Give Me a Sign

I would really like see more talking about the episode and storyline, not this stuff about nothing

Egle Ramanauskaite

drew with glasses .. yes

Nicola

I like that episode 😅 and wow, Drew… it is not the best episode, but from a nine down to a four? How dare you 😂

This is one of my favorite podcast episode (not the episode itself!)! Loved the Dan VS Leo list, so funny!

Charlotte

I agree same with like the feats of clay that drew pointed out.

Jessica Villalvir

Really need a episode with a Billy Crudup. He's so good at being evil.

Kate Anness

I'd give this about a 7/10. I do like this episode, but its not the best. It does have some good ground laying for sure as Drew said. Also this is the episode Piper finally admits who her true love is. Which helps with my raring, besides that there's not alot of excitement in this episode. I also like the idea of how it shows how spells can be meant for one thing but really end up for something completely different. Not a spell gone wrong, per say just not the exact intention.

Liz

As Drew pointed out, it's a good groundlaying episode and a great setup for the evil hierarchy and all things Source in the next season.... I actually think this episode is why I really went off Prue in S3, due to her hypocrisy relating to a certain Mr. Turner... it always felt like if it was Prue's bad boy they had to just trust her judgement and faith unconditionally... but, anyone else's bad boy, absolutely not.

Steph Youthed

Just a thought: If Prue could astral project to her sisters while being tied up, couldn't she just astral project behind herself and untie her ropes? 🤔

Elisa Brogren

I'm with Drew on this one, I LOVE this episode. It does lay the groundwork for things to come while also letting the characters soak in things that have already happened. I think it's important to sometimes have more "laid back" episodes where the audience and characters can sink into a lot of what's been happening. I also love the Piper/Phoebe antics in this episode alongside the Prue/Bane relationship. Another great pod episode!

Ali

Drew you gotta find a way to watch with the original music. I just watched this episode with the original music and the end scene where Piper is saying “I didn’t need a sign to tell me where my heart lies”…….the original music is perfect…..”lyrics as Piper says this …..”I see you smile again and what’s done is done. Just a little heartache. Just a little hope…” someone get Drew the DVDs!!

Sharna Finlay

You 3 Crack me up every episode. Love re watching for the hundredth time with you 3 🤣🫶

alex lebron

I skip the intro because I don't want to hear the new song

Anh-Phi

Love it, I hate that I can’t hear what holly is saying because it keeps cutting out 😭😭

Jenn Sylvester

As frustrating as I'm sure the delay is for both you guys and the editor, it does give us great moments such as: Drew, excitedly to Holly: "God I love you so much! We share a brain at this point, don't we?" Holly (responding to Brian): "No" Drew: :(

Elinor (MithlaOfficial)

Digging the glasses, Drew! 🙂 Also I do have to say I’m usually on the same page as Drew when it comes to what gets me excited about eps. You need those high stakes and the girls in peril usually to end up with a higher rating for me. It’s just more engaging and amps up the tension/suspense. But this definitely didn’t have any pay off in regards to Piper’s choice. Not sure I ever completely saw it that way before when Holly said it, I was like “yes, you’re so right”. They could’ve done something more with that - given it some defining moment

Danielle

Apple. When it’s an embedded YouTube video, only YouTube premium subscribers can lock the screen on a video while it continues to play

Josh Atkins

do you have an apple or Android? if you lock your phone as an iPhone normally it pops up on the Lock Screen and you can press play and still hear the audio that's what I do haha

Dani Cipolla

Well, I see what you're all saying. BUT I love the puns and wordplay that mess up all the "signs" that Piper and Phoebe get. They think one thing is a clue, but then that clue points in the other direction. I thought it was so funny, because it was showing the pros and cons of Leo and Dan and that you can't just cast a spell to figure it out. I think Piper wants a normal life and can envision that with Dan. That's why she even considers moving out. BUT I think she ultimately chooses Leo because he knows everything (and she loves him)-- she's a witch and needs to constantly attend to the life of saving people even if that means not being able to sit through a "normal" date out of the house. Dan's a fantasy. If she COULD give up her duty as a Charmed one to be with Dan, THAT would have been an interesting episode.

