Cuckolded by a Bridesmaid - Part 2

I highly recommend you click here to read part 1 if you haven't already. This part won't make much sense if you don't.

“Jeremy,” Audrey said as she opened the door. “I’m so glad you could come.”

“Hot damn,” Jeremy replied. “You look like you’re ready to go.”

“Damn right I am,” Audrey said. “Are you ready?”

The sounds of kissing and moaning soon reached Jonah’s ears. He leaned over to try and see down the short hallway that led to the door, but he was too far away for a good view. Instead, he remained there on his knees with his stiff cock wrapped in a condom he was unlikely to get a chance to use that night.

“Mmm, you really are ready,” Audrey said. “You’ll find a condom in the nightstand. Wrap yourself up and join me on the balcony.”

Audrey walked right past Jonah without looking at him and Jeremy headed for the nightstand and pulled out a condom.

“Hey man,” Jeremy said as he stripped. “Sucks that you couldn’t make it happen for her. Audrey is one hot fuck, man. I am telling you, when she gets in a mood like this she is out of this world. That pussy of hers is the most perfect thing. She gets soaking wet and somehow she’s still fucking tight, and damn does she love a hard fucking when she’s horny.”

Jonah couldn’t think of a single thing to say, so instead he looked away.

“What happened, man? Couldn’t get it up?” Jeremy asked.

“He got it up and then he lost it,” Audrey called out from the balcony. “He wasn’t man enough to fuck me. Classic nice guy bullshit. I offered him what every man says he wants and he went fucking soft. Now get out here and fuck me, Jeremy.”

Jeremy looked at Jonah, laughed, and rolled the condom down his sizable cock before confidently strutting out onto the balcony.

“Come closer, Jonah,” Audrey called out. “I want you to watch. I want you to see what you missed.”

Jonah knew he could have left, but he didn’t. For some reason he crawled towards the balcony and waited on his knees as he watched Jeremy slide into Audrey’s pussy from behind.

“Oh, fuck,” Audrey said. “Now that’s what I need. That’s why I’ve needed for hours. Fuck me, Jeremy. Fuck me hard.”

“With pleasure,” Jeremy said as he pulled out and slammed his cock back into Audrey’s slick pussy.

Jonah expected it to feel painful to watch, but it wasn’t. If anything, it was the opposite of painful. It was a surprisingly erotic thrill to see Jeremy’s cock sliding in and out of her slick pussy, out of the pussy that Jonah had prepared – as she’d put it – with his tongue. Audrey’s moans were loud and beautiful and the sound of their bodies slamming together over and over provided an arousing soundtrack, all of which left Jonah with a renewed stiffness between his legs.

“Harder,” Audrey begged. “Jeremy, fuck me harder. Pound my pussy.”

Jeremy put a hand on her shoulder and another on her lower back and fucked Audrey harder. He put genuine power into each of his thrusts and Jonah watched drops of Audrey’s juices fall to the concrete floor of the balcony, indicating a remarkable level of arousal on her part.

Then Audrey looked back at Jonah and smiled. “Nice guys don’t fuck like this,” she said. “That’s why you’re on your fucking knees watching while he’s inside me. That’s why you’re going to spend the rest of the night eating my pussy while that cock of yours misses out on the pleasure of fucking me. It’s too bad you’re a nice guy, Jonah.”

Jeremy buried his cock in Audrey’s pussy, looked over his shoulder, and smiled. “You had a shot at this, man. You had a shot and you blew it. How does that feel?”

They both seemed to be getting off on the idea that Jonah was watching, and perhaps that he was watching as someone who’d failed where Jeremy was no succeeding. He didn’t have an answer for Jeremy’s question, though, so he stayed silent.

That is, Jonah stayed silent until Audrey said, “Answer his question, Jonah. How does it feel to know that you could have had my pussy if you could have kept your dick hard?”

“It feels bad,” Jonah said.

“But your dick is hard now,” Jeremy replied. “Your dick has been hard since I walked in.”

Audrey laughed and added, “I think we know what kind of guy Jeremy is.”

