Stargirl 2x9 - Poll!

I don’t think you can kill eclipso. He’s true evil. He must exist just as much as true good must exist. I think the most we can hope for is trapping him in an alternate plane of existence. Perhaps, could we trade him for McNider, Cindy, and anyone else stuck in that Shadow land? Or would that only make Eclipso stronger?

HollyCzanirov87

Kill it if its not possessing anyone. If it posess someone try to exorcise it to something that can contained.

Doby Greg

I wonder if Doctor Mid-Nite is in the shadow reality because he was possessed and the Shade put him there, and they might do something similar with Pat.

Crystal Squirrel

They should redeem him and have him join the new JSA

Prince of Za Waurdo Over Salmon

I think they´ll kill him because he is a too powerfull villain than they could use as a reaccuring one, but not beeing the big bad. So my hope is, that they´ll think they trapped him, or killed him (at besrt Pat does it, or all of them together), but he isn´t gone and will come back as a big bad in another season.

Alex the Patron

75% of me say trap him but they will need a new way to trap him since the diamond is shattred and they need someone who can fight him. Courtney and her staff and beth and the goggles are not enough. The other 25% I say kill him need justice for the doggo.

spencer

There's something about the way Eclipso is being written that I can see Courtney, Cosmo, and the JSA trapping him. However I think they should try to kill him if possible, since trapping him seems to kill someone else.

Joel

I think that they will trap him. Also we never really saw Cindy die. Eclipso just seemed to have dragged her down into the Shadowlands or some other prison. Maybe she is the host or anchor to kill, and he is keeping her out of harms way?

or cause its the multiverse all jay garricks look the same like all the wells look the same...............as for the age, if they are following the comics all of the jsa members were cursed/blessed with slow aging via a mission back in the day. thats how despite them being around since the 40s they are still walking around in the 2020s looking like they are in their 50s-60s instead of their 90s

rickie woodson

just get him off the planet. hell dimensions exist hence him existing in the first place so no need to kill him. they just need a magic user on this team thats all. where's black alice when you need her. i'd even take traci 13 or zatanna's little cousin zachary zatara. too bad they killed the wizard's kid #nevershouldhavehappened

rickie woodson

he's a demon and they arent magic users so....yeah they cant kill him, so i say get on the phone to zatanna so she can fix the black diamond and recast the spell that trapped him in the first place. there is also jade (jenny alan aka the new green lantern from this season) since her powers are magic based. maybe a combo of her and shade together could imprison eclipso. too bad none of them know jakeem has the thunderbolt

rickie woodson

Give em a job

Gavin Hardiman

Story wise trap him but really they should kill him he’s too much of a threat

From a practical standpoint, he's too dangerous to keep around. The world would be better off without him. So I say kill the bastard

A.J. Agreste

I feel like Eclipso is going to get defeated by the energy of the cosmic staff. Light defeats dark

Kab

I have a theory of Jay Garrick appearing both The Flash and Star Girl. Jay must have lived on Earth 2 (Star Girl) his entire life fighting along side with the JSA. Jay may have left Earth 2 after the JSA was defeated by the ISA (as seen where his helmet is spotted) and takes Joan to Earth Prime to retire and soon discovers Barry Allen and fight along side to move on from his team's defeat. And Exactly how old is Pat and the rest of the JSA each flashback scene says "decades early" it sounds the writers are trying to say that Pat is old since the actor himself is in his 50's. Does that question you guys alot?

If you trap him, he can come back in future seasons whenever the writers need him.

SonOfDarkHelmet