Debbie Trencher

Can you please upload the audio as well? Or upload the video via Patreon instead of YouTube? Not able to lock my phone without the podcast pausing

Josh Atkins

Drew definitely caught me off guard with the glasses! He's one of those people who can pull them off well!

Alyssa Olsen

Always amused by the 3 of you. Don’t worry Drew, I got your “never-nude” reference lol.

Erin Marie

When I originally watched this aired I thought it was okay. I see now that it does seem flat. What I liked was Piper and Phoebe's conversations as it seemed fun/quirky in a way.

Diana

I'm dying with the rating steady dropping from the beginning of the podcast to the end for drew 🤣. But we did have a lot of first in this one. First upper level demon, first mention of the source, first time seeing Prue with her photography stuff. It was an ok episode 🤷

Bonnie Tyson

I'm so happy you said you "LOVED IT" in the beginning Drew! I rewatched it last night and thought it was great and was so worried you wouldn't like it. 😂😁 I don't accept the changing of the mind. 🙃

Sandro

And also why would Phoebe cast that spell when Piper told her expressly not to ? I forgot how childish Phoebe was until Cole came on.

Milor Echasse

Drew, pretty please do an HOH episode whit the 3 of U together IRL in the plane oO Was already at 5 at the beginning, felt like a filler BUT I remember loving Piper's boldness when it airs (o tempora o mores...), but she was the one climbing that Abded-Bane appolo and to my young self, she was embodying a bold sexually free women on TV, even the "trouple" Piper/Leo/Dane was really unknown for me on TV. The girls were like wearing pink sweaters but they were also free women I felt at the time.

Milor Echasse

Call me crazy but I’m not going to be sleeping with a guy who orchestrated the murder of 9 witches and tried to kill me and my sisters only a few months ago. I don’t care how unfortunate his life has been.

Rebecca Jacqueline

I'm one episode ahead, as of now. Looking forward to commentary on the MURPHY'S LUCK episode. I know it's going to be epic.

Steven Maggiolino

"sequels are not reboots" - "we're not talking about reboots, jeez"👀

Janine Krispin Deiermann

Same!! Was a good podcast episode.

Anna Parzygnat

The ending of Season 2 episode 20 (Astral Monkey) is every reason why I will always be team Leo.

Andrew Chavis

One of my favorite episodes from season 2. It was interesting to see the difference in Bane following the episode Ms. Hellfire. Shannen and Antonio were fun to watch. It would have been interesting to have Bane return for more episodes. Keep up the great work! I hope Jamen is doing better and better with each passing day, and as always love and support to Shannen. Praying everyday for her. Love to all.

Steven Maggiolino

I agree this one was not one of my favorites….I love how Drew flipped on his rating. Y’all are hilarious. 🤣 P.S. Brian I hope your son is doing better! Been thinking about you guys 🥰

Miranda Coffman

I feel like this episode and Awakened should’ve been swapped chronologically. You cannot get a better sign for choosing than Leo saving her life

Roanne Grech

Always the best part of any Wednesday. Thanks guys! You're the best! Hope Jamen is still recovering quickly. Thinken 'bout cha boo. Health and love.

Misty B

Wooow. The lag added to the humor in the podcast. And the autopsy of the episode revealed the cause of the low rating. Giving it a 5.

Trudy Uitti

I think when piper mentions (not in this episode) that "Dan, has their relationship on the fast track.. not me." it shows that the pace that Dan was moving too fast for Piper. He was trying to move her in his house, talking about babies, saying I love you on the first date. I don't think that's how Piper's attachment style works. Like its been under a year... Leo she chased. she missed him when he was gone. He understands who she is more. IF Dan's over romantic pushiness was so great she wouldn't still be thinking about Leo. Hence why she never needed a sign to show her where her heart lies, because if Leo hadn't left in S1 she would still be with him. #teamleo

VT

This is definitely a filler episode. But that’s okay, I love it anyway.

Derick Lindsey

Hahaha Drew, please post a picture of the list you wrote down 🤣

Fabián Maciel

Thanks for another fabulous HoH episode!