Jeremy pulled out and slammed his cock into Audrey’s pussy with remarkable power, causing her to cry out. He smiled and did it again with his gaze locked on Jonah’s face. Then he pulled out, stepped aside, and said, “Get over here.”

Jonah hesitated, mostly because he wasn’t sure he wanted to commit to whatever Jeremy had in mind.

“What the fuck are you waiting for?” Jeremy said. “Get over here. Now!”

Compelled by feelings he didn’t quite understand, Jonah crawled out onto the balcony and stared at Audrey’s freshly-fucked pussy, which was still gaping from the thickness of Jeremy’s cock.

“Eat that fucking pussy,” Jeremy instructed. “Let me see you eat it before I fuck it again.”

“Do it,” Audrey added without giving Jonah a moment to think. “Do what he says.”

Jonah hesitated and Jeremy put a hand on the back of his head and pushed him hard between Audrey’s ass cheeks. His nose pressed against her anus and his lips against her labia. He extended his tongue and licked as they both wanted him to. He tasted the latex of Jeremy’s condom. He tasted the sweet juices that were still dripping from Audrey’s pussy. He tasted the sex they’d had, the sex that he could have had if only he’d been able to stay hard.

Jeremy grabbed a handful of Jonah’s hair and pulled back. “How does that pussy taste?” he asked.

“Good,” Jonah answered.

“You know what? Let’s take this party inside,” Jeremy said. “I wanna have a little fun with him.”

Audrey and Jeremy walked into the room and Jonah watched the beautiful redhead kiss the man that had just fucked her so hard. She stroked his cock as he played with her perky, milky white breasts. He pinched and pulled on her nipples and she moaned into his mouth like it was the hottest thing in the world. She seemed to be up for anything, which Jonah knew made her something of a dream girl.

They seemed occupied with a new round of foreplay, so Jonah took a moment to assess his situation. They weren’t keeping him in the hotel room and he certainly could have left at any time, but he kept choosing to stay. He chose to eat Audrey’s pussy after Jeremy had fucked her. He chose to tell Jeremy it had tasted good. He chose to stay when they both laughed at him a little. Not only that, but his cock remained stiff throughout. Arousal hummed through his body. Jonah couldn’t deny that he was enjoying himself, even if each and every little thing they made him do seemed utterly insane.

Armed with a desire to go along with whatever insanity was about to unfold in Audrey’s hotel room, Jonah crawled off the balcony and towards the couple kissing and fondling each other by the bed. He stopped just short of them and watched Jeremy’s strong hands grasp Audrey’s ass as she sucked on his tongue and stroked his latex-wrapped cock.

Audrey finally looked down at him and smiled. “Jeremy thinks you deserve a 69,” she said. “Does that sound like fun?”

“Yes,” Jonah answered with a vigorous nod.

“You’re on the bottom,” Audrey said. “So get in the bed.”

Jonah hurriedly crawled onto the mattress and rolled onto his back with his head nearly hanging off the foot of the bed. Audrey crawled onto her hands and knees on top of him and he moaned as she wrapped her fingers around his cock and stroked him through the condom. He felt the slippery latex move up and down his shaft and when she leaned down and kissed his thighs Jonah thought he might be moments away from enjoying a blowjob.

“You’re so hard,” she said before laughing softly.

“Do you wanna give him a little bit of pussy?” Jeremy asked.

“Fuck no,” Audrey replied. “He doesn’t deserve pussy. He had his chance and he blew it. You deserve my pussy. You showed up. You fucked me like I needed to be fucked. You’re going to keep fucking me for as long as I need it. He deserves to watch, and I’m pretty sure he likes to watch, whether he’s willing to admit it or not.”

Jeremy stepped up and rubbed the head of his cock over Audrey’s pussy lips as Jonah watched from just a few inches away.

“How’s the view,” Audrey asked as she released his cock from her grasp and squeezed his balls.

“It’s beautiful,” Jonah replied.

Audrey laughed. “Of course it is.”

“You want me to fuck her?” Jeremy asked. “You want to watch me fuck her perfect cunt?”

