Part 2 - Never Have I Ever | Fourplay

This fictional story features only adult characters (18+) and portrays consensual interactions throughout.

(3'rd Person POV)

Drew stepped inside Brad&Cody's place first. Ryan followed, smirking, carrying a six-pack of beers neither of them would end up touching.

Brad sat back on the couch, scrolling through his phone like this wasn’t the most chaotic setup imaginable. Cody stood in the kitchen, pouring water into mismatched glasses, his eyes going straight to Drew’s crotch every couple of minutes.

They all said hey, did the quick bro-hugs or hand slaps, and within minutes the “catching up” split into two separate wavelengths.

Drew and Brad drifted toward the part of the living room where Brad’s home gym setup lived. Cody could hear the clunk of weights before he even sat down on the couch. Ryan dropped beside him, groaning.

“Bro. Gym talk already?” Ryan muttered.

“Of course,” Cody rolled his eyes. “Brad’s been waiting for this.”

In front of them, Brad was pointing at his adjustable bench like it was sacred.
“Dude, I worked out at your place a while back when I was in that cut phase,” Brad said, lifting a dumbbell to demonstrate his strength. “Your gym’s legit.”

Drew nodded, impressed. “This? Man, it’s fucking good. Compact as hell, but you’ve got all the stuff that matters. Cables, pull-ups, even a sled mat?”

“Hell yeah,” Brad grinned, flexing just slightly.

Back at the couch, Cody made a gagging noise. “You’d think they are about to jerk each other off over a barbell.”

Ryan sighed. “I swear, we need to do something else. If we don’t, this foursome is going to turn into a flexing contest between those two.”

Cody smirked. “I wouldn’t mind watching that, honestly. But I want their cocks out, like, right fucking now.”

Ryan snorted. “I’ve got an idea. Let’s play something. ‘Never Have I Ever’?”

Cody raised an eyebrow. “What’s that gonna do?”

“Just wait and watch.” Ryan leaned in, licking his lips deliberately and speaking loud enough for Brad and Drew across the living room to hear. “Never have I ever… kissed someone else’s boyfriend.”

The heat in his eyes made it clear: this wasn’t just a game.

Cody grabbed Ryan’s face with both hands, fingers digging into his jaw as he yanked him close. Their lips crashed together, hot and messy, tongues instantly tangling in a hungry fight for control. Cody sucked on Ryan’s lower lip, biting just hard enough to make him grunt before shoving his tongue deep into his mouth. A string of spit dripped from their chins as their mouths moved frantically, breathing through their noses like they couldn’t bear to pull apart.

Ryan’s fingers curled into Cody’s hair, holding him there as their tongues slid together wetly, the sounds of their kiss filling the room; impossible for Brad and Drew to ignore. When Cody finally moved his mouth away, a string of spit still connected them, his chest heaving.

Ryan licked his bottom lip, tasting Cody there, and smirked. “I guess we both have kissed someone else's boyfriend.”

Brad and Drew had stopped mid-gym talk, now turned toward the couch , both rubbing the hard outlines in their pants, eyes locked on Cody and Ryan. The kiss had clearly gotten their attention.

Ryan’s breath was shallow, his hand resting casually on Cody’s thigh. Neither of them said a word at first. Just let the tension stretch out for a little while.

Brad and Drew walked toward them, slow and cocky. Brad tilted his head at Drew, nodding toward the couch. “These guys are such attention whores,” he muttered with a grin.

Ryan didn’t miss a beat. “Well. Play along then.”

Drew stepped right in front of Ryan instinctively. Brad mirrored him in front of Cody, hands already ghosting over their shoulders like they owned them. For a second, no one moved; it was all anticipation.

Drew raised a brow and said, “Never have I ever had my dick sucked by a pornstar.”

Cody laughed, looked up at him and tugged Drew closer at an angle. “Lemme change that for you.”

Brad glanced at Ryan, smirking. “Well. Don’t leave me out of it.”

And just like that, the couple swap happened.


────୨ৎ────

(The story from this point on is written from Cody’s POV.)

Drew had been standing in front of Ryan, but I reached up and tugged him toward me, pulling him in diagonally by the waistband of his jeans. He looked surprised, but didn’t resist. I tilted my head up at him, all innocent eyes and filthy thoughts.

“Let me show you what this 'pornstar' can do,” I said, grinning and then, still looking at Brad, I peeled Drew’s pants down with both hands.

Brad raised an eyebrow. “Finally. He’s been wondering if you were the big brother for a reason.”

Drew’s cock flopped out and fuck. It was insane. Thick, long, a heavy veiny monster that bounced against his thigh before hanging straight toward me like it knew I’d be the one worshipping it next. My mouth actually watered. I’d been curious, sure, but this thing was practically a weapon.

I licked the tip, slow, teasing, then wrapped my lips around it and sucked him in inch by inch. His body twitched like he hadn’t expected me to go that deep, that fast.

Across from me, I saw Ryan reach for Brad’s waistband and tugged his sweats down in one smooth motion. “Holy Fuckkkkk,” he muttered when Brad’s cock sprang out; thick and hard and already leaking.

Brad didn’t say anything at first. Just smiled. He placed one hand gently on the back of Ryan’s head, fingers sliding into his hair, and used the other to swing his cock across Ryan’s face... left, then right, slow and heavy. A wet slap each time it tapped his cheek. Ryan blinked, lips parting, his breath catching like he hadn’t expected Brad to tease him like that.

Brad smirked, swinging his thick shaft slowly across Ryan’s face again. “Bigger than Jason’s, right?” he said, cocky and casual, before slapping it softly against Ryan’s cheek. The sound was wet, heavy.

Drew laughed while his cock was still sliding on my tongue. I glanced up and saw him grinning, eyes locked on the scene beside him. “Go on,” he said, voice rough with arousal. “Show him why you’re the better ex.”

────୨ৎ────

Read Next Part