Mortius / Nerdy Prudes Must Die | Bully the Bully thru Act1 Finale

I will NEVER get over Jon's phsyical acting AND vocals in this. It can be awful to sing while sitting and leaning back bc it compresses your diaphragm, but he hits that IM NOT A LOSER so gorgeously. And he really acts and looks so terrified. That fall was AWESOME

Corvid

2026-02-07 02:44:28 +0000 UTC

The fact that Mortius DIDN'T go back to appreciate Jon's belt in "I'M NOT A LOSER" killlllled me

Marco Jones

2026-02-02 07:03:55 +0000 UTC

What a great ending! Weird of them to put a whole hour of credits though.. But oh well 🤷

Bub

2026-01-16 20:40:20 +0000 UTC

Just realized how much Jeff Blim energy Max is giving. Also, something about the absolute disgust on Kim's face duing Go Go Nighthawks sends me every time

Evan Moran

2026-01-14 23:28:19 +0000 UTC

Ah yes, I forgot npmd has an actual ending 🙈

jackie jasmine

2026-01-13 21:36:16 +0000 UTC

Yas I really love the Animation they did! Unsure on what Spoilers there are however as I don't see any in the Animation

DPMAN

2026-01-13 15:12:13 +0000 UTC

Hey Mortius, I loved your reaction to the show so far and I'm leaving this hear since its an animation for the Second half of "Nerdy Prudes Must Die" the song, it does contain slight spoilers for some things so I would recommend watching it After finishing the show, but I think it would be really cool anyways. It's about 2-3 minutes and the artist is ThirdChildArt https://vm.tiktok.com/ZNRhHuvgY/

Rex Saltus

2026-01-13 00:24:41 +0000 UTC

i'm FEENING for more

Max

2026-01-12 19:33:55 +0000 UTC

5:03 "I'm desperately going to need a fourth show across the hatchetverse" Mortius nightmare time is calling your name!! /lighthearted

S.E.W.

2026-01-11 16:22:36 +0000 UTC

Maybe Richie doesn't actually sweat too much biologically. I bet he sweats because he wears three outfits at once. When he's telling Peter to go for Ruth 'cause she's thirsty, there are direct references to The Guy. Melissa asks Paul if he wants to join the company baseball league. Paul and Peter say 'Yeah, I don't want to, though.' Ted and Richie both say to their friends 'You're effing useless, Paul/Pete.' I recommend the soundtrack version of Go Nighthawks! for the amazing harmonies between Curt and Corey. Peak Jock Friendship. Your Nat 1 for Zeke the Nighthawk is a lot of fun, but Max is only angry at a select few people and the football team pretty much did whatever he said. :P Wish he'd gone back to his house and dealt with his dad. Call him a cuck for once, Max! I'd cheer for that. When Richie says 'Eff Clivedale, eff 'em straight to hell!' he's directly quoting Paul and I think that's sweet.

Kory Misun

2026-01-11 10:09:45 +0000 UTC

It's amazing and sad that he said it with so much confidence. He really believed in himself, however briefly.

Kory Misun

2026-01-11 09:58:39 +0000 UTC

Honestly once the TGWDLM revamp comes out on Youtube, Mortius should react to it and see the new changes lol

Reshia Winfield

2026-01-11 09:56:14 +0000 UTC

I remember seeing someone describe Dirty Girl as "unfortunately a banger" which is so accurate imo

oh no elizabeth

2026-01-11 04:22:24 +0000 UTC

-referring to the line about Pete looking like the Homeless Guy- “Is that a reference to TGWDLM?” Oh… oh, Mortius… there’s supplemental material to watch

Daniel Wilson

2026-01-11 01:55:18 +0000 UTC

Since you saw it live how effective was the remote door slam Max does during NPMD in person? I feel like it's kind of lack luster in the recording and the real impact is lost. I imagine that being such a cool thing to experience irl in the theatre! Did they only slam that one door or all of them?

