May 24th, 2022: Donaldson, Offense, Bullpen, Green, Gil
Added 2022-05-24 12:01:02 +0000 UTCRoger Angell, the greatest ballwriter to ever live, passed away Friday at his home in Manhattan. He was 101. If you’re only going to read one thing today, read Angell’s 1975 profile on Steve Blass. Just a masterclass in combining serious reporting with sensitivity. Now let’s get to today’s post.
1. Weekend thoughts. Banner weekend for the Yankees, eh? They went full 2021 Yankees for a few days there. The offense no-showed during the doubleheader, multiple relievers melted down, they made dopey mistakes on the bases, lost to the Orioles, and got dunked on after a benches-clearing incident. I can’t remember the last time the Yankees walked away from a war of words without looking like chumps. A few thoughts on the last few days.
Donaldson vs. Anderson
As you no doubt know, Josh Donaldson continued his feud with White Sox shortstop Tim Anderson over the weekend. The two first got into it following a hard tag at third base last week in Chicago, then they got into it again Saturday. Donaldson admitted he called Anderson “Jackie,” a reference to a quote Anderson made in a 2019 Stephanie Apstein article. Here’s the quote:
“I kind of feel like today’s Jackie Robinson,” he says. “That’s huge to say. But it’s cool, man, because he changed the game, and I feel like I’m getting to a point to where I need to change the game.”
Anderson’s quote has been passed around without context the last few days. The article is about Anderson feeling isolated as a Black man in a predominantly white sport. All Donaldson’s comment did was reinforce that isolation. The best case scenario is Donaldson is a moron who for some reason is fixated on a three-year-old article. The worst case is much, much uglier.
Donaldson gave the token “I’m sorry he got offended” apology and said he only “joked around” with Anderson, but joking around is between friends, and these two aren’t friends. Donaldson used Robinson’s name to belittle Anderson repeatedly over a number of years. Robinson is one of the most important figures in American history and reducing his name to an insult is shameful.
"It's a tough one given the history, especially the series in Chicago and the little bit of beef between Anderson and him," Aaron Judge told Dan Martin about Donaldson's comments to Anderson. "Anderson is one of the best shortstops in the game and is a big part of MLB and how we can grow the game."
Donaldson said he’s willing to meet face to face with Anderson to apologize, but a) Donaldson has a history of misrepresenting face to face meetings with White Sox players, and b) Anderson doesn’t owe him anything. As far as we know the White Sox left town without the two meeting. If the Yankees and White Sox see each other again this year, it will be in the postseason.
MLB investigated the incident (the league interviewed Anderson several times and Donaldson at least once) and Donaldson has been suspended one game. He’s appealing and is eligible to play until the appeal is heard (he can’t serve the suspension while on the COVID list). Here’s what MLB discipline czar Michael Hill said in the league’s statement:
“MLB has completed the process of speaking to the individuals involved in this incident. There is no dispute over what was said on the field. Regardless of Mr. Donaldson's intent, the comment he directed toward Mr. Anderson was disrespectful and in poor judgment, particularly when viewed in the context of their prior interactions. In addition, Mr. Donaldson’s remark was a contributing factor in a bench-clearing incident between the teams, and warrants discipline.”
Donaldson has never been all that likable and he’s rubbed opposing players the wrong way for a long time. It’s one thing to call Gerrit Cole out for using sticky stuff. That is 100% fair game in my opinion. There are lines that shouldn’t be crossed though, and no matter what Anderson said in an article three years ago, using Robinson’s name to mock someone is beyond that line. I’d like to think that is common sense, but I guess not.
“I understand that Josh has been very forthcoming with the history of it, the context of it,” Aaron Boone told Peter Botte over the weekend. “I don’t believe there was any malicious intent with that regard. This is just somewhere in my opinion he should not be going.”
The amazing, disappearing offense
The Yankees scored one run in Sunday’s doubleheader. It was the first time they scored no more than one run in a doubleheader since Sept. 2014 against the Orioles, and the first time they did it at home since Aug. 1991. They did it twice in a four-day span that month. The Tigers got them on Aug. 10th and the Royals on Aug. 13th, both at Yankee Stadium.
It won’t go into the history books, but the Yankees got hidden perfect game’d by Michael Kopech. He retired the final 13 Yankees he faced on May 15th and the first 17 Yankees he faced on May 22nd, so that’s 30 (!) consecutive Yankees retired across two starts. Good for him, bad for the Yankees. Monday night’s lineup had serious 2013-14 vibes:
- 1B Anthony Rizzo
- RF Aaron Judge
- DH Giancarlo Stanton
- 2B Gleyber Torres
- SS Isiah Kiner-Falefa
- LF Aaron Hicks
- CF Estevan Florial
- C Jose Trevino
- 3B Marwin Gonzalez
This is why you don’t punt offense for defense at multiple positions, by the way. Especially not when COVID still lingers as a threat to sideline multiple players at once. Donaldson, Joey Gallo, and Kyle Higashioka are all on the COVID list right now, and while Gallo hasn’t been good as a Yankee, he’s better than his replacement.
