Gran That Jam | Patreon-Exclusive In-Person BOTC

I love how this game played out <3 Amazing!

Niina Jokela

SPOILER. Love Oli's reveal of his revenge. The look on Adam's face in particular -and Laurie running over to shake hands

Stuartdouglas19 .

As usual, Adam is totally confident and totally wrong.

John

you paid money to come here and insult her.

Moo!

Laura Cooper

I think my favourite part of this was watching the good team accidentally doing evil's job for them.

Jake Samuels

I thought the same thing, but then I realised they pretty much had to in order for the game to end. There was no way the town would execute him at that point, so it would’ve just been prolonging the inevitable, which was the same thing happening the next night and potentially the night(s) after as well. Maybe one extra night would’ve been fairer..? / but I see why they did it.

no shade at all just genuinely curious. if the story tellers are supposed to be on the side of whoever is losing to highten the story, why would they chose to make isaac drunk instead of brooke at the very end? he could have survived that night i think and they could have had another night.

Carley was acting like such a b this episode. Wtf girl chill out

Sarah A

To be clear, not ish-ing on Brooke's choice, she doesn't know who everyone is, but it would have opened a vein where it's not a Zombuul. and one heck of a loooooooong vein.

Stacey McPeek

I think the better bluff for Brooke would have been to have taken the Po out for a drink, as it would have explained the lack of death the night before and then she could have convinced someone not to kill the next day. (potentially Dom would kill a corpse and they could have thought it actually was a Po.) just a thought.

Stacey McPeek

Dom's immense desire to be the lunatic got me hahah This is my favorite thing on YouTube, I love everyone's camaraderie and personalities working together to create a great experience for the viewer. Plus- thanks Terri!

Waiting for the day I can buy the NRB BotC Post Credits Scenes Album, that sucker gonna reach Billboard Top 20 in a day

Ishtar

i know im 10 months late but im absolutely screaming at the fact that no one pieced together that isaac "drunked" carly the night she gambled adam, to pin him as the demon!

Ashlee dima

Every time I see someone take a mile long walk to the lectern I curse the set designer.

So much satisfaction for Oli. Love the long con!

Serena The Ging

Moo!!! 🐄

Caledronius

Wow, Oli's big reveal at the end was so glorious.

Sully is indeed a lovely cow

Ian W

I’m surprised no eyes fell on Dom. He was SO QUIET after he was executed!

Loonicy

After this episode you HAVE TO make Brooke and Blair good/evil twins in a game. You don't even need info, mixing up their names alone is going to cause half chaos.

Levana Tse

Finally joined, BotC content snuck me in lol

Billiard boys!

Thanks for the spoiler dumbass

Stuart Reed

Sry Ben I don't agreed with what you said about evil

MbtCancelByAllCommunitySoonCancelledByAllCommiteeSoonCancelByAllPlayersSoon

Subbed tonight specifically to see this episode, and was treated to The Revenge of Oli Davis™. Fantastic.

Dean Gordon

Even in a PG situation at final 3, if only Evil are alive (but don't know each other) it's still an Evil majority win.

I'm a lovely cow XD XD

4.I.S

Oli's revenge after a year on the Billiards Boyz was a sheer gem to behold. Well done Oli.

only alive players can nominate for execution and all alive players were evil (Dom, Brooke, and Oli) so they wouldn't nominate anyone

Ruben Anthony

Cry-laughing at Sullivan!

Mister M.

No, you don't need to clarify it as a win condition. The win condition is still that there are 2 players left alive, one of whom is the demon. Here, because there are only evil players alive and they all know each other, it is inevitable that the win condition is reached. So Ben could have gone through having the minions refuse to nominate that day, then they go to sleep, and then the demon kills one of their minions. But it's pointless because there is nothing good can do to stop evil winning, and evil knows it. However, there are other scripts with characters that can mean only evil players being left alive does not inevitably give the evil team the win, and in those cases the Storyteller would play out the last day. For example, one evil player may be a marionette and not sure if they are really evil, or a poppygrower could have died poisoned and the evil team were never told who their fellow evil players were. In such a case, an evil player may end up nominating the demon, and then good could still win.

I haven’t read the rules but I agree they should have definitely clarified that as a win condition. I mean, it makes intuitive sense but the rules should always strive to eliminate ambiguity.

Lexicorn Fell

OK I get now that the reason for this is that the dead players can't nominate and the alive evil players won't nominate anyone, so it's a de facto win for evil. Weird that the rules don't mention that as a specific win condition.

SEAN BADGER

Oh! but they can't nominate! Got it. Thanks!

SEAN BADGER

Dead players can still vote.

SEAN BADGER

Not according to the rules?

SEAN BADGER

Killing all the good players is one way the evil team can win.

Lexicorn Fell

The three players were evil. You have to be alive to vote to nominatel someone. All good players were dead.

Fernando

Fortunately Oli woke up

Fernando

Can anyone help me understand why the game ended with three players alive? The video didn't track ghost votes, but it seemed like there were still enough ghost votes to outvote the evil players on the last day. They might have killed the demon on the last day, right?

SEAN BADGER

The godfather learning about outsiders is the characters ability. Therefore it's waking up.

Knut Behrend

That's correct info. Oli woke up to the godfather ability to learn outsiders in play. No mistake

I know mistakes happen, but Ben did give Adam wrong information night one (the 1 on Carley and Oli when neither woke up) which threw everything off for town, sowing all kinds of mistrust. Really sad the game played out the way it did.

Matthew Just