Llexica

2026-01-10 22:25:51 +0000 UTC

I was thinking that wondering if it's following the lord's in black. Is the colours making the lord's that are part of it?

Katie Young

2026-01-10 20:17:00 +0000 UTC

She's also mentioned in Black Friday! She's Tim's usual babysitter in that one.

איתי קורן

2026-01-10 17:58:20 +0000 UTC

“it’s not the musicals that invoke the colors, it’s the forces behind hatchetfield” is an A+ fan theory and I will be adopting it now.

Ink Inc

2026-01-10 17:21:07 +0000 UTC

Ig but That’s not really how spoilers work. I mean, I didn’t forget my first time watching it + building tension is just as effective a twist.

Ink Inc

2026-01-10 17:08:42 +0000 UTC

Doesn't it sound familiar? Pete: "Yeah...I don't want to though.." Richie: "..You're fucking useless Pete!" In another universe Paul: "Yeah..I don't want to though.." ----separate scene--- Ted: "...You're fucking useless Paul!" How the tables have turned!!

KriszGamer00

2026-01-10 16:50:53 +0000 UTC

The hard commitment to the bit is really great halfway in I was like wow you usually break by now

D. Sparrow

2026-01-10 13:59:58 +0000 UTC

Act 1 ended with the "It's Nightmare Time" leitmotif, that we first heard in TGWDLM (especially in the song "Not Your Seed"), in some parts of Black Friday's background tracks, and in Nightmare Time's opening theme. It's a nice touch! EDIT Act 2 has a totally different vibe from the rest of the Hatchetfield musicals. It feels like a story from Nightmare Time finally clawed and scraped its way into the more light-hearted musicals. So if you're even a little curious about what Nightmare Time is like, the rest of the show could have passed as one of those stories.

Sunayama

2026-01-10 13:56:24 +0000 UTC

Paused in the correct place during the start of bury the bully because you really need to process that so you can have your full attention dedicated to "we're gonna hack all his limbs of piano slam" because that's yet another processing session all on it's own

D. Sparrow

2026-01-10 13:38:11 +0000 UTC

That and all the clicking haha

Dave Ballinger

2026-01-10 13:34:00 +0000 UTC

It was so special! I was there too

Dave Ballinger

2026-01-10 13:27:49 +0000 UTC

can't really blame him for that, he's an analysis channel so he's gonna try connecting the dots to plot threads that get thrown out there. Plus he's got the benefit/curse of watching through YouTube compared to the live audience and as a side effect: control over video playback lol

Chris

2026-01-10 13:23:01 +0000 UTC

Ahhh you kinda spoiled yourself by going back to the beginning for the Crime Scene. The Lang’s put it at the beginning so that you would forget and get to love him before he was killed.

Dave Ballinger

2026-01-10 13:13:24 +0000 UTC

"They're walking through the audience? Interesting." Way to forget one of the funniest jokes from tgwdlm and all the instances of characters walking through the audience in black Friday /lh

D. Sparrow

2026-01-10 13:13:20 +0000 UTC

In regards to Dirty Girl, I recommend a few more listens because it’s a genuinely good song and a bop to listen to

Dave Ballinger

2026-01-10 12:49:56 +0000 UTC

Omg part 2 so soon! This is amazing

Dave Ballinger

2026-01-10 12:39:44 +0000 UTC

There is a fourth show that is across the hatchet verse. It's called Nightmare Time

kayla ling

2026-01-10 12:11:06 +0000 UTC

I'm glad you like the lighting. The lighting is cool :) The lighting is very cool :)

erin quilmer

2026-01-10 11:57:43 +0000 UTC

Damn. You're supposed to forget about Ritchie being the first victim, but you went back. That's sorta disappointing :/

Bretton B

2026-01-10 11:41:01 +0000 UTC

Also unfortunately it doesn’t look like Gatsby tour is going that far west. All EST and CST time zone areas.