“(They are) more than just not feeling well. They feel sick. It’s not just allergies. They’re not available to play,” Boone told Bryan Hoch about the COVID trio. (For what it’s worth Donaldson’s, Gallo’s, and Higashioka’s lockers are all next to each other in the clubhouse.)
Judge is incredible. Two homers Monday night, five homers in his last seven games, 11 homers in his last 20 games, and 16 homers in his last 27 games. Rejecting that contract extension offer and then doing this is an all-time baller move. Judge couldn’t possibly do anything more for his team, offensively or defensively. He is the super early AL MVP favorite, and I don’t think it’s close.
It’s the rest of the offense that has been a problem lately. Every single run the Yankees scored in their last three games came on a Judge homer. Rizzo (.183/.289/.310 and 77 wRC+) and DJ LeMahieu (.211/.300/.310 and 88 wRC+) have been pretty bad in May, and with Rizzo slumping, there’s no lefty impact in the lineup. Stanton and Torres have been quiet the last few games too, which hasn’t helped.
Rob Brantly, who was called up Sunday to replace Higashioka, broke up Kopech’s perfect game with a double, and with that double Brantly accounts for 14% of all extra-base hits by Yankees catchers this season. Kiner-Falefa’s last extra-base hit was May 2nd*. Hicks has two extra-base hits (one double, one homer) all season. After the top guys, this lineup is punchless.
* Yeah, that ball was fair Monday night and should have been a double, but would saying he has one extra-base hit since May 2nd really be much better?
I don’t know how long Donaldson and Gallo will be sidelined, but there’s no reason not to play Miguel Andujar right now (he was called up to replace Donaldson). Florial needs to play as long as he’s around too. Gonzalez hasn’t been good and he has no future with the Yankees (he might not even last the season). Any at-bats he gets over Andujar and Florial are a wasted opportunity.
(How do you let Marwin take that at-bat Monday night representing the tying run in the ninth inning against a dude throwing 97-98 mph sinkers? lol)
The offense will be prone to cold spells because there’s just nothing at the bottom of the order. When Judge, Rizzo, Stanton, et al have a quiet night, no one will pick them up. The margins of the roster are too weak and must be improved at the trade deadline. For now, the non-Judge portion of the offense is in a rut. It is the biggest reason for this little three-game losing streak.
Bullpen problems
The cracks in the bullpen dam are starting to burst. Chad Green is done for the year and Luis Gil can’t replace him (more on them in a bit), Aroldis Chapman is dealing with an Achilles issue (why is he pitching in a tie game if he’s not 100%?), Jonathan Loaisiga still isn’t right, and Miguel Castro is Miguel Castro. He looks amazing one day and unrosterable the next.
Clay Holmes and Mike King were nowhere near the high leverage radar at this time last year and now they’re doing almost all the heavy lifting in the bullpen. The difference between those two and everyone else is stark:

The rest of the bullpen hasn’t been bad, though there’s certainly a big drop off between Holmes and King, and everyone else. In terms of shutdowns and meltdowns (i.e. relief appearances that swing win probability at least 6% in one direction or the other), Holmes and King are at 18 shutdowns and three meltdowns combined. Everyone else is at 33 and 18, respectively.
I would like to see two things happen with the bullpen. First, give Clarke Schmidt a look. I mean actually pitch the guy. Monday was his 36th day on the active big league roster and he’s made only five appearances. I get that he’s the long man and Boone doesn’t want to use him unless it’s a long man situation, but the rotation has been too good to wait around for a short start.
Schmidt has pitched well when he has pitched and he has the power stuff (and by all accounts the dogged competitiveness) to excel in a shorter relief role. It might not happen right away, but why can’t Schmidt be another King? It’s crazy to me a dude with as much talent as Schmidt is sitting unused while so many others struggle to get important outs, especially while he’s healthy. Schmidt hasn’t been healthy all that often. He is now. Might wanna use him, you know?
Green’s injury opens a bullpen spot, meaning when the 13-pitcher limit kicks in Monday, Schmidt can stick around. I would understand sending him to Triple-A to get stretched out as a starter, but there’s a chance to help the MLB team in relief, and learning how to get outs at the big league level regardless of role is valuable experience. It’s time to give Schmidt some of it. (Plus I feel pretty good about Hayden Wesneski being the next-in-line starting pitcher in Triple-A.)
