XaiJu
SongsFromASuitcase
SongsFromASuitcase

patreon


EARLY ACCESS: GLEE VS ORIGINAL 2 (patreon edit)

EARLY ACCESS: GLEE VS ORIGINAL 2 (patreon exclusive edit)

https://vimeo.com/785754220/92fb4b5761

EARLY ACCESS: GLEE VS ORIGINAL 2 (patreon edit)

Comments

kitty kitty pus pus the way i scream!!!!!!!!!!!! LOLLLLLLL

simon davis

yes I love them singing the scientist. to me better the the original>

Linda

I cant wait until you watch the next ep of Glee (which you probably already have) to hear the full Scientist song. I think you'll double down on liking the glee version better lol.

Kenyatta (KD) Smith

What Does the Fox Say would be amazing omg

Jacob

I feel like with a few of these you might've picked the Glee versions if you were given better clips of the Glee versions. Especially for Girl On Fire, American Boy, Every Breath You Take and Mustang Sally. I can think of parts of those performances that are better than what was chosen here. Hope that's ok to say. 🙈 As for a part three, you should compare these: Sam and Rachel singing A Thousand Miles to the original version by Vanessa Carlton The New Directions boys singing I Saw Her Standing There to the original version by The Beatles Starchild singing Marry The Night to the original version by Lady Gaga Marley singing Wrecking Ball to the original version by Miley Cyrus Jake and Marley singing Nasty/Rhythm Nation to the original version by Janet Jackson Rachel singing Glitter In The Air to the original version by Pink Santana singing Alfie to the original version by Cilla Black And just for shits and giggles, the Glee cast singing What Does The Fox Say to the original version by Ylvis. 😂

Siobhan Linehan

Lol I like the whole song, I just don't like Kanye doing it. Blaine does his part on the glee version I believe (haven't listened to it completely in a few)

Haughtbreaker Nic

I also really love the Glee version of American Boy, but I also have Kanye's verses memorized, so what does that say about me lol

I Am Not Chamari

I will admit that I love the Glee version of American Boy.

Erin

I'm gonna be the one to disagree on American boy ONLY because I think Kanye ruins it the most.

Haughtbreaker Nic

I definitely think that context plays a huge part in my preference and it’s hard for me to separate the song from the characters and storylines. It’s really hard for me not to be biased. There’s is just so much more behind the GCVs than just the lyrics, vocals, and production.

Annie Willow

Not any of my favorites that Glee has performed but I must say that I agree with every one of your picks Audrey.

Veronica _R_T

Hopefully I don’t come off as rude, but those were really bad song choices imo. Especially the American Boy one…like who actually thinks the Glee version is better 😭. Also surprised you received hate for picking Barbra over Lea considering Barbra is one of the most acclaimed vocalists ever.

Jacob

Yeah, it's odd in both ways, but we gotta choose the one that best brings new audience on YouTube

Audrey and Danny's Editor

Suggestion…I think it would be better for future videos if you reacted to audio only as to not let the visuals affect your decision. Also, so you don’t get spoilers for future episodes!!

Guillermo Orozco

I agree with your choices when listening to the two versions of Girl on Fire Alicia Keys' version had way more a kick to it and had more power. I love the cover and listen to both versions all the time as it's one of my favorite songs and I love both versions but Alicia Keys' was a lot better in those recordings. Somebody on TikTok once pointed out in the song Rather Be that when she sings the No No No No No place I'd rather be part that it sounds like she is singing No No No No No no Greys Anatomy and now that's all I hear when I listen to the song no matter which version I listen to.

Lydia Shepard

Very true. That didn’t occur to me. I can see your dilemma.

Stephanie Authier

I chose two songs from each season of glee, whoever watches on YouTube and doesn't know about the watch parties would come at her for just choosing songs from season 1-3 🤷🏾‍♀️

Audrey and Danny's Editor

I completely agree about the context issue. Why don’t we limit the comparisons to songs you’ve heard in context? Your editor still will have so many songs to choose from and they’ll only keep growing along with the watch parties. Also, your Patreon members who are watching GLEE for the first time will also be able to view the songs in context and maybe not come after you. Don’t you make me come down there from Canada Audrey! 🍬 🧂 💦!!!

Stephanie Authier


More Creators