XaiJu
Scott Paul Johnson
Scott Paul Johnson

patreon


Patron Questions | 04: Josh Karnofsky • I - ii Progression Help

New here? Wondering where to start? Click here

Josh is wondering about chord shapes in relationship to the pentatonic scale.

Click here for the community post about this specific lesson to ask questions, post pictures or audio, or to see what other people are saying about this lesson.

Check out the Lesson Archive for more Patron Questions.

Patron Questions | 04: Josh Karnofsky • I - ii Progression Help

Comments

Hmmm I agree with both you AND Josh. But at the 7:25 mark you said you did not agree with the thinking of (Josh’s) C Shape as it would make you think you are in the Key of D. But that would be D Major, true. The C Shape that Josh is speaking of would be correct if we are speaking of B MINOR. And that is what the ii chord is: B Minor. Finally - I agree with Scott. We are here to make melodies (music). Not to play scales over chords. I wish we could have a three way conversation re: this. Fun stuff. Music theory is like a never ending puzzle. Thanks.

LoungeActor


More Creators