Dominated by the Girl Next Door - Part 4

Click here to read the previous parts of the story.

"Cassidy really liked you, you know," Chloe said as she looked down at Phil and smiled.

His tongue was buried in her pussy and he was loathe to remove it - she tasted exceptionally good - but Phil pulled back, swallowed the cum he'd retrieved from his neighbor's freshly-fucked hole, and asked, "Really?"

Cassidy was Chloe's beautiful, kinky friend and a week ago the two of them had used him aggressively over the course of a few hours. They'd made him suck and gag on a dildo, fuck his ass with that dildo, eat their pussies, worship their asses, lick and suck on their toes and feet, and much more.

Chloe grabbed a handful of Phil's hair and pulled him towards her pussy once more. He looked up from his hands and knees - he felt so submissive in that position, especially when he was between her legs - and he pushed his tongue deep into the folds of her slick, creamy cunt.

"She said she's never played with a guy like you. A guy that's willing to do literally anything to make a girl happy," Chloe explained. "She said she's been with guys that claim they're submissive, but those guys are always just in it for themselves, and you're not like that."

Phil would have said something, but Chloe tightened her grip on his hair and pulled him closer, smothering his face with her pussy and spreading the mixture of her juices and her lover's cum over his skin.

"She's right about that, of course," Chloe continued. "You are a true sub, Phil. You're willing to do anything I want as long as it makes me happy. You're willing to take any sort of humiliation, aren't you?"

He nodded as best he could with his tongue still buried in her pussy.

"If a guy gave me an anal creampie, would you clean it out of me?" she asked.

He nodded. It would be difficult, but Phil would do it. Of course he would. It was just such a turn on to do whatever Chloe asked, even if it was disgusting or unpleasant.

"If I wanted to piss all over your skinny, pathetic little body, would you let me?" Chloe asked as she reached down to rub her clit.

"Mmm hmm," he said while tonguing her pussy and searching for more of the cum her lover had left inside her. He wouldn't have enjoyed being pissed on, but he would have enjoyed the delight on Chloe's face while she did it, and that's really all he cared about.

"You're such a naughty boy," she said. "Such a dirty little bitch. So willing to surrender your dignity for me. That makes me so fucking wet. It turns me on, Phil. Fuck, I came harder on his dick today because I was thinking about feeding you his load when we were finished. How fucking wild is that? And now I'm going to cum again while you're devouring his spunk out of my messy little cunt."

Chloe had been clear that Phil wasn't permitted to play with his cock, which is why he refrained from reaching back and rubbing himself in the panties she'd made him change into the moment he'd stepped into her apartment.

"Get your fucking tongue deeper inside me, you little cum dumpster," she hissed. "Taste him on your tongue. Taste the sweet, creamy load he busted up inside me. Taste it and fucking swallow it."

Phil searched her pussy for the last remnants of the load that had been vigorously fucked up inside of Chloe. He gathered what he could and swallowed over and over while she rubbed her clit, held his hair tightly, and showered verbal humiliation on him, all in the pursuit of what seemed like it would be yet another beautiful orgasm for her.

"Fuck...oh...fuck...I'm cumming!" she cried out.

For a moment her grip on his hair tightened so significantly that Phil winced from the pain. Then Chloe released her grasp, spread her legs wider, and let an orgasm wash over her. Phil had already witnessed several of her climaxes, but it was thrilling each and every time. Knowing that he'd been responsible for the pleasure of such a beautiful girl was the most incredible feeling, and the fact that she'd cum from humiliating him only made it hotter.

"Get on your back," Chloe instructed after her orgasm.

Phil dutifully moved to his back on her living room floor and Chloe got up, pulled his panties aside, and freed his stiff, undersized cock that had strained against the delicate lace.

She took his dick in her hand and an involuntary moan escaped his lips as Phil's hips shot upwards as if they were instinctively trying to penetrate. He knew that wouldn't happen, of course. Chloe would never let him fuck her. It was a miracle she was even touching his cock.

"I'm going to let you cum," she said. "But you'll need to pay a price for it. A bitch like you - a dirty little cum dumpster - doesn't deserve an orgasm that's pure pleasure."

"I know," Phil replied.

Chloe released his cock, moved to his feet, and grabbed his ankles. She lifted them high enough that Phil's ass came off the floor and then Chloe folded them forward until his feet were above his head and his ass rested against Chloe's chest while she looked down at him.

