supposedly haunted but there's been a bigfoot sighting there too :)

Barbara Wicks

A charm bracelet of your baby teeth...at least you think they are yours...🦷🦷

Kathryn

A spider ornament. #arachnophobia

Carrie A.

Blanche Dever-eaux-no's "Ho-Ho-Homicide for the Holidays Calendar of V̶i̶c̶t̶i̶m̶s̶ Men".

Stacey Conner

My mother-in-law gave me her veil from her first wedding and said “I hope this brings you better luck.” Years later I found out her first husband died tragically. The veil remains in its original box tucked away in the attic.

Amanda Clary

A gift of seeing your own death.

Taylor Makenzie

Not the creepiest but definitely the weirdest present that I actually received was gift wrap. Yes I was gifted - gift wrap. I’m surprised the universe didn’t implode

Kristen Duke

A video of you committing horrific murders that you do not remember doing because you have a split personality who is a serial killer

Athena Pennington

I'd have to say a nice, hard covered book -- but when you open it, the print inside is a transcription of your secret diary that you'd lost years and several changes of address ago; and there's no sender's name or address on the label.

Jessa

Creepiest Christmas gift would be from an unknown sender of a doll that is dressed like you and has a piece of your hair attached.

Jessica Noel

My brother has requested that when he dies his actual skull be bronzed and given to a member of the family as a gift. So far I'm the only one in the family to not say NO!

Lady Barronmore

A beautifully wrapped box with a face-hugger inside. Surprise.

Aunt Debbie Halloween

a Dybbuk box? A picture of me as a child at my bday party with John Wayne Gacy making balloon critters? Oh this could get very dark quick LOL

Michelle Ford-Copley

The creepiest Christmas gift would be a glass ornament with a pair of eyes that resemble my dead grandmother’s. I loved her dearly, but If I kept it displayed somewhere it would always feel like she’s watching me. That is creepy.

Christine Brown

A purge mask with a “Happy 2021” note attached to it

Genevieve Fernety

Photographs of me and my children taken without my knowledge

Heather

A "Feliz Navidad" phone call from my grandmother who passed away 10 years ago. It would be creepy but oh so welcome ❤🎄

Lulu Luna

A box with nothing but a set of spare keys to your home.🙈

Maya Maldonado

A portrait of Joe Biden sniffing kids would be pretty creepy.

Tracy

The creepiest Christmas present I could receive would be The Arachnid Ornament from your last episode! 🕷🕸🕷

Anthony guzman

If a friend watched one of your craft videos and made a tiny coffin box for my cat...who’s still alive. I would love the art but feel very creeped out.

Vi

One of the nails that was used to crucify Christ.

B T

A photo of you and your loved ones opening presents by the tree at that exact moment that just appeared under your tree overnight with a card that simply reads “He knows when you’re awake...”

Louise Hartley

My first cat’s bones. He passed away in 2010.

Cecilia

This needs to be a screenplay!!!! Write the rest of the story!

Aunt Debbie Halloween

The Ark of the Covenant

Lynne Esquivel

A meal of human flesh

T Chan

The cat from ‘Pet Sematary’ 🙀

Dharma

A bloody tooth, with a note that says, "Now we're even."

Lynne Esquivel

A fork from Rose

Whitney lenox

❤️merry Christmas

Selene Precisi

💕

Sky Blu

The creepiest Christmas present I could receive would be the gift of Krampus all you naughty adults can't fit in Krampus bag so he will have to cut you down to size muahahaha... I better mind my P's and Q's 😈🕸🕷

Sky Blu

Covid coated bed bugs from Rudy Giuliani

Genevieve Fernety

An all expenses paid trip to spend the night, B&B style, on the grounds of the The Covenanters' Prison which is accessible via Greyfriars Kirkyard in Scotland. It is by far the creepiest place I've ever set foot on and I've set foot on any I could foot on! I love the creepy and macabre but I would still have a hard time crossing under the connecting archway again but as a gift, how do you say no?!

Melissa Plunkett

One of Ted Bundy's old letters

Tabatha Redar

An empty box (that actually contains a ghost)

Madeline Hayman

This is brilliant 🤣

Clara Vratsanos

Body parts with a love note!!!

Suzanna Dunn

My Mom has one like that in the hall across from the guest room...

Aunt Debbie Halloween

A letter posted from the haunted house of my childhood. The disturbed boy who died in the house is hosting a reunion. You are all invited. Remember to run up the basement stairs after turning out the light. You can lock yourself in any of the walk-in closets, if things get out of hand. Death masks are optional.

Tiffany Hicks

My grandmother's recipes in her hand writting, she passed away in 2003 and she NEVER wrote her recipes, and no one knows them, so it'll be creepy to receive them now; but also magical.

Lissette

Jack Nicholson's eyebrows. Not because of what they are...but because I shudder to think of what he'd look like without them. They make up 90% of his amazing face.

Diana Vega

A gift wrap box filled with framed photos of my nightmares and my horrible cousin laughing at me with her mouth full of chocolate. She will find my misery joyful. 😖

Samantha Varela

a gorgeous gift basket but instead of lotions and soap beautifully wrapped severed body pieces of your stalker with a note that's says from your #1 admirer in very creepy writing and receiving it right after moving to a new town

Lillian Carabajal

We live on a farm. Just this morning, the wind last night blew the chicken and duck coup into our neighbors yard and a predator attacked our ducks. Chickens are still missing. The ducks bodies were strewn across our pasture, a complete massacre. Merry Christmas to us???

Delaney Drake

An animatronic male gorilla skull, that talked. It would say it’s name is Ndume, a male gorilla I use to take care of, and repeatedly ask why I left him, and what do I expect to happen to me now.

Drea

The dead mouse my dog just brought me. Ewww

Nancy Conner

A miniature doll clone of myself in a coffin dated in the near future.

Lynn

That would be my husbands original cornea in a jar. His new cornea is from a man who jumped out of an airplane, and his chute didn’t open. I always feel like a strange man is watching me undress. I have this weird fantasy that the old cornea comes back to claim his woman. Very Sexy. Lol.

Ellen Mattesi

An album of photos you feature in but didn't know were happening.... from a stranger.

Branwen Frost

A box of live moths *shudder*

Amanda Phoenix

All the ghosts of my xmas past coming to christmas dinner and telling me stories of what has been, what is happening and what is to come in my life.

