Poly Werewolves (complete)

    Lucky in love has never been something said about you. You have been remarkably unlucky in love all your life. If it weren’t for the unwavering support of your family, you’d think you would be entirely loveless. 

    You’ve had girlfriends and boyfriends since high school. All of them have found someone else while they were dating you. Usually, this is the person they spend the rest of their lives with. You feel happy for them, but at the same time, you feel like no more than a doormat to someone else's home of happiness. 

    As such, you’ve dated rarely. You have the occasional one night stand or heavy petting session, but for the most part, you’ve concluded that romance is not for you. Instead, you focus on your business. With some help from your parents, you’ve opened up a toy store. It has always been your dream since you were young. Hearthway Hollow always seemed to have endless businesses and places for grownups, but shops and places for kids and teens was severely lacking. 

    Your toy store has everything, including a small book section with comics and hard to find things. The first couple of years were extremely hard, but now, as you celebrate your fifth year, you’re finally turning a corner. The store is popular, and you feel extremely pleased with your success.

    One day an adorable couple comes in. They’re around your age. The guy is tall and beefy, thick arms and a slightly protruding belly. He’s hairy and has the brightest blue eyes you’ve ever seen. The girl is absolutely tiny, she’s a beanpole with flaming red hair, and every inch of her is covered in freckles. They giggle and flirt all throughout the store. You have so much fun watching them. They play with the toys, and the guy awes over the stuffed animals. The girl then takes out a toy sword and is beating him on the ass as he tries to read books.

    “Sorry!” She chirps, her voice is sweet and cute. She sets the sword aside. “We’re just having fun! We got carried away.”

    You smile and wave at them. “Don’t worry about it. This is a toy store after all.”

    “I think you should call the cops on her,” the guy says.

    She sticks his tongue out at him. “We love your store,” she says. “We just moved back to Hearthway Hollow, and we were so excited we stopped moving to come to visit.”

    “Oh,” you gasp. “How long have you been away?”

    “About eight years,” the guy says. “We both went to college out of state, and we got kind of settled out there.”

    “My grandma left me her old house, so we decided to come back home.” The girl walks up to the counter. She has the prettiest brown eyes, and thick, pretty eyebrows. “I’m Mara,” she says.

    “Colin,” he holds his hand out, and you shake it.

    “Nice to meet you,” you try to think if you knew them. But if so, they would have been a grade or two below you in school. “And welcome back.”

    “We’re really excited about your store!” Mara says. “We were worried we wouldn’t have any fun places when we came back.”

    “Really?” You chuckle. “I’m just a little toy store.”

    “We’re collectors,” Colin says. “Figures, comics, anything like that our house is full of it.”

    Mara bobs her head. “Once we get unpacked, you’ll have to come see it. We want to start hosting game nights too.”

    You gasp. “I’ve been trying to get that off the ground myself.”

    “Maybe we could work together then,” Colin grins. “Get something going, start a new tradition down here in the Hollow.”

    You smile, feeling a little bit excited. “That’s great. I’d love to.”

    Mara reaches into her back pocket and hands you a card. “We’re hoping to get our business started back up as well.” 

You look over the card, seeing that Mara and Colin operate an on-call IT company. “Well, if I have any technical issues, I’ll give you two a call.”

The couple beam and set their purchase on the counter. After they leave, you keep thinking about them. They were both so bright and bubbly,  and they looked so happy, it made you start to dream about having someone. It seemed like everyone you knew was getting courted and running off with their werewolf, why not you?

That evening you close up the shop and walk up the back stairs to your apartment that’s over the shop. You get up there and see a delivery guy is knocking on the door. 

“Oh there you are,” he hands off the big bags of food into your arms. “Enjoy.” He starts to walk off.

“Wait a second!” You gasp. “What is this? I didn’t order any of this.”

He reads your name off the receipt, and you agree that’s you. “It was a gift order.” He points to the message written on the brown paper bag. “As I said, enjoy.”

You’re stunned, who would order you a week's worth of take out? You go inside, sitting everything down so you can read the writing on the bag.

“This isn’t exactly a deer or a bear or something, but hopefully this will get the message across. Can’t wait to court you.”

Your heart starts hammering. Can this be true? Is it real? Are you really being courted?

    You dig into the bags, never so happy to get free food before. Free food is always the best, but this was the most fantastic meal you’ve ever had.

    You wake up the next morning, and as you’re getting ready to go down and get the shop opened, you receive another delivery. This time it’s a box of piping hot coffee and two huge boxes of pastries. This comes with a note as well.

    “Hope you don’t mind this as your courtship, Hunting takes too much time!”

    You’ve never been so happy and excited before. This was way better than getting a deer and having that meat sit in your freezer forever. You don’t know how to cook, especially not venison. 

    You get pampered with excellent food and items from your wishlist over the next few days. You’re loving it, but at the same time, you’re eager to know who is courting you. You go through customers in your head, exes, even neighbors. You have no clue who could possibly be courting you.

    One afternoon, Mara and Colin come into the shop again. You’re happy to see them. They looked tired, but they still exude that happy energy as before.