"Stroke your cock," she instructed.

Phil's cock was just a few inches from his face in that position, and while the folding of his body was a little uncomfortable, he was still hard and he felt an unexpected rush of excitement at what he knew was coming.

"Stroke that worthless dick of yours until you cum all over your face," Chloe said with a devilish smile. "Soak yourself in your rancid spunk, you disgusting little cum dumpster."

Phil closed his eyes a moment before pleasure surged through his loins. His cock stiffened, his balls jumped in their sack, and he unleashed rope after rope of hot cum on his face.

The pleasure of his climax was unquestionably enhanced by the sensations of the cum hitting his skin. It landed on his forehead, his cheeks, one of his eyes, his chin, his lips, and in his mouth. The fact that Chloe moaned as he covered himself in his load only made it hotter.

"That's a good little cum dumpster," she said. "Now smile for me."

Phil smiled and heard - his eyes were still closed - Chloe take a picture. He felt a sense of panic wash over him and he tried to roll away, but Chloe leaned on his ass and his lower back ached.

"Don't worry," she said. "I told Cassidy I'd make you cum on your face and I had to take a picture for proof. She's the only one that will see it, though. I promise."

Phil wasn't entirely sure he believed her, but there was nothing he could do about it. She'd taken the picture. She'd probably already sent it to Cassidy. It was out in the world now. It was proof that he was the cum dumpster Chloe said he was, and there was something just a little bit exciting about that, which is why he didn't bother putting up a fight.

"Cassidy has a friend she wants to introduce you to," Chloe said. "Someone who's willing to play with a guy like you, and who's willing to let us direct the play."

Phil reached up to wipe the cum from his eyelids, stuck his finger in his mouth to suck it clean, and opened his eyes to see a smile on Chloe's face. "What does that mean?" he asked.

"You'll find out," she replied. "Though I can tell you that it means we're going to have some fun with you. He's available Saturday night, so I expect you to be available too."

"He?" Phil asked as a mild sense of dread washed over him. What had he gotten himself into?

Chloe smiled. "Yes, Phil. We're going to let a guy play with you. Use you, really. It won't be that different from the last time, except it won't be a dildo in your mouth and ass. It will be a cock. A real man's cock. To be honest, I think it's a big fantasy of Cassidy's. I mean, I'm totally into it, too, if I'm being honest, but I think she's going to cum hard on Saturday night."

The idea of being used by a man terrified Phil, and yet that sense of terror was softened by idea of pleasing Chloe and Cassidy with his willingness to be used.

"You're not going to disappoint us, are you Phil?" Chloe asked.

He shook his head. "No, I won't."

"Good," she replied. "Now let's go to my bedroom. I'm going to ride your face with my tight pussy. I'm going to make a mess with all that cum, Phil, and you're going to lick it all up like a fucking whore. Do you understand?"

"Yes, I do," he answered. Phil couldn't wait to be her little cum dumpster.

Phil stood in front of Chloe's door with his hand raised to knock. It remained there, though. He felt a mild tightness in his chest as his heart pounded. He was excited and terrified at the same time. If he knocked, he would cross a boundary he'd never even considered crossing before. He'd service a man. He'd almost certainly suck cock and there was a good chance he'd get fucked. Never in his life had Phil imagined doing any of those things with a man, and yet he was one knock away from committing to those very things.

He could have walked away. He probably should have. He didn't, though. He knocked. He knocked because of the intense pleasures he'd experienced while in submission to Chloe. Phil just couldn't resist the allure of experiencing that pleasure again, even if it meant offering himself to a man.

Cassidy answered the door in a pleated skirt and a cropped sweater. She wore a sparkly belly button ring and her hair was pulled into a playful high ponytail.

"I'm so glad you showed up," she said. "I was worried you might bail."

"I...I almost did," he replied.

Cassidy reached out and grabbed his hand like she was worried he might still run. She pulled Phil into Chloe's apartment and he saw his neighbor - who also wore a short skirt and a cute sweater - sitting next to a short, skinny guy that reminded Phil a lot of himself. For some reason he'd expected a guy like the kind that Chloe seemed to sleep with. A tall, muscular, masculine guy who fucked with great vigor.

"Phil, I'd like you to meet my friend Roman," Cassidy said as she led Phil towards the couch.

