Lol I'll share after this season is finished. My thoughts on seasons when I first watched have changed a lot rewatching them now I'm older
James Payne
2024-07-02 09:47:02 +0000 UTC
Okay but now I need to know where season 6 would fall into your ranking of the seasons
William
2024-07-01 21:25:19 +0000 UTC
First half of season 10 was pretty good, the second half was a bit of a disaster. I would like to see a reaction to the first half, in part bc of one of the guest stars they drudged up :)
I haven't watched since season 10.
Liz Strong
2024-06-30 23:21:39 +0000 UTC
I've only watched this season once, as it was my least favorite (I just thought it was too slow-paced.) But I'm happy to watch your [abbreviated] reaction!
Liz Strong
2024-06-30 23:19:37 +0000 UTC
We're here! I firstly want to say that it's fantastic news to hear you're planning on watching up to S9, as I enjoy all those seasons and would really love seeing your reactions. As for Roanoke, it's the first season I ever watched live, weekly, with two of my friends super early in the morning at boarding school. The build up with the show's teasers was superbly done- they made it a huge mystery as to what the season would entail, which made this first episode fantastic and hype television. I also love the poster! Seeing your reaction to this documentary style is really interesting, and what I like is that it's still scary... even though it's a documentary, and a dramatic reenactment. All I'll say is that I really enjoy this season, and I am stoked for more reactions. So much mystery in this first ep! Upon rewatch, I'd say my season ranking (excluding this) is: S4 < S1 < S3 < S5 < S2.