XaiJu
blankcheck
blankcheck

patreon


BC March Madness 2025 - Day 21

In a victory for felt freaks everywhere, the Muppets move on to the next round!

Up today - lots of charismatic movie stars of the 90s being hot, being in love, and being iconic.

It's Elmore Leonard Adaptations vs. Richard Curtis Rom Coms.

With Elmore Leonard, we'd cover a curated selection of four films:
Get Shorty
Jackie Brown
Out of Sight
Be Cool

With Richard Curtis rom-coms, we'd cover five very British romances:
The Tall Guy
Four Weddings & A Funeral
Notting Hill
Love Actually
About Time

So, what say you - Jackie or Julia?

Comments

As much as i love Love Actually, on balance i would rather watch the elmores. Maybe someday they will get Lindy West on for a special Love Actually only episode 🤩

Hannah K. Garden

And all the Brit jokes David could make (or be made about him)!

William Hanzel

The wilder (pun unintended) is that blazing saddles and young Frankenstein were in the same year, so some could say that the blank check was actually the producers that initially bounced but cleared big time down the road.

Barbara Anderson

I voted for Mel mostly because he had one of the startling blank check runs ever in the 70s. Blazing Saddles was a big hit that gave him a blank check, and he cashed it in to make Universal monster spoof in B&W. That's a big swing. And then Young Frankenstein was an even bigger hit, so he cashed in *that* blank check to make an actual silent comedy in 1976. Absolutely bananas behavior!

Anthony Strand

Bong would tell you

Jack o Diamonds

I honestly thought the exact opposite about who would cruise, even with Bong as a past finalist, I think Mel Brooks has actually never even done as well in March Madness as I thought he would, this year OR last time. I voted for Bong but my reading of Blankie demography has always been that Brooks is a lock for the final four, he keeps running into stronger headwinds than I expected and perhaps happily I can rethink at this point haha

Rad Rodge

I voted for Mel. I'm more interested in those discussions. History of the World Pt. 1, The Producers, SPACEBALLS!!! Ever heard of it?!

Matt Demello

Most shocking upset so far. I don’t think I was the only one expecting Bong to cruise to the final two. This opens that side of the bracket way up.

Harley Richard

In other news HOW is Mel Brooks beating Bong Joon-ho?!

Olivia Haidar

Man, bummed Richard Curtis is behind- all fast paced and fun movies, and that’s what makes for the best commentaries imo.

Chris Almberg

Big same it's not about what movies are better is about what would inspire a more entertaining commentary, also an excuse to watch some movies I otherwise might never

David Figueiredo

I voted for the return of the UK bit.

Jon Arnold

Everyone voting for Elmore Leonard is out of their minds, this is reverse UK bit aggression!

George Seabrook

Finally a win! Still sucks we don’t have a straight comedy series. I hope next year we get American pie and Adam Sandler movies.

Good

Honestly, I'd prefer watching the Elmore Leonard movies, but I voted for the romcoms because I want to hear David talk about the British Christmas songs tradition and listen as they try to explain Love Actually in general.

Shane Rhyne

Shout out to whoever's picking these matching images for each post, I'm always impressed!

TimeGentleman

I'll no doubt be put in the Tower, but only one way to vote.

zero

This is why I voted for the RomComs, for Tall Guy recognition.

Glenn Peters

I went on a cruise in 96 and this was one of 3 movies they played so I've seen Get Shorty soooooooo many times I absolutely love it.

Chris Radicone

Be cool baby

Ian Joshua Postman

STOP PUTTING BILLY MADISON UP AGAINST KID SHIT!!!! aGGGHH..

Sweetjimmyt

😂😂😂 so many gems

Good

Think I'd rather watch Killshot

colony of birchmen

"Fuck you, fuckball!" is an all-time line.

colony of birchmen

About Time is one of the best rom coms ever made! David would totally love it.

Hadley Anthony

Could they please do the Elmore Leonard series, and then just sneak in the Tall Guy? It doesn’t get talked about enough.

Christopher Weithers

Aww, neither version of The Big Bounce?

