CrimeInSports

Strange Affairs & Frozen Blood - Pottstown, Pennsylvania

This week, in Pottstown, Pennsylvania, a twisted tale emerges, when a rich, brash local, with a million enemies, is found horribly murdered & frozen solid, in his own car. Detectives have a mess on their hands, comsidering the dead man's nephews was having an affair with his wife. Plus, the dead man was having his own affair. The whole thing goes on for years, as conspirators turn on each other, with surprising results!!

Along the way, we find out that Van Halen is music i...

A Troublemaking Bad Influence - Billy Martin - Part 3

This week, we catch up with Billy, as he is forced back into the Army, missing an entire season of Yankee baseball. He is also labeled as a "troublemaker", and a "bad influence" on teammates like Mickey Mantle, just because they go out drinking, every night, and a major brawl happened to beak out at the Copacabana, at Billy's birthday party! He fights, he scraps, and he gets traded, all over the league!

Watch the Yankees play a whole season, while you're in the Army, fight wit...

Haunted Drunks, The Museum Of ABBA, Death Before Disgusting Bathrooms

More of the funniest reviews on the internet! We read reviews for an entire museum, dedicated to the Swedish disco group, ABBA. A haunted house experience, where the scariest part of the whole thing just might be the smell of a drunken employee. A major city's Greyhound bus station, where you may wish to be killed, just to avopid having to use their bathroom & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the...

Murder In The Blood - Grasshopper Junction, Arizona

This week, in Grasshopper Junction, Arizona, a man tries to have a morning coffee, with his friends, who run the town's only restaurant, but discovers a bloody mess of a scene, with their brutally murdered bodies. At the same time, a pair of brothers, on the run from the law in Alabama, lead police on a chase, through the desert, throwing weapons out the window, as they flee. When they're caught, the items in their car tell an awful, and bloodthirsty story!!

Along the way, we ...

The Murder And The Miracle - Mont Vernon, New Hampshire

This week, in Mont Vernon, New Hampshire, a comfy country home is the setting for a terrible massacre, causing detectives to be suspicious of the spouse, only to find out that it's actually a much darker plot. A group of teens, calling themselves "Disciples of Destruction" set out to make a name for themselves, but didn't count on one thing; a miraculous survival by one of the victims. Also, the prying ears of a friend's mom! Remorseless & cocky, will they all pay the price??

CRIME IN SPORTS & STM FEED ISSUES:

Hi everyone!

No idea what happened with the RSS feeds for the podcasts! It is a known issue that is affecting a few podcasts. It's an RSS feed generator issue, and the network is working on it! It's not you!

Thank you for the patience!

Updates here: https://status.libsyn.com/notices/q3q2e5s2bdwhv03e-temporary-rss-issues

Cow Killing Street Fighter - Billy Martin - Part 2

This week, we start out with Billy, being a big part of the NY Yankees, and making lifelong friends with Micky Mantle. After a few World Series wins, and a quick marriage, Billy settles into the serious business of partying, and NY night life. This includes many fist fights, both on & off the baseball field, and a carzy time, at a ranch, where shots are fired, and things end up dead!

Marry your gr\irlfriend, because her friend just got married, punch anyone who slides in,...

The Queen Of Goodwill, Cheeky Scottish Burger Anger, Riding The Zombie Bus

More of the funniest reviews on the internet! We read reviews for a McDonald's, that happens to be in Scotland, where people are terrified of "cheekiness" & ketchup throwing children. A discount store, where one woman rules over the proceedings, with an iron fist, and a bad attitude. A major city's Greyhound bus station, where no one works, but everyone seems to use the bathroom & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman as they explore the mos...

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE HISTORY OF EXECUTIONS

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the history of executions in the United States.

BONUS - CRIME IN SPORTS - KERMIT VS RUDY

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the legendary fight from 1977 between NBA players Kermit Washington and Rudy Tomjanovich -- a fight that changed their lives and ruined a reputation.

Face Eating Frat Boy - Tequesta, Florida

This week, in Tequesta, Florida, an absolutely insane, and horrific pair of murders is interrupted by a neighbor, who also gets attacked. The murders are incredibly horrendous, with knives, a machete, and is finished off, with an attempt to eat the faces off of the victims. It's a crazy act, by a young man, who seems to have gone crazy, claiming superpowers, and that he is chased by demons, and is half dog, among some even stranger beliefs!! Will he be mentally competent to stand trial??