Roman stood - he was a few inches shorter than Phil - smiled, and offered a quick handshake as he said, "It's a pleasure to meet you, Phil. I understand that we're going to have some fun together tonight."

Cassidy squeezed Phil's hand and said, "That's right. Though I guess I can't speak for how much fun Phil is going to have since he's really just going to be our little toy tonight. I know you're going to have fun, Roman, and I know Chloe and I are going to have fun."

Chloe stood, approached Phil, and unbuttoned his pants. She slowly lowered his zipper and reached into his underwear to caress his soft cock. Her lips found his neck for a series of soft kisses and his dick came to life in her hand.

"Phil's going to have a good time," Chloe said. "He can't help but have a good time when he's serving me and Cassidy. Isn't that right? You loved being our little bitch the last time we played. You fucked that dildo like you were an experienced cock whore, Phil, and now you get a chance to enjoy a real cock while we watch. You're excited, aren't you?"

Phil didn't have an answer. Not a good one, at least. His dick was hard so he was excited in at least one respect, but he felt impossibly nervous about what he was expected to do that night.

"He certainly looks excited," Cassidy said as she pulled Phil's pants and underwear down and cupped his balls.

In that moment, Phil was living out the perfect threesome fantasy. He had a beautiful girl stroking his cock and another playing with his balls. He was in heaven, and he could have stayed there all night. That wasn't in the plans, though.

Chloe released his cock and took off Phil's shirt. Cassidy helped him out of his shoes and he kicked his pants and underwear aside, leaving him naked and stiff in front of Roman and the girls.

Cassidy's hands moved over Phil's ass and she gently squeezed his flesh, kissed the back of his neck, and asked, "You're going to do as you're told, aren't you Phil?"

"Yes," Phil answered as he watched Roman smile.

"You're going to let us use you hard, aren't you?" she asked.

Phil nodded. "Yes, I am."

"Then get on your knees," Cassidy instructed.

Phil dropped to his knees and both Cassidy and Chloe sat on the couch. He stared at their long, smooth, perfect legs as their skirts rode up and his eyes wandered to how lovely their perky breasts looked in the soft sweaters they wore.

"Don't look at us," Chloe said. "Look at him. Look at the man you'll be servicing tonight."

Phil looked up at Roman, who stepped closer and smiled down at him. For some reason, he didn't feel anywhere near as nervous as he thought he would.

"Take out his cock," Cassidy instructed.

Phil's hand shook a little as he reached up and unzipped Roman's jeans. He reached inside in search of the cock he would soon service for the two dominant girls sitting on the couch. He found the flaccid shaft and pulled it free. The teeth of the metal zipper gently dug into the impressively long and thick flesh that now rested outside of Roman's pants.

"It's bigger than you expected, isn't it?" Cassidy asked.

Phil nodded. Roman was short and skinny and his cock didn't fit his frame. Not even close.

"Use his whore mouth until you're hard," Chloe said.

Roman stepped closer, placed his cock between Phil's lips, and grabbed his head with two hands. A moment later he began to thrust, pushing his soft flesh in and out of Phil's mouth at a slow, steady pace.

It was entirely different from sucking on the toy. Phil wasn't in control. He wasn't the one to decide how deep he went. He wasn't sucking on rubber. Instead, he was being used as the sex toy. His mouth was being fucked for another man's pleasure, though it helped to remember that it was actually Chloe and Cassidy he was trying to please.

"Fuck, this is so much hotter than I thought it would be," Chloe said.

Phil glanced her way to see that his neighbor had pulled her skirt up and was rubbing her pussy through her panties. She lifted her sweater, took one of her breasts in her hand, and played with the flesh in a manner he found intoxicating.

"Look up at me," Roman instructed. "Don't look at her. Don't look at them. Look at the man you're sucking, Phil. Look at the man whose cock is getting hard in your mouth. Look at the man who owns you in this moment."

Phil was surprised to feel his balls tingling with desire as Roman took charge. His cock bounced a little, too, signaling that he felt an undeniable level of arousal in a manner he wasn't entirely comfortable with.

"Fuck his face faster," Cassidy said. "I want to see him gag on your dick, Roman. I want to see his eyes watering as you use his mouth."

Roman did just that and soon enough Phil was gagging. The cock in his mouth got harder and thus it pushed deeper. It reached his throat with ease and Phil couldn't help but choke a little. His eyes watered and saliva began to escape his mouth and travel over his lips and down his chin before dripping onto his chest and legs.