E.Z. Hart

Get shorty is going to be a fantastic commentary. 🔥🔥🔥

Good

I WANT Richard Curtis. I do NOT want to listen to David savage Love Actually.

Emily Scott

its a win/win .. Leonard means we get to watch some of my favs, Curtis means I get to fill in blind spots. GET OUT AND VOTE BB

David Rosenblatt

I really enjoyed that one!

Patrick McEvoy

Have we heard why they aren't doing 3:10 to Yuma (either version)?

Patrick McEvoy

Never again Hugh Grant

CT13

I voted for Elmore Leonard this time...didn't I do it, baby, didn't I do it, baaaaaybeeee

Marty TC (child-sized Cardassian)

How about a write in campaign for 1985s Stick? Directed by and starring Burt Reynolds with Leonard writing the screenplay based on his own novel.

David Draper

This victory will be JUSTIFIED

Manish Agarwal

I voted for Jackie Brown. I want one of the most underrated movies to beat one of the most overrated movies.

ryan mcgrath

By making them too good and successful???

Will Redmond

Has anyone seen 52 Pickup? I enjoyed the book but haven't gotten to it.

Christian Mayfield

This is my real "do both" day

Will Redmond

You’re fortunate not to remember Be Cool. It’s sacrilege after the fantastic movie that was Get Shorty.

ComedyCrowd

Pirate Radio should definitely be on the Richard Curtis list. One of his best films in years.

ComedyCrowd

Be Cool is so bad; I recommend you switch it out for one of the lesser-known adaptations.

ComedyCrowd

Curtis would be fun, but just think of all the different directors and their contexts we’d get to engage with for Leonard.

Njord

Two times with Jackie won’t kill us

Njord

LOVE seeing the Curtis hate here. :) I feel like he helped kill the rom-com....

Geoff Gershon

Love Actually is a cinematic crime.

Geoff Gershon

Yes PLEASE Elmore Leonard - three of those are legit great movies while most of Richard Curtis' stuff is trash or mediocre at best.

Geoff Gershon

I wish "About Time" was "In Time"

Regis L

Be Cool the novel is ok, but the movie is terrible. Both versions of Shorty are amazing.

David Draper

Vote curtis, they’re completely insane and none of them are boring

Jeremy M

insane to not want to hear David talk about 90s-00s british ephemera at any chance we get

Marie

One of my favorite movies of all time and I’d love to hear it covered on the main feed first but had to vote EL anyway

Jeremy Dankowitz

Not a big fan of the Curtis oeuvre, but any excuse for British Bits is welcome.

Hoot n Waddle

TIME TRAVEL ROM COM

Rachel H Smith

Clearly gotta hold it off for a George Armitrage series, which... I would strongly consider voting for instead of either of these options. They call it Pod's country... until all hell casts loose!

JTA

I prefer the films in the Curtis library, but don’t want to listen to my favorite podcasters shit on Love Actually for two hours lol

Chad Perry

Why would you assume we'd never get a QT series?

bearisonford

We need to set aside Brown for Tarantino

Anthony Oleszkiewicz

Since we’re probably never going to get a Tarantino main feed series, I’ll at least get to hear #thetwofriends get to talk about Jackie Brown this way.

Maximilian Katz

I hate Richard Curtis

Colin

Just read 2 random EL books (Bandits, then Swag)... i love the vibe... let's go EL!

David McElroy

Still firmly on the Romcom train! Every time David gets to talk about Britain is golden, hop on y’all

Keira Q

petition to include Paul Schrader’s Touch (1997) in the Elmore Leonard series

Daniel Hensel

W results so far

Khar

I am now seeing Big Bounce omitted from this list? Clearly a mistake

Aaron VanTuyl

I want EL to take this whole thing. 3 out of those 4 films are classics. I really don’t remember Be Cool.

Jeremiah Drueke

So happy to be on the right side of history. SOMETIMES THEY BIG BOUNCE, BABY!

Aaron VanTuyl

Go away Richard Curtis

Matthew O'Reilly


More Creators