Dawn Mead

I had a smile on my face watching this entire podcast. loved it

Kazz (Charmed4lifekaren)

Sorry Drew, not a bad boy, we all know you're a Golden Retriever boy.

stacey ✨

Not to dismiss the other awesome parts, but to be fair, this episode deals predominately with that triangle.

Dawn Mead

They talk primarily about them because it's their characters

Stephanie Barrett

When she says that my heart burst. I was so happy

Stephanie Barrett

When she says that my heart burst. I was so happy

Stephanie Barrett

I agree - the comedy between Holly and Alyssa in this episode was great! I’ll admit though I find their discussions of Leo vs Dan highly entertaining 😂

Laura Shergold

The moment Drew flipped and declared 'This episode sucks!' I may have spit out my coffee laughing 🤣

Casie Jean

I so agree!

Alicia

I'll never get used to the new theme music and don't want to CUZ it's too much like 80's Miami Vice (it's just all wrong).

Gloria Strait of Juan de Fuca

I can’t wait till you get to season 3 and beyond where the podcasts will no longer focus on the Piper/Leo/Dan love triangle. Shannen and Alyssa and some of the guest stars bring so much to these shows but every podcast just boils down to who Piper liked more that particular episode and how that ends up effecting how Brian and Holly end up liking the episode. Like this episode, the comedic chemistry between Holly and Alyssa was exceptional but not discussed at all. I’ll keep watching these hoping that eventually you guys will surprise me and not spend 80% of the podcast talking about P/L/D.

Robert Quadrini

Oh I love this episode even though not much happens. Prue is definitely in lust not falling in love which is why she says she trusts him. Sex and lust have clouded her judgement 💁🏻‍♀️😂😂 I think there’s some awesome classic sibling moments that make you laugh. Also this is the episode that you guys were filming when you did that doco “Women of Charmed”. I watched it on YouTube recently and Holly had me cracking up 🤣

Sharna Finlay

The way Drew’s rating changes so drastically! Re Piper’s choice I think what happens is that her head finally catches up with her heart. After 28+ minutes we’ve got Leo might want his wings back one day and “Dan is still great and normal which is good considering I’m not.” I think Dan is everything she thinks she wants/should want. He’s everything about that normal life she ‘s always thought about. But Leo is Leo and that’s where her heart lies…and has done for like a whole season.

Laura Shergold

There are some fun scenes in this - particularly at the start with Piper and Phoebe, and that “I never needed a sign to tell me where my heart lies” ending but I’m with you some of the middle drags a bit. I do like Prue and Bane though! This podcast ep however, I was laughing out loud for much of the second half. You guys can always make me laugh so thank you! ❤️

Laura Shergold

I love watching this podcast. I love how you keep it real. You guys are the best lots of love your way❤️

Annie O’Malley

Lol @ sweet baby Drew asking if he’s a bad boy ☠️

Haley

Thanks for this guys! It’s been a bit of a tough week for me so far & ‘HOH Wednesday’ just made it a whole lot better. I watched the ep earlier & gave it a 7. Now I’ve lit my candle, watched HOH & giggled along with you. FEELING SO MUCH BETTER! So thanks once again for working your magic! 🖤✨

Jacqui Bennett

Holly... What's in box on the floor behind you?

Gary E Davis

That would have been comedy gold Phoebe trying to get a premonition off the rag and passes out!!!

Gary E Davis

She’s literally looking at Leo when she says she doesn’t need a spell to know where her heart lies! So, y’all maybe missed that. Also, prue and Bane arnt in love, it’s just some hot passion that we are all here for,

Jenn Sylvester

Omg this is one of my favorite episodes in season 2

Taylor Holbrook

this is such an awesome episode!

Camille

Holly is rocking the Angela Lansbury lens!

Bernard Duff

Just got the notification this, and I am now wondering whether Delta wifi will support this stream lol.

Neoshia

New episode.. where’s my air pods lol 😂

Melanie Stout

This is the first episode where the Source is first mentioned!

Chris Holmes

❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

Jade Watson

Definitely a fav! “Panties” 🤣💀

Kevin Jenkins

Love this episode!

Christina Persechino

Yay! 😍

Radical Retro Rewind Podcast?! Ryan Hunter Studios

Yaaasss!!

Christina Persechino