Jennee

2026-01-10 10:40:30 +0000 UTC

every time i hear that “i want you to repeat after me” i’m transported back to may 2024 🥹 in starkid’s london concert that year, jeff blim sang npmd and we the audience filled in richie’s parts. it was so cool. i still get chills a little when i hear that line in either context.

fizzycolalizzie

2026-01-10 10:30:29 +0000 UTC

This is actually super interesting, because it shows Max controls what happens in the audience too, just like after Pete's song he yells at the audience to shut up.

TiaMattia2

2026-01-10 09:53:32 +0000 UTC

And is Nightmare Time's opening music

Corvacks

2026-01-10 09:47:52 +0000 UTC

Hmm I just the realized the "cool" part of Bully the Bully is probably a reference to Cool from West Side. How fun!

SummerSoulsandStars

2026-01-10 08:33:59 +0000 UTC

There’s another reason everyone hollers about Pete looking like the Homeless Man but it’s a spoiler for nightmare time if you ever decide you want to check it out. So. I shan’t say.

Erikka Lynn

2026-01-10 07:47:41 +0000 UTC

I hope you at least watch Nightmare Time on your own. And then maybe make a short video with your thoughts at the end. Could be a fun Patreon exclusive video too?

Mikayla Prushik

2026-01-10 06:49:01 +0000 UTC

yeah that act 1 finale is WILD. i was lucky enough to see it in person and jesus christ was it weird to go to intermission and get snacks while still reeling from that last song lol

fromhigherthings

2026-01-10 06:15:34 +0000 UTC

Favorite note from Jon and Jeff’s livestream of the show: The snaps in Bully/Bury the Bully come on Beats 1 and 3 instead of 2 and 4 so even the attempts to be “cool” with the snaps are off.

Jennee

2026-01-10 05:35:25 +0000 UTC

I don't know about anyone else but the bury the body song always sounded like a self-aware attempt by the character to sweep the situation under the rug to me. Like she knew she was in a musical and she used the song to cover up her actions.

Somedude Watchintv

2026-01-10 05:17:45 +0000 UTC

Hey Grace Chastity may be a psychopath but at least she’s nice to Bill at Church.

Isla Sullivan

2026-01-10 04:13:40 +0000 UTC

I love that this show wraps act 1 where it begins and sees through the plan they made and then act 2 is the “after”, it reminds me of into the woods just a little bit of getting to happily ever after, like you were talking about with everything being happy, and then act 2 having all of the results/consequences of what getting to that happily ever after took

Kat Sheridan

2026-01-10 04:02:47 +0000 UTC

Not really. When the cops say, "First the Jagerman boy, now this?" They're referring to the fact that he's been missing for two weeks, not that they know he's dead yet.

Gabriel the Sorcerer

2026-01-10 03:41:51 +0000 UTC

And if you need a good reason to watch the TGWDLM remount when it goes up on YouTube, Will Branner (Max) plays Professor Hidgens in this version and it just shows Max wasn’t even him at full power

Sarah Rodrigues

2026-01-10 03:35:04 +0000 UTC

18:00 now that I think about it, there's a small plot hole in NPMD specifically about when the bodies are found (more specifically which is found first)

Chris

2026-01-10 03:34:14 +0000 UTC

ALSO since the lighting doesn’t make it clear and the captions incorrectly identify that sound, the noise in the second verse of the title song isn’t thunder cracking, it’s Max slamming the doors at the top of the stairs in Richie’s face

Sarah Rodrigues

2026-01-10 03:32:26 +0000 UTC

And also a specific one called “The Tragedy of Max Jägerman” that will 1000% vindicate your color theory but if you don’t watch NMT first then it won’t be in the way you’re expecting

Sarah Rodrigues

2026-01-10 03:29:31 +0000 UTC

Act 1 and Act 2 of this one are such different vibes. It's such a long set up, but it's really worth it to be endeared to these characters before they start dying. I think that it starts with Richie getting discovered and goes back is a good way to show the audience that horror stuff is coming I'm excited for the next episode because that has my favorite song. I hope that you're hooked enough that you come back to finish it quickly (don't burn yourself out)

