Unique Stats Choices Implementation Poll

The results in the last poll were pretty clear, so I'll keep you posted on their development. For some reason, I had a feeling the sixth option would be really popular :D Below are the details of the next poll.

As you might know, I'm working on a RPG system to make the game more entertaining. The stats are grouped in two categories:

• Main Stats. Corruption and Purity. Each will have their own color reflected in the choices.
• Side Stats. Exhibitionist/Modest, Charming/Seductive, Submissive/Dominant. All of them will be represented by an unique color, which points you that you have access to a special fetish choice.during an event.

My question is how you'd like to see the special fetish choices playing out and I'll use the following situation: 

You picked the waitress job to gain credits to restore your ship's flight capabilities and you're serving at a table. The customer at this table is rather rude, keeps complaining about the food and about the service. Everytime you lean over to pick up his food you see him trying to peer under your work skirt. You're getting tired of his behavior and you'll get access to an unique special fetish choice, called Lean further and subtly raise your skirt. How would you like it to work:

• Locked/Unlocked Design. If your exhibitionist stat is above 2 and you're wearing a short skirt, the choice gets unlocked. Otherwise, it's grayed out and you need to pick a generic choice. The choice guarantees success.
• Risky Unlocked Design. You can pick the choice, but you can either fail or succeed. Odds of success depend on whether your character is more exhibitionist of more modest, and on the length of the skirt your character is wearing. 

The first idea is used in Mass Effect and other RPG games. You need paragon/renegade to make a special action (which is a guaranteed success), otherwise you need to pick a generic one.

The second idea is what I came up with. It can make the content more entertaining, because even if your character is very exhibitionist, wearing a long and tight skirt makes the odds of success probably impossible. A modest character who wears a very short and loose skirt could have higher odds of success, but such a choice will lower the modesty stat of this character and increase the exhibitionist one.

Please pick the idea you find more fun.