Rebecca wiesniak

A staticky call from my grandma who passed away earlier this year and told us that she was seeing men in dark suits with small, round black eyes staring down at her in bed. If she called and said “they got me” I think I’d just about nope my way off this plane of existence.

LisbetFae

Absolute creepiest gift for me would be a box of photos or items I don't recognize, until I -very slowly, and only with the help of others- realize they're pictures and memories I had forgotten.

Catalina Quintero

A whole set of pictures of myself, some personal items i thought i lost, but where taken day by day from a stalker that is still hunting me and a human heart. All wrapped in a gorgeus christmas box.

Rex AM

A positive pregnancy test lol

Dana Lielyn

A personalized tombstone dated for December 26

Kelly Phillips

Henrietta and Merna singing Go Tell It On The Mountain at my front door... (If you don't get the reference, type Henrietta & Merna can't sing into YouTube. It's something).

Tadgh Kirby

A musical box that seems to start playing by itself at random times in the middle of the night.

Suzana S.

A doll of yourself made out of your own hair that someone has been secretly stealing from you in your sleep.

Alicia Harrington

A video montage of footage from hidden cameras in my home - hidden and recorded by someone unknown and I can never find the cameras.

Sarah Priestley

A doll, which looks like me and is made of my hair. It would be even creepier if the present would lie on my porch without any note. I think I would never sleep again 😱

Nathalie Riegler

A set of giant multi-wicked candles to hide the smell of the bodies in my basement! 🎁🎄

GreeneQueen2

A taxidermied pet that looks eerily similar to your own pet that you had cremated a year prior

Jewish Snail

<3 my creative friend but definitely one of these furbies https://www.instagram.com/p/CIJs5ZjFZGP/

Sarah

Receiving a box of photographs that when you start to look through them, they appear to be of a 1980's satanic ritual. There are people in creepy animal masks performing the rite. Then you see a photo of yourself as a child at the ritual.........

Alyssa Bailey-Broom

A framed photo of you dead at your own doorstep holding the very photo you just received.

Tiffy Pan

A dollhouse recreation of my childhood home with a doll scene in every room of my mother killing my five year old self in multiple ways. Wrapped in a Christmas bow.

Diana Sandrick

An unexpected printout by someone who hacked my WIFI-connected printer that read, "Merry Christmas. We know where you live."

Sarah

A severed head would be at the top of the list. "What's in the booooox?"

Yvonne Villalobos

A beautiful carved box full of eyelids and a note saying “we all see you”.

Emina Ibrahimovic

A pet I owned, mounted so they were some functional piece or furniture. That would be creepy to me and rude to the pet.

Lauren M

One that I could possibly receive is a framed spider but that’s not too creepy, depending on the spider. The creepiest thing for me is a doll or marionette and I hope no one ever gives me one!

Linda Constantinescu

A tree that i plant which comes alive at night roaming the grounds in the dark and doesn't seem to like me.

Katherine

Wow.... I feel so blessed. The 27th is my birthday and usually its a pretty crummy time to have a birthday, but now I have something to look forward to!!!

Elmari Jankowitz

As a HUGE fan of the macabre, unusual and everything Halloween, the creepiest thing I could receive would be a Victorian era casket with the glass viewing window complete with female skeleton wearing a Victorian gown.

Tammy Warner

Body parts with a love note (shiver)

Suzanna Dunn

A Christmas gift from my in laws to thank me for the Christmas gifts I got them this year. I bought them each their own beautiful wood urn for their ashes. They’ve been in the same plastic case inside a cardboard box since we’ve received their cremains. (More than a couple years now)

Lacie Fazio

Receiving an intricately carved cherry wood music box that when you open the lid, a large taxidermy rat in a tutu pops up and dances to a tinkling rendition of Avalanche by Leonard Cohen :D

Chelsea V.

A jar of completely intact toenails

Heather

Locks of my hair when I haven't cut my hair in years and my childhood teeth. Accompanied by a note that says, "I've saved these for you." from anonymous.

Bay Mehl

A Primark gift card XD

TikTokia

An old, rusted ring I purposely threw into the Atlantic Ocean

Jessica Luegering

Creepiest Christmas gift that I can think of is someone whispering sweetly into my ear, “Honey, I have something to tell you; the test was positive”

Lara Dean

A dybbuk box..

Vanessa Jaramillo

Anything someone buys me just because it was on sale! UGGGGG

kimberly Flanary Starr

I have that in my top drawer😂 my daughter’s teeth collected by the tooth fairy and curls from her first hair cut.

Lacie Fazio

A collage of candid photos of myself when I thought I was alone.

Crystal Castle-A'neals

Sexy pyjamas from the mother in law, Or honestly, a spider ornament lol

Jess Guihot

Raw meat

Tara Turner

Oh My lanta I don’t have a chance in hell to win one of those ornaments with all these creepy gifts and stories wow my life is way to traditional hahaha

Bonnie Coniguliaro

Dry aged placenta jerky

Erin

A photo of me in the shower taken from outside the window gifted with trinkets from around the house and a note attached saying, "I see you when you're sleeping, I see you when you wake....".

Andrea Moore

A box of 365 notes that described what I wore and how I looked every day for the past year from a “secret admirer”

Rebecca Lailer

A family photo from my childhood that I’m not in (despite memories of the photo being taken). Come to find out, I never actually existed. 😳

Ashley Jones

Being gifted heirloom earrings with the relatives head attached! :)

Sufani Garza

A copy of my own death certificate

Maggie Jordan

One of my pets that passed and has been taxidermied

Stacy Houston

Gift certificate for the local mortuary.

Brenda Hunt

A Raggedy Ann doll

Louise Lundh

A hand crafted leather wallet from Ed Gein!

Carlos Ponce

A set of real, articulated reindeer skeletons and a sleigh for my Jack Skellington display in my front yard.

Tara Soucy

A very beautiful wrapped big box filled with hair clippings.

Zayda Gonzalez

My own hair and nail clippings gifted to me by a scorned lover.

Rachele Russello

An eclipse of moths that group to make a fluttering portrait of E.T.’s face with a horse body. I said what I said. 🤣🙈

Spooky Phantasma

I think the creepiest gift would be a journal from HH Homes, it would be a journal of how he Tortured and killed his victims accompanied with pictures of the crimes he committed with his most prized possession from his victims.