Allison Watts

2026-01-10 03:24:29 +0000 UTC

Love seeing all the tidbits you pick up on that so many other reactors don't - all the interrogation of the meaning of the color symbolism, the choreography, that level of attention to detail pays off soooo much with a show like NPMD and it makes it much more entertaining to follow along with a reaction when I can tell the reactor is as keyed in as I am

Samantha Casimir

2026-01-10 03:17:28 +0000 UTC

If you’re okay with a couple NMT episodes being spoiled then when you finish this I would recommend checking out on your own time (perhaps in the background while working or cooking or something like that), the video essay “Grace Chasity and the Horrors of Purity” by fencecollapsed, it really delves well into Grace and everything she represents. If they ever release the rights to this show and I get the chance to play her that video would be so important to how I would approach it.

Sarah Rodrigues

2026-01-10 03:11:18 +0000 UTC

A few notes about Nerdy Prudes Must Die (The song) When max flicks his hands as Richie is running up the stairs the theatre doors slam shut showing more of that power that Max holds he can literally shut a door from the stage. Also that little piano cue at the end of the song is a motif that plays throughout the hatchetfield series. It comes from Not Your Seed in TGWDLM when Alice sings, “Look what happens, Nightmare Time.”

Jayden Callaghan

2026-01-10 03:06:07 +0000 UTC

You should check out the couple of like 30 second animations that people have made for the ending of the song, Nerdy Prudes Must Die .

SleepingNight

2026-01-10 02:58:32 +0000 UTC

The exchange between Pete and Richie regarding Ruth is also a callback to TGWDLM; “I don’t want to tho” is Paul’s response to Melissa’s offer to join the office softball team and the second part is also a reversal of Joey and Jon’s roles in that show, when Paul is explaining the events of La Dee Dah Dah Day to the office: “Like a flash mob? “Yeah, right? I mean what else could it have been?” “Well did you get a video of it?” “No…” “…You’re fucking useless, Paul.”

Sarah Rodrigues

2026-01-10 02:53:44 +0000 UTC

The fact there's the other students in the background when Richie dies is such a cool thing, cause yes, they were all there, but he was alone when he was attacked

Caryn Smith

2026-01-10 02:51:30 +0000 UTC

The Homeless Guy reference has layers, both to TGWDLM but also to the Nightmare Time episode “Time Bastard” (and technically its preceding title “Forever and Always” too but that’s just bc of how those two connect) I won’t elaborate beyond that but if you haven’t entirely eliminated the possibility of putting NMT in a slot in the future then that’s the episode I’d be looking forward to the most in the event you started it one day

Sarah Rodrigues

2026-01-10 02:49:25 +0000 UTC

the delivery on jon's "I'M NOT A LOSER" has given me chills every time that i've heard it since this show was released

ariona leilani

2026-01-10 02:49:13 +0000 UTC

Hey, Mortius, remember what you say about a kind of connection between Grace and Max's movements. Just keep that in mind and you progress through the show.

Kris Shepard

2026-01-10 02:49:01 +0000 UTC

The final 7 notes of Act 1 actually is the main melody of Nightmare Time. It essentially symbolises the supernatural core of Hatchetfield and is a scathing reference to transition straight into Act 2. It also hints that, for people who have been watching Nightmare Time and reading between the lines. Things might be a little bit different from the previous 2 shows...

FryTheFish

2026-01-10 02:47:28 +0000 UTC

I do hope that (eventually, no pressure) you get around to Nightmare Time. One of my personal favourite Hatchetfield characters only appears in that series and it goes a lot more in depth with the lore

Addy0302

2026-01-10 02:40:33 +0000 UTC

I'm so happy to be a patreon subscriber right now...I can NOT wait for more

Skye Alexander

2026-01-10 02:38:39 +0000 UTC

Im sure you noticed it, but in the background the singers are singing the "cool as I think i am" motif at Richie's death. This motif is very very important, and this is the second most prominent showing of it AND one of the best moments in the show