And second, Wandy Peralta. What’s up with this? The guy was a fairly trusted reliever down the stretch last season and now he’s at the back of the bullpen. Monday night was Wandy’s first outing in four days, and his last four appearances before that came on eight, one, four, and four days rest. Wandy has pitched five times in May. Five! It’s not enough.
Peralta got burned by ground balls last night and I’m not holding that against him. Can’t blame a guy for not being not razor sharp when he’s used so infrequently. There’s a good (not amazing, but good) reliever in there somewhere, so use him. It’s not like taking innings away from Castro is going to be some grand misuse of resources. It’s fine. Try it.
The Yankees are pretty good at building bullpens and, if necessary, rebuilding them on the fly. It might be necessary this year. Green’s hurt, Chapman might be cooked, Loaisiga could be a one-year wonder (I don’t think he is but it’s possible). If they have to go out and get bullpen help, they will. Schmidt and Wandy (and Ron Marinaccio?) are worth a shot first. It’s time to try them.
“We’ve got guys that are very capable down there, and to go with what we’ve been getting with our starting pitching, we’ll be okay,” Boone told Hoch about his bullpen. “It’ll create some opportunities for other people and some different roles. That’s going to come in the course of a season. It forces guys to step up, and we have people that have a chance to do that.”
Miscellany
Jameson Taillon and Luis Severino during the doubleheader: 14 IP, 8 H, 1 R, 1 BB, 12 K. The Yankees have gotten very good pitching all season, but damn, wasting two starts like that (on the same day no less) really stings. Gotta turn those in wins. Taillon’s sporting a 2.95 ERA (3.22 FIP) through eight starts. He’s been so good … A few weeks back I noted Giancarlo Stanton had only two walks in 74 plate appearances, or 2.7%. Since then Stanton’s walked 12 times in 92 plate appearances, or 13.0%. Good to know I can still fix things with my words. Stanton’s season 8.4% walk rate is still a bit below his 11.5% career average (10.9% last year), but it’s looking more normal now … And finally, JP Sears will make the spot start Wednesday, Boone confirmed. He’s been excellent in Triple-A (21.1 IP, 11 H, 3 R, 2 BB, 30 K) though he’s only stretched out to 65 pitches or so, so he won’t pitch deep into the game (maybe Schmidt will piggyback?). I assume Marinaccio will be sent down to clear a roster spot. As for what happens after the spot start, who knows. Hard to predict roster moves given the current COVID situation.
2. Two Tommy John surgeries. All things considered, the Yankees have stayed very healthy this year, though they did get slammed a bit over the last week. It was bound to happen at some point. Here is the latest on two injured Yankees.
Green headed for Tommy John surgery
This sucks. Chad Green will indeed have Tommy John surgery, ending his season and possibly his Yankees career. Green has been one of the best, most durable relievers in the game since being called up for good in 2017, and his reward is major arm injury five months before his best (only?) chance at a big free agent payday.
Here’s the reliever WAR leaderboard since Opening Day 2017:
- Josh Hader: +11.6 WAR
- Raisel Iglesias: +8.3 WAR
- Liam Hendriks: +8.2 WAR
- Chad Green: +8.0 WAR
- Blake Treinen: +7.6 WAR
Green is the only one of those dudes (and the only reliever above +7.0 WAR since 2017) who did not spend a good chunk of time as a closer, and thus didn’t get the leverage boost. I know Green wasn’t what he was in the past this year, but he’s been really good for a really long time. He was the perfect modern reliever as a strikeout guy capable of pitching at any time and in any role.
“What Greenie means to this team, and what a great reliable player he’s been for us, it’s tough news,” Aaron Boone told Peter Botte over the weekend. “It’s usually something that pitchers are able to return from. I know he will. He’s an outstanding athlete that takes great care of himself and has a really good work ethic. I know that, in time, he’ll be fine. I expect him to pitch several more years at the level we’ve come to expect.”
The Yankees have now lost a Major League pitcher (i.e. someone expected to be a mainstay on the big league roster rather than an up and down guy) to Tommy John surgery every year but one since 2014. Here’s the list:
- 2022: Chad Green
- 2021: Zack Britton
- 2020: Tommy Kahnle (plus Luis Severino in Spring Training)
- 2019: none
- 2018: Jordan Montgomery
- 2017: Michael Pineda
- 2016: Nathan Eovaldi
- 2015: Chase Whitley
- 2014: Ivan Nova
The one year the Yankees didn’t have a pitcher Tommy John surgery was 2019, the year they set injured list records. Go figure. Anyway, the typical Tommy John surgery rehab timetable is 14-16 months these days, so there’s a chance Green could return to big league games next August or September. There’s also a chance he won’t see an MLB mound again until 2024. Rough.