Melissa

A beautiful gold ornate mirror from an auction that shows you how you look as a decaying corpse. Skin disintegrating, maggots eating one of your eyes, and all that fun stuff. Might make me decide to get cremated after all.

Kathleen palmer

Krampus’ long creepy tongue!

Geneva

It would be terrifying to receive a set of Victorian gloves, from an estate, that are dyed a beautiful vibrant green color. As you wear the beautiful gloves in the snowy weather to holiday parties and caroling, you begin to noticed that your hands are sweating and the room is slowly becoming brighter. You are feeling nauseous and your hands start to hurt. Before you slip into unconsciousness, you admire your beautiful green gloves. Later the coroner tells your loved ones that the antique glove you received from your great aunt were dyed with "arsenic green" and it slowly leached into your skin. They would have returned the gloves to your family, but they seem to have disappeared from the morgue. Merry Christmas!

Anna Mallory

A vintage embalming kit complete with syringes and a trocar..... including a nosy neighbor to try it on.

Rigoberto Ramirez

A set of headhunter's knives.

Nicole Mason-Martin

A gift certificate with seats and a backstage pass to the circus with a clown tour guide.

Melisa Miller

A furby that moves around at night while you're sleeping.

Toni Scarlett

My Mom loved to donate to different animal missions. So one year for Christmas she donated to a Wolf Foundation in my name, They sent a bracelet made of wolf hair as a thank you Christmas gift from my Mom. I put it on and wore it while she was here but I couldn't get that thing off fast enough after she left. Totally creeped me out and was also very scratchy. I didn't realize wolf hair was so coarse. My Mom was always looking for strange and unusual gifts for me. I love all things Victorian/Edwardian and, I guess, in her mind that meant creepy things because they did things like necklaces with fancy works of art made from the hair of a dead person.

Jayme Gaines

A box of dead roses and dead fake snakes wrapped around them with a red ribbon .

Nicole Clem

A taxidermied elf, or a bloody Santa suit with some reindeer teeth in the pocket.

Amy Sewell

Mine was modeled after Tim Curry. I'm no Christine McConnell though. 😄

Tracy Gralton

A book of what will happen the rest of your life.

Megan Gay

A porcelain doll with its eyes scratched out

Micah

A package with no note, containing an album with social media pictures of me with my face missing in all of them...

Simón J.

Those vintage Victorian dolls 😳 My grandmother would get me one every year on Christmas, and they collected high up in my closet. They all fell one night and the way they fell, must’ve pulled down my closet door handle where when I woke they were fallen with the closet door open. Begged my mother to get rid of them after that!

Stephanie Fuchs

A new set of eyes delivered by The Creeper 🎁🎄👀

Casey

An engagement ring made from the clavicle of an ex-lover. 💍

Beth DePietropolo

A hex bag, bones from a deceased relative, or a taxidermy pet that has died recently. 😬

Kaitlyn Lachance

Ok, now we’re just listing things I would want 🎉

Christine McConnell

A sewing machine from Buffalo Bill or a cookbook from Hannibal Lector.

Sara E Briggs

To have all 48 Barbies from my childhood that washed out into the gulf with my home during Hurricane Katrina. With all things we recovered after the storm, we never found so much as a leg 🦵🏻 Merry Christmas 🎄🎁

Courtney McCanlis

As an artist I think the creepiest one I could receive is a self portrait of the sender...in the nude!

Angela Bell @angbellart

Ummmm... I would watch this movie!! ☠️

Christine McConnell

This one is SO dark 😂😂🥺

Christine McConnell

Day of the week underwear from my uncle Ted.

Cookie Connoisseur

An encyclopedia of death, every book bound in the skin of your loved ones, furry and human, except the one baring the first letter of your name.

Katie Brunero

i wake up to a note, my boyfriend nowhere to be found. “merry christmas, come to the closet for a surprise,” the note reads. confused and groggy, i wander over and open the door. i hear rustling amongst the rows of clothes in front of me. a smile begins to form on my face, assuming my boyfriend is going to jump out and try to scare me. his hands emerge from between the clothes, holding a small box, perfectly wrapped. i start to laugh, telling him to come out. just as i reach for the box, i hear my boyfriend’s voice from downstairs.

Maddy Fox

A box infected with COVID-19 ☠️

Heather Anderson

A hand embroidered prediction of my own death.

Christine McClain

A monogrammed body bag.

Ethyl O

Mine went out with our house during Katrina. I would love to see her again, I modeled after Angelina Jolie 🖤

Courtney McCanlis

A bag full of miscellaneous hair, fingernail clippings and teeth.

Heather Collins

The ring we buried my grandmother with. 💍

Keir Rice

A ghostly visit from my late Grandmother wishing my little family a Merry Christmas. Creepy, yes, but to feel a connection with her again would be a gift nonetheless.

Ryan the GM

a candle with a note that says the candle will light up one day, and that if it burns out, your life burns out as well.

Famke Hagedoorn

My own head. 😬

Thatgirl

Something like in a the movie Seven! “What’s in the box?!”

Rachel Marts

A piece of junk from a yard sale with the thought that it was something I actually wanted and liked. I had this happen from my wife’s grandmother who sold a lot of things she thought were antiques most of which should have been on the way to the dump. It was something that didn’t even make sense given it was some piece that went to something else like the disks to the old records or a vhs head cleaner when I have neither. It was kind of creepy because I had to act like it was something great, while not understanding the logic behind it.