Lydia

2026-01-10 02:36:22 +0000 UTC

My favorite part is "Cooler than I think I am" in the background of Nerdy Prudes must die at the end. Literal chills every time

Jacob Morton_

2026-01-10 02:35:13 +0000 UTC

Your color theory/thought process is so fascinating. Very well thought out.

logicaldreamer

2026-01-10 02:23:45 +0000 UTC

I am so happy you’re finally reacting to NPMD as it is not only my fav Starkid show but also one of my fav shows ever. I know you mentioned not watching nightmare time but if you do I highly recommend watching Abstinence Camp as it delves deeper into the relationships of Pete as Steph as well as who Grace is as a character. One of the things I love about NPMD as a song is the “I’m not a loser” because not only is it referenced in cool as I think I am, but also the double meaning of the word. While he may not be consider himself a loser in cool kids standard, he fell into the second definition of loser because of what he lost.

Flynn The Dance Teacher

2026-01-10 02:19:02 +0000 UTC

This is genuinely one of my favorites and I'm so glad this came out so quickly! Cannot wait for you to get to act 2, cause you'll get a lot of lore near the end of the musical. Won't tell you what the lore is, just smth to look forward to :) Also Bully/Bury the Bully are my favorites from this musical and just genuinely fun songs to sing :3

Faerin

2026-01-10 02:14:49 +0000 UTC

Richie: “I love this school! I love being alive 😃” Half of the audience: “NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO” Sends me every time The show does such a good job at making you forget about Richie’s death JUST long enough for you to get attached

Lindsey

2026-01-10 02:08:45 +0000 UTC

Such a shame that this show only has one act but it’s so refreshing to see more Starkid productions with happy endings! Don’t know if I like the implications of a show ending on the moral of “don’t feel bad that you killed a man because everything’s objectively better now” but I’m so glad the characters go on to win the Big Game and are able to enjoy the rest of high school (me, happily in denial)

Mafidon

2026-01-10 02:03:20 +0000 UTC

Ruth really does surprise me during this chunk of the show. After she found out that Pete got beaten up, she's not afraid to tell Steph off, or speak her mind in general. She might get bullied at school, but her effs to give have run out. Because both Max and Ruth say 'Watch some prn, you'll see!' and because he's really sweet to her in the Waylon Place, I've developed a Max/Ruth fondness, lord help me. They have the potential to be really sweet, and if anyone can help her with her deodorant and confidence problems, it's Max Jagerman. It's such a shame, because he was really nice for a bit, and then, well... But that might just be the beers. I don't know why Bean School is excellent, but I always cringe out of my skin at that part. Pete's got a great point after the two week skip, but my mind goes to 'Imagine how happy you'd all be if Max hadn't died, got emancipated from his bully-menace of a dad and turned a corner?' Sadly, Hatchetfield doesn't do Happy Endings, there's always a major shakeup and the world is changed forever. In terms of Deadly Sins, I think Guy had... I don't know yet (Commenters, please help), Black Friday had a mix of Greed and Gluttony, and Nerdy Prudes centers around Wrath and Lust. Lots of vengeful plans, lots of teens who can't calm down. I'll need to keep an eye on the people bathed in certain colors, 'cause I've got a theory brewing. PS, at the end of NPMD, recognize the last few notes? Not Your Seed. 'Look what happens, nightmare time!'

Kory Misun

2026-01-10 01:48:07 +0000 UTC

Random tidbit from seeing the show live, Richie Naruto ran down the stairs when they went through the audience.