"Cock slap him," Cassidy instructed.

Roman pulled out, grabbed a tight handful of Phil's hair and pulled back until he was looking skywards. A moment later Roman's wet dick slapped against Phil's cheek. He closed his eyes and winced from the surprising pain and several more dick slaps rained down, leaving him stewing in a remarkably potent sense of humiliation.

"Feed him your balls," Chloe said.

Roman's slight but impressive forearm muscles rippled as he tightened his grip on Phil's hair, stepped closer, and dropped his balls into the waiting, open, eager mouth that Phil offered.

"Suck his sack," Cassidy instructed before a loud moan escaped her lips. She'd joined Chloe in masturbating and Phil desperately wished he could watch. Roman's cock had almost entirely blocked out his view, though, so he dutifully sucked on the balls in his mouth while the two gorgeous girls masturbated to the sight of his humiliation.

"His dick is hard," Chloe noted. "Honestly, I can't believe his dick is actually hard."

Phil knew she was talking about him. He could feel how hard his dick was and he was just as surprised as her, if not more so. Submitting to Chloe had shown him that he found pleasure in humiliation, but he was still somewhat astounded that sucking on a man's cock and balls left him in an erect state.

"Put a condom on his cock, Phil," Cassidy instructed. "Dress up the dick that's going to take your ass."

Chloe grabbed a condom - a Magnum - from the side table and offered it to Phil as Roman stepped back. He took the condom, tore it open, and looked up at the man that would soon be in his ass.

Phil had a chance to save some of his dignity. He'd sucked cock and worshiped Roman's balls, but he could have gotten up and walked away. He could have ended his relationship with Chloe right there, but he didn't. He reached up and rolled the condom down Roman's impressively large cock. He even stroked it a few times once it was dressed for sex.

"Get on your hands and knees facing us," Cassidy said.

Phil fell to his hands and knees and looked up at the beautiful, dominant, kinky girls sitting on the couch. They scooted a little closer together and at almost the same time the girls reached between each other's legs and switched from masturbating to light lesbian fingering.

"It's going to hurt," Cassidy said. "It always hurts the first time you get fucked in the ass. There's no avoiding it, and that goes double when the guy has as big a dick as Roman does."

Phil looked over his shoulder to see Roman drop to his knees behind him. He spit in his hand, reached out, and rubbed the warm, slippery liquid all over Phil's asshole. A thumb penetrated him a moment later and Phil turned his attention back to Chloe and Cassidy and saw that both girls had removed their sweaters. Their nipples were hard and they wore looks of intense pleasure on their faces as they fingered each other.

"Fuck him, Roman," Cassidy said. "Fuck the filthy whore on his hands and knees in front of you. Take his ass and pound it as hard as you want."

"Show him what it's like to be a good little bitch," Chloe added. "Stretch out that asshole of his. Use him hard until you cum."

Phil winced as Roman's cock slipped inside him. It was bigger than the dildo he'd fucked just a week ago. It was longer and thicker and it felt harder in his ass. It filled him slowly until he felt Roman's pubic hair against his ass.

Roman's hand slowly moved up Phil's back and into his hair before taking a tight grip. He pulled hard and Phil's head snapped back. Roman pulled out, paused with just the tip of his cock in Phil's ass, and then filled him with a long, deep, hard thrust that elicited a groan of pain.

"How does it feel to get fucked?" Cassidy asked in a voice dripping with lust.

"It...it hurts," Phil replied.

Roman filled him again, grunting from the effort of the thrust.

"Do you want him to stop?" Chloe asked.

"No," Phil answered without hesitation. "Please...don't stop, Roman. Don't stop." It hurt, but Phil didn't want him to stop. Phil wanted to get fucked for the pleasure of the two girls masturbating in front of him. He wanted to get fucked on his hands and knees - like a bitch - while he watched Chloe and Cassidy masturbate to the sight of him taking cock from behind. "Please, Roman, fuck me harder."

Both girls moaned and the looks on their faces suggested that they loved that Phil was acting like such a slut. Chloe slipped three fingers into her pussy and rubbed her clit furiously. Cassidy played with her tits and massaged her sex organ. Both girls stared at Phil, watching his face as he experienced a mixture of pain and humiliation at being fucked by a man for the first time in his life.