Some team will sign Green to a 1+1 deal this offseason, like the Dodgers did with Kahnle*. He’ll get a low base salary for 2023, his rehab year, then a more representative salary in 2024, when he should be a full-go. It will also be his age 33 season. The earliest Green will get the chance to test free agency as a healthy player coming off a full year is 2024, when he’ll be almost 34.
* Kahnle’s deal paid him a $750,000 salary with a $550,000 signing bonus during his rehab year, so $1.3M total. His healthy year salary is $3.45M. Ryan Tepera got two years and $14M this past offseason and Trevor May got two years and $15.5M last offseason. Could a healthy Green have gotten something in that neighborhood? I think so.
Will the Yankees sign Green to that 1+1 deal? Eh, maybe. We’ve seen them do it before (David Aardsma, Octavio Dotel, random Yankee Jon Lieber), though it has been a while. In Hal Steinbrenner's austerity era, spending money (and a roster spot) on a player you know won’t contribute all year just isn’t something the Yankees seem willing to do. Odds are Green will wind up elsewhere.
Like I said before, Green these days isn’t what he was earlier in his career, but he was still a rock solid Major League reliever, and one who made the Yankees better. He was what, their fourth or fifth best reliever on paper? That’s pretty good. Losing Green is a blow to the Yankees and I hope he gets healthy and is still able to make some good money before the game is done with him.
Gil also headed for Tommy John surgery
Luis Gil also needs Tommy John surgery. You think Hal asked about a buy one, get 50% off discount? Probably. Gil got hurt during his Triple-A start last week. It was his first Triple-A start following his MLB spot start. The difference between the Triple-A injured list and MLB injured list is several hundred thousand dollars in salary, plus service time. Bad timing for Luis.
A healthy Gil would have been a candidate to fill Green’s vacated bullpen spot and I really like him as a potential high leverage reliever. I don’t think the control will ever be good enough to start, but Gil has the fastball and power stuff to really overwhelm hitters in short bursts. His first inning two weeks ago was as dominant as any inning any Yankees pitcher will throw in 2022 (video).
This is Gil’s final minor league option year and he’s already spent more than the 20 days in the minors needed to burn the option. So, when he’s ready to be activated next year, he has to go right on the MLB roster. The Yankees can (and will) send him on a 60-day minor league rehab assignment, but yeah, Gil’s losing his final year of proper minor league development. Sucks.
Also, Gil has already spent enough time in the minors this season to delay his free agency*, so whenever the Yankees need a 40-man spot, they can call him up and put him on the 60-day injured list, and it wouldn’t chop away a year of control. They’d have to pay him more in 2022, but it would be a drop in the bucket. Gil to the 60-day injured list could happen at some point.
* I don’t think the Yankees manipulated Gil’s service time. He legitimately needed more Triple-A time to work on his control (and work on his command, but control comes before command).
Given the current state of the bullpen, having Gil around as an option sure would have been nice. Pitchers get hurt though. It's what they do. Tommy John surgery isn't perfect but it has a high success rate, and Gil is still only 23. He's got a lot of career ahead of him. Hopefully this is just a bump in the road, and a year from now we're looking forward to him joining the bullpen and carving out a long-term.
3. 2022 draft prospect: Oregon State LHP Cooper Hjerpe. The 2022 MLB Draft will take place during the All-Star break and the Yankees hold the No. 25 pick. Here are the draft prospects we’ve already profiled. Some will be players the Yankees are reported to have interest in, some are players who fit the team’s M.O., and some are players I happen to like.
Hjerpe (pronounced “Jerpy”) has been the best pitcher in the country this spring, which a) is at least partially a product of so many other top college pitchers getting hurt, and b) isn’t the same thing as being the top college pitcher prospect. For example, Gerrit Cole was the best prospect in the 2011 draft even though Trevor Bauer, his teammate at UCLA, outpitched him.