Audrey stroked Jonah’s cock again and he moaned before answering, “Yes, I want to watch you fuck her. Fuck, please.”

Jeremy’s cock slowly filled Audrey’s pussy before pulling out. Jonah marveled at the beauty of her lips clinging to his shaft while he moved in and out of her body. He marveled at the sounds of extreme wetness generated by the penetration. He marveled at the sheer beauty of witnessing sex from such a close angle.

“Harder, please,” Audrey said. “Fuck me harder.”

Jeremy delivered, picking up the pace and power of his thrusts as Audrey wrapped her fingers tightly around Jonah’s shaft and stopped stroking him. It seemed that she didn’t want anything to distract her from the pleasures of taking a pounding.

Juices dripped out of her pussy and onto Jeremy’s face. He ran his tongue over his lips to soak them up and savored the taste of her pussy as his cock throbbed in her hand.

“Lick my clit,” Audrey demanded. “Jonah, lick my fucking clit. Right now.”

Jonah extended his tongue but he wasn’t quite close enough to get to her clit. He lifted his head from the bed and elicited a moan as he found her sex organ and gently massaged it. Jeremy’s balls brushed against his forehead with every thrust, but Jonah didn’t stop.

“Is he making you feel good?” Jeremy asked. “Is he licking your clit and making you feel good?”

“Fuck yes,” Audrey answered. “Now fuck me harder. Pound my fucking pussy and make me cum.”

Jeremy fucked her harder and Jonah made sure his tongue continued to massage her throbbing clit. He wanted to play his part in her orgasm even if he wasn’t going to be the one fucking her. He got his wish, too, as Audrey’s screams of pleasure soon filled the bedroom. The flow of juices from her pussy increased, leaving Jonah’s face covered in slick wetness as he slowed his rhythmic licking while Jeremy pushed every inch of his cock inside her and held it there.

“God damn!” Audrey cried out before crawling forward and rolling off of Jonah.

Jeremy’s cock slipped out of her pussy and fell onto Jonah’s face. Audrey’s laugher filled the room as Jonah rolled his head to the side, which left Jeremy’s stiff, condom-wrapped cock resting on his cheek.

Audrey crawled closer, straddled Jonah, and laid on top of him. She took Jeremy’s cock in her hand and stroked him slowly as his balls rubbed against Jonah’s head.

“You know what would be hot?” Audrey asked.

“What?” Jeremy replied.

“If you put your balls in his mouth,” Audrey said.

Jeremy laughed, grabbed Jonah’s head and adjusted it so he was looking upwards, and set his big balls over Jonah’s lips. He kept them closed, though. He felt the hot, sweaty, wrinkled, hairy sack against his nose, lips, and chin, but he wasn’t going to suck on it.

Then Audrey started moving her hips and rubbing her pussy all over Jonah’s cock, which was still wrapped tightly in a condom. She teased his shaft and then he felt the tip slip inside her. He moaned. He couldn’t help it. He was only half an inch inside Audrey, but it felt stunningly good. The moan was a mistake, for the moment he opened his mouth it was filled with Jeremy’s balls.

“That’s it,” Audrey said softly as she continued to stroke Jeremy’s big cock and tease Jonah with her pussy. “Suck on his balls. Fuck, suck on his balls and help him cum.”

Jonah caved. He wasn’t sure why, but he didn’t want to disappoint Audrey. He wanted to suck Jeremy’s balls because it’s what she wanted him to do. It was fucking crazy, but he did it. He sucked on the big, sweaty, hairy balls in his mouth. He did something he’d never considered before, something he never would have thought he’d do, and he did it eagerly.

“Fuck, you two make a good team,” Jeremy said. “You’re gonna make me cum. Fucking hell.”

“Do you hear that?” Audrey said in seductive voice. “Your ball sucking is making him feel good, Jonah. Keep it up. Suck those sweaty nuts. Suck those sweaty nuts and make him cum and I’ll give you a reward. I promise. I’ll give you an incredible reward.”

