The Dreamlands Campaign

As I continue work on Dream-Quest, I find my thoughts drifting into places I never expected — surprising, yes, but in the best possible way. That’s fitting, I suppose, since I never intended to create a game inspired by Lovecraft’s Dreamlands in the first place. The idea arrived unbidden and since then it’s taken on a life of its own, pulling me along with it. What follows, then, isn’t a final word carved in stone, but a glimpse into where my imagination has been wandering lately as I explore the possibilities of this game and what it might ultimately become.

One of the qualities that makes the Dreamlands so compelling as a roleplaying setting is how naturally they lend themselves to pick-up play. Unlike, say, the Forgotten Realms, the World of Greyhawk, or other well-mapped and meticulously detailed fantasy campaign settings, the Dreamlands lack a fixed geography. H.P. Lovecraft never provides us with a definitive atlas. Instead, he offers shifting hints, vague directions, and dream-logic connections. The result is a world that resists permanence and, when it comes to roleplaying, that instability is less a drawback than an invitation.

Because the Dreamlands refuse to stand still, they encourage adventures that are vast in scope but fleeting in practice. A palace of a thousand rooms or a wilderness stretching beyond sight need only exist for as long as the characters wander through them. Once they depart, they may never return. In another campaign setting, an unfinished dungeon or an abandoned plot thread might feel disruptive, a mistake left uncorrected. Here, though, incompleteness is part of the texture of dreams. What frustrates in a conventional fantasy game becomes, in Dream-Quest, a source of atmosphere and wonder.

The same principle extends to characters. Earthborn adventurers exist in the Dreamlands only while they sleep. When their players aren’t at the table, their characters simply vanish — until the next dream. This conceit neatly sidesteps one of the perennial challenges of long campaigns, namely, scheduling. A group might meet sporadically, even with months between sessions, and the nature of the Dreamlands provides an elegant explanation for their intermittent appearances. Earthborn characters become a community of dreamers, drifting in and out of the dream at irregular intervals, yet still weaving themselves into the same shared tapestry. Just how Dreamborn characters — those native to the Dreamlands — fit into this arrangement is something I’m still considering, but I welcome suggestions in the comments.

This way of approaching the Dreamlands also points toward a different method of presenting the setting. Instead of a canonical map or encyclopedic gazetteer, Dream-Quest will provide referees with a collection of locations, encounters, and motifs to be assembled through play. Each referee shapes the Dreamlands for his own campaign. Sarnath, Ulthar, or the Land of Mnar might appear, but not always in the same place or even in the same form, from one game to the next. Random tables might replace wandering monsters with dream elements, such as surreal events, sudden shifts, or uncanny encounters, that send players down unexpected paths. In this vision, the Dreamlands are modular: a toolbox of fragments, ruins, and possibilities, rather than a single, definitive world.

In such a context, “canon” becomes meaningless. What matters instead is tone. Lovecraft’s Dreamlands are not gonzo or whimsical in the modern sense. They are melancholy, brooding, and tinged with quiet loss. That atmosphere, combined with the thrill of discovery, is the anchor that makes each group’s Dreamlands distinct yet recognizably part of the same tradition. The referee’s greatest task, then, is not mastering rules but cultivating that tone, building a dreamscape that feels authentic to its Lovecraftian inspirations.

What, then, does adventuring in the Dreamlands look like? Unlike most fantasy campaigns, players are not chasing piles of gold or dragon hoards. Instead, they pursue things far more elusive: meaning, memory, escape, transformation. A journey might begin with the search for a way home, like Basil Elton in “The White Ship,” gazing ever further across the sea. Or it might center on a quest for something intangible, like a half-remembered song, the answer to a nagging question, the rediscovery of a place thought lost. Sometimes the goal is concrete, such as finding a missing companion or recovering a treasured relic. Just as often, the prize is less tangible: significance, beauty, or even transcendence.

Taken together, these qualities make the Dreamlands an ideal setting for campaigns that don’t demand constant attention. They support both one-shots and long-running but infrequent games, where players drift in and out as time and schedules permit. A Dreamlands campaign doesn’t need to compete with a group’s “main game”; it can rest alongside it, ready whenever the time is right. Like dreams themselves, the Dreamlands are timeless. They wait patiently, and they welcome wanderers whenever they return, even if years have passed since the last visit.