This season Hjerpe owns a 2.36 ERA (1.93 FIP) with 135 strikeouts and 17 walks in 84 innings. That works out to a 41.0% strikeout rate and 5.2% walk rate. The tough to elevate Hjerpe has allowed eight home runs (two this year) in 173 career college innings, or 0.42 HR/9. That’s one homer every 21 innings or so. Here are Hjerpe’s’s current draft rankings:
- Baseball America (subs. req’d): No. 48
- FanGraphs: No. 61
- Keith Law (subs. req’d): No. 62
- MLB.com: No. 46
Hjerpe had a rough start at Arizona two weeks ago (4.1 IP, 8 H, 5 R, 4 ER, 2 BB, 5 K) with a lot of top scouting executives in attendance, though he bounced back well last week (6 IP, 3 H, 2 R, 1 ER, 1 BB, 10 K), and he’s popping up in first round mock drafts because he’s the rare healthy and performing college starter. Here’s video and here’s part of MLB.com’s free scouting report:
While Hjerpe doesn’t light up radar guns, he does have a full starter’s repertoire, a ton of deception and a huge competitive streak. His fastball will typically sit in the 91-93 mph range, occasionally touching a bit higher. It plays up because of a funky, cross-fire delivery that makes the ball hard for even right-handed hitters to pick up, and because he combines it with his breaking ball so well. It’s kind of a Laredo, coming from a low three-quarters slot, and Hjerpe can vary its shape. One is more of a slow sweeping curve, thrown in the mid-70s, and the other is tighter with more slider characteristics, thrown up around 80 mph. His average changeup features good fade and should be a weapon for him in the future.
Even with the funk in his delivery, Hjerpe tends to always finish online, leading to a belief that he’s going to throw more than enough strikes in the future, and he is fearless on the mound. His ceiling is a bit limited, but mid-rotation southpaws who perform well in big college conferences tend to do decently when the Draft comes around.
Keith Law (subs. req’d) recently noted Hjerpe will be a “darling of model-heavy teams with great Trackman data on his fastball and slider.” For the deep pitching nerds, FanGraphs adds his “fastball has a shallow vertical approach angle as well as an odd lateral one.” Hjerpe’s low arm slot …

… is unconventional, though unconventional deliveries don’t scare the Yankees. They’ve taken Clarke Schmidt, Matt Sauer, and T.J. Sikkema in the top three rounds in the last five years and all three went into the draft with delivery concerns. And, of course, all three have had injury issues in pro ball, so maybe the unconventional delivery thing isn’t some badge of honor.
There’s a strong case to be made Hjerpe is the best healthy college pitcher in the 2022 draft, and with 24 picks to be made before the Yankees go on the clock, there’s a pretty good chance he’ll come off the board before they pick. The top college arms rarely last long on draft day, though this is an unusual draft class because of the injuries, so who really knows?
I know this much: Hjerpe is an analytics darling, which is up the Yankees alley. Also, Hjerpe is said to be a big makeup guy, and that’s also something the Yankees value. That’s one reason they went for Schmidt despite his Tommy John surgery, because he’s a competitive guy who doesn’t scare easily. Hjerpe does check a lot of the boxes the Yankees prioritize.
4. Remembering a random Yankee: Brody Koerner. This week’s random Yankee is another request, and a player who likely never would have reached the big leagues without the pandemic, as messed up as that sounds. Here’s the random Yankee archive. You can find links back to everyone we've covered there.
Koerner grew up outside Washington DC and he was No. 500 on Baseball America’s top 500 prospects for the 2012 draft (subs. req’d). He was not drafted out of high school, however, so he followed through on his commitment to Virginia, where he had a 7.00 ERA in three years. That includes allowing 57 runs in 62 innings his draft year.
Despite the ugly numbers the Yankees saw enough in Koerner to make him their 17th round pick in 2015. His signing bonus was not reported, an indication it didn’t approach the $100,000 slot for picks after the 10th round. Koerner had surgery in May 2016 to repair a small fracture in his elbow, then, in 2017, he broke out with a 3.52 ERA in 107.1 innings split between High-A Tampa and Double-A Trenton.
"We treated it like a bone chip," Koerner told Randy Miller about the elbow surgery. "It was a fracture. They just broke it off, then pulled it out and cleaned up the bone a little bit. I was shut down for six weeks, then began rehabbing."
In 2018 and 2019, Koerner was an organizational arm who split his time between the rotation and bullpen, and Double-A and Triple-A. He had a 4.89 ERA in 202.1 innings those two years. Koerner spent the 2020 pandemic season at home rather than at the alternate site, and in 2021, he threw 77 innings with a 3.39 ERA with Triple-A Scranton. He made 15 starts and 11 relief appearances.
Injuries and COVID decimated the Yankees pitching staff early in Aug. 2021. Domingo German was placed on the injured list with elbow inflammation on Aug. 1st, and two days later Gerrit Cole and Jordan Montgomery were placed on the COVID list. To replace the arms, the Yankees called up Koerner, as well as Luis Gil and Stephen Ridings. It was the first MLB stint for all three.
Because of the recent bullpen workload, Aug. 3rd against the Orioles was essentially a punt game. The Yankees were using the three rookies no matter what because the regular big leaguers needed rest. Gil got the start and was fantastic, striking out six in six scoreless innings. Ridings then struck out three in a scoreless seventh. The offense built a 9-0 lead through four innings.