There was something about the fact that Roman was actually a little smaller than Phil that made it even more humiliating. It would have been easier to cling to some shred of his manhood if he was getting fucked by a guy that could have overpowered him with ease. He wasn't, though. He was getting fucked by a short, skinny guy with a huge cock and he was doing so willingly, all for the pleasure of the beautiful girls playing with their pussies.

"Spank his ass, Roman," Cassidy instructed. "Make him feel like a real bitch as you fuck him. Spank him hard."

Roman did as ordered, delivering a series of swift, painful blows to Phil's ass while driving his cock hard and deep at an ever-increasing pace. Phil couldn't help but wince from the dual pain of being fucked and spanked, though he noticed that the discomfort of the cock in his ass was slowly decreasing.

"Can you squirt?" Cassidy asked.

Chloe looked at her and nodded.

"Are you thinking what I'm thinking?" Cassidy said.

"That we should cum on his face while he's getting fucked in the ass?" Chloe asked.

Both girls stood and moved to either side of Phil's head. Roman pulled his hair until he was looking straight up and his eyes darted from one wet pussy to the other. The girls masturbated furiously and Roman fucked him faster, driving every inch of his fat cock into Phil's ass with each thrust.

"Fuck...please, cum on my face," Phil begged like a complete whore. "Cum on my face while he fucks my ass."

Chloe looked back towards Roman, bent over, and laughed. "Your dick is dripping. You fucking love this, Phil. You're a cum dumpster and a cock whore, as it turns out. You fucking love getting pounded in the ass. You fucking love that Roman is using you like a whore. You fucking love that your ass is going to make his cock cum."

"Yes, I do!" Phil cried out. He wasn't sure what was true. He just knew that he was hugely aroused and he wanted to make the two girls masturbating next to him feel good.

"I'm close," Cassidy said. "Are you close?"

"Fuck yes," Chloe replied.

The girls masturbated furiously and both squatted so their pussies were closer to his face. Phil stared at their plump labia and their swollen clits and the juices leaking out of them. He listened to the sounds of sex and Roman's grunts and the moans of the gorgeous girls masturbating inches from his face.

Then, just as both girls screamed, Phil closed his eyes and two torrents of liquid hit his face. They soaked him completely. They drenched his hair. They filled his mouth and he swallowed eagerly. They came all over his face and he immediately ascended to a place of submissive bliss. He was being used for the pleasure of all three people in the room and he was high on it in a way he'd never been before.

"Oh...fuck!" Roman yelled as he buried his dick deep inside Phil, brought his hand down on his already reddened ass, and came hard.

"Look at that, you fucking cock whore," Cassidy said. "You just made a man nut while his dick was deep in your ass."

"You just did something most straight men will never do," Chloe added.

Cassidy laughed as she collapsed on the couch. "Oh, I don't think it's right to call him straight. Formerly straight, I think. That sounds right."

Roman pulled out of his ass and Chloe stepped back, removed the condom from his shaft, and quickly moved in front of Phil. "Tilt your head back. It's time for you to be a good cum dumpster."

Phil sat back on his knees and tilted his head back. Chloe upended the condom and poured the thick load into his mouth. The bitter, salty, delicious taste danced on his tongue and he stared up into his neighbor's eyes as she smiled.

Chloe offered Phil the used condom and said, "You can jerk off into this. You can cum, but you have to hold his load in your mouth until you do, and then you have to drink both loads. Do you understand?"

Phil nodded, took the used condom, and rolled it down his cock. Roman sat next to the girls on the couch and they all watched as Phil masturbated with a load of cum in his mouth. He came in just a handful of strokes. Of course he did. He was too turned on not to.

When he was finished, Phil poured his cum into his mouth and swallowed both loads.

"You can take a short break," Cassidy said. "I could use a drink, actually. How about you go make us all something? When you get back, you can get to work on sucking Roman's cock back to a nice erection so we can watch him fuck you again. Maybe we'll make you ride him this time. We'll teach you how a good whore does the work to make her man cum."

Phil nodded, got up, and headed for the kitchen to make everyone a drink. He wasn't sure how long they planned on using him, but he knew he was committed to doing what the girls wanted. He knew he was eager to be Chloe's toy, and Cassidy's toy too if it made the girls happy. Serving them was all that mattered.