XaiJu
Travis Manning
Travis Manning

patreon


Private Practice | 4x13

no spoilers in comments pls :)

** previous season access will be available on the archive if your tier allows.

Comments

The way it came across to me was that was a fear based response rather than hate. She felt she had to be defensive instead of accepting because the position of her MIL was I want to take the baby not help find a way to keep her sons family together.

Helen Moore

The baby almost suffocated though. It wasn’t a “could be” situation…

Travis Manning

Seemed to me like the DIL didn’t want anything to do with the MIL though … so why should she be obligated to help ?

Travis Manning

Blind people raise children all the time, the mother in law should have been finding ways to help her daughter in law and grand child and support them instead of trying to rip them apart. There are programs and people and all kinds of things to help people with disabilities. At the end of the day if we say that someone who is blind or has one hand, or deaf doesn't have the right to be a parent we are headed down a slippery slippery slope.

Helen Moore

I think it’s a slippery slope to simply say people with disabilities Can’t be parents. Who are we to deny blind people, deaf people, severely asthmatic people, and people who are missing legs or hands the honor of being a parent? They would absolutely need help. And that’s my problem with the grandmother in this episode. She didn’t want to help Lizzie with the baby. She wanted to take the baby away and give Lizzie random holiday visits like she was a druggie mom who had harmed her child, not the honorable soldier who sacrificed limb and love for her country. I think the situation of both grandma and mom raising the baby is the best, but I was team mom all the way. You can’t simply take someone’s child because you want to replace the son you lost.

Biancalama

okay also, from personal experience: i’m gonna need everyone to stop telling charolette to forgive her rapist like what?? i get when people say shit like “forgive so and so for yourself” and sure holding onto anger isn’t great but i wholeheartedly believe you do not have to forgive your fucking rapist!! idk it’s all very nuanced and whatever Charolette needs to move on from this trauma i support. but Cooper is so right in this episode, screw your oath! that man will not get prosecuted the only way to save other potential victims is to kill that man! kill him please. like i am begging Sam to please let that man die. no rapist should be allowed to live. edit:i guess jail is an alright solution, i know prisoners don’t fuck with rapists so i hope he’ll get fucked up real bad in there

Alicia Cue

Well I guess we could see it coming from the minute she said thank you and hugged her daughter. I'd rather not give my opinion on this though. Poor Addison. Also I agree with you : Pete can fuck off. Damn he's annoying me. Oh and I wanted Lee to die all episode long too. But hopefully he'll rot in prison until he does which is even better. (The scene where Charlotte comes into the OR and tells him she wanted to make sure her face would be the last he'd seen if he didn't make it was very powerful).

Shin Yukina

lmao we are the same😭 the way i said shove that shit further in and let that mofo die right before you did like who would even know if Sam simply walked away😗🫢 the way i’d let that rapist die and not lose an OUNCE of sleep🤷🏾‍♀️ also Pete once again being the most annoying character on this show literally like 4 minutes into the episode 😭😭 i cannot take himmm what do you mean the woman who suffocated her baby because she literally cannot see her should take that baby home with her??? do you think it would hurt more to have her baby safe and with her grandmother or to find out however much later she accidentally killed her child??? like use your motherfucking brain puhleaseee pete and stay in your lane edit: pete if that baby is accidentally killed by her mother, it is on him!! i get wanting to keep a mother and child together but when it literally puts the child at risk who are you really helping???? like ooooh that man boils me blood

Alicia Cue


More Creators