That paved the way for Koerner, then 27, to make his MLB debut in the late innings. His MLB debut did not start well – Koerner allowed a leadoff single to Cedric Mullins and a run-scoring double to Ryan Mountcastle – though he settled down and finished the game with just the one run allowed in two innings (video). That game was the first and still only time in American League history a team used at least three pitchers in a game, and every one made his MLB debut.
“It’s been a whirlwind to be honest with you. The last 24 hours have been crazy. It culminated with being able to pitch in Yankee Stadium. It’s a blessing from God for sure,” Koerner said after the game. “It was awesome. It was a lot of fun. That's what you dream of when you're a little kid when you start playing when you're five years old.”
Gil and Ridings were on the roster as COVID replacements, so they were sent back down soon thereafter (the Yankees manipulated the COVID list to avoid the 10-day rule with Gil and give themselves an extra roster spot between his starts). Koerner was a regular call up (Luke Voit was placed on the 60-day injured list to clear a 40-man roster spot), which meant a) he got to stick around, and b) the Yankees weren’t worried about losing him on waivers when the time came to drop him from the roster (unlike Ridings).
Koerner was called up and made his debut on Aug. 3rd. He then sat in the bullpen and did not appear in another game until Aug. 20th, when he threw a scoreless ninth inning in a blowout win over the Twins (video). Koerner was sent down the next day and Estevan Florial was called up because Brett Gardner was banged up, and the Yankees needed the outfielder.
The Yankees dropped Koerner from the 40-man roster three days later and he went unclaimed on waivers, so he reported to Triple-A Scranton. Weirdly, the Yankees re-added Koerner to the 40-man roster on Oct. 3rd, then designated him for assignment on Oct. 5th. I have no idea why. Maybe it had to do with postseason eligibility? The Wild Card Game was Oct. 5th and Koerner was dropped from the roster before the game. I never got an explanation for this move. I dunno.
Koerner became a minor league free agent after last season and his Yankees (and MLB) career consists of one run on two hits and two walks in three innings spanning two appearances. He struck out one and hit a batter, so five of the 13 batters he faced reached base. Koerner has 24 days of service time, equaling $73,612.01 in salary at the league minimum ($570,500 in 2021). He never appeared on a Yankees prospect list of any length by any publication.
No team signed Koerner before or after the lockout this past offseason. He eventually signed with Tecolotes de los Dos Laredos of the Mexican League last month, allowed two runs in a five-inning start, then the White Sox signed him to a minor league contract. Koerner is currently with their Triple-A club. Chicago isn’t blessed with tremendous depth, so if he pitches well and they get hit with a few injuries, Koerner could find himself back in the big leagues.
5. Rapid fire thoughts. The Marlins beat righty Pablo Lopez in arbitration over the weekend. He’ll make $2.45M this year rather than the $3M he was seeking. I bring this up only to note Lopez has a 1.67 ERA (2.29 FIP) in eight starts and 46 innings this season, and he leads all pitchers with +2.2 WAR. If you want evidence 2022 performance will not factor into arbitration rulings this summer, that’s about as good as it gets. Aaron Judge’s hearing is set for June 22nd. I think there’s a decent chance the two sides work out a one-year agreement for 2022 and avoid a hearing (neither side wants one). A long-term deal though? Forget it. That’ll have to wait until the offseason.
(Send your requests for Tuesday's random Yankee series and questions for Friday's mailbag to RABmailbag at gmail dot com.)
Comments
Couldn't agree more with your Schmidt and Wandy comments. Don't understand the non-use of those guys. I've said before in these comments, I think Schmidt could be the B+ version of King. The pitching models tend to agree, and he's looked very solid and in control when he's pitched. The SP has been solid (no doubt the ball is helping); stop waiting for the sky to fall! I wonder how much their newish sinker-approach has to do with playing with the mush ball all of last year, and seeing how much impact that had. Just an idle thought. (Think this is also just a Matt Blake thing, who has been a God send. From having to coach Indians' SPs without top-end fastballs. Haven't missed Larry for a minute.)
Alexander Rinaldi
2022-05-25 00:41:40 +0000 UTCThe case law has been decided. You read it here first, from Jingling Baby himself, the Yankee fan who's never happy. In other news, Jingling Baby makes a racist comment towards white people with his award-winning logic.
Alexander Rinaldi
2022-05-24 23:48:37 +0000 UTCHoping he makes a phantom IL stint (or even a real one would be just fine too) if he doesn't pull it together soon. Not many (realistic) options with that contract. Can't demote him unless he agrees. Cutting would be just dumb at this point. Need a bigger sample size (and real alternatives).