Kevin Brodie

The head of Ted Bundy as a Christmas tree topper

Stephanie Ervin

Mother-in-law gifting baby teeth... as a “sweet” gesture 😐

Jenny Vasquez

Joe Biden

Tracy

This small, peculiar gift appeared as if by magic under the tree, after Christmas had wrapped and company had left me on my own, just before the stroke of midnight. I picked it up, unsure yet curious of where it came from, and carefully untied the satin black ribbon and peeled back the matching paper to reveal a small wooden box with an eye carved into the top. The box appeared to be beautiful, familiar even. Upon opening the box, I saw a brass key, ornamental in design, sitting atop a blood red cushion, with no lock to open. "Is that it? Did someone leave this behind by mistake? Surely this key must have meaning for somebody else." Then it hit me. I recognized the eye that was carved into the box. I had seen it before when rifling through the old belongings of my new home's former residents, carved atop a chest, and tucked away in a dusty corner of the manor's carriage house. I threw on my jacket and boots, and hurriedly braved the gusts of wind as I crunched across the snow to the entrance of the carriage house. The door creaked open as I entered and quickly slammed shut behind me. I reached for a match and lit an old oil lantern, casting its amber light across the room as shadows danced in the corners and branches rapped against the window from outside. "Ah, here it is." I brushed away the cobwebs and pulled a heavy, worn, wooden chest from the corner of the room. The eye carved into the top matched that of my mysterious gift exactly. I shoved my hand into my pocket and withdrew the brass key, pushing it into the lock, and turning it with a trepedatious fervor. Click. The key had worked. I lifted the lid of the chest and held the lamp over its contents as the musty scent of mildew washed over me. Photos. The chest was filled with photos, old ones, tattered and stained at the edges, all stacked neatly as if being presented to me. I began flipping through them. They appeared to have been taken on this property, old owners perhaps. Groups of people working; families dressing up in garb of another lifetime and posed together; candid shots of life around the house. Then I realized something. I pulled the light closer and felt my breath leave me as stillness filled the room. This was me. These pictures were of me. I grabbed another fistful of photos from the chest and scattered them across the cold floor. My hands shaking, I inspected them and confirmed my thoughts. An old sepia photo of me in the yard wearing clothes I don't own; an even older grayish-blue photo of me holding up a child I don't recognize; a candid shot of me under a tree in the backyard cemetery which still stands today. "How could this be possible? These photos appear to span across multiple generations." All I could hear was my heavy breathing against my pounding heart. I looked closer and began to notice another similarity across the scattered photos, a haunting pattern. I was the only person who was staring at the camera. No, staring through the camera, back at me. In every one. I withdrew stack after stack from the chest, only further confirming my horror. Groups of strangers, families, and children all seemingly unaware of any photo being taken, but my face contined to glare back at me, almost scowling, in every shot. Something about my expression seemed so unnatural. I sat there through the night, unbothered by my body turning cold, fueled by my need to understand as I flipped through every photo and back again. It wasn't until the sun began to rise that I packed everything back into the chest, lifted it into my arms, and scurried back into my home. I didn't have all of the answers yet, but one thing was for certain: this was the creepiest Christmas present I could have ever received.

Johnny M

I suddenly hear creepy music playing in the middle of the night, i search the house and I find an old wooden music box, I open it and inside I see a strand of my hair and a note that says " hello" Merry creepy Christmas everyone!

Ioanna

A furby. The accompanying card gives instructions not to get it wet or feed it after midnight.

Denise Osborne

I always thought the idea of memorial jewelry to be both creepy and touching. I lost my best cat friend and familiar last year just before Christmas. A memorial pendant that could hold some of his ashes or a lock of his fur would be both creepy, and very sentimental to me.

Arazia

It would be pretty creepy to open a package on Christmas morning only to discover photos from your own funeral on some vague future date.

Heather Morrison

A package in the mail with a caligraphied note from Christine saying "See you soon..." and an elaborate First Aid kit with tourniquets, rolls of gauze, suture sets, etc. 😱

Hope Ohana

A live, pet tarantula... (although, I've been watching tarantula/spider-enthusiasts on YT to help me with this phobia!). Merry Christmas!

Nan

A tombstone carved with my name and predetermined date of death.

Howard Becker

Fruitcake made by Fruitcakes, Happy Holidays from the neighborhood asylum

Kennedy

A new food bowl for my kitty Hannibal that passed away a few years ago, because I can still hear him run down the stairs when I open a can of tuna.

Alyce

A elf on a shelf😱

Lilly

A wicked sparkling green or red festive Arachnid!

Amber Noseworthy

A doll that looked a lot like me gave me the creeps.

Kris

A lobotomy kit!!

Liz Vera

A box full of pictures of me and my family taken by someone watching us.

Alicia

Photos of someone (or something) watching you sleep at night

Katie Spearin

A stuffed version of my yorkie who passed away in June. Just an oddity I'm gifted from an estate sale down the street. Except each night I can swear that pieces of him were feeling more real.. and the strange noises start soon after. On the 13th night, a loud bang is heard and I rush to the source. Behold, my yorkie Gizmo is alive! Turned out the estate owner was a witch. She had seen my grief and cast a spell where my tears could resurrect my soulmate. The toy had the corpse of my yorkie she had sewn inside it. Each time I cried over it.. the body became more alive. There is still some stuffing and thread attached to him but I love him nonetheless ♡

Heather Brown

The ring my great grandmother was buried with

Nikki Vasquez

A real heart (is it human? pig?) that's been covered in glitter and turned into a Christmas tree ornament and the Christimas card says "Home is Where the Heart is..."

Zachary M

A body part in a jar!

Sarah

A box filled with wriggling centipedes! Yuck!!

Genevieve (pirateystripes)

A re-gifted swamp scented earwax candle from your father in law

Stephanie Beard

A vintage item that turns out to be super haunted

Lauren M

Good question. I've worked in the funeral business as a cosmetologist so dead and unsightly things don't creep me out. I would have to say a day at the carnival with clowns would creep me out.

Cat Cordova

A box of photographs capturing my life sent from an anonymous stalker. YIKES

Lesley Allen

One of your spider ornaments.

Annie Kendig

The clay head I made in mortuary school

Tracy Gralton

I love that the red silk ribbon is the only non thematical thing here. You'd think the giftee would stay on brand and tie the box with human veins 😆 the pillow is made from a kidney and stuffed with hair and included is photographs of the humans whence everything came.... augh

Laura Griffin

body parts definitely

Molly Higgs

The creepiest present I could get would be a polaroid of my family sleeping surrounded by apparitions.

Kathleen Shannon

A velvet jewelry box with an all - black eyeball in it, that watches as you move

Jess Tracey-Beck

A big box of over worn dirty dentures 😕 for some reason the pink parts or them creep me right out. Now imagine parts worn down from grinding. Deep set stains. The undersides you see old goo, dried blood and puss from ulcers related poor fittings .. then there's the odor of the collaboration resting in a cardboard box...

Angela Pearson

I'd think some kind of preserved body part from the gifter!

Davin Boggess

Deer steaks

Mrs. Yliana Chaleff

Receiving a video of Unsolved Mysteries and while watching it, realize it's about my own murder with my friends and family being interviewed.

Christy Ercole

An old fashion creepy doll in a suit, top hat, ND monacle with a note that says from Santa. Except everyone swears up and down they didn't buy you the doll...