Lindsey

2026-01-10 01:45:14 +0000 UTC

The one moment Max was endearing. </3

Kory Misun

2026-01-10 01:44:16 +0000 UTC

Hopefully he’ll watch NMT on his own time at the very least because respectfully something tells me at least 80% of his lore questions during this show will be able to be answered by that series 😂

Lindsey

2026-01-10 01:42:50 +0000 UTC

Fun fact in case nobody mentioned it yet-- In TGWDLM, grace chastity is mentioned by the father character when he talks about his daughter and his difficult relationship with her. He says so I said "why can't you date someone like grace chastity? She's a good girl." And she said "GRACY CHASTITY IS A NERDY PRUDE" and I said "one, I said someone LIKE grace chastity. And two, that's not a very nice thing to say" and she said "YOU JUST WISH GRACE WAS YOUR DAUGHTER" and I said "WELL AT LEAST SHES NICE TO ME AT CHURCH" and that was the last thing I said to her. Oh my God. That argument was the reason she ran to deb. IM the reason she's in this mess.

[Reacted]

2026-01-10 01:40:28 +0000 UTC

Mortius - "I'm going to need a 4th show to connect it all." Also Mortius - "I'm not going to watch Nightmare Time." I kid! (Mostly.) I understand that it's a huge time commitment. That said, if you want to get interconnected stories and learn more about the lore, that's where you need to go. I agree with what I've seen a lot of comments say to you, that even if you don't react to it, you should take the time to watch it on your own. It's absolutely worth it. As someone who is obsessed with lore and theorizing, I've watched through all of both seasons multiple times just to catch new things every time. I would absolutely love to see you react to them, but even if you can't do that, I hope you get a chance to watch them at some point.

Gabriel the Sorcerer

2026-01-10 01:39:09 +0000 UTC

richie saying pete looks like the homeless guy hits so much harder with nightmare time! if you plan on watching them in your own time, i definitely recommend watching time bastard, and then coming back to this.

bigbraveboop

2026-01-10 01:36:01 +0000 UTC

Yes… Joey playing the homeless man in TGWDLM is the only reason why everyone hollered…. The one and only reason 🙂

Lindsey

2026-01-10 01:33:59 +0000 UTC

I am no longer capable of saying “skeleton” in a normal way thanks to this show

Lindsey

2026-01-10 01:31:37 +0000 UTC

HERE IT IS!!! the best song of the musical in this one! IM SO EXCITED

Theking

2026-01-10 01:22:33 +0000 UTC

NPMD is basically “local 18-year-old experiences sexual attraction one (1) time: man dead, several traumatized”

Mafidon

2026-01-10 01:21:52 +0000 UTC

it's been years and i still regularly reference the cool beans part of bully the bully, it's in my head always, keep the beans beans the cool keep the beans the cool keep the beans BEAN SCHOOL

ariona leilani

2026-01-10 01:17:45 +0000 UTC

I like that we're getting these so quickly

Nola Scott

2026-01-10 01:17:39 +0000 UTC

This came out exactly as I finished the first part lol

Parsley

2026-01-10 01:17:21 +0000 UTC

Commenting before watching. Am I wrong for having bully the bully and bury the bully as my favorite songs? I love a good reprise

CollinZcruel

2026-01-10 01:16:16 +0000 UTC

omg i'm about to go to the gym and u best ur ass i'm watching this while on the treadmill im so EXCITED AAAAAAAAAA

ariona leilani

2026-01-10 01:16:03 +0000 UTC

Nerdy Prudes Must Die | Bully the Bully thru Act1 Finale

Comments

I will NEVER get over Jon's phsyical acting AND vocals in this. It can be awful to sing while sitting and leaning back bc it compresses your diaphragm, but he hits that IM NOT A LOSER so gorgeously. And he really acts and looks so terrified. That fall was AWESOME

The fact that Mortius DIDN'T go back to appreciate Jon's belt in "I'M NOT A LOSER" killlllled me

What a great ending! Weird of them to put a whole hour of credits though.. But oh well 🤷

Just realized how much Jeff Blim energy Max is giving. Also, something about the absolute disgust on Kim's face duing Go Go Nighthawks sends me every time

Ah yes, I forgot npmd has an actual ending 🙈

Yas I really love the Animation they did! Unsure on what Spoilers there are however as I don't see any in the Animation

i'm FEENING for more

5:03 "I'm desperately going to need a fourth show across the hatchetverse" Mortius nightmare time is calling your name!! /lighthearted

It's amazing and sad that he said it with so much confidence. He really believed in himself, however briefly.