Alexander Rinaldi
2022-05-24 23:44:58 +0000 UTCAre you aware the Rays just lost 2 of 3 to the Orioles? They are a little better this year, and you can't win every game. You may have noticed a few guys went on the IL in just a couple days time. We play the Rays, Jays, Angels, Tigers, Cubs, and Twins coming up. How will we ever survive? *shutters* Cashman "gets a pass" because the record is good. That isn't mutually exclusive to "improving the roster." There isn't a team in baseball that *isn't* looking to improve their roster. What in the world would make you think *any* GM would be sitting back, happy with their roster, just the way it is...? You want him to get roasted because they are good? Is 1 day of a bad lineup "too long" for Cashman to get a pass? Amazing, indeed!
Alexander Rinaldi
2022-05-24 23:40:18 +0000 UTCWe can deduce that he likely isn't racist by knowing he's been in the league for 10+ years and has never had any such accusations. How do we know you, Judge, or anyone isn't a racist? The whole point is that you have to *prove* it. No one proves a negative in this country; never have, and never will. La Russa is the one who threw out the "racist comment" quote, not TA. JD is not the most well-liked guy, which *is* a well-known thing. We also know that he likes to get under the skin of the opposing team -- as he did to Giolito last year with the "sticky stuff" comment. MLB didn't say JD's comment was racist, either. They had the very reasonable take that it was insensitive and disrespectful. But that's not enough for people like you. There *has* to be more behind it. IMO, Jackie Robinson's name should be respected. He's the only player to have a day named after him, where everyone in baseball wears his number, which is otherwise universally retired across the sport. He is essentially a demigod in the baseball world (and an iconic American hero). MLB could've suspend JD a game for taking "Jackie's name in vain," and IMO (just mine), that would've been a good enough reason.
Alexander Rinaldi
2022-05-24 23:19:03 +0000 UTCYou are part of the problem actually. He's getting under his skin. Donaldson didn't randomly decide to call Anderson Jackie, he's parroting back what was said in an article. I will give you the point I don't know if Donaldson is racist but I sure as $hit know that calling dude Jackie isn't racist. You should go back to your safe space I think my man. This adulting stuff may prove hard for you.
JohnLag
2022-05-24 23:12:27 +0000 UTCBoone says Donaldson "shouldn't have gone there" but doesn't do anything about it? Yanks should have suspended Donaldson for 2 games.
DocBob
2022-05-24 22:34:51 +0000 UTCHow do you know Donaldson isn't racist? Frankly, if you're so insensitive to the BS that black people have gone through in this country that you think calling a black person "Jackie" is OK then you're a bit guilty yourself.
DocBob
2022-05-24 22:31:05 +0000 UTCJust really thankful to Donaldson for absolutely fucking demolishing the good vibes so we could have this instead. "[Anderson said] that neither Donaldson nor anyone else from the Yankees has reached out about the situation." https://theathletic.com/news/tim-anderson-react-josh-donaldson/UhAkz6sQugQP/ Anyway I'm sure that'll be the end of it and everyone will have moved on by tomorrow. Great job Yankees.
Michael Nelson
2022-05-24 21:38:34 +0000 UTC(Incidentally, both Gallo and Higgy had been tested but came up negative, or hadn't yet tested positive, or something to that effect. I'm not sure 10 days is gonna be enough for those dudes to "get better" either.)
Michael Nelson
2022-05-24 21:14:41 +0000 UTCApparently Donaldson was placed on the 10-day IL without even being tested for COVID. I know, the player only needs to be experiencing COVID-like symptoms and the team doesn't need to wait for a diagnosis, but I feel like maybe this is the FO's way of stashing him till this gets sorted out. I'm not sure 10 days is gonna be enough. Cashman used to really prioritize character, so I'm surprised he acquired Donaldson at all, given the dude's reputation pretty much everywhere he's ever played and everybody he's ever played against. But I guess it was all worth it to get ... Isiah Kiner-Falefa.
Michael Nelson
2022-05-24 21:10:08 +0000 UTCDonaldson speaks for all white people... interesting news
KT
2022-05-24 20:36:23 +0000 UTCThe comment was obviously race based. The worst thing anyone’s ever said? Of course not. But to think Donaldson was just making fun of Anderson completely divorced of any racial component shows why white people can’t be trusted to decide what is and isn’t racist.