Face Eating Frat Boy - Tequesta, Florida

This week, in Tequesta, Florida, an absolutely insane, and horrific pair of murders is interrupted by a neighbor, who also gets attacked. The murders are incredibly horrendous, with knives, a machete, and is finished off, with an attempt to eat the faces off of the victims. It's a crazy act, by a young man, who seems to have gone crazy, claiming superpowers, and that he is chased by demons, and is half dog, among some even stranger beliefs!! Will he be mentally competent to stand trial??

Brilliant Brutality - Prairie Village, Kansas

This week, in Prairie Village, Kansas, a wildly intelligent doctor hands in their medical license, amid a failing marriage, and begins to lose their mind, while slipping into a world of alcohol, drugs, strange threats. This all escalates into one crazy evening, and two murders, that are so brutal, that the town has to change all the street addresses! Was it insanity, or just the most cold blooded crime imaginable?

Along the way, we find out that "Mr Stinky Feet" sounds like a crazy musi...

Brilliant Brutality - Prairie Village, Kansas

This week, in Prairie Village, Kansas, a wildly intelligent doctor hands in their medical license, amid a failing marriage, and begins to lose their mind, while slipping into a world of alcohol, drugs, strange threats. This all escalates into one crazy evening, and two murders, that are so brutal, that the town has to change all the street addresses! Was it insanity, or just the most cold blooded crime imaginable?

Along the way, we find out that "Mr Stinky Feet" sounds like a ...

Brothels, Brawling & Baseball - Billy Martin - Part 1

This week, we start a series on one of the most colorful characters in sports history. A hard drinking brawler, who knew nothing but success in baseball. We start this tale, with Billy's dad, taking off, while he was a baby. We delve into his upbringing, just hanging around his aunt's brothel, or getting into constant fights, but at the same time, discovering baseball as a way to get out of his rough neighborhood, dead jobs that awaited him. Did we mention fighting? Because he fights a LOT! 2025-09-23 00:36:00 +0000 UTC View Post

Flea Ridden Slum Trailer, Blacklight Problems, Inventing A Slur

More of the funniest reviews on the internet! We read reviews for a trailer park, that the residents seem to want investigated for fleas that cover people & general trash concerns. A mini golf course, where the blacklight conditions are the only attraction, but a particular employee makes it less attractive. A highway gas station, where the bathrooms are scary & you may have to fight someone, wearing a visor & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman...

Flea Ridden Slum Trailer, Blacklight Problems, Inventing A Slur

More of the funniest reviews on the internet! We read reviews for a trailer park, that the residents seem to want investigated for fleas that cover people & general trash concerns. A mini golf course, where the blacklight conditions are the only attraction, but a particular employee makes it less attractive. A highway gas station, where the bathrooms are scary & you may have to fight someone, wearing a visor & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo & Jimm...

Lawnmower Man - Willard, Ohio - SPECIAL GUEST: WILL FORTE!!

This week, in Willard, Ohio, a deeply disturbed man moves back in with his mother, only to go deeper into strangeness, by not leaving the house for over nine months, not getting any psychiatric help, and heavily day drinking whiskey. One night, when his neighbor mows her lawn, after dark, he decides it's finally time to leave the house. This ends in a bloody confrontation, featuring unprovoked attack, and a lawnmower!!

WITH SPECIAL GUEST: WILL FORTE!!

Along the way, we find out th...

Lawnmower Man - Willard, Ohio - SPECIAL GUEST: WILL FORTE!!

This week, in Willard, Ohio, a deeply disturbed man moves back in with his mother, only to go deeper into strangeness, by not leaving the house for over nine months, not getting any psychiatric help, and heavily day drinking whiskey. One night, when his neighbor mows her lawn, after dark, he decides it's finally time to leave the house. This ends in a bloody confrontation, featuring unprovoked attack, and a lawnmower!!

WITH SPECIAL GUEST, WILL FORTE!!

Along the way, we ...