Michael McGinnis

A photo album of when I was little. In every photo is an image of an unknown spirit standing next to me.

Gail J Marmet

A Roller Derby outfit.

Alexandria Faith

We gave my brother-in-law an old theatre seat from a movie theatre that is haunted by it’s previous owner: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-production-company-films-paranormal-activity-interior-1.5252789

Pauline Potocky

Clown doll. *shudder*

Barbara Campbell

The creepiest present would be Surprise! It's going to be 2020 again!!

Allison

Bag of human teeth

Marie Kirby

A dybbuk box

Claire Fern-Smith

Your own death certificate ⚰️ 🎁

Jessica Pray

An accordion!

Gina Mustico

A newspaper clipping of my own obituary

Brandon Grew

My mother’s ashes encased in Victorian mourning jewelry.....

Karmell Mazurek

I think a collection/scrapbook of observations, photographs and odds and ends all about me from an unknown person. Almost as if they had been secretly watching me and cataloging what I did. Then sending it to me like a twisted Christmas love story..

Jennifer Edwards

a small unmarked box of children's teeth and a few strands of hair, could be from an animal.

Marie Nemirovsky

A jigsaw puzzle of family pictures with a stranger photoshopped into them, replacing my husband.

Hillary A Mills

A pair of mittens sewn with bits of my hair collected over the years

Brooke

Receiving a 2 lb bag of hair and nail clippings from an unknown source! 😱

Dianna Roberts

A live cordyceps mushroom that humans are susceptible to.

Tessa Breedlove

Anything from the back of a beige ‘68 Volkswagen Beetle...

Taylor Lockhart-Lang

A photo album from a stranger with a photo a day of the view of your living room from the lawn.

Christine Phillips

To find a Christmas present under the tree that is purrring.. Its the cutest fluffy blue eyed kitten wearing a old ratty collar covered in dirt with a name tag "max".....also in the box you find a photo of you when you were 8 holding a similiar cat sporting same collar that just happens to have the same name.....

Shirley

A snow globe which looks normal in the daylight, but at night time half-formed figures can be seen clawing at the glass. On the base of the snowglobe is a name... Krampus

Rebecca Fitzjohn

When my Cat, Shadow passes away, I've always wanted someone to make her into a rug for me with her head still attached like they do with bears.

Michelle Mills

A severed head in a box with a pretty bow would be pretty creepy

Erik R.

An ornately decorated hand thrown urn for YOUR ashes, but not your husband's.

Michelle Greenhouse

A picture of yourself that looks slightly wrong but you're the only one who notices and that was send by someone you loved, who died. Or a piece of jewelry you're wearing but with blood on it. Both are identical down to the scuff marks

Collira

Merry Christmas to you and yours, Christine. And thank you for the joy your artistic talents bring me.

Lynn

Creepy present would be: A handwritten letter, dated this year, from my dad. He died in 2004.

Peggy Christie

I’m going to have to go with Immaculate Conception. 😬🥴

Katherine Young

An unmarked Christmas card with only a future date and time written in it.

Jared A

From an anonymous gifter, a book detailing all possible paths humanity's history could take, including then dark ones, all the way up to the end of the world.

Rebekah Essick

OMG. That’s terrifying,

Peggy Christie

Picking up a box that is slightly wet on the underside and then opening it to find one of my tattoos in the box then I check my body where that tattoo should be to see a huge section of skin missing and I’m bleeding and not understanding how that happened and how I didn’t know about it. And then the mind games begin.

Melissa Rith

Your two front teeth in a music box with the song "all I want for Christmas is my two front teeth" playing.

Angie Loyd

Probably a doll that looks like me!

Lauren Mandelke

Oh I think it would have to be the very specific thing I've always wanted but never told anyone that no one would ever happen to guess I wanted. Like how did that person know?!

Nina Lueras

A set of dangling dollhead earrings in which the dollheads looks like the gift receiver with the eyes missing.

Heather Cherry-Roberts

My husband taxidermied!

Jessica

Favorite so far!!

Jade

Felicity

The mounted bones of my sons pet cat.

Cathy Fontaine

I once received a used vibrator from a stalker...

Morticia Kensington

The worst/creepiest present is no present 😂 even if a present is something gross (or if it’s just something I don’t want) at least someone was thinking of me I guess??? And as long as a gift is wrapped nicely, I don’t really care what’s inside because I just love opening packages- if someone took the time to wrap an empty box- then that’s creepy 😭

Haley Roth

A gift box containing old family photos, but as you look through them you notice a sepia colored photo of your great grandmother as a baby, and the man holding her is your husband, and he looks exactly the same as he does right now.

Kristina

A diorama of myself and family doing exactly what we are doing at that moment with an ominous figure lurking and watching....

Melissa

There is a gift with my name on the tag but not who it's from, and when opened it's a hand painted canvas. And the scene is exactly me, holding this painting, all the details correct down to what I'm wearing, who is around, what they are doing and everything in the room as it is in that moment. But at the painted window lurks a deathly figure through the open curtains... when I look up at my window, the curtains are closed. Shall I open them or do I not dare...

Gingerpuffs

For me the creepiest Christmas present I could receive is the true identity of Jack the Ripper and letters or evidence proving it, showing he was somehow related to me.

Vanessa Garcia

The creepiest gift I could receive would be a lovely pair of pearl earrings, shaped and polished from the teeth of dearly departed. They lay atop a red velvet hair stuffed pillow. Inside a human flesh leather box. Tied neatly with a red silk ribbon.

Heather Turner

The keys to Buffalo Bill’s house from Silence of the Lambs! https://www.housebeautiful.com/design-inspiration/a34302878/buffalo-bill-silence-of-the-lambs-house-for-sale/

Lauren Statts

My Mom had gifted me with a bright orange sweater vest that she crocheted herself and made me wear it to middle school.

Cherie Wheeler

My own severed head portrait in wax.

Deborah Paulsen

Your doppelganger in a large box with a note saying 'If you would like to trade places, please get in the box and close the flap'

Sam Richards

A small box probably meant for a gift card with a simple note inside that says "I took care of them. You're welcome."

Steve Jenks

A friend gave me a antique fashion dolly called, "Hannah's Unfortunate Sleighride Accident". She was dressed for outdoor frolics in a velvet coat and black boots, and her porcelain head was fractured and oozing blood. But she still smiled so prettily!!