    “How is moving going?” You ask.

    “So far so good,” Mara sighs. “We’re hoping to have it all in order by the end of the week,” she sighs.

    “She’s dreaming pretty big,” Colin runs his fingers through her hair, and she leans into his palm. “We still have to paint a room or two before we can get anything ready. Not to be boring or anything,” he chuckles. “We actually came in to see if you’ve been enjoying the treats.”

    You furrow your brow. “Treats?”

    Mara nods. “We know how the courtship is supposed to go,” she says. “But we really don’t have the time to go out and hunt. So we figured food and goodies would get our point across.”

    You stare at them, unsure how to take this in. “Both of you?” You gasp.

    “We know it’s a bit odd,” Colin replies. “But we both felt that attraction to you. The instant pull. We knew what it was.”

    “Is it ok?” Mara asks. “I know this isn’t how courtship rituals usually go, but we just wanted to make sure everything was ok?”

    “Both of you?” You repeat again.

    Colin and Mara smile. “We like you a lot,” Mara says. “We want you with us.”

    You feel tears sting your eyes. “Really? Me?? You rub at your eyes and chuckle softly. “Oh wow. This is never, ever my luck.” You look up at them, smiling through your touched tears. “I never expected to be courted. Let alone by two amazingly cute people.” You sniffle. “I thought I’d never-”

    The two of them come behind the counter, hugging you. Colin kisses the top of your head while Mara kisses your cheek. 

    “This makes me really happy,” you confess to them.

    Mara stands on her tiptoes, placing her cherry flavored lips to yours. Colin then turns your head, kissing you. 

    “We’re happy to have found you,” Mara said. “For a long time, it felt like we were missing something.”

    “Now, we have you,” Colin nuzzles to your hair.

    “Can I come by tonight?” You ask, your voice cracking. “I’d like to see you again.”

    Mara giggles. “As long as you don’t mind a messy house. We’d love to have you come by. Good luck leaving though,” she winks.

    “Don’t let her threaten you like that,” Colin chuckles. “She does hog the blankets though so feel free to cuddle me tonight.”

    Your cheeks burn, and you can’t focus the rest of the day. You’re nervous and fidget a lot, you keep thinking about Mara and Colin. No wonder nothing ever worked out for you, they were across the country, far away from Hearthway Hollow. You grin like an idiot, thinking how you’re finally so lucky.

    That evening, after closing, you make your way towards their house. You have to drive there as it’s on the far edge of Hearthway Hollow. In fact, it’s in the expensive neighborhood where each house has a forest between them for privacy. When you reach their house, you’re stunned. It’s huge, at least three floors. Peeking around the corner, you see a massive pool in the back. You suck in an anxious breath and ring the doorbell.

    You hear yelling and scampering inside. Excited chatter and then the door opens. You look up, staring a massive brown wolf with bright blue eyes.

    “Colin?” You whisper.

    Behind him is a red wolf with a bushy, thick tail. Mara rushes out, hugging you tightly and pulling you into the house.

    “Oh wow,” you whisper. 

    Mara licks you cheek and grabs your hand. “We kind of wanted to show off,” she says. Her tail is going a mile a minute. She’s bigger than before, but still quite tiny. Colin is enormous, thick and fluffy all over. 

    “She wanted to show off,” Colin says, his big paw rests on your ass. 

    Mara licks your neck and nibbles there. “You smell so good,” she moans into your ear. “Like new plastic.”

    Colin’s paw squeezes, and your mouth hangs open as you start to feel the ache of arousal. 

    “You-you’re home is beautiful,” you manage to squeak out. “I wasn’t expecting you to live in Fancy Hollow.”

    “Yeah,” Mara chuckles shyly as she steps back. “My grandma was loaded. I mean, it’s a beautiful house and everything, but it feels like so much.”

    “That’s why we thought game night would be fun. We’d get to share it,” Colin says.

    “Have you eaten yet?” Mara asks. “Are you hungry?”

    You shake your head. “I haven’t eaten, but I’m not hungry. I had a big lunch,” you glance up at Colin, seeing him lick his chops. “But, if you guys need to eat- uhm-” you feel strange.

    “I could eat,” Colin snarls into your ear.

    Mara smirks. “You’ll have to forgive him, he uhm...he kind of went into heat this afternoon.” She pulls up your shirt and kisses your chest. “It’s been all I can do to contain him.”

    “Did you say...heat?” You whimper.

    “Glad we found you when we did,” Mara unhooks your bra. “I need all the help I can get with him.” She plays with you breasts while Colin watches. His strong finger rub between your legs, feeling your heat through your pants.

    “I wish I had big boos like this,” she squeezes one in each paw. She then licks your nipple and takes it in her mouth, sucking hungrily on it.

    You whimper, feeling both of them touching you was almost too much. Colin tilts your head up, kissing you and biting your lip. He snarls and moans as his kisses trail down your neck.

    “Colin,” Mara huffs as she unzips your pants. “Behave, don’t eat her.” She tugs off your pants and helps you step out of them. Her fingers slick against your slit. “She is mighty wet though.” She takes her glazed fingers and places them on Colin’s tongue. He sucks them and snarls.

