Charmed Season 4 Episode 3

It really sucks Prue has passed on. I do love though through her passing how much it changes the rest of the sisters. Phoebe now the middle sister who needs to keep the peace. Paige the new witch and white lighter! Piper now needing to step up in Prue’s place and let me say. She grows so much and becomes such a strong woman from it. ❤️

Mara Smith

This comment rocked. Yeah you are right it is her book too she just has to learn that it is extremely powerful and could probably cause mass destruction if the wrong person grabbed it. Yeah i keep forgetting Leo can't die again but its hard not be scared lol and i am so bummed about the music that appears to be one of the main complaints which sucks but i still love show and im definitely curious to see what song choices they originally made. But next episode will be up soon just got off work

Omg that was amazing ive watched that scene again she is so powerful im happy she is a good witch

Yeah once i realize what they are truly saying I understand but i just say what i feel cause it is my genuine reaction and that acting got me messed up. I love Piper and she needed to get that out for sure

Thats not a rant that is a good comment i will definitely give room for Paige to grow just jacking the book was messed up but nobody is perfect we all mistakes but what makes us great is recovering from those mistakes can't wait to see what happens next

True lol i remember that freaking tank phoebe brought home

Remember that Piper and Phoebe even casted love spells in season 1 😂

Adina

Loved the reaction and sending love to all y’all. Like the comments before me has pointed out, Paige is still fresh fresh to this, so go easy on her. Remember, it took the girls over two seasons to learn some of these things (referring to the episode where they went to the future and Phoebe was burned). She has had so little time and no one has properly explained anything to her. When you said that it’s not the same as when prue was alive; you’re right. It’s not. It’s different. It’s a different dynamic, and you have to give Paige time. Remember when you saw Prue as ”the angry one” in the beginning? They all grow and learn. Paige is probably my favorite sister. Season 7 is my favorite season, I promise you there are so much awesomeness heading your way! Just try not to compare anything that is to come with the seasons with Prue. Also, that scene at Prues grave in this episode has me BAWLING every single time. It’s how a lot of people feel when they are left behind. If you watch that scene again after some time, it’s so cathartic. Sorry about the rant hahah. Just love this series and your reactions so damn much. Appreciate it! Stay safe everyone!

Adina

I dont blame paige though they literally said "hey you're a witch" and that was it, never explained to her how stuff works plus I think she's only like 23 in this season so still kinda young and naive. And I know you didn't like the word "hate" towards prue but I get it, when you lose someone you're so angry at everything and sometimes even the person who passed. I feel for both paige and piper in that scene at prues grave, Holly's acting is absolutely amazing but especially at that scene. Cant wait for more!

Amanda P

LOL loved your reactions to Paige messing with the book and Cole being blown off his butt by Piper. Was looking forward to this one :D

Simone Poinga-Hill

Remember that the Book of Shadows belongs to Paige as well. She has just as much ownership over it as Piper or Phoebe. Think back to Season 1 for a second. If Prue, Piper, or Phoebe had taken the book out of the house for whatever reason, it wouldn't have been a big deal. This is Paige's Season 1. Yes, she did borrow the book. She was always going to bring it back. It was just an unwise decision. She is just like Piper and Phoebe in Season 1. They didn't really have the reverence for it then that they have now. Plus, like Phoebe said, Piper had been completely ignoring Paige and hunting demons, and they hadn't sat down to explain a single thing to Paige about the Book or really anything else, like personal gain spells. I would say that Paige made a mistake, but she gets a pass. I loved seeing Phoebe use Levitation so much this episode to fight the Furies. Leo is already dead. He can't actually die again. The only way Leo can die as a Whitelighter is from the poisoned arrow of a Darklighter. He didn't actually die last season when they turned him into ice and shattered him, just like Piper didn't kill him in this episode by blowing him up. Just pointing this out since you keep fearing for Leo's life, like last season when he was hit with an energy ball and exploded into orbs. Haha. And when it comes to the songs that play at the beginning of episodes (or any songs during any scenes now), remember that they are not the original songs that were chosen for the episodes. ALL music has been replaced in this version with terrible music from a stock library of fake bands/artists, instead of the awesome music of the early 2000's. So try not to judge the show for the mediocre music too much, it's not their fault. :(