Michelle Heather Cohen

The head of my dead husband, in a beautifully giftwrapped box with a bow around it

Lajla

I got a picture collage of myself from a guy I had talked to in a forum online( we only talked once) It looked like he had hunted down a variety of my social media things to get all the photos and then edited them together to make a collage. It wouldn’t have been that creepy if we were friends and he had access to the photos without much effort. But the time and energy put in to it for a person you’ve only talked to once was super creepy.

Steph Cummins

An old and tattered envelope, sealed, containing a card with nothing written but my name and a single future date. Not too soon, but not too far off into the future so that the anticipation builds to a maddening crescendo as that moment finally comes...

Rachel Kilgore

A container of Danish Shortbread cookies that had actual shortbread cookies in them I stead of sewing supplies!

Michelle Heather Cohen

The gift of knowledge or premonition of how you'll die-but not when...that would be quite unpleasant with a side of fear and unease haha!

Angela Coppola

A video of my family and I opening presents that night from a point of view I’m not familiar w/. And a tag that says “You better watch out, You better not cry. Better not pout I’m tellin’ you why. Santa Claus is coming to town”.

Marina salinas

I got a very creepy porcelain doll that had my face on it but was dressed in Victorian era clothing 😬. I swear the thing moved when we weren’t looking

Alexandria

One of those antique owl clocks with eyes that move back and forth, only with human looking eyes or goat eyes.

Mandy Ramsdell

My grandma gave me a damn-it doll when I was ten. It was made from cat hair. 😐

Jennifer Patino

Hearing a cat meow at the window in the dead of night and going outside to pet it, only to see Barnabas from the 60's Dark Shadows series as a vampire instead

Erin Solomon

My sister gave me a Christmas doll that looks like chuckie omg I love it but my daughter and niece hate it. One year I woke up Christmas morning and my daughter tied a butcher knife to it’s hand and put it on my nightstand. This year it sits in a high chair with knives on the tray. Ugh my daughter is really a jokester! The doll appears In photos once in awhile that I send to my niece and she is like “really aunt Bonnie the creepy Christmas doll in the background “ lol I I never even realized it. Such fun I have with her I think she is adorable but she does look like chuckie

Bonnie Coniguliaro

A hair doll made from my hair they've collected

Summer Rose Barnes

a full size version of the Tall man from Phantasm.

sophia king

A package with photos of my family in our home, like stalker photos from someone anonymous. *shudder*

Hannah Chen

a tiny diorama of a christmas eve scene.. with real taxidermied mice children spying on santa mouse eating his milk and cheese cookies after putting their presents under the tree 🎄🐭🎁

Tammy Huth

I'm working on my family tree, but I live several hours away from where generations of my family have lived. So my living family has promised to send me pictures of grave markers and pictures of my dead relatives. That is the creepiest and best present I could ever receive.

Callie 1000

the creepiest gift I could receive.... hmm!! an eerily accurate voodoo doll of me, with actual locks of my hair used to make, mini pieces of articles of clothing that I actually have, with the eyes x'ed out and in pins stuck all over the body. I weirdly also love this idea tho? does that make me creepy?

Cassdog

A box of my own underwear...👀

Uzannesay

A plain brown envelope is inside our mailbox addressed to my maiden name. It contains a prepaid cremation document.

Terrie Mcgill

A life insurance policy! How many episodes have we seen on the crime TV channel when the spouse takes out a policy because they "care"‽! I would look at this gift as my ticket to the grave! ⚰☠

Dawn Galusha

During my freshman year of college in 1979 I had my jewelry stolen including a charm bracelet (the kind where you collect the charms—many are no longer available). It would be creepy if the same bracelet turned up as a wrapped present under my tree.

Kathy Ann

My mom made a homemade mop doll with my face as a four year old printed on it. I hide it in places for my fiancé and stepson to scare them regularly. Happy to share pictures!

Becca Van Tassel

A Greenbay Packer jersey, when I'm a diehard Bear's fan...

Paul and Lynne

A clown toy with a pull string. If its eyes move or blink I may have to toss it in the fireplace.

Toi Thomas

A box of toenail clippings that the giver is oddly proud of.

Kelly Lucero

A taxidermy of a human foot and a nail polish gift set kit.

Ian Holmes

An album of pictures taken of you through the window of your house, across the street and around the corner with a note saying “can’t wait to watch you next year too”

Bryony

OMG I want one of them. They are so beautiful 😍

Gaëlle Saunier

A meaningful tattoo cut off of a special someone's skin and framed behind glass

Paulina K

The creepiest gift I could receive is my grandfather knocking on our door. He died two years ago and his ashes sit in a Paw Patrol bag in my dad's closet.

Jasmine

Creepiest gift: coupon for one free Massage from your dentist. True story. Beat creepiest gift: red fighting spider ornament. True story.

Kittypants

Your own head! 😱 *Twilight Zone moment*

Tess Llanos

There was a little girl I used to teach swimming lessons to and she always gave me a "present" when I arrived. The present would be dead dragonflies or butterflies because they reminded her of me....Still not sure how to take that.

Amanda Hornick

Someone you just met gives you a photo album full of candid photos of yourself, dating back many years.

Lulu Hall

A pair of necropants!

Heidi Miller

🎄👻Happy 𝗦𝗽𝗼𝗼𝗸𝘆 Christmas Everyone! The creepiest present 🎁 I could receive is my ex coming back in my life. Wait, no that’s too creepy! I would say a polaroid book of pictures of me leading to my ultimate death.💀

Lex

I did receive it.. a rotting deer head that stares at me every morning when I look out my window. I collect bones and hubby works in the woods and found this one decomposing and thought of me 🖤

Amaren

An invite to stay the night in a very old haunted hospital. Part of that invite includes having to sleep in the morgue.

Krista Scholl

A custom made lamp shade, courtesy of Ed Gein!

Amelia Ibberson

A used, old, dug up coffin with a mysterious resident inside, police sirens outside and a firm knock on the door.

Kristina Hinojosa

Creepy gross - Fingernail clippings. Creepy good - A spider ornament! 😏

Sonja Tompkins

A new set of meat cleavers.... How did you know mine are were worn out...

Dawn Hargy-Louden

Winner!

Lisa Skibenes

Pictures of yourself taken without your knowledge....

