Chapter 459 - How do you handle it? - Get her involved

Sarah was bleary-eyed when she first looked your way but she soon put the pieces together and as her eyes lit up, you could see that this would be the quickest situation she's ever been able to wake up to.

You could tell she was about to comment on what you and Mary were up to but you knew that if she was to start talking suddenly and Mary was unprepared, the chaos it could cause would be something you wouldn’t be able to predict.

Instead, you sneakily tried to keep Mary's focus on you while also, pointing a finger in Sarah’s direction, signalling to her to stay put for a moment. Your eye line was still on Mary so you couldn’t see if you were successful, but the fact that Sarah hadn't spoken yet gave you some relief before you went to smooth things over with Mary.

“You said I could put you in your place right?” you said, starting up the conversation again from before.

“Yes! Tell me what to do and I’ll do it” Mary quickly shot back, starting to move her hands when she saw you weren’t thrusting into her chest as hard as you were before.

“What if I want you to be involved with the others? What about Grace? Or Lucy or Sarah?” you asked, steering the topic in the direction you wanted.

“I’ll… If you want me to and it’s something that you find hot then of course I’ll…” Mary said, started to reply.

“But would you enjoy it? I know I will. Watching you with Grace has probably been one of the things I’ve fantasised about the most but a part of that is knowing you are getting pleasure from it as well.” you explained, wanting her to reveal her feelings.

You could tell the rapid change of topic was pulling Mary out of the experience you were having so you picked up the pace of your thrusts, showing her that she still needed to be pleasing you while also answering your questions.

“I don’t know… I’ve never really done that before. I know she's attractive and just having you order us around would already get me pretty hot. Imagining us side by side while we both serve you… and maybe if Grace…” Mary replied, starting to go off into a fantasy that she was clearly enjoying.

You took a brief glance in Sarah’s direction to see that she was clearly hooked on Mary's words, not knowing that Mary could be having some of the same thoughts that she did. You could see Sarah’s hand disappearing down under the covers while she listened, something you weren’t planning on stopping.

“And what about Lucy? Or what if I asked Sarah to kiss you while I watched? “ you questioned, seeing Mary go to turn her head towards Sarah before you stopped her.

“Don’t. Keep looking at me. If she was watching you, that wouldn’t change your answer. So?” you added, staring straight into her eyes so that she couldn’t look away.

You watched Mary get flustered over the question but even with her looking right back at you, you could tell that the thoughts of her and Sarah and Lucy together were running through her head.

“...I think… I’d like that” Mary admitted, looking slightly shocked that she had actually said that out loud.

“Good. Now, close your eyes… Trust me” you ordered, letting her take her time and not rush her as if she was suspecting what was about to come next.

When she had finally taken her eyes off of you and closed them, you finally took a good look in Sarah’s direction.

She was clearly just as surprised that Mary was willing to admit that she was open to being more intimate with her and Lucy so it felt like you also had to give her some time before you set things in motion.

When Sarah did look your way, you signaled her to get closer, motioning to your lips and then to Mary. You didn’t think either of them would voluntarily be the aggressor in this situation so having Mary close her eyes and having Sarah make the first move seemed like the best plan you could come up with in the short time you had had.

Sarah seemed to get the hint based on your gesturing and moved closer to Mary, sitting on her knees above her before leaning forward. Even you started to get nervous as Sarah inched closer to Mary but you watched intently as Sarah closed the distance and pressed her lips against Mary 's , letting one of her hands cup her cheeks to keep her close.

Even if Mary had expected it, she clearly panicked for a moment when the kiss started, still feeling you hovering over her and knowing it was someone else kissing her. Flustered or not, she did slowly start returning the kiss and you watched the two of them get more comfortable in the kiss and start to get more heated.

Mary still kept her grip on the sides of her cleavage as if her body was telling her to keep giving you pleasure and with the sight in front of you, it was hard not to move your hips as you watched the two of them make out.

It seemed like neither of them wanted it to end but only so they wouldn’t have to deal with the consequences after. Instead, just keeping the current situation as it was until you told them otherwise.

“Sarah, come here” you ordered, breaking the trance they had over one another.

The brief moment where they were looking at each other for the first time brought a deeper blush to their cheeks but Sarah used your words as an excuse, raising herself back up and getting face to face with you.

“Good girl” you whispered, practically watching her melt over your words as you moved in to kiss her.

Knowing she had just kissed Mary upped the intimacy of the whole situation and knowing that Mary was watching left you having to split your thoughts so you knew she was okay alongside Sarah.

You moved a hand down to the side of her breast, at first letting it linger there as you enjoyed feeling her body beneath you before bringing it over to her hand, interlocking your fingers. You didn’t know what message you were trying to send her other than that you wanted her to be acknowledged in this moment but you felt her squeeze your hand in return.

That was the only sign you could hope for as you and Sarah continued, the kiss with you feeling a lot more passionate than the one she and Mary had experienced. Again, enough time passed where you felt ready for the kiss to end and when you pulled back, all three of you spent a moment looking between each other before both Mary and Sarah looked in your direction to see what you wanted to happen next.