Which is more terrifying?

Both depending on route 🙏🙏

Yellow Soap

I honestly don't know.... It really depends on the overall situation and whether I think he is about to kill me too. Does he still have a weapon in his hands? Why did he kill the other person? What are his vibes (I tend to sense and notice things that most ppl don't, like micro-expressions).

J

Same here.It really suits to all yandere types.We know before day 1 Peter killed someone(we least know,that he killed original owners of ,,his,, home) so be calm about killing is like you see to people you kill like trash and not people,so you feel like you did nothing wrong just rid off some trash.Is something what only real psycho people can do...and is really scary just think about it.Cuz in that point,you lose all humanity you had left...Everybody can be crazy after this but calm?Only some of them,which is killing like drinking water,is not necessarry you want do it but you need it to live and vanish thirst in your mouth.Or be like soldiers,which killing enemies is their job.

Natijx

Same here.We know before day 1 Peter killed someone(we least know,that he killed original owners of ,,his,, home) so be calm about killing is like you see to people you kill like trash and not people,so you feel like you did nothing wrong just rid off some trash.Is something what only real psycho people can do...and is really scary just think about it.Cuz in that point,you lose all humanity you had left...

Natijx

Gosh,after I readed last words I couldn´t stop laughing XD But,yop.I would do same XD

Natijx

Crazy Is kinda hot haha, but calm are def terrifying

Tachibana uwu

"Calm" until day 4. For Day 5 "Crazy" because it contradicts the image you had of him until then. It would be more shocking to see him freak out when he realizes his time is running out to become "your boyfriend" if he hasn't managed to convince Y/N by then.

SabiBittner

omg i gotta see both

ADR _X

Crazy would be hotter but technically calm is scarier

But either way I wouldn't stick around to find out if he has a crazed look or not, I'm booking it. I know I can't outrun him, but I'm not gonna fuck around and find out

MK21ithinkidk67to86r

I think if Peter murdered somebody and calmly walked to me with no expression on his face and greeted me, I'd pee myself. But if he murdered someone and speedwalked to me with a crazed face i'd smack him.

MK21ithinkidk67to86r

The crazy eyes would be terrifying in the moment, but the calmness would be terrifying to think about

Marie Artoinette

Idk, both are hot

Xander

based af

Panana_B

Calm look is horrifying

mark

Same <3

Shania Garcia

im just messed in the head and would find them both attractive lol

Alexis Rose

Calm is when you really know they’re insane

Paris

tbh both

rey

I feel like the whole "crazed look" could be a bit cliche. While for me personally... if someone came up to me after just killing someone with a calm look... id get the impression that they've done it before so much that its normal or natural to them. Which I think would make me feel a bit more scared than someone just walking up with said crazed look.

Lexi_Tyson (SilverTyson)

For me, calm makes me feel safer. Makes me feel like I'm less in danger. If they seem a bit... out of it, I'm going to panic more.

Cinnamon Roll

Both points have their respective scary components. I be feeling safer with calm however towards me, since when he goes crazy towards me it is more likely I can not pursuate him to not do that to me. Impulsivness is less controlable. Calm means: You can talk with him. Tho: Crazy doesn't nessecarily mean their a psychopath. Normal people can become crazy in dire situations for a moment, but crazy means impulsive as said before, which is unpredictable. Calm ist still very dangerous, but atleast one has a fighting chance to talk through it and come to a calm out of a dangerous situation. Once it escalates, the chances of death rise extremly.

Ineke

I assume they would feel calm after slaughtering someone since they may as well feel relieved to know they handled someone who may steal YN away from them.

Tulip

Thank you Inverted, you truly spoil us to much.

Nia Bothwell

Crazy means they just lost their mind and composure. But Calm... Calm means they know what they are doing. They have done it before and they know what they are capable of. One is a psychopath trying to keep his mask on. The other has accepted their psychopath and torn the mask apart.

Rincet

Crazy murder face means "I enjoy killing no matter the reason" but Calm murder face means "I dont really care about killing or other human beings in general, but obviously I'd do anything for you, Darling"

Safaia Kitsune

Calm grin with emptiness?... horrifying and supersexy lol

Eugene

Also, the diary entries seem all the more ominous because you can't imagine that he has another side that seems to be anything but "calm".

SabiBittner

I would have picked crazy but your use of "empty look" makes it scarier to me because it could allude to "well guess you're next" since we know YB/YG is just crazy for us anyway right? lol

Connie DW

Calm is absolutely terrifying because they've done it with clarity of thought. If they look crazy they wouldn't be thinking and less likely it was in their control

Erica Kendrick

While "crazy and psychotic" can be scary due to the fact that in such an disturbed and erratic frame of mind, they're a clear and obvious threat, it's more "expected" or "understandable" in a deranged man, and violence is all but expected from them; it puts you on edge, and the fear comes from knowing that they're unstable and an obvious threat to you. But calm and collected? - that's composure. That's someone with seemingly total control over their thoughts and actions; that's calculation. He's clearly unstable, but because he's showing nothing, there's no way of knowing what's coming next, or how much of a threat he is to you in the here and now. That's a terrifying concept to me.