Kimberly Hope

A Tickle me Elmo of Singing Barney the dinosaur. Any other talking or singing toy is fine, but those two seem like they would be bate in a horror movie. Elmo laughs while the killer sneaks up behind you. Ugh

Dianna Hummel

I have an ever growing cabinet of curiousities. My dream would be to have a full sized taxidermy two headed calf.

Sarah S

the results of a DNA test proving Ted Bundy was your real father

Angela Menard

All my past family members, in their own beautifully constructed coffins. So we can celebrate together as a family.

Suzie

The creepiest thing I could think of was my mum giving me back all my baby teeth that she kept 😂

Kimberley Howes

I received an old clown marionette. He has an unusual smile. I keep him up because when my daughter was little, she was freaked out by it. But I still love him!

Michelle Clark

A mirror that when you look into it you see horrific deaths of yourself and loved ones and can't put a face/location/time on anyone so there's no way to try to change any of it.

Caroline Quincy

My sister last year got me a krampus gnome and we set it up outside this year and I get scared every time I leave the house! Kind of silly but it’s my favorite!

Catalina

Creepiest gift was receiving a photoshopped photo of myself with a guy I used to work with as a "couple". 😳

Claudia Garcia

Body parts

Ashley King

A vintage pocket watch that’s not telling the time but counting down the time you have left.

Eric Mutzabaugh

The reassembled skeleton of a favorite childhood pet dug up from the backyard of the house I grew up in. Both creepy and unsettling. 😳😖

Rebecca M Barfield

A vintage baby doll head necklace that is now possessed by an evil spirit. When you are out in public it will turn it's head to look and follow people and shout mama to scare people.

Jessica Ledbetter

A few years ago I received a severed baby arm from my boyfriend. It was the silicon prop from Feast II, it now lives in a glass dome in my office.

Amanda Denery

The cancerous mass they removed from my husband a few weeks ago. Love the new episodes, the house is looking amazing. Hope everyone has an amazing Christmas.

Eliza Estrada

Happy Holidays Christine! Loved the spiders! My creepiest present was a Furby. At first I loved it, but it started laughing randomly and talking without me interacting with it ... it freaked me out so much that I buried it in my closet under other toys, but I would still hear it laugh. So, eventually it found it's way to a donate box and far away from my house.

A.M. McPherson

A Christmas blue jay from my childhood that cheeped. My mom found it in a box in their attic. Figured it would love to have it. She shipped it to me. I was taken back when opening because it had somewhat slowly melted from the Texas heat and its chirping had become demonic sounding. I quickly placed it back in the box.

Shae

A photo of my late husband holding today’s newspaper.

Nelia Torres

When I was younger there was a talking doll named Julie. She was programmed so you could talk to her and she’d respond. I wanted her soooo badly and was super excited to get her for Christmas! Well, Julie came out around the time Child’s Play came out and my cruel older brothers decided to call her “Girl Chucky”. That made me *terrified* of her and I didn’t want to play with her! I would hide her behind my other dolls. 😬🤣🎄

Christina Desiere

Pictures of me sleeping with bugs on my face

Christine Manca

Tickle-me-Elmo. I swear they are all haunted. Hearing "ha-ha-ha" coming from your closet in the middle of the night is just terrifying.

Jenny Rose

An authentic poison ring💀just big enough for a small dose of belledona ☠️Merry Christmas to you🕷🕸🎄

Lisa Thibeault

So far I would say it is my Fosse-Troll. I love it but I cant help but understand why people are telling me it looks creepy. Lol

Megan

OH! I like this one!!

Christine McConnell

A set of used mortician makeup brushes

Donna Blue

An object from a nightmare you had years ago. Left on your doorstep with a note stating "It's Time."

Trevor Howell

Probably if someone were to gift me my old childhood pet rabbit called Henry except hes not quite 100% alive and looks like a Frankenstein bunny with mad eyes, empty patches on his fur and big claws and teeth...think the white rabbit meets Victor Frankenstein...🐰🧟‍♂️ I'd still keep him though..🖤

Lucy Starling

Pictures someone took of you through your windows

Deanna Stanwood

My grandmother’s ring, she was buried with it in 1992.

Heidi Eschedor

A mysterious tooth laying perfectly beneath the Christmas tree with no tracks, note, or otherwise identifiable signature.

Caryn Oles

A necklace of kidney stones.

Kate Peltier

Picture this if you will- a box wrapped in red and to perfection shows up under your tree... who’s is it? No one knows ... on the tag is your name in calligraphy. You open it to find a book, hand-bound. Inside you see photos of your childhood and Christmas past. Something odd about the photos though. . .All of your family are in them. Who could have taken them? As you keep flipping the pages the photos go on every year of your life ... even photos of private moments .. who took these ? How? As you reach the final page you see a photo of you asleep in your bed safe and sound ... wearing the same pj’s you wore to bed. You pull the photo and flip it over. The date written on the back yesterday night December 24th .... there is no more room in the book....

Chad

An antique photo album with black and white photos taken of you from strange vantage points while you went about your life. In each photo there is a shadowy figure that gets closer and closer to you as you turn the page until you get to the last photo of you in this very moment and the figure is right behind you reaching for you.

Mike Czaplinski

An ear, a la Vincent Van Gogh

Suzanne Hegedus

A repeat of 2020 😧

Kiley Wade

A store bought, pre-assembled gift basket! 🙀🙀🙀

Marianne Claffey

A lifelike porcelain doll that looks identical to myself with a voice box that when activated says, “I know what you did.”

Michele DeBacker

Ooohhhh this is a hard question! I think the worst present I could get would be a snotty tissue! I’m a nurse so I handle all kinds of gross stuff, but snot instantly brings me to my knees!🤣

Jessica Darne

Your own death mask.

Cat DuFoe

My cats regularly bring me random body parts, sometimes the owner isn’t even discernible. So it’s Christmas everyday in my household because they love me enough to bring me gifts

Chrissy Jackson

An unmarked envelope with a lock of cut hair, and then finding out that it was your hair 😳

Lesley Niezynski

Your own obituary

Nick Z

A Golden Girls ouija board with a post card of Sophia putting a Sicilian curse on me👵🏽👝

Justin

True Story: Last year for Christmas my family all bought our plots together. For Me, Mom, Dad, my sister, and an extra one for my best friend. We went to visit them to discuss what graves we also wanted.

Dave

Merry Christmas! Creepiest gift would be an anonymous letter (think cut out magazine letters) with a warning of your significant other’s secret life and devious plans for you!