Honestly once the TGWDLM revamp comes out on Youtube, Mortius should react to it and see the new changes lol

I remember seeing someone describe Dirty Girl as "unfortunately a banger" which is so accurate imo

-referring to the line about Pete looking like the Homeless Guy- “Is that a reference to TGWDLM?” Oh… oh, Mortius… there’s supplemental material to watch

Since you saw it live how effective was the remote door slam Max does during NPMD in person? I feel like it's kind of lack luster in the recording and the real impact is lost. I imagine that being such a cool thing to experience irl in the theatre! Did they only slam that one door or all of them?

I was thinking that wondering if it's following the lord's in black. Is the colours making the lord's that are part of it?

She's also mentioned in Black Friday! She's Tim's usual babysitter in that one.

“it’s not the musicals that invoke the colors, it’s the forces behind hatchetfield” is an A+ fan theory and I will be adopting it now.

Ig but That’s not really how spoilers work. I mean, I didn’t forget my first time watching it + building tension is just as effective a twist.

Doesn't it sound familiar? Pete: "Yeah...I don't want to though.." Richie: "..You're fucking useless Pete!" *In another universe* Paul: "Yeah..I don't want to though.." ----separate scene--- Ted: "...You're fucking useless Paul!" How the tables have turned!!

The hard commitment to the bit is really great halfway in I was like wow you usually break by now

Paused in the correct place during the start of bury the bully because you really need to process that so you can have your full attention dedicated to "we're gonna hack all his limbs of *piano slam*" because that's yet another processing session all on it's own

That and all the clicking haha

It was so special! I was there too

can't really blame him for that, he's an analysis channel so he's gonna try connecting the dots to plot threads that get thrown out there. Plus he's got the benefit/curse of watching through YouTube compared to the live audience and as a side effect: control over video playback lol

Ahhh you kinda spoiled yourself by going back to the beginning for the Crime Scene. The Lang’s put it at the beginning so that you would forget and get to love him before he was killed.

"They're walking through the audience? Interesting." Way to forget one of the funniest jokes from tgwdlm and all the instances of characters walking through the audience in black Friday /lh

In regards to Dirty Girl, I recommend a few more listens because it’s a genuinely good song and a bop to listen to

Omg part 2 so soon! This is amazing

There is a fourth show that is across the hatchet verse. It's called Nightmare Time

I'm glad you like the lighting. The lighting is cool :) The lighting is very cool :)

Damn. You're supposed to forget about Ritchie being the first victim, but you went back. That's sorta disappointing :/

Also unfortunately it doesn’t look like Gatsby tour is going that far west. All EST and CST time zone areas.

every time i hear that “i want you to repeat after me” i’m transported back to may 2024 🥹 in starkid’s london concert that year, jeff blim sang npmd and we the audience filled in richie’s parts. it was so cool. i still get chills a little when i hear that line in either context.

This is actually super interesting, because it shows Max controls what happens in the audience too, just like after Pete's song he yells at the audience to shut up.

And is Nightmare Time's opening music

Hmm I just the realized the "cool" part of Bully the Bully is probably a reference to Cool from West Side. How fun!

There’s another reason everyone hollers about Pete looking like the Homeless Man but it’s a spoiler for nightmare time if you ever decide you want to check it out. So. I shan’t say.

I hope you at least watch Nightmare Time on your own. And then maybe make a short video with your thoughts at the end. Could be a fun Patreon exclusive video too?

yeah that act 1 finale is WILD. i was lucky enough to see it in person and jesus christ was it weird to go to intermission and get snacks while still reeling from that last song lol

Favorite note from Jon and Jeff’s livestream of the show: The snaps in Bully/Bury the Bully come on Beats 1 and 3 instead of 2 and 4 so even the attempts to be “cool” with the snaps are off.

