[Wolf Lord+ Edition] Let me pick your Brain - Part 1
Added 2023-05-04 13:43:59 +0000 UTCThis one features a massive spoiler for the next Patreon chapter (Chapter 14), so I can't ask the general Patreons on feedback for it.
Figured I could ask all of you instead, as you've already read chapter 14 yesterday!
The 'Let me pick your Brain' series is a series of passage feedback requests, in which I will be posting some (HIGHLY WIP) passages, to receive some general feedback on for future chapters.
That means this post will contain MASSIVE SPOILERS for the upcoming chapters.
If you would prefer not to be spoiled and rather read full-chapters when they are released, feel free to ignore this post.
For the rest of you, I'd like to hear your opinion on the following passage:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----- Passage Feedback Below --------- That means there are spoilers involved! -----
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----- Passage Feedback Below --------- That means there are spoilers involved! -----
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[There is no further context required for this passage.]
[Beginning of passage]
Seeing Thea assume a low, nearly crouching stance in the centre of the arena in preparation for the first round to begin, Astra could not help but marvel at her form. Her eyes remained glued to Thea as she maintained her low stance, the air in the arena charged with anticipation. As the buzzer sounded, Thea shot forward with incredible speed, closing the distance between her and Lan in the blink of an eye.
Astra was amazed at how Thea seemed to dance around Lan, evading his chainsword swings effortlessly and using her smaller, more agile frame to her advantage in such a way.
Despite being in the same class as Thea and being around the same age, Astra felt like she was watching someone from a different species entirely. Thea’s ability to perfectly stay out of reach for each of Lan’s brutal-looking strikes was a testament to her incredible forethought and control over her own body, something Astra had always struggled with in her own combat exercises.
'Her form is just so… perfect. I’ve never seen anyone fight with two knives like that; it’s like they’re a part of her body, rather than weapons wielded by a Marine… My sword style would not stand a single chance against her, whatsoever...'
As the fight continued, Astra's admiration for Thea only grew stronger. She was awestruck by Thea's strategic thinking and her ability to adapt to her opponent's movements in real time, despite the doubtlessly stressful balancing act she had to nail to keep up the pressure without being caught by one of Lan’s strikes.
Astra could tell, looking in from the outside and sharing a similar combat style to her, that Thea was calculating each move with precision, her eyes scanning Lan for any signs of weakness or hesitation without pause.
She couldn't help but hold her breath as Thea dodged yet another powerful swing from Lan, her body twisting and contorting in seemingly impossible ways to avoid the deadly chainswords, as if it was the most natural thing in the world.
Up until this point, Astra had thought that Strength builds were inherently superior to Dexterity for close-range combat, but seeing her idol effortlessly dodge, contort, and twist through the oncoming assault of attacks, hope regarding her own Attributes blossomed in her heart. Inspired by Thea's performance, Astra resolved to push herself harder in her training going forward and attempt to emulate Thea’s graceful and fluid, yet deadly combat style.
She had been awestruck by Thea the first time she saw her on the podium the day before. A mid-worlder in Alpha Squad. Not just that, but an undercity cyan mid-worlder.
For Astra, Thea was a shining example of the heights that even mid-worlders could achieve.
Even if the inner- and core-worlders in her class mocked her and the other mid-worlders or looked down on them, having Thea and Isabella in Alpha Squad was a clear testament to the folly of their thoughts, that mid-worlders were somehow inherently inferior to them.
She was further amazed at how Thea seemed to anticipate Lan's next moves, always staying just out of reach of his weapons, regardless of how dangerous a given swing seemed to be. It was as if Thea was simply toying with the intimidating, hulking man.
When Thea timed her moves just right to exploit Lan's vulnerability and injure his arm, leaving him visibly frustrated and off-balance, Astra could not help but yelp in surprise at the sudden change in the fight. This opening should not have existed!
Astra herself had not been able to find any opening in Lan’s defences, much less such a devastating one, despite her best attempts at doing so. Although Astra was an outside spectator, she had somehow been less capable than Thea, who was in the middle of a fight for her life, at spotting this minuscule chance.
With sparkling eyes, Astra followed the rest of the fight, as it was clear to her that Thea had already won the first round with that decisive strike. Being injured in such a way, Lan was obviously unable to keep up with Thea who rapidly closed out the round with another incredible gambit by throwing her knife to distract Lan, and get close enough for the kill.