Alisha Edwards

A mounted deer head with a suspiciously red nose 🤔

Randy Ladner

Your beloved pets’ heads.

Sandra Martinez

An anonymous collection of candid photos of where you were and what you were doing this month.

Craig Simms

Perfectly intact clothing....that a family member was cremated in.

Alice

A box from my parents with the skeletal remains of all the pets we have lost over the years, with a note that says "we've sold the house!"

Rachel Blair

Some else's teeth.

Red Queen

My cat left a rats head on my pillow the other morning. I like to think that was his Christmas present to me , the positioning was the creepiest part about it but the sentiment was there bless him 🤣

Plaguedoctor 13

An old 1800's death photo of one of my relatives, the kind where the eyes were left open 😨 and it looks just like me!

Serena Jordan

Really long, fake fingernails that I would have to wear no matter what. I find them incredibly creepy and can't for the life of me see the purpose of wearing long, delicate talons when creating art. Nightmare fuel!

Sally

A photo album of our “love”... from a stalker

Lindsay Powell

A framed tattoo on actual human skin

Samantha Huth

A haunted antique toy music box. True story we received one for our child and promptly disposed of it when it started acting creepy on its own

Melanie Lick

A basket of single shoes in different sizes that are obviously worn and belonged to different people. Whose shoes are they? Where is the other shoe? Why are you giving me shoes, I hate feet???

Jennifer Williams

for the unaware: https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FStoned_Fox&psig=AOvVaw1tWYFRDfY5H14mDjJxtOyi&ust=1608906406790000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAIQjRxqFwoTCNCo38jp5u0CFQAAAAAdAAAAABAD

Kimberly Adamski

Wet hair from the shower drain 😖🤢

Jade

Unwrapping a gift, but all that's inside is a slip of paper with a date that's far in the future and a time.

Ty Gowen

Nothing! A gifts a gift do your worst!! I'd love it!! Hahah

Ali Whitehouse

this is a hard question, because everything I think of could be taken as a "but that's really slightly thoughtful/sweet"...lol..with that I'll say receiving a body part, that isnt a heart.

Cami Walker

A box filled with cockroaches....EWWWWWW....just thinking about it makes my butt draw up

Sherrie Potgieter

The bad taxidermy fox

Kimberly Adamski

A spooky looking cuckoo clock that never chimes on the hour but goes off randomly. Think it would scare a few of my friends...

Kat McConnell

Your green spider

DeeDee Wood

A duplicate of your house key given by an anonymous sender.

Alex Aronson

Hahahaha!

Christine McConnell

A beautiful antique formaldehyde filled mason jar of human eyes *cue the Rockwell "Somebody's Watching Me" song lol

Prissy Witch NJ

A present under the tree containing a significant item from that one family member that was supposed to make it for Christmas but mysteriously never showed up.

Rachel Marts

A lock of your own hair

Hannah Collins

Exercise equipment 😱 jk But for real I would have to say a severed body part. Pretty much any severed body part would be creepy. 🔪🩸👃👂🦶🦵💪🤲💀

Orealgreenleaf

Lampshade made with the tattooed skin of friend. Especially if they have a lot of tattoos.

Michelleslbqueenbee

An eviction notice from my landlord. That guy is such a jokester!

Andrew Ryan

The creepiest Christmas present I could receive would be a shrunken head covered in extra open eyes which seem to follow me around a room mounted upon a desiccated monkey's paw with a single wish left. (Anything with too many eyes creeps me the hell out and shrunken heads give me the heebie-jeebies 🤣)

Roxanne Araña

A piece of jewelry I lost years ago. Well before I met the gift giver.

Tamara McCool

A present from yourself you have no recollection of buying or wrapping

Jess Vann

The Annabelle doll for sure

Christine Peterson

A piece of jewelry made of your own baby teeth.

Ann Adams

Your significant other's baby teeth

Tammy R Dowden

My husband says when he dies he’s giving me his heart preserved in resin. I’m sure that’s going to creep people out.

Jen

A note under the christmas tree reading, “We are watching your every move and know where your relatives live!”

Jackie Adair

A life-size waxwork model of yourself. “Erm....Thanks for the terrifying gift...”

Tim Willers

I collect old medical equipment and things from supposedly haunted places and one year an ex gifted me a lobotomy kit from Danvers State Hospital. This year I gifted myself one of the original seats from the haunted Egyptian Theatre in DeKalb, IL.

Nicholas Frig

An arachnid ornament for next year's holiday bush 🖤🎀😁

Blockhead Wigs

A Shrunken Head!

Nicole Williams

My sister legit gifted me this but a 16in vibrating pennywise plushie doll ... it dosent talk or anything just VIBRATES !!!

Batsi Von Crazi

Human skin leather bound book!

Natalie Coleman

Creepiest gift a live spider

Merina Lewis

That's a good one!

jessica franzen

A casket with my name on it while the person who gave it to me stares back at me with a wide smile.

margie delao

Internal organs from someone you know!

Emmanuel Ferlita

A certain porcelain doll that about 2.5 feet tall and lives in my mother's room. That thing gives me the creeps and I love dolls.

Kat Bregman

An arachnid ornament!!! 😆 Merry Christmas to you and yours, Christine!!

Kristin Ott

A cemetery plot with your name on it (or an urn).

Laura Duckworth

An unmarked box containing an album full of instant polaroids dating back to childhood that were taken from behind bushes and walls and from cars, and the last one in the album was of me opening the box...

Sinister Sarah

The gravestone of an ancestor (though I secretly wish I had one)

Amy Hartman

A painting of my sleeping from the view of my window

Miggea

Blahaha :D That would do it!

Christine McConnell

A preserved/ embalmed body piece of One of my ancestors

Laura Amoroso

Land to make the haunted garden I’ve dreamed of creating since I was little (I was a huge fan of sleepy hollow and Maleficent in sleeping beauty growing up!).

Carley Arnold

Merry Christmas eve and Christmas!! 🎄 🤗

Merina Lewis

I LOVE this one!!!

Christine McConnell

A Mogwai with a broken clock and a bag of potato chips

Martha Thursday

A pair of handmade earrings...made of polished children’s teeth! 🦷 💎

Kaitlin Taylor

A ring or piece of jewellery a relative was buried with

Clara Vratsanos

I would say maybe the skeletal remains of a family member! 🤷

jessica franzen