I don't know about anyone else but the bury the body song always sounded like a self-aware attempt by the character to sweep the situation under the rug to me. Like she knew she was in a musical and she used the song to cover up her actions.

Hey Grace Chastity may be a psychopath but at least she’s nice to Bill at Church.

Not really. When the cops say, "First the Jagerman boy, now this?" They're referring to the fact that he's been missing for two weeks, not that they know he's dead yet.

And if you need a good reason to watch the TGWDLM remount when it goes up on YouTube, Will Branner (Max) plays Professor Hidgens in this version and it just shows Max wasn’t even him at full power

18:00 now that I think about it, there's a small plot hole in NPMD specifically about when the bodies are found (more specifically which is found first)

ALSO since the lighting doesn’t make it clear and the captions incorrectly identify that sound, the noise in the second verse of the title song isn’t thunder cracking, it’s Max slamming the doors at the top of the stairs in Richie’s face

And also a specific one called “The Tragedy of Max Jägerman” that will 1000% vindicate your color theory but if you don’t watch NMT first then it won’t be in the way you’re expecting

You should check out the couple of like 30 second animations that people have made for the ending of the song, Nerdy Prudes Must Die .

The fact there's the other students in the background when Richie dies is such a cool thing, cause yes, they were all there, but he was alone when he was attacked

the delivery on jon's "I'M NOT A LOSER" has given me chills every time that i've heard it since this show was released

Hey, Mortius, remember what you say about a kind of connection between Grace and Max's movements. Just keep that in mind and you progress through the show.

I do hope that (eventually, no pressure) you get around to Nightmare Time. One of my personal favourite Hatchetfield characters only appears in that series and it goes a lot more in depth with the lore

I'm so happy to be a patreon subscriber right now...I can NOT wait for more

Im sure you noticed it, but in the background the singers are singing the "cool as I think i am" motif at Richie's death. This motif is very very important, and this is the second most prominent showing of it AND one of the best moments in the show

My favorite part is "Cooler than I think I am" in the background of Nerdy Prudes must die at the end. Literal chills every time

Your color theory/thought process is so fascinating. Very well thought out.

Richie: “I love this school! I love being alive 😃” Half of the audience: “NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO” Sends me every time The show does such a good job at making you forget about Richie’s death JUST long enough for you to get attached

Random tidbit from seeing the show live, Richie Naruto ran down the stairs when they went through the audience.

The one moment Max was endearing. </3

Hopefully he’ll watch NMT on his own time at the very least because respectfully something tells me at least 80% of his lore questions during this show will be able to be answered by that series 😂

richie saying pete looks like the homeless guy hits so much harder with nightmare time! if you plan on watching them in your own time, i definitely recommend watching time bastard, and then coming back to this.

Yes… Joey playing the homeless man in TGWDLM is the only reason why everyone hollered…. The one and only reason 🙂

I am no longer capable of saying “skeleton” in a normal way thanks to this show

HERE IT IS!!! the best song of the musical in this one! IM SO EXCITED

NPMD is basically “local 18-year-old experiences sexual attraction one (1) time: man dead, several traumatized”

it's been years and i still regularly reference the cool beans part of bully the bully, it's in my head always, keep the beans beans the cool keep the beans the cool keep the beans BEAN SCHOOL

I like that we're getting these so quickly

This came out exactly as I finished the first part lol

Commenting before watching. Am I wrong for having bully the bully and bury the bully as my favorite songs? I love a good reprise

omg i'm about to go to the gym and u best ur ass i'm watching this while on the treadmill im so EXCITED AAAAAAAAAA

More Creators

Doesn't it sound familiar? Pete: "Yeah...I don't want to though.." Richie: "..You're fucking useless Pete!" In another universe Paul: "Yeah..I don't want to though.." ----separate scene--- Ted: "...You're fucking useless Paul!" How the tables have turned!!

Paused in the correct place during the start of bury the bully because you really need to process that so you can have your full attention dedicated to "we're gonna hack all his limbs of piano slam" because that's yet another processing session all on it's own