Alexis Merson

Calm is scarier in my opinion (I wouldn't add the glazed over eyes), it's proof that they know what they've done, and it wasn't a crazed fit of passion, it shows mental clarity in the worst way. It shows that they've done this many times before and is passed the point of an adrenaline craze when they kill. Though if you want to add to the unhinged look, if Y/N tells them what they did was horrible, they could definitely do the crazed look and begin to rant about how they "did this for us!" Which would show just how far gone they truly are.

kedamono lee

Crazy is scarier, crazy means impulsive and unpredictable, means you might be next. Calm on the other hand? Calm is disturbing yes.. but it also means there's still a chance that you can talk yourself out of the situation.

Gae-ta

crazy is at least a high-point emotion from a situation. calm or no reaction is just a removal of basic human emotion and is far more terrifying to me.

WhiteWolf

crazy is scary when i dated yb and worked over night come to the sleep i just rapted by yb

이승아

calm is way worse, even so if the eyes aren't empty, just... Uncaring. It suggests a clear head, complete control over the situation, and a disregard for human life. Someone who has just done it enough or is casual enough with it, they aren't moved in the slightest by what they had just done. Terrifying. Makes my heart race lol.

Panana_B

It's really scary when he've killed someone and stay calm, and even scarier when they have clear eyes. That means he has absolutely no idea that he did somthing wrong. Even with blood on his hands.

cori87

Calm suggests that they're thinking clearly, while crazed suggests that they're possessed by passion. So calm is scarier because you probably can't reason with them like this.

Reed A. Saur

Crazy is scary, calm is kinda hot

Junipurr

Me: *votes* Also me: the question was, “Which is scarier?” not “Which is hotter?”

Jocelyne Ledezma

Crazy look would make me feel like he would try attacking me if he has a calm look I would just be like ok he did that to prove his love he wouldn't just hurt me now

Danni

Don't get me wrong I like both options cold and sadistic look is great but the idea of Peter smiling at you after killing someone in Cold blood just seeing his smile and thinking that you'll agree that he's done good I can't help but want that more.

skylar chlobean

Calm, but with a blank expression. Not being able to read someone can be horrifying… and let’s be real with this fan base they would be into a “calm face”, probably not the tone you are going for in that scene

TeddyCakes233

Calm is more unnerving. It's not what you expect to see from someone who just killed someone. You EXPECT a crazy person to have a crazy expression. Someone who can flip between (or balance) a crazy act like murder + a calm demeanor is just. Mmmmmm. Shudders.

Mori Covington

We see him crazy already, so calm + violent would be new and therefore disturbing

Filberson

I found crazy more scary xD damn if they are calm at least give me space to process the thing, but if they are crazy I'd be more in panic not knowing what are they going to do next

KukiKiu

crazy gross predatory sharp toothed Cheshire grin pleeeeeeease ;w;<3

dublinwaltz

I like thinking that he’s super crazy during/right after the kill, but like the day after he’s fine

kammy

I would say crazed smile is more scary if I didn't know him, since he might kill us too in the heat of the moment, and he might be up for negotiation if he's calm and listening? But since I know how Y/B is like to Y/N , calm would be scarier since we don't know what he's planning for us next (hopefully I name sense)

rain

More hot than terrifying both ways

rey

I think it would be better if they drew the expressions I just can’t imagine it without it being goofy 😭

Bubble_fart

It depends on who he’s killing just imagining it is gross, I think him not second guessing his murder and coddling y/n would be the scariest mentally but empty eyes are just more sad then scary

Bubble_fart

Calm. It's disturbing to see him calm after killing someone. So I couldn't tell you if he's still sound in the head.

Grimtales _134

Honestly, I think ether could work just as well given the way he is.

Yin

To be so calm and collected after ending another's life? That's truly horrific.

FollyFromTheStart

Ok, then how would you suggest Peter look after killing somebody?

Bonnie Callahan

I think objectively the calm is spookier, BUT crazy is sexier

ZeldAry

My toxic trait is that I find the crazed smile attractive 😂

Yandere Cutie

Both are corny

Bubble_fart

You’re not sick. Yeah, YB isn’t exactly the most stable person out there, but he’s very 3-dimensional and can be a total sweetheart too. They’re actually two of many reasons why he’s so interesting and loved by so many of us.

Taylor Campbell

Glad most of us agree lol

GreenAlienXD

I say calm cause it shows that killing someone isn't a problem in their eyes. That YN hasn't seen their crazy side yet and will dread it even more when it comes out

Sparky111000

I feel love it depends on who the victim is. I feel crazy would work with someone who's really been a huge thorn in his side, kinda feeling cocky and victorious about it. Calm would work with what he would feel like was a necessary kill in his mind. Like, "it was necessary to do that because xyz." I hope that makes sense.

CM Addams

Crazy is freaky but it’s expected you know what is coming next, being calm however, it confuses you because it isn’t normal, that that makes it a lot more unnerving

Smol Sinn

Calmly he approached and smiled at you. "I hope that bad man didn't hurt you..."

Adam Costello

🤣 that calm look would have me panicking lol just "oh fuck I'm next aren't i?" type shit lol

Dana Fear

Crazy and hot. IM SORRY HE IS

Nook Miles

Can y’all please refund my memebership

Mandy Wiles

Granted I find both attractive cause I’m sick

Puff Puff Pomf