Display Cutouts | Patreon Weekly #325

Hey Patrons, in this weekly I’m going to go over some technical changes I plan to make to display layouts on Android and iOS.

There’s also an audio Q&A this month! There’s a list of questions and timestamps below the weekly.

Notches and Hole Punches

Let me quickly take you back to 2017. Phone displays were all perfect whole rectangles, as god intended. Then Apple made this in 2018:

I understand the desire here, people want selfie cameras and also big edge-to-edge displays, but in my opinion the notch is a horrid compromise between the two. It creates a region of the screen that’s mostly useless most of the time. I would rather just have a thin display bezel or no selfie camera at all. Of course, everyone copies Apple, and now notches or hole punches are pretty much ubiquitous.

When I upgraded my phone last in 2019, I very specifically picked one with no hole punch and a pop-up selfie camera (a Oneplus 7 pro) and happily stopped thinking about notches entirely. For the last 6 years I’ve seen Shattered with a perfect full-screen display. Meanwhile everyone else has been getting the system status bar on iOS, and a black void on Android:

I’m thinking about this again now, as recent Android changes are forcing Shattered to actually handle notches in some way. Sure I could just have the app itself put a black void there instead of the system, but I might as well look and see if anything better can be done.

So after a quick survey, here’s how display cutouts currently look:

• On Android the vast majority of devices use a relatively small center hole-punch. After that there’s a little mix of left hole punches, right hole punches, and center teardrop notches (small notches). Some Android phones do have big bulky notches, but they seem to have fallen out of favour a while ago.

• On iOS many slightly old iPhones still use a big fat center notch, but newer iPhones use a “dynamic Island”, which is basically just an extra-wide center hole punch. This island can get bigger or smaller depending on background apps (e.g. music), but it seems that fullscreen games like Shattered force the island to shrink to a minimal size.

There’s still no way for me to do much with devices that have big bulky notches, but it seems that display cutouts on the whole have gotten a lot smaller. I think it may be possible for me to actually support some of these, and let devices with cutouts display Shattered in true fullscreen!

For most menus this is as simple as just lowering the title text and top-right back button, but the in-game UI is a bit more complex. Obviously rendering it into a larger notch wouldn't work without major changes:

But for the more medium sized ‘dynamic island’ things are a lot more promising. This could maybe work with the health bar moved up slightly and the buff bar on two rows:

And with smaller modern android hole punches (S24 Ultra pictured here) the game almost totally works as-is:

So I'm going to need to do a bit more testing and designing, but it's looking like some older devices will need to stick to showing a void or the status bar, but more modern ones should be able to get true fullscreen with relatively small UI changes!

Audio Timestamps

This month there were 21 questions from 11 Patrons

• 0:08 "What's been the single most difficult hurdle or aspect about managing the development of SPD? " - #1 ring of force stan

• 1:44 "my pawn goes up to f3 to attack your bishop! will the bishop escape?" - radiantchaos

  

• 2:05 "Today I shall ask the compulsory question of "how was your day/week/month?"" - Joshuackiwi

• 3:21 "Question: What inspired you to start modding Pixel Dungeon?" - Slenderazi

• 4:44 "Will you add discord emojis for Duelist and Cleric?" - Veek

• 5:19 "what does the back of the amulet actually look like?" - DaltonGoesFast

• 5:50 "do you have uno?" - radiantchaos

• 7:17 "Have you considered enemies with advanced AI? Maybe they'd do things like pickup and use equipment laying around, lure the player into traps or rooms of enemies, or position based on the player's class." - 1-800-thewolf

• 9:40 "What would you never add to the game normally, but you would if you had 100 Evans?" - 1-800-thewolf

• 10:28 "Do you like cheese?" - Slenderazi

• 11:05 "After you are finished with Shattered pixel dungeon what is the next project you want to work on?" - kokon

• 12:00 "what are your favorite and least favorite parts of making these Patreon EvanCasts? " - Depresbian

• 13:09 "i remember having a discussion about how the accuracy vs speed tradeoff of vanilla's weightstone was a more interesting choice than shattered's damage vs speed augmentation, but that accuracy being invisible made it ultimately better to replace it with damage. now that the tangible effects of accuracy are telegraphed to the player, how do you feel about weapon augment mechanics? " - Depresbian

• 14:51 "what's your favorite alchemy item?" - Depresbian

• 15:54 "What is the airspeed velocity of an unladen swallow?" - Slenderazi

• 16:10 "What is your dream project? If you the means, skill and knowledge to direct a team to create any vision, what would it be? Game, movie, music anything" - DaltonGoesFast

• 19:45 "Wait a second. If I have a cursed throwable item. Let's just say an Explosive Tomahawk. When I throw that bad boy and the curse procs, does that mean it explodes in my hand and then it's thrown? Or when I throw it, then it explodes. If you have time, explain it like your 3 years old." - Chewyou#4688

• 20:46 "If you were flush with endless amounts of cash, and could afford to license songs. What music would you replace the standard music with? Ex, the Demon Hall with some sick metal. (Wield Lighting to split the sun - Primordial, just to list a song.)" - Chewyou

• 21:54 "How do you feel about the current playerbase and it's state? Do you know which countries have a lot of good players or good high chal statistics? I've heard about big communities in South Korea and China but only communicated with Chinese part a little bit" - Rivlin the speedrunner #1

  (Note that I mis-spoke at around 24:19. when I said "the Reddit community" I meant "the Discord community")

• 25:36 "When it's finally time to sunset Shattered, are you finally gonna us the magic combo to hit the fly's in order to guarantee the health potion? " - Chewyou#4688

• 26:43 "Are you excited about the imminent release of Hollow Knight Silksong? " - Block Vader