Forest Serial Killer - Oak Grove, Oregon

This week, in Oak Grove, Oregon, when a group of bystanders attempt to save woman's life, after she was brutally stabbed, in a Denny's parking lot, no one can imagine that it would lead to the discovery of a makeshift forest graveyard, and one of the worst serial killers that the northwest has ever seen. He's a nasty one, with the cover of a good father, husband & business owner, but a night time hobby of prowiling the streets!!

Along the way, we find out that we haven't heard of ma...

Forest Serial Killer - Oak Grove, Oregon

This week, in Oak Grove, Oregon, when a group of bystanders attempt to save woman's life, after she was brutally stabbed, in a Denny's parking lot, no one can imagine that it would lead to the discovery of a makeshift forest graveyard, and one of the worst serial killers that the northwest has ever seen. He's a nasty one, with the cover of a good father, husband & business owner, but a night time hobby of prowiling the streets!!

Along the way, we find out that we haven't h...

UPDATE:

HEY WHY AM I HEARING AN AD?

As we have explained, before, we have baked-in ads with our new network.

We are in the middle of phasing those out. We do have to honor what has already been sold. Once we are through with that, we are going to go through and scrub the ads out of the episodes. We were replacing the audio file with an ad-free file. This is unrelated to the issues we were having... it's just going to make things more efficient while we wait for the baked-in ads to be phas...

A Most Monstrous Murderer - Cierre Wood

This week, a man who never quite made the impact he wanted to, in the NFL, despite his Notre Dame pedigree. Whenever his talent would get him to a good spot, he'd screw it up, with his actions. He was out of the NFL, by age 25, and ready to start being an even worse person. The prison sentence he's currently serving, is for a crime that was so horrific, the judge wished he could sentence him to even more time. A true monster!

Start football late, but have your natural abilty take you to...

A Most Monstrous Murderer - Cierre Wood

This week, a man who never quite made the impact he wanted to, in the NFL, despite his Notre Dame pedigree. Whenever his talent would get him to a good spot, he'd screw it up, with his actions. He was out of the NFL, by age 25, and ready to start being an even worse person. The prison sentence he's currently serving, is for a crime that was so horrific, the judge wished he could sentence him to even more time. A true monster!

Start football late, but have your natural abilty t...

HALLOWEEN VIRTUAL LIVE TICKETS ARE NOW AVAILABLE

No way!? That’s great!

They’re doing another Halloween Live Stream!

WHO: You!

WHEN: 10/30/2025

TICKETS: $20

BUY TICKETS HERE: moment.co/smalltownmurder

*video playback will be available for two (2) weeks after the live event.*

shut up, and give me murder!!!

Elderly Golf Orgy, Cats In Your Groceries, Controlling Your Stink

More of the funniest reviews on the internet! We read reviews for a retirement village in Florida, where the drubken fights are only stopped by drunken orgies. A grocery store, where you can learn to understand insults in other languages, while petting all the cats that may desire. A personal item that either makes you feel fry & fresh, or like you have pants full of paste & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opin...

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - TED BUNDY VS GRK (PART 2)

This week, James and Jimmie wrap up the story of how Ted Bundy helped authorities catch the Green River Killer.

BONUS - CRIME IN SPORTS - ATHLETES WHO LOST THEIR FORTUNES

This week, James and Jimmie discuss professional athletes that have lost their fortunes.

Down South Death Demon - Edwards, Mississippi

This week, in Edwards, Mississippi, a terribly murdered body is found, stuffed inside of hog feed container, on a rural farm. This leads police to hunt for the man who was last seen with the woman, but he has already moved on to other horrific acts, including brutally killing his aunt, and attacking a stranger with a knife. His demeanor in court is absolutely wild, as he screams at the jury & judge, while giving the middle finger to prosecutors. Will he be held responsible?

Killer Cookie Conspiracy - McHenry, Illinois

This week, in McHenry, Illinois, several members of an extended family begin to get sick, and even drop dead, from a seemingly mysterious illness. These deaths just happen to be exactly what one family member needs, as he pays off his debts, with the money he collects. Is there some kind of enviornmental cause for the deaths? Maybe the water supply? Or, is it poisoned cookies, doughnuts, and pea soup?? Bodies are dug up, and one arrogant man says it's all done to set him up!

A...