Seeing the spectacular finish to the first round, Astra jumped up in joy, unable to contain her excitement. As she was clapping and celebrating Thea’s first win, Astra suddenly realised the looks she was getting from her fellow Marines around her, who all seemed to be taken aback by her candid show of support for the winner of the first match.
Feeling slightly embarrassed by their glances and the fact that she had so openly shown her support for her idol, Astra lowered her hands, smiled sheepishly, and said, “Ah… My apologies…” while trying to regain her composure in the midst of her fellow Marines.
Looking back towards her idol inside the arena, she saw Thea casually walk back towards the centre of the arena, readying herself for the second round. Astra quickly returned to her previous spot close to the blue barrier, anticipating the beginning of the second round with bated breath…
[End of passage]
What do you think of this passage, as in: First Impressions?
Was it entertaining and if so, why?
Was it not entertaining and if so, why not?
Do you feel it adds something to the story, to see the fight from Astra's PoV?
Do you like different PoV inserts, such as this, in general?
Are there any major changes you would personally like to see?
Thank you for partaking in the feedback!
Comments
Fantastic points! I'll be sure to implement this in my rewrite, thank you!
LunaWolve
2023-05-05 19:35:44 +0000 UTCHope im not too late weighing in, Life happens to those that live, my note may make easy flair change into an existing passage anyway. But regardless of the alternative pov used, be it Lan or an audience member, it is there first time seeing or being in a fight since their integration into the system, (unless they had duals in there dormitory the night before) and from the audience they can be wondering if their own capacity matching up to another new integrator, or from LAN’s perspective awe, or awareness of their new capabilities. Thea was kinda making her ability relatable to the arcade games she would play (like coming up with a strategy on my Freya!) which for me at least let me have the feeling of she has had practice with altered states or abilities, and it’s tying in for her. But by acknowledging at least subtlety the change it will help create more impact of the integration, and lend weight to the choice of the Marine and how they integrate into the system.
Tarkkail Mejn
2023-05-05 19:26:25 +0000 UTCLooking forward to it :)
Trasen56
2023-05-04 19:09:40 +0000 UTCI like this comment a lot, cause that's what I started doing on the continued section of the chapter, haha xD First is Astra's PoV, slightly changed from what is here, followed by Lan's going into round 2.
LunaWolve
2023-05-04 18:50:58 +0000 UTCIf your planning on doing multiple PoV's something you could do is to have Astra's PoV for the first round, then transition to Lan's PoV for the second round, starting with him reviving and getting annoyed seeing Astra supporting Thea. This could set up some conflict between Lan's clique and the group of midworlders Astra referenced when she said Thea was their idol. That conflict could potentially act is an initial icebreaker between Thea and Isabelle if they both stick their necks out to defend other midworlders. Perhaps a brawl between midworlders and the others breaks out during the 1 free mealtime and Isabelle and Thea get involved to defend their people. You could even have them be forced to go through some sort of disciplinary action together for being in the brawl; nothing forges bonds faster than mutual suffering!
Trasen56
2023-05-04 18:01:38 +0000 UTCAppreciate the thoughts and the links, once again!
LunaWolve
2023-05-04 17:36:56 +0000 UTCI like the passage, but feel like you are in danger of retreading the same fight scene a second time. Perhaps quickly going through the first round and doing the more detailed descriptions during the second round could avoid Astra's reactions/descriptions of the fight being repetition of what we already read. As others pointed put, Lan could also make a good PoV, especially if you start at the second round, as he would be trying to adjust to her fighting style and learn from his first loss. Either way I like it. Also, the way Astra describes Thea's fighting style shares many characteristics with Northern Shaolin Kung Fu: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northern_Shaolin_(martial_art). Obviously Thea's is actual fighting vs more the performative stuff done at Shaolin now, but I thought it was cool. Unfortunately I couldn't find any good videos demonstrating the style but there is a channel on youtube called 'Ranton' run by a guy who trained Northern Style at Shaolin and has several videos talking about his overall experience: https://youtu.be/XZuKUPMpcwA
Trasen56
2023-05-04 15:13:32 +0000 UTC