AlternateHistoryHub posts
Poll results from 204 total members!
A bunch of polls are going up soon. We will now narrow down the options to the top 4 from each category
Napoleonic Trilogy update : Full timeline is coming out tomorrow with an extra Patreon/Members exclusive portion on specific fronts in the weekend!
Happy voting
Backgrounds vs No Backgrounds (Examples in Post Below)
I'm trying to find the balance between the classic look and new improvements, but I need your help.
Do you prefer backgrounds like these or no backgrounds at all?
Backgrounds vs No Backgrounds
I'm trying to find the balance between the classic look and new improvements, but I need your help.
Do you prefer backgrounds like these or no backgrounds at all?
I will make a poll after this post so you can vote, but I would also love to read your comments on this!
The Week Late Halloween Special!
What do you think happens next in this timeline?
How does this impact the Civil rights movement and South Africa?
What are some other Halloween themed ideas for the video next year?
Also, I'm working on a brand new end screen animated credits featuring the updated Patron list as well as the YouTube Members.
Thank you for all of your support!
What if Jack the Ripper killed Gandhi?
Happy Halloween!
The idea was to post this video today, but production got delayed with putting the final polish on this extremely wacky, but fascinating scenario!
The good news is that after what has been the best round of suggestions yet, I have the next step of the voting process ready for you (Posting in an hour)
Alternate History of Antarctica idea
Has the size of Europe and used to be connected to the mainland with via a bridge
We could even have multiple Patron polls about resource distribution
Are there horses? Where?
What about Iron? Spices?
Choose your own adventure scenario!
Alternate history of Antarctica
Lately I’ve become completely obsessed with a map showing what Antarctica looks like beneath the ice — and honestly, it’s like something ripped straight from a fantasy RPG.
So here’s a thought: what if that landmass existed somewhere else — say, in the middle of the Atlantic, or instead of Australia?
Which parts of it would resemble other regions of Earth?
What kinds of civilizations, cultures, or kingdoms might rise there — cut off from the rest of the world? 2025-10-27 19:38:42 +0000 UTC View Post
Suggestions time!
One suggestion per tier (e.g. Tier 3 = 3 suggestions).
A Point of Divergence is helpful but not required.
All suggestions will go up for a vote this weekend!
It’ll be tough to top last time’s ideas—but hey, you’ve surprised me before.
Special thanks to everyone who suggested these!
Originally I was going to have 10 of these, but the following 5 scenarios are going to be added separately to the 1 hour Dumb Scenarios special this December!
What If New England Seceded Over the War of 1812? (1812–1815) Tasi
What If Texas Remained Independent? (1836–1845) Arizona Lorax
What If America Opened Up Korea Instead of Japan? (1853) The Great Khan
What If Russia Sold Alaska to Britain or Liechtenstein? (1867) Conor Hilchie and Mike Assist What If the Battle o...
Remastered scenario suggested by BeaverNation!
The entire video got an upgrade and I'd love to hear your thoughts on it!
New Suggestion post coming very soon!
Dumb Scenarios #3 Early Preview
What If Columbus Never Discovered America? Pitched by Ryan over on Patreon
This is just scenario #3 of the new 10 that are coming out (hopefully) next week. Each one was suggested by Patreon members.
Some of the others on the list are: What if Napoleon didn't invade Russia in 1812? What if Texas remained independent? What if the Franco-British union was formed during WW2?
Mongol Bow vs The Katana
A while back "The Nerdy One" pitched this idea and not so long ago you voted on which of the two invasions to be altered.
Video is out now and it's one of my favorites
What do you think?
Considering how things end do you want to see a sequel?
Dumb Scenarios : Patron Edition
That's right, I will cover 10 more dumb scenarios, only this time they will be suggested by YOU
Suggestion rules :
1 Suggestion per patreon tier. (Example: Tier 3 gets 3 )
No April Fools type suggestion. This needs to be something people actually thing could happen, but it's actually dumb
Cannot be one of the 20 already covered or have a lot of overlap with them
Needs to have some level of popularity
Write down how you want to be credited if/when your scenario p...
Patreon Exclusive video poll
Over at the community vote the Sino-Soviet war became the winner with 39%, meaning it will become a public video.
Meanwhile Frederick III got just 9%, putting it in the vault.
The remaining 2 candidates are now up for exclusive video election, so cast your vote on which suggestion finalist you want to see more
Exclusive videos master list
https://youtu.be/VMixU7WmLqM : Spain never forms
https://youtu.be/8qklAu1VCOY Christian China
https://youtu.be/LvWRAE0p5as Soviets crush Poland
https://youtu.be/lkJ-DDpk9sA WW2 in 1878
What happens if you drop 100 nukes on St. Petersburg in 1908?
This one took a while to make, but personally it might be my favorite one
Shoutout to MichaelAL1776, David Leonard and Tamas Polgar for suggesting this scenario
Fork in the road poll
I recently got really inspired by one of the suggestions you made about the Mongol invasions of Japan.
I went down the rabbit hole and I'm working on the script right now, but there are 2 somewhat different approaches here.
Both invasions could have worked, but which one do you prefer to see:
The first invasion in 1274: Swift shock. A smaller force overruns Kyūshū early, toppling the young Kamakura shogunate and turning Japan into a Yuan springboard before 128...
After tackling WW2, now its time for a Southern Win timeline attempt
This all started as a suggestion from one of you, but now a couple of months later... here we are!
So many ways this could go from here!
Let me know what you thought about this one
Ancient and Medieval playoffs
Honorable mention for the Viking age never starting with 19.5%
2025-07-16 19:19:55 +0000 UTC View PostSuggestion results:
Ancient and Medieval slot: Extremely close Top 4 choices playoffs
Modern #1: Extremely close: Top 4 choices playoffs
Modern #2: Extremely close: Top 4 choices playoffs
America slot: 25.5% win for Zach Martin's Teddy Rosevelt, second best is at 15%
Format : 62.3% win for multiple picks
If you want a more detailed breakdown let me know in the comments.
Posting the playoffs polls now
Time to cast your votes!
As usual this isn't going to be easy and we might have playoffs between the top voted suggestions
2025-07-05 18:29:42 +0000 UTC View PostIt's that time of the month again. Show me what you got
Last month's suggestions were stellar so you have to get really creative this time around
QnA: Dunkirk edition
Any questions you might have about the scenario
2025-06-15 19:05:59 +0000 UTC View PostThe Axis win cinematic experience!
I will have a special QnA devoted to this I guess... alternate history movie tomorrow so write down any questions you may have while watching this
Next big timeline will either be Chernobyl or Napoleon, as usual decided by you
Thank you to everyone who made this possible!
T -4 days until the Dunkirk cinematic expiriance
One epic timeline to rule them all! Enjoy this very special teaser and get ready for a 90+ minute banger
2025-06-02 17:00:11 +0000 UTC View Post