Jingling Baby
2022-05-24 19:05:23 +0000 UTCUnderstood there are multiple perspectives here. My perspective is you are a space alien and need to be brought in for questioning by the Govt. Should we honor my feelings in this instance? Jackie never was a racial slur and the guy literally "went there" telling everyone in an interview how he feels like the modern-day Jackie Robinson. If you're that much of a narcissist that you'd say that out loud... I feel like a modern-day Albert Einstein because I helped my kid with math homework. They had beef and Donaldson "burned" him with a comment. Calling him a racist is literally such a little biatch move. People like Mr. Anderson cheapen the meaning of words by throwing them out in the wrong situation. Would have all the respect in the world if he said "I didn't like him making fun of me and I'll pay him back one day".
JohnLag
2022-05-24 16:32:36 +0000 UTCMoving the All-Star game last year was insanity as well.
KT
2022-05-24 16:28:46 +0000 UTCGo ahead and give him a pass. Shortsighted as it is. Hopefully Cashman is not sitting back saying we are playing 690 ball so no need to do anything. It will be another season without winning anything but be happy we are doing well in May.
Mike
2022-05-24 15:55:53 +0000 UTCIf being racist gets you suspended (it should) and we only take one side's thoughts into consideration in determining whether or not an action is racist, that feels like a really slippery slope, no? Intention sort of has to matter at least a little bit.
Nick
2022-05-24 15:55:01 +0000 UTCHe probably gets "a pass" for at least as long as the team is playing at a .690 clip... Amazing.
Nick
2022-05-24 15:45:04 +0000 UTCCould be recency bias but has the umpiring been truly awful over the last week plus??Feels like the Yanks have been the recipients of several terrible calls a game lately and on top of that feels like umps are quick on the trigger to eject them. Also, wow how bad is Hicks.... I think one of us could stand up at the plate in his place and generate more offense by not even swinging the bat. No way Gardner wouldn't be an upgrade over him. What's the Yanks realistic options? Can they demote him or cut him at this point? There's gotta be fringe players still available as free agents or in the minors who'd produce more than he has.
Phil
2022-05-24 15:44:03 +0000 UTCWith respect, I think you should reevaluate your position on this. Here’s why: it shouldn’t matter whether you personally or Donaldson feels his comments are racist, clearly Anderson does. We’ve got roughly 250 years of history in this country alone to tell us that letting white people decide what’s racist or not doesn’t work. I can tell you from experience that “I’m sorry if you feel bad” doesn’t do much when my girlfriend is upset (or when I’m upset) about something that was said. Nor should it! Putting the responsibility on people being punished to “get over it because I don’t personally want to think of myself as cruel” is a bad way to go through life. Personally, I’m disappointed the Yankees didn’t step in with a penalty. It’s a bad look for the team and the sport, especially in a day when baseball is bemoaning it’s low level of engagement with African Americans.
Mottpott
2022-05-24 15:39:54 +0000 UTCThe lineup last night was disgusting and an embarrassment. How long does Cashman get a pass? They have had an easy schedule and imho will be exposed as the schedule toughens over the next month.
Mike
2022-05-24 14:34:10 +0000 UTCOh man, poor Tim Anderson. Stuck in the modern game feeling like he's breaking the segregation barrier. What a complete D-Bag he is. So basically MLB has outlawed trash-talking or any of that. Anderson gets to put out an absolute BS quote for virtue-signaling points and can't be called on it? I know the left is busy changing the definition of words but what Donaldson did was not racist. Perhaps if Anderson hadn't tried to make himself out to be some kind of martyr he wouldn't be getting teased. Donaldson is a jerk no doubt but he's not racist and the suspension is literally the most insane thing MLB has done in recent memory.
JohnLag
2022-05-24 14:33:39 +0000 UTCIt's funny. I was just thinking the other day how easily Donaldson had seemingly integrated with the Yankees and then....controversy! Donaldson is prickly. You can drop the "ly" if that suits your speed. I doubt he thought it was racist, but that's just it with Donaldson. I doubt he thought. I had hoped both Donaldson and Anderson could have made some peace and come up with a positive statement on Sunday, but it doesn't seem to fit either's style. Beyond that, the Yankees seem to be into their first slump of the season. Some fans have grown tired of Green as he's become a bit more mortal and HR prone. Problem is, he's still been good and a reliable arm and now that's gone. He's an arm they could depend upon for 70+ games. Toss in Chapman's issues, and suddenly the second-tier arms are now being used in high-leverage situations. The Yankees are good at building pens, as Mike noted, so hopefully that continues. I'm a little concerned about the near term, but that's why it's also good the team banked some wins and a lead. They may need them. (BTW The conspiracy side of me thinks the Yankees are going to use this situation to send Chapman on a rehab assignment to get back on track, and that he's really not injured. I'm sure I'm overthinking it!)
MikeD
2022-05-24 13:43:37 +0000 UTC