    “I want it,” he growls.

    “Then ask her,” Mara kisses your neck. 

    Colin looks at you and kisses you softly. “Can I eat you?”

    You gulp down a breath and nod. “Oh yes, please.”

    Colin scoops you and Mara both up, tossing you over his shoulders he carries you through the house. You go into a room with a huge fireplace. It looks like it’s supposed to be a living room, but they have their bed laying on the floor in there. Colin throws you down onto the bed and Mara squeals and giggles.

    You start to laugh, but then Colin grabs your legs and yanks you down towards the edge of the bed. His mouth is soon upon you, he bites and licks his way up your legs until his great big head is firmly planted between your thighs.

    You cry out, moaning and sighing as his tongue burrows deep inside your pussy. Mara comes up beside you, smirking.

    “Isn’t he great at that?” She kisses you, touching your chest and moaning softly. “How does he feel?” She pants.

    You kiss her, grabbing her close and running your hand down her center. “I want to show you.” You slip your fingers between her legs, and she grins brightly. 

    “Anh-” her mouth opens wide. “Oh my.”

    You rub and tease her clit, gently tapping it. It’s pretty big, you’re actually surprised. You kiss her, sucking her tongue as Colin slurps and devours you. His rough, hot tongue pushes inside you, squirming around before lapping up your cream and swirling around your clit.

    You moan into Mara’s mouth and she giggles. She enjoys playing with your breasts, groping them and squeezing them with both hands. You dip your fingers inside her, feeling her molten core and how wet she is.

    “I can’t take it,” Colin growls as he sits up. You look down, seeing his cock is thick like a beer can, his knot twitce as thick. He’s flaming red, and the tip is spilling precum like a leaky faucet.

    Mara giggle in your ear. “What do you want?”

    “Oh wow,” you look at Mara. “How do you take that?”

    She winks. “Like a champ.” She reaches down, and with her hand, she spreads open your dewy folds. “I think you want him.”

    Colin snarls and grabs your hips, lifting you off the bed and rubbing his cock against you. You whimper, biting your lip. 

    “I want to watch this,” Mara sits up, helping Colin guide himself inside you. She watches in awe and licks at his knot.

    You cry out, never having taken something so big before. You stretch around him, melding to the form of his big werewolf cock. It’s a mixed sensation of pleasure and pain, but it all melts together to make your thighs tremble.

    “Be easy with her,” Mara coaxes Colin. 

    “So...good…” Colin growls. He pulls you closer, grinding himself inside you. “Tight,” he howls low.

    Mara smirks, licking and sucking his knot as he starts to move. She reaches down, tapping your clit as Colin fucks you. Your back arches off the bed and you grunt and sigh. You buck and tremble, not used to all these sensations at once. 

    “She looks like she’s enjoying herself,” Mara moans as she touches herself.

    Colin snarls, moving faster and harder. He shakes you, and the bed and Mara watches it all with pure joy on her face. She bends over, kissing you and nuzzling between your breasts. Colin rocks you, plunging deep inside you. You then feel him push harder, his knot is begging for entrance. You cry out, reach down as you feel it slip inside you. You wail in pleasure. His knot grinds against our most sensitive spot, and it’s all you can do to hold on to sanity. 

    Mara kisses you, moaning loudly. You hear Colin’s long, drawn out howl as a molten heat flood inside you. Colin grunts and moans, kissing Mara before he lays on you. Mara comes down beside you, kissing you softly as Colin’s cock keep pumping inside.

    “Oh wow,” you pant. “What was that?”

    Mara giggles. “That was mating,” she snuggles beside you and Colin. “I’ve been dealing with him all day,” she says. “It felt nice to share.”

    He grunts and lifts his head. “You’re next,” he growls at her.

    Mara smiles at you. “Sorry,” she says. “We finally find you, and he goes into heat.”

    You shake your head. “No, really,” you pant. “I love sex, this felt so good.”

    Mara’s eyes brighten. “I like to hear that.”

    Colin kisses you, pulling himself out of you. “Mara, you should clean her up.” He pulls you onto his chest and Mara pets down between your legs. She licks you up, cleaning Colin’s thick cum as it globs out of you. You whimper and twitch, still so sensitive from Colin’s heat induced onslaught.

    “Yum,” Mara licks her lips, joining the pile. “Ok, I am hungry now,” she yawns.

    “Should we order?” Colin asks. He reaches out and grabs his cellphone, handing it to Mara. “By the time it gets here I’m going to be on again,” he groans.

    “Really?” That fast?” You gasp.

    “I have two beautiful women with me that I love. How am I ever supposed to calm down?” He kisses your cheek.

    Mara yawns and sits up, stretching. She smiles dreamily at you and Colin. “This is perfect,” she takes the phone and snaps a few pictures. Mara then sneaks between you two and nuzzles between your breasts.

    “You’re going to have to share those,” Colin growls at her.

    “You can have her butt, I know you prefer that,” she giggles.

    You sigh dreamily and melt into their embrace. Finally, you’re lucky in love.