Jonah sucked harder as he thought of Audrey taking the full length of his cock inside her. He couldn’t imagine what other kind of reward she’d offer. That was the only thing that made any sense.

Jeremy’s balls jumped in his mouth and a moment later his moans filled the room. His balls jumped over and over. He was cumming. He was flooding the condom with his seed and Jonah was about to claim his reward.

“Was that good?” Audrey asked as she gently peeled the condom from Jeremy’s cock.

“It was incredible,” he answered before stepping away.

Audrey looked at Jonah, smiled, and asked, “Are you ready for your reward?”

“I am,” he said.

“Close your eyes,” Audrey instructed. “Close your eyes so you can enjoy it.”

Jonah closed his eyes and Audrey rubbed her pussy over the tip of his cock. She took the tip inside her over and over, but she refused to give him more, driving him mad with lust in the process.

“Audrey, please,” Jonah said.

“You’re so desperate,” Audrey replied. “I like that. I love that.”

Jonah felt her pussy swallow his cock. His mouth opened and a long, low moan escaped. He felt something against his lips. A strange taste hit his tongue. His eyes shot open and he saw Audrey holding the open end of the condom against his lips. The cum poured down the shaft and into his mouth as she slowly moved her hips over his cock. Jonah nearly gagged as the full taste of Jeremy’s cum registered on his taste buds, but he was inside Audrey, he was fucking the beautiful redhead, and he didn’t want that to stop.

“That’s good,” she said. “Take his load while you enjoy my pussy.” Audrey moved her hips just a little, offering him a hint of pleasure as the rest of Jeremy’s load poured into his mouth. She tossed the condom aside, smiled, and said, “Now swallow his cum.”

Jonah closed his mouth and swallowed. The taste was horrifyingly bad, but he did it. He did what she wanted. He earned his reward.

“Show me,” Audrey said. “Show me you swallowed.” Jonah opened his mouth to show that he’d consumed Jeremy’s cum and she lifted her pussy from his cock and crawled forward to sit across his chest.

“Wait, what are you doing?” he asked.

“You didn’t think I was actually going to let you fuck me, did you?” she asked.

“Yes, that’s what I thought,” Jonah answered.

Jeremy laughed heartily from across the room and Jonah felt a deep sense of frustration build inside him.

“Oh, Jonah, no,” Audrey said. “I told you, you had your chance and you blew it. You don’t get to fuck me. You’re lucky I let you feel my pussy at all. No, your reward was Jeremy’s cum. Your reward was getting to drink the load of a real man, not some pathetic nice guy that couldn’t get hard when a beautiful girl offered her pussy for his pleasure.”

“That’s not fair,” Jonah said.

Audrey threw her head back and laughed, with Jeremy joining in soon after. “I know it’s not,” she said. “But life’s not fair, is it?” She crawled forward and dropped her pussy onto Jonah’s mouth. “But, I am going to make you cum before the night is over. You’re going to worship my pussy a great deal before that happens, though. Even that’s not fair, but again, I don’t give a damn about fair. You can leave if you’d like, but I think we both know you’re going to stay as long as you can because the chance to eat a pussy like mine doesn’t come along all that often, does it?”

Jonah couldn’t really answer with her pussy smothering his face, but he didn’t bother trying. Instead, he ate her pussy like he knew she wanted, for she was right. He wasn’t going anywhere. He was going to stay as long as she wanted, because even if she didn’t offer an orgasm it would be a night well spent. After all, a girl as beautiful as Audrey didn’t come along very often and Jonah almost never got to spend time with a pussy like hers.

“Can you go again?” Audrey asked as she moved her hips over Jonah’s face, smothering him in her slippery juices.

“Sure,” Jeremy responded.

“Good,” she said. “I think our ball sucking boy here would like to put his mouth to use in helping us a second time.”

Jeremy laughed and Jonah was a little embarrassed that his cock throbbed at the suggestion that he’d end up sucking balls again. He wasn’t going to turn down the chance to do so, though. Clearly, his body wanted it. There was no denying that, so he wasn’t going to fight it. He was just going to enjoy every minute of his night with the wildest girl he’d ever met.

The End.